## _wp07299 - 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp07299 - 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction, scope, and conceptual framework
- Purpose: analyze “total costs to society” of renewables support, including the true cost of reducing carbon emissions by substituting an equivalent amount of fossil fuels.
- Two externality sets identified:
  - Global negative externalities from GHG emissions, leading to excessive global emissions.
  - Appropriation problem for rents from technological development of new (renewable) energies, leading to underinvestment in R&D.
- Key conceptual challenges:
  - Uncertain costs of climate change and benefits of avoidance.
  - Difficulty in enumerating all cost components of renewable production and public support.
  - Large uncertainties in renewables R&D and learning-by-doing; future technologies and costs unknown.

### Justifications for public support to renewables
- Three primary welfare-justifying reasons:
  - Carbon-emissions reduction: renewables are “carbon neutral” in their use; public subsidy is a separate argument only when fossil fuels are not properly taxed for carbon emissions.
  - Technology spillovers and learning-by-doing: R&D and deployment generate spillovers not fully appropriable by developers.
  - Energy-importing countries’ interest in reducing fossil-fuel import dependence for security of supply.
- Additional strategic motive:
  - Petroleum-importing countries may seek to influence petroleum prices via demand reduction/taxation/alternatives, but this provides less global-welfare justification.
- Trade-offs and costs of subsidies:
  - Foregone tax revenue.
  - Subsidies can stimulate overall energy demand; could be counterproductive relative to policies that discourage energy demand.

### Forms of subsidies and support instruments
- Enumerated subsidy types:
  - Direct lump-sum payments to renewable producers (possibly location-dependent).
  - Output-tied payments: fixed support per unit of renewable output.
  - Support to current factor inputs (e.g., agricultural subsidies for biofuel feedstocks).
  - Capital support: subsidized financing or direct capital purchase support.
  - Guaranteed producer prices (feed-in-tariff schemes) guaranteeing minimum prices for delivered electricity for set future periods (up to 20 years).
  - Implicit support via avoided taxes (loss of potential government revenue), e.g., motor fuel excise exemptions and corporate tax credits.
  - Government support to renewable developers’ R&D (including competitive research programs such as EU Framework Programs).

### Renewables supply and country-level support (major advanced economies)
- EU target: indicative target for 22 percent of all electricity generation in the EU to be based on renewable energy by 2010 (against 14 percent today, mainly hydropower based).
- Germany:
  - Renewables (apart from hydropower) make up 6.4 percent of overall energy consumption.
  - Share of renewables in electricity generation is 10.2 percent; in heat generation 5.4 percent; in fuels 3.6 percent.
  - Multiple mechanisms: grants, feed-in tariffs, reduced-rate loans, preferential tax treatment.
- United Kingdom:
  - Capital grant support for offshore wind and small-scale technologies up to a budgetary limit.
  - Large certificate scheme funded through power utility rate increases (10 percent by 2010, increasing to 15 percent by 2015).
  - Estimated cost: GBP1 billion by 2010 for the certificate scheme.
- Japan:
  - In 2002, total central government support was ¥145 billion.
  - Small portfolio standard scheme: 1.35 percent by 2010.
- Canada:
  - Support mainly at the province level.
  - Renewables represent about 60 percent of total electricity supply and 35 percent of overall energy supply (2004, driven largely by hydropower).
- United States:
  - Energy Policy Act of 2005 combined with agricultural subsidy policies imply substantial favors to renewables; biofuels particularly favored.
  - Repeal of federal and local fuel excise taxes for alcohol-based fuels and biodiesel corresponds to an implicit subsidy of approximately US$12 billion for the period 2007–11 (Metcalf (2006)).
  - Corporate tax credits and state-level supports further incentivize wind- and bio-based power; solar remains far from competitive.
  - Energy Policy Act plus other policies also imply substantial direct or implicit subsidies to traditional fossil fuels.

### Shares and composition of renewables (2004, major OECD countries)
- Key country figures (2004, primary energy consumption basis and TWh equivalents where provided):
  - Canada: renewables 35 percent of overall energy; total renewables ~560 TWh equivalents; hydro 353 TWh.
  - France: total renewables 182.1 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.7 percent.
  - Germany: total renewables 126.6 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 3.9 percent; non-hydro share in electricity 4.9 percent.
  - Spain: total renewables 96 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.9 percent; non-hydro share in electricity 8.1 percent.
  - United States: total renewables 608 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.2 percent.
- Electricity-specific: non-hydro renewable share in electricity in 2004: Spain in excess of 8 percent; Germany about 5 percent; Canada non-hydro’s share in electricity less than 2 percent (hydro dominating).

### Cost-effectiveness: subsidies per ton CO2 displaced
- Selected subsidy costs per ton CO2 displaced (Table 2 summary):
  - France: Biomass €86; Photovoltaic €328; Geothermic €155.
  - Germany: Biomass €195; Photovoltaic €1,200; Hydro €118; Geothermic €163; Wind €167.
  - United Kingdom (composite): €117.
  - Italy (composite): €200.
  - United States: Biomass €39; Biofuels €315; Photovoltaic €49.
  - EU (Kutas and Lindberg (2007)): range €260–3,400.
  - World (Anderson (2006)): Biomass €135; Biofuels €150.
- Anderson (2006) central estimates for biofuels abatement costs:
  - Current: US$250 per ton of carbon (about €55 per ton CO2).
  - Projected to fall to US$100 by 2020 (equivalent to €21 per ton CO2).
  - Projected US$60 by 2050 (equivalent to €13 per ton CO2).
  - Net cost range for 2050: €-75 to +300 per ton of carbon (-20 to +80 Euros per ton of CO2).
- European Commission (2006) assessment: estimated cost to the EU of achieving a 20 percent renewables target by 2020 is in the range €40-60 per ton CO2 displaced.
- Overall observation: subsidy-cost figures are generally far higher than commonly accepted marginal damage costs of CO2 emissions (typically US$10–30 per ton).

### Biofuels: production, tax exemptions, and subsidy magnitudes
- Production dominated by the United States (bioethanol) and Germany (biodiesel).
- Table 3 (2006, selected figures):
  - France: Bioethanol 297 thousand tons; Bioethanol exemption 38 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel 671 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 33 Euro/cents per liter; Total biofuels 968 thousand tons.
  - Germany: Bioethanol 608 thousand tons; Bioethanol exemption 65.5 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel 3,039 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 47–32 Euro/cents per liter; Total biofuels 4,440 thousand tons (includes plant oils).
  - Italy: Bioethanol 0; Biodiesel 223 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 41.3 Euro/cents per liter; Total 223 thousand tons.
  - Spain: Bioethanol 227 thousand tons; exemption 37; Biodiesel 79 thousand tons; exemption 27; Total 306 thousand tons.
  - United Kingdom: Bioethanol 93 thousand tons; exemption 28; Biodiesel 162 thousand tons; exemption 29; Total 255 thousand tons.
  - United States (estimates): Bioethanol 19,000 thousand tons; exemption 15 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel 880 thousand tons; exemption 20 Euro/cents per liter; Total 19,880 thousand tons.
- Koplow (2006) U.S. subsidy estimates for 2006:
  - Total government support to bioethanol about US$6 billion on volumes of 4.9 billion gallons.
  - Support to biodiesel about US$450 million on volumes of 245 million gallons.
  - Predicted minimum subsidies by 2009: US$7.5 billion for bioethanol (on 6 billion gallons) and US$2 billion for biodiesel (on 1.4 billion gallons).
  - Equivalent subsidy rates predicted: US$1.5–2 per gallon gasoline equivalent for both fuels.

