## _wp09102

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp09102](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/_wp09102.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/_wp09102.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/_wp09102.pdf.json)

---

### Major themes and overview
- SEE group: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Kosovo, Macedonia, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, Serbia, Slovenia.
- Paper objectives:
  - Identify bottlenecks to introduction of advanced PFM reforms in SEE countries.
  - Outline objectives of reforms, discuss achievements, identify systemic problems and propose options to solve these.
  - Focus on medium-term and performance-oriented budgeting; relevance also to integrated cash and debt management.
- Main messages:
  - Consolidation of ongoing PFM reforms and further improvements remain important for economic and political goals.
  - Progress uneven across reform areas; consolidation of government funds into treasury single account systems is an example of broad progress.
  - None of the SEE countries has introduced a complete, functioning medium-term and performance-oriented budget.
  - Considerable resources have been spent on advanced PFM reforms with mixed results.

### Fiscal institutions and aggregate outcomes (1990–2006) — fiscal control
- Four major PFM objectives and related fiscal indicators:
  - Fiscal control: Overall and primary balances, public debt stock.
  - Financial discipline: Arrears, consistency between budgets and accounts.
  - Efficient resource allocation: Spending share of GDP, composition of spending.
  - Cost-effective service delivery: Quality-adjusted service costs.
- General government expenditures as share of GDP (1994, 2000, 2006 or closest years):
  - Albania: 1994 41.0, 2000 31.4, 2006 28.8
  - BH: 1994 n.a., 2000 53.5, 2006 47.6
  - Bulgaria: 1994 44.7, 2000 39.7, 2006 35.5
  - Croatia: 1994 42.41, 2000 51.0, 2006 47.7
  - Kosovo: 1994 n.a, 2000 n.a, 2006 27.3
  - Macedonia: 1994 45.4, 2000 38.0, 2006 34.3
  - Moldova: 1994 25.5, 2000 30.2, 2006 40.3
  - Montenegro: 1994 n.a, 2000 42.8, 2006 40.4
  - Romania: 1994 32.4, 2000 35.3, 2006 32.92
  - Serbia: 1994 n.a, 2000 37.63, 2006 42.3
  - Slovenia: 1994 47.3, 2000 41.7, 2006 42.6
- Overall fiscal balances (1994, 2000, 2006 or closest years):
  - Albania: 1994 - 14.0, 2000 -   9.1, 2006 -   3.1
  - BH: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   6.0, 2006 3.0
  - Bulgaria: 1994 -6.6, 2000 -   1.0, 2006 3.5
  - Croatia: 1994 1.71, 2000 -   6.3, 2006 -   3.0
  - Kosovo: 1994 n.a., 2000 n.a., 2006 3.6
  - Macedonia: 1994 -   2.6, 2000 2.2, 2006 -   0.6
  - Moldova: 1994 -   8.1, 2000 -   2.6, 2006 0.2
  - Montenegro: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   2.6, 2006 -   2.2
  - Romania: 1994 -   1.0, 2000 -   4.0, 2006 -   1.72
  - Serbia: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   0.93, 2006 -   1.5
  - Slovenia: 1994 -   0.2, 2000 -   1.2, 2006 -   0.8
- Interpretation:
  - Most SEE countries reduced or stabilized government expenditures as a share of GDP over the period; exceptions include Croatia, Moldova, Serbia where shares increased.
  - Fiscal balances improved notably, especially from 2000–06; most countries have modest deficits or surpluses.
  - Improvements reflect both favorable market conditions and strengthened aggregate fiscal control.

### Financial discipline — PEFA-based indicators (six countries)
- Indicators reported: actual expenditure versus approved budget (difference %), variation in sectoral spending compared to approved budget (%), stock of arrears (% of actual total expenditure). t-3, t-2, t-1 relative to PEFA year.
- Albania (PEFA year 2006):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -7.38, t-2 -6.08, t-1 -1.27
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 17.9, t-2 17.2, t-1 9.8
  - Stock of arrears: No commitment control
- Kosovo (2007):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -14.1, t-2 -3.4, t-1 -8.4
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 43.3, t-2 41.6, t-1 12.1
  - Stock of arrears: Not fully recorded
  - Note: 2004 budget expressed in commitment terms. 2005 budget put on a cash basis.
- Macedonia (2007):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: <5 2.9 - 4.7 <2 (table indicates PEFA benchmark "<5" and variation "<2")
- Moldova (2008):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 11.3, t-2 8.9, t-1 15.9
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 3.9, t-2 0.5, t-1 0
  - Stock of arrears: t-3 1.4, t-2 1.0, t-1 0.6
- Serbia (2007):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -6.2, t-2 2.8, t-1 -3.9
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 17.8, t-2 6.2, t-1 4.0
  - Stock of arrears: t-3 12.5, t-2 11.7, t-1 10.6
  - Note: data considered uncertain because not audited for the last four Fys.
- Montenegro (2008):
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 10.7, t-2 10.8, t-1 27.6
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 5.3, t-2 5.6, t-1 -1.7
  - Stock of arrears: <2
  - Note: data on the stock of arrears may not be complete.
- Interpretation:
  - Budget estimates remain inaccurate in many SEE countries.
  - Arrears persist in several cases despite improvements from 1990s conditions.