### Biofuels share, carbon displacement, and implicit cost
- Biofuels share cited: 4.5 percent (out of a total a volume of about 170 billion gallons).
- Average production cost (subsidy counted relative to amount of carbon displaced):
  - Bioethanol in the United States: close to US$400 per ton CO2 displaced.
  - Cellulosic ethanol (hypothetical): potentially US$100–150 per ton CO2.
  - Current quota price in the EU ETS: about US$20 per ton; Chicago climate exchange for 2007 delivery: about US$4 per ton.
- Carbon displacement fractions:
  - Bioethanol displaces about 40 percent of the carbon in fossil-fuel based motor fuels.
  - Biodiesel displaces about 48 percent.
  - Cellulosic ethanol displacement rates expected to be close to 96 percent.
- US tariff on imported bioethanol:
  - Ad valorem: 2.2 percent.
  - Specific: US$0.1427 per liter.
  - Total support constituting about US$0.60 per gallon, or about US$0.80 per gallon of gasoline equivalent.
  - Tariff exemptions: Central America and the Caribbean (subject to certain restrictions); Canada and Mexico exempted under NAFTA; Brazil not exempted.
- US biodiesel tariff: 1.9 percent.
- EU bioethanol tariff: €0.192 per liter (corresponding to US$1.25 per gallon of petrol equivalent).
  - 101 developing countries are exempted from this tariff; Brazil is not among them.
- EU biodiesel tariff: 6.5 percent (ad valorem).

### EU public support estimates and implicit CO2 costs (Kutas and Lindberg, 2007)
- Calculated average public support to bioethanol and biodiesel in the EU, by support category, 2006 (Million euros; euros per liter; million liters):
  - Total support: Bioethanol 898; Biodiesel 2,436.
  - Total consumption, million liters: Bioethanol 1,740; Biodiesel 4,680.
  - Average support, euros per liter: Bioethanol 0.52; Biodiesel 0.50.
  - Authors’ estimates of total support: Bioethanol 0.58; Biodiesel 0.62.
  - Equivalent support, euros per liter of fuel based on energy content: Bioethanol 0.87; Biodiesel 0.68.
- Support per unit of fossil fuels displaced, by supply category:
  - Support euros per liter of petroleum equivalent: Ethanol from sugar beets 0.87; Ethanol from corn 0.87; Biodiesel from cooking oil 0.68; Biodiesel from rapeseed 0.68.
  - Net gain in non-fossil energy, percent: Ethanol from sugar beets 50–68; Ethanol from corn 22–32; Biodiesel from cooking oil 77–89; Biodiesel from rapeseed 45–63.
  - Support, euros per liter of fossil fuel equivalent displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 1.25–1.70; Ethanol from corn 2.70–3.80; Biodiesel from cooking oil 0.59–0.68; Biodiesel from rapeseed 0.84–1.17.
  - Support, euros per ton CO2 displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 450–620; Ethanol from corn 1,600–3,400; Biodiesel from cooking oil 260–270; Biodiesel from rapeseed 750–990.
  - Support, US$ per ton CO2 displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 590–820; Ethanol from corn 2,130–4,520; Biodiesel from cooking oil 340–360; Biodiesel from rapeseed 990–1,300.
- Interpretation:
  - Costs per ton net reduction in CO2 emissions within the EU are extremely high for ethanol produced from corn, and lowest for biodiesel produced from cooking oil (supply limited).
  - For biodiesel from rapeseed (common in the EU), costs are in the range US$1000 per ton of CO2 displaced.

### Germany: renewables overview, feed-in tariffs, and electricity context
- Germany (2006, Table 6 figures):
  - Total, renewable energies: 202 TWh.
  - Electricity generation: 73.9 TWh (Wind 30.5 TWh; Hydro 21.6 TWh; Biogenics 19.7 TWh; PV 2 TWh).
  - Heat generation: 89.3 TWh (Biomass 84.1 TWh; Solar 3.3 TWh; Geothermal 1.9 TWh).
  - Biofuels: 39.9 TWh (Biodiesel 28.9 TWh; Bioethanol 3.6 TWh; Vegetable oil 7.4 TWh).
  - Investment, € billion: Total 11.6 (Electricity generation 4.5; Heat generation 3).
  - Revenue, € billion: Total 11.3 (Electricity generation 6.6; Heat generation 20.7; Biofuels 3.3).
  - Revenue per kWh Supplied, €: Electricity generation overall 0.089; PV 0.550; Heat generation (biomass) 0.017; Total, renewable energies 0.056.
  - Emissions Avoided, Million tons CO2: Electricity generation overall 68.1; Biofuels 12.7; Total, renewable energies 101.5.
- Electricity context (2005):
  - Germany generated 613 TWh of electricity in 2005.
  - Generation mix in 2005: Coal and lignite 49.8 percent; Nuclear 26.6 percent; Gas 11.3 percent; Renewables (including hydro power) 10.5 percent.
  - Federal Government phase out of nuclear generation capacity to be completed by 2030.
  - Renewable supply expected to increase by 75 percent since 2000 by 2010 (average annual rate of almost 12 percent).
  - Targets: at least 12.5 percent by 2010, and 20 percent by 2020.

### Feed-in tariffs (EEG 2004) and differentiation by technology
- Features: Guarantees rate for production, priority access to the grid, obliges customers to purchase output.
- Payments to energy producers under scheme: about €4.4 billion in 2005 for 44 TWh of electricity (average rate about €0.10 per kWh).
- Estimated by 2012: feed-in tariff will provide 89.4 TWh with customer payments about €9.4 billion, average rate €0.105 per kWh; BMU projects 82 TWh and payments €8.1 billion.
- Between 2000 and 2012, total tariff payments for an anticipated 650 TWh of renewable energy production expected to amount to some €68 billion, including additional costs of €30–36 billion.
- Feed-in tariff differentiation by technology (Table 7, 2006, euro/cents/kWh and terms):
  - Large hydropower (5–150 MW): 3.62–7.51; Guaranteed term 15 years; Yearly degression rate 1.0 percent.
  - Small hydropower (5< MW): 6.65–9.67; 30 years; 0 percent degression.
  - Biomass (<20 MW): 3.78–21.16; 20 years; 1.5 percent degression.
  - Geothermal (<20 MW): 7.16–15.00; 20 years; 1.0 percent degression (starting in 2010).
  - Wind energy (onshore): 8.36/5.28; 20 years; 2.0 percent degression.
  - Wind energy (offshore): 9.10/6.19; 20 years; 2.0 percent degression (starting in 2008).
  - Photovoltaics: 40.60–56.80; 20 years; 6.5 percent degression.
- Observations:
  - Solar (PV) receives dramatically higher average electricity prices and is expected to provide 4.5 percent of total renewable electricity while taking up nearly 20 percent of total fees.

### Supplementary payments for CHP and feed-in-related payments
- Supplementary payments for electricity exports to the grid (€ cents/kWh, Table 8 excerpts):
  - Existing old CHP plant:
    - 2002: 1.53; 2003: 1.53; 2004: 1.38; 2005: 1.38; 2006: 0.97.
  - Existing new CHP plant:
    - 2002: 1.53; 2003: 1.53; 2004: 1.38; 2005: 1.38; 2006: 1.23; 2007: 1.23; 2008: 0.82; 2009: 0.56.
  - Modernised CHP Plant:
    - 2002: 1.74; 2003: 1.74; 2004: 1.74; 2005: 1.69; 2006: 1.69; 2007: 1.64; 2008: 1.64; 2009: 1.59; 2010: 1.59.
  - New small-scale CHP plant between >50 and 2000 kWe:
    - 2002: 2.56; 2003: 2.56; 2004: 2.40; 2005: 2.40; 2006: 2.25; 2007: 2.25; 2008: 2.10; 2009: 2.10; 2010: 1.94.
  - New small-scale CHP plant ≤50 kWe, which start continuous operation before the end of 2005, and fuel cell units:
    - 5,11 cent for a period of 10 years beginning from the start of continuous operation.
  - Supplementary payments for small scale CHP plant up to 2 MWe will only be made up to a total electricity export of 14 TWh from these plants.
- Note: Table 8 source: German Ministry of Environment (2007).

### EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) and implicit subsidies to carbon-intensive producers
- EU ETS design intent: create disincentives for carbon intensive electricity generation by limiting overall emissions as defined by the National Allocation Plan (NAP).
- Allocations and effects:
  - Phase I (2005–07): large fossil-fuel based electricity generators received generous free emissions rights.
  - Phase II (2008–12): free allocations still very substantial, amounting to at least 90 percent of 2000–05 emissions.
  - Future free emissions rights perceived as a function of current emissions, reducing incentives to abate.
- Quantitative details (Germany):
  - Under Phase I, German electricity generators received approximately 394 million tons CO2 in annual emissions rights.
  - Phase I German NAP limited average annual emissions under the scheme to 499MtCO2 between 2005-07; an estimated 79 percent went to electricity generators.
  - Market value of emissions rights averaged roughly €15 per ton CO2.
  - Based on these assumptions, the annual implicit subsidy is roughly €5.9bn.
  - Using the Stern Review’s (2007) US$30 per ton CO2 social damage cost implies an annual implicit subsidy of €9bn.
- Conclusion: free allocations and exemptions under ETS have generated implicit subsidies to carbon intensive sectors substantially greater than explicit renewable support costs.

### R&D, public finance programs, and deployment support
- EU-level R&D:
  - FP6 (2002–06) budget for non-nuclear technologies approximately €815m; development of nuclear technologies €1.23bn.
  - Overall FP budgets have increased by over 250 percent since the first program.
  - Share of energy-related research expenditure within the program fell from 50 percent to 14 percent.
- German federal R&D trends:
  - Overall support for energy-related research fell sharply—by two-thirds or more since the early 1980s—largely due to reduced nuclear expenditure.
  - Federal funding trend:
    - Funding increased from about €0.6 billion to about €0.7 billion between 2005–08 under the 5th energy research program 2005–08.
    - Rises to €0.8 billion between 2006–09 under the ‘€6 billion’ and ‘high tech’ strategies (much increase goes to nuclear dismantling).
  - BMU reported renewables R&D expenditure in 2006 was €98 million (wind €15.7 million; solar €32.3 million).
- Deployment and finance programs (selected highlights):
  - Producing Solar Power Program (introduced 2005): low-interest loans from KfW; private projects up to €50,000; between 2005 and July 2006, >25,000 loans, total €784 million and capacity 199 MW in PV systems.
  - Market Incentive Program: budget €190 million in 2002 and 2003, rising to €213 million in 2007; since 2000 supported ~625,000 projects with funding €827 million; estimated total investment triggered €6.5 billion.
  - ERP-Environment and Energy-Saving Programs: loans since 1990–2005 totaling €10.7 billion.
  - 100 000 Roofs Program (1999–2003): funded 55,000 installations, capacity 261 MW, cost ~€560m.
- Note: precise extent and efficiency of programs complicated where support is bundled with heat/efficiency objectives.

### Regional (Länder) support and historical federal-state funding (1991–2001)
- Annual support by category (selected figures, € million):
  - Wind power total 1991–2001: 259.6 (1991: 13.2; 2001: 2.4).
  - Solarthermal total 1991–2001: 234.6 (1991: 5.7; 2001: 12.6).
  - Photovoltaic total 1991–2001: 163.7 (1991: 5.4; 2001: 27.9).
  - Biomass total 1991–2001: 295.0 (1991: 2.8; 2001: 37.1).
  - R & D total 1991–2001: 334.4 (1991: 12.5; 2001: 23.1).
  - Total (combined) 1991–2001: 1,785.5; Annual totals example: 1991: 96.9; 1995: 181.6; 2001: 151.9.
- Source: German Ministry of Education and Research (2005).

### Policies affecting inputs, taxes, and fossil fuel subsidies
- Mineral and environmental taxes reformed since 1999 to provide incentives for energy saving; coal generally exempt.
- Subsidies for domestic coal extraction: cut from €4.7 billion in 1998 to €2.7 billion in 2005; further falling to €5.7 billion in aggregate for 2006–08.
- Reported micro-level allowances in 2005:
  - Allowances on electricity fuels: €3.9 billion.
  - Allowances on heating fuels: €2.3 billion.
- BMU macro-fiscal analysis (2005/2006) suggests higher macro-fiscal costs:
  - Electricity exemptions: €6.2 billion.
  - Heating fuel exemptions: €4.8 billion.

### Biofuels for transport (Germany specifics)
- Germany: world’s largest producer of biodiesel and biological oils for fuel purposes; main overall biofuels producer within the EU.
- Production figures and projections:
  - Biodiesel production in 2006: about 3 million tons.
  - Bioethanol production in 2006: about 600 000 tons.
  - Biodiesel production estimated to reach about 4.2 million tons within the next three years.
  - Bioethanol production rose from about 20,000 tons in 2004; plans could increase capacity up to about 2 million tons within few years.
- Government targets:
  - Preliminary target market share for biofuels: 5.75 percent by 2010.
  - Further increase to 10 percent by 2020.
- Forms of public support: output support; excise tax exemptions; support to energy crops; rural development support; capital grants; subsidies to feedstock; R&D support; support to consumption.
- Preliminary assessment: public support to biofuels in Germany is an expensive means of reducing petroleum use and German carbon emissions.

### Effectiveness caveats and policy implications
- Table 2 estimates do not provide a final verdict; costs are improving and subsidies may be justified if fundamental technological breakthroughs occur.
- Two main reasons for high biofuel abatement cost:
  - Biofuels are less energy-efficient than gasoline (more gallons needed to replace a gallon of gasoline).
  - Net carbon displacement is less than gross displacement because biofuels production is on average relatively carbon intensive.
- Policy implication:
  - When fossil fuels are properly taxed for carbon emissions, an additional subsidy for renewables is not justified solely on carbon-replacement grounds.
  - Subsidies may be justified for R&D spillovers and energy security considerations.
- Policy phasing logic:
  - If production and R&D externalities are the main motivation, subsidies should be phased out as technologies mature and become competitive (given correction for environmental externality effects).
- Example policy shift:
  - Germany began stepping down preferential treatment of biodiesel by imposing an excise tax of €0.06 per liter in August 2006, to be stepped up gradually to €0.45 per liter in 2012.
  - Indications that German biodiesel production is no longer growing, and may be falling.

### High-level assessment and recommendations
- No general efficient pricing of emissions currently exists; in absence of correct emissions pricing, subsidies to renewables may offset under-priced emissions.
- Optimal subsidy level for renewables is uncertain; feed-in tariff expenditures are large and rising, with photovoltaics receiving high support relative to output.
- Public support to R&D can be justified because private appropriability of social returns is limited, but probabilities and timing of breakthroughs are uncertain.
- Distortions from direct or implicit subsidies to fossil fuels (including free ETS allocations) should be discontinued; while they remain, they add partial justification for renewable subsidies.
- Biodiesel and bioethanol for road transport are heavily supported: subsidy rates at least in the range €0.5–0.7 per liter in the EU, and about US$2 per gallon for bioethanol (fuel-equivalents of petrol) in the United States.
- Recommendation for further work: quantify efficiency of different policy measures more precisely and extend policy analysis; authors intend to contribute further analysis.

*Source PDF filename: _wp07299 - References; Canonical source URL: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf*

### 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD

### _wp07299 - 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD

### Tables — major data items and classifications
- 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD Countries, 2004
- 2. Average Cost, Euros Per Ton of CO2 Displaced, When Fossil Fuels Are Replaced with Renewable Energies
- 3. Production Volumes (thousand tons), and Values of Tax Exemptions (Euro/cents per liter), for Biofuel and Biodiesel in Major Eurpopean Countries and the United States
- 4. Calculated Average Public Support to Bioethanol and Biodiesel in the EU, by Support Category, 2006
- 5. Calculated Average Public Support to Bioethanol and Biodiesel in the EU Per Unit of Fossil Fuels Displaecd, by Supply Category, 2006
- 6. Overview of Main Renewable Energies, Germany, 2006
- 7. Feed in Tariffs by Technology, 2006
- 8. Supplementary Payments for Electricity Exports to the Grid
- 9. Breakdown of German Federal Government Energy R&D by Research Theme/Ministry 1974–2000
- 10. Combined Federal States (Länder) Support for Deployment of Renewable Energy Technologies

### Figures — visual distributions, cost-effectiveness, forecasts, and support trends
- 1. Distributions of Renewable Energy in Major OECD Countries, 2004
- 2. Cost-Effectiveness in Carbon Abatement, Different Uses of Biomass
- 3. Forecast Quantities and Fees of Feed-In Tariffs, by 2012
- 4. German Federal Government Support for Basic R&D, 1974–2007

*Source: _wp07299 - 1. Renewable Energy, More Detailed Source Classification, Major OECD (PDF chapter/section).*

### References .............................................................................................................