### Efficient resource allocation — sectoral composition and capital spending
- Albania functional breakdown of expenditures (1995, 1998, 2006) — selected items:
  - General public services: 1995 38.31, 1998 50.10, 2006 21.57
  - Health: 1995 5.61, 1998 3.80, 2006 8.24
  - Education: 1995 2.30, 1998 1.94, 2006 10.77
  - Social protection: 1995 21.70, 1998 20.07, 2006 26.59
- Bulgaria functional breakdown of expenditures (1995, 2000, 2006) — selected items:
  - General public services: 1995 47.11, 2000 27.49, 2006 22.93
  - Health: 1995 3.37, 2000 5.62, 2006 11.04
  - Education: 1995 3.99, 2000 4.56, 2006 5.01
  - Social protection: 1995 25.46, 2000 37.09, 2006 35.04
- Government investments as share of GDP (2001 / 2003 / 2006):
  - Albania: 7.1 / 4.6 / 5.7
  - BH: 14.5 / 10.8 / 6.4
  - Bulgaria: 3.9 / 3.4 / 4.7
  - Croatia: 5.4 / 5.7 / 4.0
  - Macedonia: 3.5 / 4.1 / 3.8
  - Moldova: 1.5 / 4.6 / 8.1
  - Montenegro: 3.8 / 3.4 / 4.5
  - Romania: 3.1 / 3.5 / 3.7
  - Serbia: 1.5 / 2.6 / 5.2
  - Slovenia: 4.0 / 3.9 / 4.2
- Observations:
  - Shift away from general public administration and defense toward health, education and social protection in Albania and Bulgaria; similar trends in other SEE countries.
  - Most countries realized a modest shift from current spending to capital spending, though some experienced reductions.
  - Capacity constraints exist to absorb increased capital spending and EU funds in new EU member states.

### Cost-effectiveness of public spending — health sector indicators
- Outcomes and productivity improved in most SEE countries over last 25 years:
  - Infant mortality (Figure 2) shows improvements.
  - Average length of stay in hospitals (Figure 3) shows increased hospital productivity.
  - Some countries experienced setbacks during 1990s transitions before recovery.
- Case payment systems and budget reforms in Slovenia and Bulgaria indicate enhancements in cost-effectiveness; further analysis needed.

### Assessment summary — PFM reform status
- Considerable improvements in PFM systems and fiscal outcomes over the last 15 years.
- Consolidation needed in basic PFM reforms (e.g., eliminate arrears, improve budget realism).
- Advanced reforms (medium-term budgeting and performance-oriented budgeting) are at early stages with mixed implementation results.
- Subsequent sections assess progress and provide suggestions for improvements in MTB and performance budgeting.

### Medium-Term Budgeting (MTB) — potential benefits and phased building blocks
- Potential benefits:
  - Improve fiscal control, financial discipline, allocative efficiency and cost-effectiveness of service delivery.
  - Greater clarity of policy objectives, predictability in budget allocation, comprehensiveness and validity of budget information, enhanced accountability and transparency.
- Common failures/practical challenges:
  - MTB can become ritualistic and resource-consuming with little practical value.
  - Spending proposals not reconciled with available resources -> spending plans become wish lists.
  - Poor coordination with national/sectoral strategies and failure to meet basic annual budgeting requirements undermine MTB.
- Phased building blocks (seven steps):
  1. Medium-term macrofiscal framework.
  2. Multiyear expenditure ceilings.
  3. Costed medium-term sector spending plans.
  4. Separation of existing from new spending.
  5. Coordination of current and capital spending.
  6. Multiyear negotiations.
  7. Coordination and integration of MTB and annual budget.

### Status of MTB in SEE countries — step scores and totals (Table 6)
- Scores by step (0–3). Selected entries and country totals:
  - Macrofiscal framework: Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 2, Mac 2, Mol 2, Mon 2, Rom 2, Ser 2, Slo 3
  - Expenditure ceilings: Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 2, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
  - Costed sector programs: Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 0, Cro 1, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 2, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Separation of new spending: Alb 1, Bul 0, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 1
  - Coordination current/capital: Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Multiyear negotiations: Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1+, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Coordination MTB/budget: Alb 1, Bul 1+, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 3
  - Score totals: Alb 8, Bul 8+, Bos 4, Cro 7, Kos 5, Mac 11+, Mol 7, Mon 4, Rom 7, Ser 4, Slo 15
- Interpretation:
  - Most SEE countries at early stages of MTB introduction.
  - Slovenia scores relatively high (two-year budget system fulfilling many MTB objectives).
  - Macedonia shows some high scores based on recent regulatory changes not yet fully tested.