### _wp07299 - References

### Introduction and scope
- Paper addresses issues at the intersection of climate and energy policy, focusing on the choice between GHG-limiting instruments (carbon taxes or cap-and-trade) and policies to promote renewable alternatives.
- Two externality sets identified:
  - Global negative externalities from GHG emissions, leading to excessive global emissions.
  - Appropriation problem for rents from technological development of new (renewable) energies, leading to underinvestment in R&D.
- Main purpose: analyze “total costs to society” of renewables support, including the true cost of reducing carbon emissions by substituting an equivalent amount of fossil fuels.
- Key conceptual challenges noted:
  - Uncertain costs of climate change and benefits of avoidance.
  - Difficulty in enumerating all cost components of renewable production and public support.
  - Large uncertainties in renewables R&D and learning-by-doing; future technologies and costs unknown.

### Justifications for public support to renewables
- Three primary welfare-justifying reasons:
  - Carbon-emissions reduction: renewables are “carbon neutral” in their use; public subsidy is a separate argument only when fossil fuels are not properly taxed for carbon emissions.
  - Technology spillovers and learning-by-doing: R&D and deployment generate spillovers not fully appropriable by developers, justifying public support.
  - Energy-importing countries’ interest in reducing fossil-fuel import dependence for security of supply; private agents may underprovide supply security.
- Additional strategic motive: major petroleum-importing countries may seek to exercise market power (via demand reduction, taxation, alternative supply) to affect petroleum prices, but this provides less global-welfare justification for renewables support.
- Trade-offs and costs of subsidies:
  - Foregone tax revenue for other public uses.
  - Subsidies can stimulate overall energy demand; could be counterproductive relative to policies that discourage energy demand.

### Forms of subsidies and support instruments
- Enumerated subsidy types (exact typology preserved):
  - Direct lump-sum payments to renewable producers (possibly location-dependent).
  - Output-tied payments: fixed support per unit of renewable output.
  - Support to current factor inputs (e.g., agricultural subsidies for biofuel feedstocks).
  - Capital support: subsidized financing or direct capital purchase support.
  - Guaranteed producer prices (feed-in-tariff schemes) guaranteeing minimum prices for delivered electricity for set future periods (up to 20 years).
  - Implicit support via avoided taxes (loss of potential government revenue), e.g., motor fuel excise exemptions and corporate tax credits.
  - Government support to renewable developers’ R&D (including competitive research programs such as EU Framework Programs).

### Renewables supply and country-level support (major advanced economies)
- EU target: indicative target for 22 percent of all electricity generation in the EU to be based on renewable energy by 2010 (against 14 percent today, mainly hydropower based).
- Germany:
  - Renewables (apart from hydropower) make up 6.4 percent of overall energy consumption in Germany.
  - Share of renewables in electricity generation is 10.2 percent; in heat generation 5.4 percent; in fuels 3.6 percent.
  - Multiple mechanisms: grants, feed-in tariffs, reduced-rate loans, preferential tax treatment; detailed in Chapter 3 (not repeated here).
- United Kingdom:
  - Capital grant support for offshore wind and small-scale technologies up to a budgetary limit from central government funds.
  - Large certificate scheme funded through power utility rate increases (10 percent by 2010, increasing to 15 percent by 2015).
  - Estimated cost: GBP1 billion by 2010 for the certificate scheme.
- Japan:
  - In 2002, total central government support was ¥145 billion.
  - Small portfolio standard scheme: 1.35 percent by 2010.
- Canada:
  - Support mainly at the province level; outside traditional sources (hydro and biomass) support is small.
  - Renewables represent about 60 percent of total electricity supply and 35 percent of overall energy supply (2004, driven largely by hydropower).
- United States:
  - Energy Policy Act of 2005 combined with agricultural subsidy policies imply substantial favors to renewables; biofuels particularly favored.
  - Repeal of federal and local fuel excise taxes for alcohol-based fuels and biodiesel corresponds to an implicit subsidy of approximately US$12 billion for the period 2007–11 (Metcalf (2006)).
  - Corporate tax credits and state-level supports further incentivize wind- and bio-based power; solar remains far from competitive because of higher cost.
  - Energy Policy Act plus other policies also imply substantial direct or implicit subsidies to traditional fossil fuels, making the U.S. environment less favorable to renewables relative to Europe.

### Shares and composition of renewables (2004, major OECD countries)
- Renewables as a whole (including hydro) notable in some countries; when excluding hydro, non-hydro renewables are moderate.
- Highest overall shares in energy (non-hydro excluded): France 4.7 percent, Spain 4.4 percent, Germany 3.9 percent (2004, primary energy consumption basis).
- Specific country indicators from 2004 (figures cited):
  - Canada: renewables 35 percent of overall energy; total renewables ~560 TWh equivalents; hydro 353 TWh.
  - France: total renewables 182.1 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.7 percent.
  - Germany: total renewables 126.6 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 3.9 percent; non-hydro share in electricity 4.9 percent.
  - Spain: total renewables 96 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.9 percent; non-hydro share in electricity 8.1 percent.
  - United States: total renewables 608 TWh equivalents; overall share in energy 6.2 percent.
- Electricity-specific: non-hydro renewable share in electricity in 2004: Spain in excess of 8 percent; Germany about 5 percent; Canada non-hydro’s share in electricity less than 2 percent (hydro dominating).

### Cost-effectiveness: subsidies per ton CO2 displaced (Table 2 summary)
- OECD and other estimates report subsidy costs per ton of CO2 displaced when fossil fuels are replaced by respective renewables. Key reported figures:
  - France: Biomass €86 per ton CO2 displaced; Photovoltaic €328; Geothermic €155.
  - Germany: Biomass €195; Photovoltaic €1,200; Hydro €118; Geothermic €163; Wind €167.
  - United Kingdom and Italy: generalized composite estimates for all renewables at €117 (U.K.) and €200 (Italy) respectively (noted as composite).
  - United States: Biomass €39; Biofuels €315 (based on Koplow (2006)); Photovoltaic €49.
  - EU (Kutas and Lindberg (2007)): range €260–3,400 (presumably across technologies).
  - World (Anderson (2006)): Biomass €135; Biofuels €150.
- Overall observation: these subsidy-cost figures are generally far higher than commonly accepted marginal damage costs of CO2 emissions (typically US$10–30 per ton).
- Anderson (2006) central estimates for global average cost of abating carbon through biofuels:
  - Current: US$250 per ton of carbon (about €55 per ton CO2).
  - Projected to fall to US$100 by 2020 (equivalent to €21 per ton CO2).
  - Projected US$60 by 2050 (equivalent to €13 per ton CO2).
  - Anderson’s net cost range for 2050: €-75 to +300 per ton of carbon (-20 to +80 Euros per ton of CO2).
- European Commission (2006) assessment: estimated cost to the EU of achieving a 20 percent renewables target by 2020 is in the range €40-60 per ton CO2 displaced (noted as generally far lower than numbers in Table 2).
- ECMT (2006) analysis (Figure 2) highlights large cost differences across uses of biomass and other renewables; direct biomass use for heat shows substantial cost advantage versus biofuels and many electricity applications, with costs sensitive to oil price assumptions ($30/bbl vs $60/bbl).