### Box 1 — Cross-country MTB findings, implementation challenges and tentative recommendations
- Cross-country findings:
  - All countries prepare comprehensive macrofiscal frameworks; this is the strongest MTB element.
  - Multiyear expenditure ceilings often too general to be disciplining (indicative, broad functional allocation).
  - Variation in scope and quality of sector spending programs; Albania and Macedonia used sector spending programs as key MTB components.
  - Limited progress separating existing from new spending; no comprehensive forward estimates systems.
  - MTBs generally remain separate documents; only Slovenia integrates MTB and annual budget in a single document.
- Implementation challenges:
  - Objectives not always clearly defined or agreed.
  - MTB models often borrowed from advanced countries without adaptation.
  - Fragmentation between MTB and annual budget undermines impact.
  - Authority of out-year estimates is weak.
  - Capacity and institutional constraints; need for capacity building in line ministries.
- Tentative recommendations:
  - Establish a clear strategy and timetable for MTB reforms with stakeholder agreement.
  - Avoid replicating other countries' MTB systems; tailor approaches to country priorities and capacity.
  - Improve the annual budget process (clearer phasing, costing capacity) as prerequisite to MTB.
  - Prepare MTB and annual budget through a unified development and negotiation process; present them in a single document.
  - Make out-year estimates the starting point for subsequent years’ budget preparation; MOF should explain differences between ceilings and previous out-year estimates.
  - Invest in considerable capacity building in line ministries.

### Performance-Oriented Budgeting — status, challenges, and benchmarks
- Ten selected PFM reform areas include performance-oriented budgeting as an advanced reform requiring:
  - Budget decisions to reflect the performance of budget programs and clear linkages.
- Appendix II — Program/performance benchmarking scores (Table 7) and interpretations:
  - Program classification: Alb 3, Bul 3, Bos 1, Cro 3, Kos 2, Mac 3, Mol 2, Mon 1, Rom 3, Ser 1, Slo 3
  - Activity/input indicators: Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 2, Mac 3, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 2, Ser 1, Slo 3
  - Output/outcome indicators: Alb 1, Bul 2, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
  - Align activities with objectives: Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
  - Efficiency indicators: Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 1
  - Performance informs decisions: Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 1
  - Direct funding-performance links: Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 0, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 1
  - Score totals: Alb 7, Bul 11, Bos 4, Cro 6, Kos 5, Mac 11, Mol 6, Mon 3, Rom 9, Ser 4, Slo 13
- Findings and interpretation:
  - Most SEE countries at an early stage of developing and implementing performance budgeting.
  - A few countries are introducing elements of output-oriented budgeting; many still struggle with program preparation.
  - None of the countries, except for Bulgaria and Slovenia in the Health Sector, have developed mechanisms where funds provided are directly related to the results achieved.
  - Almost all countries have introduced programmatic budget classifications, but quality varies; programs often describe agency activities rather than operational objectives.
  - Significant overlap often exists between programmatic and organization classifications; tendency to create one program per organization and one subprogram per department.

### Box 2 — Country status, common patterns, implementation challenges and policy implications for performance budgeting
- Country-by-country status (selected points):
  - Albania: MTBP includes programs and indicators; most program data are activity-related; no structured performance data collection or systematic use for decision-making.
  - Bulgaria: Program structure with output and outcome indicators and target values; budgets appropriated by program and economic classifications, but accounting systems do not allow proper tracking by program.
  - Croatia: Program structure established; limited impact to date; performance indicator work started in 2008.
  - Macedonia: Program structure established; since 2005 requirement for strategic plans; so far no performance indicators.
  - Slovenia: Program structure established; activity indicators exist; limited focus on results; purchaser-provider system for hospital financing exists alongside traditional cost recovery.
- Common patterns and indicator quality:
  - Activity and input indicators pervasive, but outputs and outcomes limited; three countries (Bulgaria, Macedonia and Slovenia) have more comprehensive output indicators, few outcome indicators overall.
  - Mislabeling is frequent: "outputs" often describe activities (e.g., number of controls) rather than true outputs or outcomes.
  - Result chains unclear; difficulty defining and assessing efficiency indicators systematically.
  - Performance information occasionally affects decisions anecdotally, but enforcement and integration into budget decisions weak.
  - Advanced performance-based payment examples limited to health sector case payment schemes in Bulgaria and Slovenia; positive productivity/resource allocation impacts reported, but challenges with price-setting and incentives for misreporting exist.
- Implementation challenges:
  - Capacity shortages, especially in line ministries.
  - Reluctance of staff to adopt changes; underestimation of time and resources.
  - Unclear reform purpose, conceptual confusion (outputs vs. activities), and reluctance to accept responsibility for results managers cannot control.
  - Unrealistic short-term action plans; premature reforms before input budget systems function well.
  - Need for parallel public sector management and HR reforms, and for accounting, reporting, internal control and internal audit mechanisms.
- Policy implications and recommended sequencing:
  - Minimum prerequisites: well-functioning input budget systems; adequate arrangements for accounting, reporting, internal control and internal audit; public administration and HR reforms to grant managers necessary authority.
  - Clarify purpose of reforms and secure stakeholder agreement.
  - Where prerequisites exist, develop complete performance budget mechanisms for select sectors rather than attempting broad coverage immediately.
  - Adopt comprehensive long-term strategies (five-to-ten-year horizon) and realistic action plans.
  - Define how managers will be held responsible for results and how performance information will influence funding decisions; combine indicators with analysis and judgment.

### Conclusions and strategic options
- Achievements:
  - Over the last 15 years SEE countries achieved important improvements in PFM, with positive impacts on fiscal outcomes and transparency.
  - Priority progress: basic building blocks, fiscal control and financial discipline.
- Remaining challenges:
  - Advanced reforms (MTB and performance budgeting) are at earlier stages; many reforms stalled or progressed slowly with limited impacts.
  - Formal adoption of mechanisms widespread, but quality, validity and usefulness often weak; MTBs updated ad-hoc and rarely influence decisions beyond the budget year.
  - Top-down elements (macrofiscal frameworks, high-level program structures) advanced more than bottom-up elements (sector strategies, activity costing, performance indicators).
- Three fundamental strategic options for countries:
  - Continue current approach accepting long-term visibility of results;
  - Increase resource allocations to try to accelerate implementation;
  - Abandon some reforms and reallocate resources to activities with highest or most immediate payoff.
- Practical guidance:
  - Adopt realistic reform strategies with clear objectives, timetables and strong country ownership; recognize cultural and administrative change may take 10 or 20 years.
  - Avoid too many parallel and overly broad reforms.
  - Consider focusing on medium-term budgeting first where it is less challenging, then on performance budgeting in targeted sectors (education, health).
  - Use results to inform decisions about reform continuation, cancellation or radical restructuring rather than automatically extending unsuccessful programs.

*Source: _wp09102 — Excerpt from IMF working paper chapter on Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries*

### 1. Main Public Financial Management Objectives and Indicators ............................................5

### 1. Main Public Financial Management Objectives and Indicators ............................................5

### Major themes and section structure
- 1. Main Public Financial Management Objectives and Indicators ............................................5
- 2. Selected Public Financial Management Objectives and Benchmarks ...................................6
- 3a. SEE Expenditure Levels ......................................................................................................8
- 3b. SEE Fiscal Balances ............................................................................................................8
- 4. Indicators for Financial Discipline in Six SEE Countries .....................................................9
- 5a. Albania Functional Breakdown of Expenditures ...............................................................10
- 5b. Bulgaria Functional Breakdown of Expenditures..............................................................10
- 5c. Government Investments as Share of GDP in SEE Countries ...........................................11
- 6. Medium-Term Budget Systems in SEE Countries ..............................................................16
- 7. Performance-Oriented Budget Systems in SEE Countries ..................................................25

### Figures and Boxes referenced
- Figure 1. Remaining PFM Reform Needs in SEE Countries ................................................................7
- Figure 2. Infant Mortality....................................................................................................................12
- Figure 3. Average Length of Stay in Hospital ....................................................................................12
- Box 1. Medium-Term Budgeting in South East European Countrie...............................................17

*Source: _wp09102 - 1. Main Public Financial Management Objectives and Indicators ............................................5*

### 2. Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries .................................24

### 2. Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries

### I. Introduction and overview
- SEE group: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Kosovo, Macedonia, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, Serbia, Slovenia.
- Progress and context:
  - Significant improvements in public financial management (PFM) over the last 15 years.
  - Slovenia: EU member in 2004. Bulgaria and Romania: EU members in 2007.
- Main messages:
  - Consolidation of ongoing PFM reforms and further improvements remain important for economic and political goals.
  - Progress uneven across reform areas; consolidation of government funds into treasury single account systems is an example of broad progress.
  - None of the SEE countries has introduced a complete, functioning medium-term and performance-oriented budget.
  - Considerable resources have been spent on advanced PFM reforms with mixed results.
- Paper objectives:
  - Identify bottlenecks to introduction of advanced PFM reforms in SEE countries.
  - Outline objectives of reforms, discuss achievements, identify systemic problems and propose options to solve these.
  - Focus on medium-term and performance-oriented budgeting; relevance also to integrated cash and debt management.

### II. Fiscal institutions and outcomes 1990–2006
#### PFM objectives and related indicators
- Four major PFM objectives and related fiscal indicators:
  - Fiscal control: Overall and primary balances, public debt stock.
  - Financial discipline: Arrears, consistency between budgets and accounts.
  - Efficient resource allocation: Spending share of GDP, composition of spending.
  - Cost-effective service delivery: Quality-adjusted service costs.

#### PFM reform agendas in SEE countries
- Ten selected reform areas (basic and advanced):
  - Basic reforms and benchmarks:
    - Complete budget classification: Budgets are fully classified by economic, functional, organizational, program and funding codes.
    - Complete budget coverage: Consolidated budgets include all general government financial flows, including extrabudgetary financing.
    - Capital budget integration: Capital budgets and associated fiscal risks are fully incorporated in the regular budget processes.
    - Consolidated TSA: Treasury single accounts cover all central government financial resources, including EBFs and foreign financing.
    - Adequate budget controls: No systematic overspending or accrual of arrears.
  - Advanced reforms and benchmarks:
    - Medium-term budgeting: Medium-term fiscal frameworks and sectoral spending plans are fully reconciled and regularly updated.
    - Performance-oriented budgeting: Budget decisions reflect the performance of budget programs and the linkages are clearly identified.
    - Integrated cash and debt management: Financial assets and liabilities are managed as a portfolio to balance net financing costs with accepted risks.
    - Unified accounting framework: There is a single accounting framework fully consistent with budget classifications.
    - Fiscal transparency: Budget systems meet the IMF Code of Fiscal Transparency.
- Note: Benchmarks consistent with broader frameworks such as PEFA.