### Biofuels: production, tax exemptions, and subsidy magnitudes
- Production dominated by the United States (bioethanol) and Germany (biodiesel).
- Table 3 (2006, summarized):
  - France: Bioethanol production 297 thousand tons; Bioethanol exemption 38 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel production 671 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 33 Euro/cents per liter; Total biofuels production 968 thousand tons.
  - Germany: Bioethanol production 608 thousand tons; Bioethanol exemption 65.5 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel production 3,039 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 47–32 Euro/cents per liter; Total biofuels production 4,440 thousand tons (includes plant oils).
  - Italy: Bioethanol production 0; Bioethanol exemption 0; Biodiesel production 223 thousand tons; Biodiesel exemption 41.3 Euro/cents per liter; Total 223 thousand tons.
  - Spain: Bioethanol 227 thousand tons; exemption 37; Biodiesel 79 thousand tons; exemption 27; Total 306 thousand tons.
  - United Kingdom: Bioethanol 93 thousand tons; exemption 28; Biodiesel 162 thousand tons; exemption 29; Total 255 thousand tons.
  - United States (estimates): Bioethanol 19,000 thousand tons; exemption 15 Euro/cents per liter; Biodiesel 880 thousand tons; exemption 20 Euro/cents per liter; Total biofuels production 19,880 thousand tons.
- Koplow (2006) U.S. subsidy estimates for 2006:
  - Total government support to bioethanol about US$6 billion on volumes of 4.9 billion gallons.
  - Support to biodiesel about US$450 million on volumes of 245 million gallons.
  - Predicted minimum subsidies by 2009: US$7.5 billion for bioethanol (on 6 billion gallons) and US$2 billion for biodiesel (on 1.4 billion gallons).
  - Equivalent subsidy rates predicted: US$1.5–2 per gallon gasoline equivalent for both fuels.
  - If total biofuels volume reaches 7.5 billion gallons by 2009, the biofuels share in total U.S. motor fuel consumption will reach about (text cuts off at that point).

### Effectiveness caveats and concluding notes
- Table 2 and related estimates do not provide a final verdict on social value of renewables; costs are improving and subsidies may be justified if fundamental technological breakthroughs occur.
- Two main reasons for high biofuel abatement cost highlighted:
  - Biofuels are less energy-efficient than gasoline (more gallons needed to replace a gallon of gasoline).
  - Net carbon displacement is less than gross displacement because biofuels production is on average relatively carbon intensive.
- Policy implication reiterated: when fossil fuels are properly taxed for carbon emissions, an additional subsidy for renewables is not justified solely on the carbon-replacement ground; subsidies may be justified for R&D spillovers and for energy security considerations.

*Italic: Source PDF filename: _wp07299 - References; Canonical source URL: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf*

### 4.5 percent (out of a total a volume of about 170 billion gallons), or a somewhat higher share

### _wp07299 - 4.5 percent (out of a total a volume of about 170 billion gallons), or a somewhat higher share

### Biofuels share, carbon displacement, and implicit cost
- Biofuels share cited: 4.5 percent (out of a total a volume of about 170 billion gallons), or a somewhat higher share than in Germany, which has the highest biofuels share today among the G-7 countries (3.6 percent).
- Average production cost (subsidy counted relative to amount of carbon displaced):
  - Bioethanol in the United States: close to US$400 per ton CO2 displaced.
  - (Hypothetical) cellulosic ethanol: potentially lower, in the range US$100–150 per ton CO2 (against a current quota price in the EU ETS of about US$20 per ton; and on the Chicago climate exchange for 2007 delivery, about US$4 per ton).
- Carbon displacement fractions:
  - Bioethanol displaces about 40 percent of the carbon in fossil-fuel based motor fuels.
  - Biodiesel displaces about 48 percent.
  - Cellulosic ethanol displacement rates expected to be close to 96 percent.
- One reason for high subsidy rates per ton CO2 displaced is that biofuels only displace a fraction of the carbon in fossil-fuel based motor fuels: about 40 percent for bioethanol, and about 48 percent for biodiesel.

### US support, tariffs, and effective subsidy levels
- US tariff on imported bioethanol:
  - Ad valorem: 2.2 percent.
  - Specific: US$0.1427 per liter.
- Total support constituting about US$0.60 per gallon, or about US$0.80 per gallon of gasoline equivalent.
- Tariff exemptions:
  - Central America and the Caribbean (subject to certain restrictions) are exempted.
  - Canada and Mexico exempted under NAFTA.
  - Brazil is not exempted.
- US biodiesel tariff: 1.9 percent (ad valorem).
- Note: biodiesel import threat into the United States judged limited as there is no major biodiesel producer apart from the United States in the western hemisphere.

### EU tariffs, exemptions, and justification issues
- EU bioethanol tariff: €0.192 per liter (corresponding to US$1.25 per gallon of petrol equivalent).
- 101 developing countries are exempted from this tariff; Brazil is not among them.
- EU biodiesel tariff: 6.5 percent (ad valorem).
- Difficulties justifying high bioethanol tariffs on purely environmental grounds; alternative/additional motivations discussed:
  - Energy security purpose (shielding against petroleum supply disruptions).
  - Positive externalities from facilitating development of future and more efficient energy technologies.
- Distinction emphasized between subsidies directed at:
  - Corn-based ethanol production (current US schemes) — gives little incentive for alternative developments.
  - Technologies based on general biomass (grass and wood fibers) — currently immature with potentially enormous upside, but current plans do not embed subsidies for such technologies.
- Policy phasing logic:
  - If production and R&D externalities are the main motivation, subsidies should be phased out as technologies mature and become competitive (given correction for environmental externality effects).
- Example of policy shift:
  - Germany began stepping down preferential treatment of biodiesel by imposing an excise tax of €0.06 per liter in August 2006, to be stepped up gradually to €0.45 per liter in 2012 (at which point the differential treatment will have been essentially eliminated).
  - Indications are that German production of biodiesel is no longer growing, and may be falling.

### EU public support estimates and implicit CO2 costs (Kutas and Lindberg, 2007)
- Calculated average public support to bioethanol and biodiesel in the EU, by support category, 2006 (Million euros, and euros per liter):
  - Direct output-linked support: Bioethanol 829; Biodiesel 2,131.
  - Support for value-adding factors: Bioethanol 39; Biodiesel 270.
  - Payments for crops on set-aside land: Bioethanol 29; Biodiesel 232.
  - Payments under energy crop scheme: Bioethanol 10; Biodiesel 38.
  - R&D support: Bioethanol 30; Biodiesel 35.
  - Total support: Bioethanol 898; Biodiesel 2,436.
  - Total consumption, million liters: Bioethanol 1,740; Biodiesel 4,680.
  - Average support, euros per liter: Bioethanol 0.52; Biodiesel 0.50.
  - Authors’ estimates of total support: Bioethanol 0.58; Biodiesel 0.62.
  - Equivalent support, euros per liter of fuel based on energy content: Bioethanol 0.87; Biodiesel 0.68.
- Calculated average public support in the EU, per unit of fossil fuels displaced, by supply category, 2006:
  - Support euros per liter of petroleum equivalent: Ethanol from sugar beets 0.87; Ethanol from corn 0.87; Biodiesel from cooking oil 0.68; Biodiesel from rapeseed 0.68.
  - Net gain in non-fossil energy, percent: Ethanol from sugar beets 50–68; Ethanol from corn 22–32; Biodiesel from cooking oil 77–89; Biodiesel from rapeseed 45–63.
  - Support, euros per liter of fossil fuel equivalent displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 1.25–1.70; Ethanol from corn 2.70–3.80; Biodiesel from cooking oil 0.59–0.68; Biodiesel from rapeseed 0.84–1.17.
  - Support, euros per ton CO2 displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 450–620; Ethanol from corn 1,600–3,400; Biodiesel from cooking oil 260–270; Biodiesel from rapeseed 750–990.
  - Support, US$ per ton CO2 displaced: Ethanol from sugar beets 590–820; Ethanol from corn 2,130–4,520; Biodiesel from cooking oil 340–360; Biodiesel from rapeseed 990–1,300.
- Interpretation:
  - Costs per ton net reduction in CO2 emissions within the EU are extremely high for ethanol produced from corn, and lowest for biodiesel produced from cooking oil (supply limited).
  - For the most common product in the EU, biodiesel from rapeseed, costs are in the range US$1000 per ton of CO2 displaced; or in the same range as for Photovoltaics for Germany (as reported elsewhere in the source).