#### Status of PFM reforms in SEE countries (summary points)
- Some countries near completion of many basic PFM reforms (e.g., Bulgaria, Croatia, Moldova, Slovenia).
- Less progress on advanced reforms; highest needs for improvement in:
  - Medium-term budgeting.
  - Performance-oriented budgeting.
- Figure 1 (text summary): shading indicated need for some, substantial, or very substantial improvement across countries and reform areas.

#### Fiscal objectives and outcomes: aggregate fiscal control (Tables 3a and 3b)
- Table 3a: General government expenditures as share of GDP (1994, 2000, 2006 or closest years)
  - Albania: 1994 41.0, 2000 31.4, 2006 28.8
  - BH: 1994 n.a., 2000 53.5, 2006 47.6
  - Bulgaria: 1994 44.7, 2000 39.7, 2006 35.5
  - Croatia: 1994 42.41, 2000 51.0, 2006 47.7
  - Kosovo: 1994 n.a, 2000 n.a, 2006 27.3
  - Macedonia: 1994 45.4, 2000 38.0, 2006 34.3
  - Moldova: 1994 25.5, 2000 30.2, 2006 40.3
  - Montenegro: 1994 n.a, 2000 42.8, 2006 40.4
  - Romania: 1994 32.4, 2000 35.3, 2006 32.92
  - Serbia: 1994 n.a, 2000 37.63, 2006 42.3
  - Slovenia: 1994 47.3, 2000 41.7, 2006 42.6
- Table 3b: Overall fiscal balances (1994, 2000, 2006 or closest years)
  - Albania: 1994 - 14.0, 2000 -   9.1, 2006 -   3.1
  - BH: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   6.0, 2006 3.0
  - Bulgaria: 1994 -6.6, 2000 -   1.0, 2006 3.5
  - Croatia: 1994 1.71, 2000 -   6.3, 2006 -   3.0
  - Kosovo: 1994 n.a., 2000 n.a., 2006 3.6
  - Macedonia: 1994 -   2.6, 2000 2.2, 2006 -   0.6
  - Moldova: 1994 -   8.1, 2000 -   2.6, 2006 0.2
  - Montenegro: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   2.6, 2006 -   2.2
  - Romania: 1994 -   1.0, 2000 -   4.0, 2006 -   1.72
  - Serbia: 1994 n.a., 2000 -   0.93, 2006 -   1.5
  - Slovenia: 1994 -   0.2, 2000 -   1.2, 2006 -   0.8
- Summary interpretation:
  - Most SEE countries reduced or stabilized government expenditures as a share of GDP over the period; exceptions include Croatia, Moldova, Serbia where shares increased.
  - Fiscal balances improved notably, especially from 2000–06; most countries have modest deficits or surpluses.
  - Improvements reflect both favorable market conditions and strengthened aggregate fiscal control.

#### Financial discipline (Table 4; PEFA-based indicators for six countries)
- Indicators: actual expenditure versus approved budget (difference %), variation in sectoral spending compared to approved budget (%), stock of arrears (% of actual total expenditure). Reported for t-3, t-2, t-1 relative to PEFA year.
- Albania (PEFA year 2006)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -7.38, t-2 -6.08, t-1 -1.27
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 17.9, t-2 17.2, t-1 9.8
  - Stock of arrears: No commitment control
- Kosovo (2007)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -14.1, t-2 -3.4, t-1 -8.4
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 43.3, t-2 41.6, t-1 12.1
  - Stock of arrears: Not fully recorded
  - Note: 2004 budget expressed in commitment terms. 2005 budget put on a cash basis.
- Macedonia (2007)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: <5 2.9 - 4.7 <2
  - (Table formatting indicates a PEFA benchmark of "<5" and variation "<2".)
- Moldova (2008)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 11.3, t-2 8.9, t-1 15.9
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 3.9, t-2 0.5, t-1 0
  - Stock of arrears: t-3 1.4, t-2 1.0, t-1 0.6
- Serbia (2007)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 -6.2, t-2 2.8, t-1 -3.9
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 17.8, t-2 6.2, t-1 4.0
  - Stock of arrears: t-3 12.5, t-2 11.7, t-1 10.6
  - Note: data considered uncertain because not audited for the last four Fys.
- Montenegro (2008)
  - Actual expenditure versus approved budget: t-3 10.7, t-2 10.8, t-1 27.6
  - Variation in sectoral spending: t-3 5.3, t-2 5.6, t-1 -1.7
  - Stock of arrears: <2
  - Note: data on the stock of arrears may not be complete.
- Interpretation:
  - Budget estimates remain inaccurate in many SEE countries.
  - Arrears persist in several cases despite improvements from 1990s conditions.