### Germany: further aspects of renewables policies and electricity
- Germany: total primary energy supply of 345 million tons of oil equivalent in 2005 (about 20 percent of total EU supply and emissions).
- Domestic commitments: raise shares to 12.5 percent for electricity and 6.5 percent for road transport by 2010.
- Policies and instruments affecting carbon intensity: EU ETS, feed-in tariffs, biofuels obligations, capital grants, fuel excise tax exemptions, R&D programs, and demand-side policies.
- Renewable energy production overview, Germany 2006 (Table 6 figures):
  - Total Energy Supply, TWh by category:
    - Electricity generation: 73.9 TWh.
      - Wind: 30.5 TWh.
      - Hydro: 21.6 TWh.
      - Biogenics: 19.7 TWh.
      - PV: 2 TWh.
    - Heat generation: 89.3 TWh.
      - Biomass: 84.1 TWh.
      - Solar: 3.3 TWh.
      - Geothermal: 1.9 TWh.
    - Biofuels: 39.9 TWh.
      - Biodiesel: 28.9 TWh.
      - Bioethanol: 3.6 TWh.
      - Vegetable oil: 7.4 TWh.
    - Total, renewable energies: 202 TWh.
  - Investment, € billion:
    - Electricity generation: 4.5.
      - Wind: 2.9.
      - Hydro: 0.1.
      - Biogenics: 1.4.
      - PV: 4.3.
    - Heat generation: 3.
      - Biomass: 1.5.
      - Solar: 0.9.
      - Geothermal: 0.6.
    - Biofuels: (not separately listed for investment).
    - Total: 11.6.
  - Revenue, € billion:
    - Electricity generation: 6.6.
      - Wind: 2.7.
      - Hydro: 1.2.
      - Biogenics: 1.6.
      - PV: 1.1.
    - Heat generation: 20.7.
      - Biomass: 1.4.
    - Biofuels: 3.3.
    - Total: 11.3.
  - Revenue per kWh Supplied, €:
    - Electricity generation overall: 0.089.
      - Hydro: 0.056.
      - Biogenics: 0.081.
      - PV: 0.550.
    - Heat generation (biomass): 0.017.
    - Biofuels: 0.083.
    - Total, renewable energies: 0.056.
  - Emissions Avoided, Million tons CO2:
    - Electricity generation overall: 68.1.
    - Biofuels: 12.7.
    - Total, renewable energies: 101.5.
- Electricity generation context:
  - Germany generated 613 TWh of electricity in 2005.
  - Electricity consumption shares in 2004: Industry 45.5 percent, Residential 27.4 percent, Commercial and public 22.4 percent.
  - Overall consumption growth: average of 1.4 percent annually over the last decade, projected to stabilize and fall slightly toward 2030.
  - Generation mix in 2005: Coal and lignite 49.8 percent, Nuclear 26.6 percent, Gas 11.3 percent, Renewables (including hydro power) 10.5 percent.
  - Coal share fell from 62 percent in 1985 to nearly 50 percent in 2005.
  - Federal Government has begun a phase out of nuclear generation capacity, to be completed by 2030.
  - Renewable supply expected to increase by 75 percent since 2000 by 2010 (an average annual rate of almost 12 percent).
  - Targets: at least 12.5 percent by 2010, and 20 percent by 2020.
- Feed-in tariffs (EEG 2004) features:
  - Guarantees rate for production, priority access to the grid, and obliges customers to purchase output.
  - Payments to energy producers under this scheme were about €4.4 billion in 2005 for the production of 44 TWh of electricity (equivalent to an average rate of about €0.10 per kWh).
  - Estimated by 2012: feed-in tariff will provide 89.4 TWh of electricity with customer payments amounting to about €9.4 billion, at an average rate of €0.105 per kWh.
  - BMU projects somewhat lower figures: 82 TWh of electricity and payments of €8.1 billion, equivalent to just under €0.01 per kWh.
  - Between 2000 and 2012, total tariff payments for an anticipated 650 TWh of renewable energy production are expected to amount to some €68 billion, including additional costs of €30–36 billion.
- Feed-in tariff differentiation by technology (Table 7, 2006):
  - Large hydropower (5–150 MW): 3.62–7.51 euro/cents/kWh; Guaranteed term 15 years; Yearly degression rate 1.0 percent.
  - Small hydropower (5< MW): 6.65–9.67; 30 years; 0 percent degression.
  - Biomass (<20 MW): 3.78–21.16; 20 years; 1.5 percent degression.
  - Geothermal (<20 MW): 7.16–15.00; 20 years; 1.0 percent degression (starting in 2010).
  - Wind energy (onshore): 8.36/5.28 1/; 20 years; 2.0 percent degression.
  - Wind energy (offshore): 9.10/6.19 1/; 20 years; 2.0 percent degression (starting in 2008).
  - Photovoltaics: 40.60–56.80; 20 years; 6.5 percent degression.
  - Note: Installations receive the first rate given (the initial tariff) for X years, then the second rate given (the basic tariff) for the remainder (20-X); X depends on the quality of the site.
- Observations on tariff differentiation:
  - Solar (PV) enjoys dramatically higher average electricity prices than other technologies and is expected to provide 4.5 percent of total renewable electricity while taking up nearly 20 percent of the total fees.
  - Justification includes immaturity of solar and desire to spur development and diffusion of PV technologies, but extent of differentiation may imply not fully efficient production and R&D incentives.
- Combined heat and power (CHP):
  - Germany employs feed-in tariffs for CHP technologies under the 2002 Kraft-Wärme-Kopplungs-Gesetz.
  - Objective: reduce CO2 emissions by 23 million tons annually over the period 2000–10, in combination with a voluntary agreement with the industrial sector.
  - Current tariff scheme summarized with payments for exported electricity produced using CHP currently between 1.23 and (text cuts off).

*Italic: Source PDF chapter content provided.*

### 2.25 Cent/kWh.

### _wp07299 - 2.25 Cent/kWh.

### Feed-in Tariffs and Supplementary Payments
- Figure 3: Forecast Quantities and Fees of Feed-in Tariffs, by 2012 (Source: International Energy Agency (2007b)).
- Table 8. Supplementary Payments for Electricity Exports to the Grid (€ cents/kWh):
  - Existing old CHP plant (Start of operation before 31/12/89):
    - 2002: 1.53
    - 2003: 1.53
    - 2004: 1.38
    - 2005: 1.38
    - 2006: 0.97
  - Existing new CHP plant (Start of operation between 31/12/89 and the date when the new Law comes into effect):
    - 2002: 1.53
    - 2003: 1.53
    - 2004: 1.38
    - 2005: 1.38
    - 2006: 1.23
    - 2007: 1.23
    - 2008: 0.82
    - 2009: 0.56
  - Modernised CHP Plant (Start of operation after the new Law came into effect):
    - 2002: 1.74
    - 2003: 1.74
    - 2004: 1.74
    - 2005: 1.69
    - 2006: 1.69
    - 2007: 1.64
    - 2008: 1.64
    - 2009: 1.59
    - 2010: 1.59
  - New small-scale CHP plant between >50 and 2000 kWe:
    - 2002: 2.56
    - 2003: 2.56
    - 2004: 2.40
    - 2005: 2.40
    - 2006: 2.25
    - 2007: 2.25
    - 2008: 2.10
    - 2009: 2.10
    - 2010: 1.94
  - New small-scale CHP plant ≤50 kWe, which start continuous operation before the end of 2005, and fuel cell units:
    - 5,11 cent for a period of 10 years beginning from the start of continuous operation
  - Supplementary payments for small scale CHP plant up to 2 MWe (this includes also units <50 kWe) will only be made up to a total electricity export of 14 TWh from these plants.
- Source for Table 8: German Ministry of Environment (2007).

### EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) and Carbon Incentives
- Design and intent:
  - The EU ETS is designed to create disincentives for carbon intensive electricity generation by limiting overall emissions as defined by the National Allocation Plan (NAP).
  - Scarcity of emissions rights across the EU increases the cost of carbon intensive production and may create long-run incentives for capital substitution.
- Allocations and effects:
  - Under Phase I (2005–07), large fossil-fuel based electricity generators (particularly coal) received generous free emissions rights.
  - Under Phase II (2008–12), free allocations are still very substantial, amounting to at least 90 percent of 2000–05 emissions.
  - Likely expectation effects: future free emissions rights perceived as a function of current emissions, reducing incentives to abate.
- Quantitative details and implicit subsidy estimates:
  - Under Phase I, German electricity generators have received approximately 394 million tons CO2 in annual emissions rights.
    - Footnote: The Phase I German NAP limited average annual emissions under the scheme to 499MtCO2 between 2005-07 of which an estimated 79 percent went to electricity generators.
  - The market value of these emissions rights has fluctuated, averaging roughly €15 per ton CO2.
  - Based on these assumptions, the annual implicit subsidy is roughly €5.9bn.
  - Using the Stern Review’s (2007) US$30 per ton CO2 assessed social damage cost of emissions implies an annual implicit subsidy of €9bn.
- Conclusion:
  - Implementing the EU ETS in ways inconsistent with the ‘polluter pays’ principle has resulted in new and entrenched implicit subsidies to carbon intensive energy sectors in the EU, which are substantially greater in magnitude than the explicit costs of the feed in tariffs promoting substitute technologies.

### Nuclear Phase-Out Decision and Supply Implications
- The German Federal Government decision in 1998 to phase out German nuclear generation capacity by 2030 was motivated by political and public concerns.
- International Energy Agency (2007) assessment:
  - A reversal of the phase-out decision coupled with refurbishment of nuclear assets would substantially promote secure supplies and reduce overall costs of mitigating carbon emissions.
- Trade-offs:
  - Shortfall from nuclear close-down might be bridged with greater use of renewables, natural gas, and higher energy efficiency.
  - The decision illustrates tensions between political and economic priorities.

### Policies Affecting Value-Adding Inputs: R&D and Capital Support
- Purpose:
  - Policies directly support electricity generation from renewable sources including public sponsored R&D, capital grants, and subsidized loans at EU, Federal and local levels to promote long run marginal product of capital and overcome short-term capital constraints.
- EU-level R&D:
  - The 7th Framework Program (FP7) supports R&D in sustainable energy systems to reduce energy-related greenhouse gas emissions, enhance European energy security, and improve energy efficiency and productivity.
  - Under FP6 (2002–06), the budget for non-nuclear technologies was approximately €815m, while the total budget for the development of nuclear technologies was €1.23bn.
  - Overall FP budgets have increased by over 250 percent since the first program.
  - The share of energy-related research expenditure within the program has fallen from 50 percent to 14 percent.
- Federal-level R&D in Germany:
  - Overall support for energy-related research has fallen relatively sharply—by two-thirds or more since the early 1980s—largely due to reduced expenditure on nuclear energy.
  - Federal funding trend:
    - Funding for overall federal energy R&D increased from about €0.6 billion to about €0.7 billion between 2005–08 under the 5th energy research program 2005–08.
    - Rises a bit further to €0.8 billion between 2006–09 under the ‘€6 billion’ and ‘high tech’ strategies.
    - In latter years, much of the increase goes to dismantling of nuclear facilities.
  - No clear indication that basic R&D support to renewable energies by the German federal government is substantially increasing; the level has been more or less stable since the early 1990s.
- Expenditure details:
  - Reported expenditure by the German Ministry of Environment (BMU) on renewables R&D in 2006 was €98 million, with approximately €15.7 million targeted at wind energy, and €32.3 million at solar energy.
  - Figure 4: German Federal Government Support for Basic R&D, 1974–2007 (Source: German Ministry of Environment (2007)).
- Table 9. Breakdown of German Federal Government Energy R&D by Research Theme/ Ministry, 1974–2007 (in €1,000) — selected figures:
  - Total:
    - Actual 2003: 375,478
    - Planned 2004: 391,253
    - Planned 2005: 412,912
    - Planned 2006: 414,392
    - Planned 2007: 419,813
    - Planned 2008: 428,403
  - BMWA — Efficient energy conversion:
    - 2003: 65,958
    - 2004: 78,496
    - 2005: 71,244
    - 2006: 70,994
    - 2007: 70,994
    - 2008: 70,994
  - BMU — Renewable energies:
    - 2003: 67,798
    - 2004: 60,083
    - 2005: 80,394
    - 2006: 83,366
    - 2007: 88,366
    - 2008: 93,366
  - BMBF — Efficient energy conversion (Centers of the Helmholtz Association):
    - 2003: 36,621
    - 2004: 39,607
    - 2005: 42,155
    - 2006: 42,012
    - 2007: 42,134
    - 2008: 44,270
  - Notes:
    - The 2005 to 2008 figures partly include funds from the Innovation Initiative of the Federal Government: they are subject to approval by parliament.
  - Source: The 5th Energy Research Program of the German Federal Government (www.bmwa.bund.de).

### Support for Technological Diffusion and Finance Programs
- Rationale:
  - Support to technological diffusion may be warranted where private uptake is sub optimal due to information gaps among small private actors (households and small businesses).
  - Program support for renewable generation is often bundled with thermal energy production or energy efficiency measures, complicating precise analysis of abatement efficiency.
- Major programs for power-generation support:
  - Producing Solar Power Program (introduced 2005):
    - Offers low-interest loans administrated by the Reconstruction Loan Corporation (KfW) to support small investments in solar PV generation.
    - Private projects with an overall investment up to €50,000 are supported.
    - 100 percent of the investment cost can be financed at rates between 3.6 percent and 4.15 percent, with payback period of 10–20 years and a redemption-free initial phase of 2–3 years.
    - Between 2005 and July 2006, more than 25,000 loans were provided, with a total of €784 million and a capacity of 199 MW in PV systems.
  - Market Incentive Program:
    - Introduced using earmarked funds resulting from the decision to tax electricity universally (also when generated from renewable sources).
    - Primarily serves to expand heat generation from biomass, solar power and geothermal energy.
    - Budget: €190 million in 2002 and 2003, rising to €213 million in 2007.
    - Since launch in 2000, the program has supported around 625,000 projects with funding of €827 million.
    - Total investment triggered is estimated at €6.5 billion.
  - ERP-Environment and Energy-Saving and Environment Programs:
    - Provide low-interest loans administered by the KfW for private companies, freelancers and public private partnerships for energy efficiency measures.
    - Since 2003, applicable to investment in renewable energies.
    - Credit terms: 20–30 years with a redemption-free initial phase of 2–5 years.
    - Interest rates typically slightly below market level, 4–7 percent in 2006.
    - A maximum of 50 percent of the total investment is eligible for funding.
    - Loans of €10.7 billion were extended between 1990 and 2005.
  - Other KfW soft loan schemes:
    - Mittelstandsprogramm (applies to enterprises) and Infrastrukturprogramm (applies to municipalities).
    - Target public institutions and non-profit organizations; the latter targets energetic modernization of communal buildings (e.g. schools, kindergartens).
    - Typical credit terms: 10–20 years with interest rates at 1–2 percent below market levels.
  - 100 000 Roofs Program (1999–2003):
    - Supported installation or extension of PV systems larger than 1 kW.
    - Funded 55,000 installations with a total capacity of 261 MW at a cost of approximately €560m.
    - Terms allowed combination with other programs under the Renewable Energy Sources Act.
    - Provided subsidized loans for up to 100 percent to a maximum sum of €500 000.
- Note: Analysis of the precise extent and efficiency of these programs is complicated where support is bundled with other energy objectives.

*Source: _wp07299 - 2.25 Cent/kWh. (PDF content provided).*

### 4.5 percent below market interest rates, and repayable over ten years with a two-year

### _wp07299 - 4.5 percent below market interest rates, and repayable over ten years with a two-year

### Support programs for renewable energy deployment and R&D
- Solar Power Development Center / Photovoltaic Technology Evaluation Center (PV-Tec) forms part of Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems (ISE) and has received €11.7 million in support since 2005.
- 250 MW Wind Program:
  - Promoted 1560 wind turbines with a total capacity of 362 MW.
  - Provided grants for installation and operation and monitoring support for 10 years under the "Scientific Measurement and Evaluation Program."
  - Until end-1996, grants of DEM 200 (€102)/kW, up to a ceiling of DEM 100,000 (€ 51,300) for facilities larger than 1 MW were available.
  - Grants up to 60 percent of the total investment to a maximum of DEM 90 000 (€ 46,000) were provided.
  - Reported payments under the scheme were €7.6 million in 2001.