#### Efficient resource allocation (Tables 5a–5c, sector outcomes)
- Albania functional breakdown of expenditures (1995, 1998, 2006)
  - General public services: 1995 38.31, 1998 50.10, 2006 21.57
  - Defense: 1995 7.09, 1998 3.52, 2006 4.42
  - Public order and safety: 1995 7.02, 1998 5.85, 2006 6.26
  - Economic affairs: 1995 12.82, 1998 10.88, 2006 15.23
  - Environmental protection: 1995 0.00, 1998 0.00
  - Housing and community amenities: 1995 3.47, 1998 2.94, 2006 5.65
  - Health: 1995 5.61, 1998 3.80, 2006 8.24
  - Recreation, culture, and religion: 1995 1.68, 1998 0.90, 2006 1.27
  - Education: 1995 2.30, 1998 1.94, 2006 10.77
  - Social protection: 1995 21.70, 1998 20.07, 2006 26.59
  - Source: IMF staff reports.
- Bulgaria functional breakdown of expenditures (1995, 2000, 2006)
  - General public services: 1995 47.11, 2000 27.49, 2006 22.93
  - Defense: 1995 6.35, 2000 6.90, 2006 5.77
  - Public order and safety: 1995 4.35, 2000 5.46, 2006 7.52
  - Economic affairs: 1995 7.13, 2000 9.80, 2006 10.69
  - Environmental protection: 1995 0.00, 2000 0.00, 2006 -0.10
  - Housing and community amenities: 1995 1.10, 2000 1.44, 2006 0.83
  - Health: 1995 3.37, 2000 5.62, 2006 11.04
  - Recreation, culture, and religion: 1995 1.14, 2000 1.65, 2006 1.26
  - Education: 1995 3.99, 2000 4.56, 2006 5.01
  - Social protection: 1995 25.46, 2000 37.09, 2006 35.04
  - Source: IMF staff reports.
- Government investments as share of GDP in SEE countries (Table 5c)
  - 2001 / 2003 / 2006:
    - Albania: 7.1 / 4.6 / 5.7
    - BH: 14.5 / 10.8 / 6.4
    - Bulgaria: 3.9 / 3.4 / 4.7
    - Croatia: 5.4 / 5.7 / 4.0
    - Macedonia: 3.5 / 4.1 / 3.8
    - Moldova: 1.5 / 4.6 / 8.1
    - Montenegro: 3.8 / 3.4 / 4.5
    - Romania: 3.1 / 3.5 / 3.7
    - Serbia: 1.5 / 2.6 / 5.2
    - Slovenia: 4.0 / 3.9 / 4.2
  - Source: IMF staff reports.
- Observations:
  - Composition of public spending shifted away from general public administration and defense toward health, education and social protection in Albania and Bulgaria; similar trends in other SEE countries.
  - Most countries realized a modest shift from current spending to capital spending, though some experienced reductions.
  - Capacity constraints exist to absorb increased capital spending and EU funds in new EU member states.

#### Cost-effectiveness of public spending: health sector indicators
- Outcomes and productivity improved in most SEE countries over last 25 years:
  - Infant mortality (Figure 2) shows improvements.
  - Average length of stay in hospitals (Figure 3) shows increased hospital productivity.
  - Some countries experienced setbacks during 1990s transitions before recovery.
- Country case studies:
  - Slovenia and Bulgaria: case payment systems and budget reforms indicated enhancements in cost-effectiveness; further analysis needed.

#### Assessment summary
- SEE countries have achieved considerable improvements in PFM systems and fiscal outcomes over the last 15 years.
- Progress in basic PFM reforms needs consolidation (e.g., eliminate arrears, improve budget realism).
- Focus shifting to advanced reforms: efficiency of spending and cost-effectiveness via medium-term and performance-oriented budgeting.
- Subsequent sections assess progress and provide suggestions for improvements in MTB and performance budgeting.

### III. Medium-term budgeting (MTB)
#### Overview and potential benefits
- MTB defined broadly as extensions of budget time horizon (term varies across countries).
- Potential benefits:
  - Improve fiscal control, financial discipline, allocative efficiency and cost-effectiveness of service delivery.
  - Greater clarity of policy objectives, predictability in budget allocation, comprehensiveness and validity of budget information, enhanced accountability and transparency.
- Practical challenges and common failures:
  - MTB can become ritualistic and resource-consuming with little practical value.
  - Spending proposals not reconciled with available resources -> spending plans become wish lists.
  - Poor coordination with national/sectoral strategies and failure to meet basic annual budgeting requirements undermine MTB.

#### Evidence from other countries
- Limited assessment in transition and developing economies:
  - World Bank 2002 study of 13 African countries: only Uganda had several key components of a functioning MTB system.
  - Among transition economies in Central and Eastern Europe: Slovakia introduced all key elements of a functioning MTB system; Russia introduced 2008–10 three-year appropriations (impacts unclear).