### Regional (Länder) support and combined federal-states funding (1991–2001)
- Funds at the federal level and federal law were main drivers, with states (Länder) also providing considerable support (e.g., Nordrhein-Westphalen).
- Overall support shown as decreasing (data do not include the most recent years), particularly to wind energy, with support to PV technologies increasing to some degree.
- Table 10 summary (by category, annual figures in € million; totals shown where provided):
  - Wind power: 1991: 13.2; 1992: 16.4; 1993: 40.0; 1994: 46.7; 1995: 39.9; 1996: 27.1; 1997: 31.0; 1998: 20.4; 1999: 14.9; 2000: 7.7; 2001: 2.4; 1991–2001: 259.6
  - Hydro power: 1991: 4.9; 1992: 4.7; 1993: 8.2; 1994: 5.8; 1995: 5.4; 1996: 3.7; 1997: 3.8; 1998: 4.7; 1999: 3.9; 2000: 2.6; 2001: 2.2; 1991–2001: 49.8
  - Solarthermal: 1991: 5.7; 1992: 17.6; 1993: 22.6; 1994: 20.4; 1995: 25.5; 1996: 31.2; 1997: 25.4; 1998: 31.6; 1999: 23.2; 2000: 18.8; 2001: 12.6; 1991–2001: 234.6
  - Photovoltaic: 1991: 5.4; 1992: 10.5; 1993: 9.0; 1994: 9.9; 1995: 9.0; 1996: 14.6; 1997: 19.6; 1998: 15.6; 1999: 19.4; 2000: 22.8; 2001: 27.9; 1991–2001: 163.7
  - Biomass: 1991: 2.8; 1992: 7.0; 1993: 18.0; 1994: 17.6; 1995: 38.9; 1996: 30.6; 1997: 38.6; 1998: 37.8; 1999: 28.2; 2000: 38.4; 2001: 37.1; 1991–2001: 295.0
  - Heat pumps: 1991: 1.0; 1992: 2.8; 1993: 2.4; 1994: 2.6; 1995: 2.4; 1996: 4.2; 1997: 2.3; 1998: 4.2; 1999: 3.6; 2000: 6.6; 2001: 9.0; 1991–2001: 41.1
  - Geothermal: 1991: 0.5; 1992: 1.7; 1993: 2.1; 1994: 2.8; 1995: 2.3; 1996: 3.8; 1997: 0.2; 1998: 0.3; 1999: 0.7; 2000: 0.4; 2001: 1.8; 1991–2001: 23.6
  - Education: 1991: 1.5; 1992: 1.7; 1993: 1.4; 1994: 1.6; 1995: 3.2; 1996: 4.3; 1997: 6.8; 1998: 5.1; 1999: 3.9; 2000: 6.2; 2001: 6.2; 1991–2001: 41.9
  - R & D: 1991: 12.5; 1992: 20.5; 1993: 28.1; 1994: 27.1; 1995: 27.1; 1996: 21.8; 1997: 30.0; 1998: 53.2; 1999: 53.0; 2000: 38.0; 2001: 23.1; 1991–2001: 334.4
  - Others: 1991: 49.5; 1992: 48.4; 1993: 48.7; 1994: 46.5; 1995: 28.0; 1996: 23.3; 1997: 26.8; 1998: 15.7; 1999: 8.8; 2000: 23.6; 2001: 29.7; 1991–2001: 349.0
  - Total (combined): 1991: 96.9; 1992: 131.4; 1993: 180.5; 1994: 181.0; 1995: 181.6; 1996: 164.6; 1997: 184.4; 1998: 188.4; 1999: 159.6; 2000: 165.2; 2001: 151.9; 1991–2001: 1785.5
- Source cited for table: German Ministry of Education and Research (2005).

### Policies affecting inputs, taxes, and fossil fuel subsidies
- Mineral and environmentally motivated taxes reformed since 1999 to provide incentives for energy saving and promote renewables; coal generally exempt from these taxes.
- Special provisions complicate impact assessment: reduced energy tax liabilities on industry; cap on effective tax rate for energy intensive industries; exemptions for electricity generation; reductions for less carbon intensive transport.
- Subsidies for domestic coal extraction: cut from €4.7 billion in 1998 to €2.7 billion in 2005; further falling to €5.7 billion in aggregate for the period 2006–08.
- Reported micro-level allowances in 2005:
  - Allowances on electricity fuels: €3.9 billion.
  - Allowances on heating fuels: €2.3 billion.
- BMU macro-fiscal analysis (2005/2006) suggests higher macro-fiscal costs:
  - Electricity exemptions: €6.2 billion.
  - Heating fuel exemptions: €4.8 billion.
  - (Note: transport fuel costs indicated as much higher in absolute and proportionate terms.)

### Biofuels for transport
- Germany is described as the world’s largest producer of biodiesel and biological oils for fuel purposes, and the main overall producer of biofuels within the EU.
- Production figures and projections:
  - Total production of biodiesel in 2006: about 3 million tons.
  - Total production of bioethanol in 2006: about 600 000 tons.
  - Biodiesel production estimated to reach about 4.2 million tons within the next three years (source: Kutas and Lindberg (2007), page 12).
  - Bioethanol production rose from about 20,000 tons in 2004 and plans could increase production capacity up to about 2 million tons within few years (source: Kutas and Lindberg (2007), page 15).
- Government targets:
  - Preliminary target market share for biofuels: 5.75 percent by 2010.
  - Further increase to 10 percent by 2020.
- Forms of public support for liquid biofuels in Germany include:
  - Output support; excise tax exemptions; support to energy crops; rural development support; capital grants; subsidies to feedstock; R&D support; support to consumption.
- Preliminary assessment: public support to biofuels in Germany, up to the time of writing, is an expensive means of phasing out petroleum in transport and of reducing overall German carbon emissions.

### Overall assessment of renewables policies in advanced countries (selected conclusions)
- OECD 2004 conclusion cited: specific targets to expand renewables less efficient than pricing emissions and letting market forces determine energy mix; report agrees with core statement but adds comments.
- Key evaluative points:
  - No general efficient pricing of emissions currently exists; emissions are at least in some cases under-priced. In absence of correct emissions pricing, subsidies to renewables may offset excess emissions.
  - Optimal subsidy level for renewables is uncertain; expenditure on feed-in tariff schemes is large and rising, particularly in Germany, with photovoltaics receiving high support relative to output.
  - Potential for very high returns from renewables R&D exists due to possibility of "breakthrough" technologies; public support can be justified because private appropriability of social returns is limited. However, probabilities and timing of breakthroughs are uncertain.
  - Public support to R&D may be biased toward "development" (scale-up and production support) rather than "research" (invention of new products and processes); Germany’s support to research has been relatively stable since the early 1990s, though recent years may indicate a rise in basic research support.
  - Large direct or implicit subsidies to traditional fossil fuels remain in the EU and United States (including coal subsidies in Germany, currently in phase-out), and free initial allocations under EU ETS embed implicit subsidies to carbon intensive producers; these distortions should be discontinued but, while they remain, they add justification for higher renewable subsidies.
  - Biodiesel and bioethanol for road transport are heavily supported in the EU and United States: subsidy rates appear at least in the range €0.5–0.7 per liter in the EU, and about US$2 per gallon for bioethanol (fuel-equivalents of petrol) in the United States.
  - Many externalities of road transport are unrelated to carbon emissions (e.g., congestion, wear, local pollution) and similar across fuel types; if motivation is solely CO2 reduction, current tax differentials between fuels are not clearly justified given small effective reductions in overall CO2 emissions from biofuels when production and consumption are accounted for.
  - The EU policy landscape is highly complex (local, federal, international policies), making aggregate assessment difficult.
- Recommendation for further work: quantify efficiency of different policy measures more precisely and extend policy analysis; authors intend to contribute further analysis.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF Working Paper _wp07299 (German renewable energy and related policies).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07299.pdf_