#### Phases and building blocks of MTB
- Typical phased approach; steps develop over time:
  1. Medium-term macrofiscal framework:
     - Extension of macroeconomic framework to at least three years including broader fiscal parameters.
     - Must be updated regularly and reconciled with budgetary decisions.
  2. Multiyear expenditure ceilings:
     - Enhance predictability for line ministries and contain aggregate expenditures.
     - Initially indicative and broad; to be effective ceilings should be related to specific organizational entities and have formal status.
     - "Binding" budget ceiling used for out-year ceilings when they become starting point for negotiations.
  3. Costed medium-term sector spending plans:
     - Based on government and sector strategies; identify costs of programs, policies and activities.
     - Quality depends on existence of performance-oriented budgeting.
  4. Separation of existing from new spending:
     - Advanced forward estimates systems allow roll-over of existing activities and focus discussion on new initiatives.
  5. Coordination of current and capital spending:
     - MTB can capture maintenance and operational costs of capital projects; early stages use lump-sum allocations; advanced systems detail costs for individual projects.
  6. Multiyear negotiations:
     - Gradually extend scope of budget negotiations to cover whole MTB period.
  7. Coordination and integration of MTB and annual budget:
     - Early stages: separate and inconsistent documents; advanced MTB: unified document updated regularly through the preparation process.

#### Status of MTB in SEE countries (Table 6)
- Assessment uses scores 0 (no significant progress) to 3 (final stage) across seven MTB steps. Scores and total ("Score") reported per country.
- Table 6 snapshot (scores by step; columns Alb Bul Bos Cro Kos Mac Mol Mon Rom Ser Slo)
  - Macrofiscal framework: Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 2, Mac 2, Mol 2, Mon 2, Rom 2, Ser 2, Slo 3
  - Expenditure ceilings: Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 2, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
  - Costed sector programs: Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 0, Cro 1, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 2, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Separation of new spending: Alb 1, Bul 0, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 1
  - Coordination current/capital: Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Multiyear negotiations: Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1+, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 2
  - Coordination MTB/budget: Alb 1, Bul 1+, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 3
  - Score totals: Alb 8, Bul 8+, Bos 4, Cro 7, Kos 5, Mac 11+, Mol 7, Mon 4, Rom 7, Ser 4, Slo 15
- Interpretation:
  - Most SEE countries at early stages of MTB introduction.
  - Slovenia scores relatively high (two-year budget system fulfilling many MTB objectives).
  - Macedonia shows some high scores based on recent regulatory changes not yet fully tested.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF working paper chapter on performance-oriented budgeting in South East European countries.*

### Box 1: Medium-Term Budgeting in South East European Countries

### Box 1: Medium-Term Budgeting in South East European Countries

### Country summaries (selected features)
- Albania
  - Introduced a medium-term budget program (MTBP) in 2001 and gradually improved it from year to year.
  - Budget ceilings are set for three years. The ceiling for the first year is now largely binding, whereas out-year ceilings are indicative.
  - The MTBP is approved by government and sent to Parliament for information.
  - Neither the MTBP nor the annual budget specifies consistency between initial budget ceilings, medium-term budget allocations and final budget allocations, or explains changes in out-year budget ceilings from one year to the next.

- Bosnia and Herzegovina
  - State and entity MOFs prepare medium-term budget frameworks on a three-year, rolling basis.
  - Entities have prepared MTBFs for some years; the first MTBF for the state was prepared for 2006.
  - Line ministries are required to prepare three-year estimates within predetermined ceilings (for the budget year in Republika Srpska and State, and for 3 years in Federation).
  - Annual and medium-term budget ceilings are indicative, in particular at the state level.
  - Consistency from year to year is not transparently monitored and reported.

- Bulgaria
  - Fiscal framework well developed and linked to the EU convergence program.
  - Ministries present medium-term budget estimates before cabinet sets budget ceilings.
  - 2008 regulations provided specific mechanism for linking the medium-term budget for one year explicitly to previous years’ medium-term budget, but implementation was incomplete.

- Croatia
  - Multi-annual fiscal framework first submitted with the 2005 budget, includes indicative three-year ceilings by budget user.
  - Ministries prepare three-year budget estimates.
  - No general costing of sector strategies; ministries should prepare development programs for capital spending and transfers and present fiscal implications of legislative changes.
  - Medium-term fiscal framework updated each year, but no explanation of changes in spending ceilings compared to last year’s framework.

- Kosovo
  - Medium-term expenditure framework introduced for 2006-08.
  - Expenditure estimates broken down by five main groups, not by ministry or function.
  - For 2007 there were ex-ante ceilings for current expenditure, but not for capital.
  - For 2008 there were no ex ante ceilings for ministries’ budget proposals, so the MTB had limited impact on budget decisions.

- Macedonia
  - The 2005 Budget Law provides legal basis for medium-term budgeting: government determines strategic priorities; budget users prepare three-year strategic plans.
  - MOF prepares a three-year fiscal strategy and proposes spending limits for the next fiscal year.
  - For 2007-09, MOF set binding spending ceilings for 2007; ceilings for 2008 and 2009 were indicative.
  - Line ministry strategic plans required to be consistent with ceilings for the whole planning period.
  - Fiscal framework for 2008–10 was submitted to parliament prior to the draft budget bill.

- Moldova
  - In 2007 the medium-term expenditure framework was developed for 2008-10.
  - MTEF provides indicative ceilings for the MTEF period, with separate ceilings for current and capital spending.
  - Provides a set of policy proposals, which should be consistent with the National Development Plan.
  - According to the MOF, policy proposals and medium-term spending plans are fairly consistent with the budget ceilings in the MTEF.
  - MTEF is approved by the government and submitted to Parliament for information; it forms a basis for annual budget preparation, but deviations exist between the MTEF and annual budget figures.
  - MTEF is updated each year, but there is not yet systematic tracking of changes in budget estimates between years.

- Montenegro
  - Fiscal framework established.
  - Budget preparation for the 2007 and 2008 budgets were based on a bottom-up approach.
  - MOF plans to introduce a top-down procedure with budgets within specific ceilings for the 2009 budget.
  - First step towards medium-term budget made in 2006 with implementation of the new capital budget process.

- Romania
  - Medium-term fiscal framework quite well developed; capacity for macrofiscal estimates and analysis is being further strengthened.
  - According to the 2002 Public Finance Law, government should establish medium-term spending ceilings for budget organizations, which should provide medium-term budget proposals accordingly.
  - In practice, this approach has not been fully implemented: ceilings set too late to effectively discipline the budget process and based on increments to last year's budget.
  - Medium-term estimates sent to Parliament for information, but projections had limited impact on annual budgetary allocations.

- Serbia
  - Medium-term fiscal forecasts are provided.
  - Annual, indicative spending ceilings, and some indicative medium-term ceilings provided by functional classification.
  - Ceilings based on history and technical coefficients, but no explicit links between sector strategies and budget allocations.

- Slovenia
  - MOF prepares a medium-term fiscal framework.
  - Two-year budget process, with authoritative ceilings, but no ceilings for year 3 and 4 of the medium-term fiscal framework.
  - At beginning of the budget process, allowed levels of increase in development programs for years 3, 4 and 5 are determined.
  - Line ministries prepare development programs that include four-year budget estimates; these are related to sector strategies and primarily include capital spending.
  - Budget is based on programs, but spending estimates are not stringently linked to specific policies and activities.

### Cross-country findings and common patterns
- All the countries prepare comprehensive macrofiscal frameworks, which are generally updated at least twice a year. This is the strongest element of their existing MTB systems.
- Many countries are EU member or candidate countries, or (recent) IMF program countries, which ensures that macrofiscal projections and related budget estimates are kept up to date.
- Many countries prepare multiyear expenditure ceilings for the budget process, but in most cases these are too general to have strong disciplining effects:
  - Ceilings are often only indicative, either by definition or because they are allocated to broad functional areas and not to accountable organizations.
  - Out-year ceilings are usually changed from one year to the next without explicit explanation, limiting their planning value.
- Considerable variation exists in the scope and quality of sector spending programs:
  - Albania and Macedonia have used sector spending programs as key components of MTB reforms (Albania: sector spending plans as key input to national strategies; Macedonia: no comprehensive national strategy so far).
  - Moldova initially developed the national development strategy largely independent of sector spending plans, but harmonization improved in the second iteration.
- Some progress in coordinating current and capital spending; most countries include at least some indication of maintenance and/or operational costs in their MTBs.
- Limited progress on remaining benchmarks:
  - Great difficulty separating costs of existing policies from new spending proposals.
  - None of the SEE countries have developed comprehensive forward estimates systems.
  - MTB discussions tend to focus on aggregate funding levels rather than specific policy priorities.
  - MTBs have had little impact on specific budget negotiations, which remain one-year focused.
  - MTB remains a separate document in all countries but Slovenia; only one or two countries update MTBs to reflect budgetary decisions.

### Implementation challenges (summary)
- Objectives of MTB reforms are not always clearly defined, understood, or commonly agreed.
  - Initial phases (medium-term macrofiscal frameworks and indicative spending ceilings) are generally agreed, but ambiguity exists on next steps.
  - Many SEE countries lack clear strategies and action plans; where present, they are not always well understood or agreed among stakeholders.
- The commonly applied MTB model may not be the most appropriate or realistic for all SEE countries:
  - Models advised have been based on practices in a small number of very advanced countries; those countries developed practices gradually.
  - Slovenia’s more evolutionary development path produced relatively greater success; its partial MTB system differs from the general recommended model.
- MTB models and reform strategies do not always reflect differing PFM priorities across countries:
  - MTBs can contribute to multiple PFM objectives, but the balance between components should vary by country (e.g., focus on forward estimates for ministry planning vs. binding spending limits for expenditure containment).
  - These differences in focus are not clearly specified in SEE countries’ MTB plans.
- Fragmentation between MTBs and the annual budget process undermines impact:
  - Only Slovenia presents the annual budget and medium-term budget estimates in the same document.
  - A unified budget process and presentation (budget document including forward estimates) is recommended.
- Weaknesses in the annual budget process have sometimes been neglected:
  - Significant discrepancies persist between spending ceilings and subsequent budget requests.
  - Budget discussions are often general, lacking policy focus, and repetitive.
  - None of the SEE countries have introduced a separate "rolling-over" phase to identify fiscal space for new activities before cabinet budget meetings.
- Authority of out-year estimates is weak in most countries:
  - Even where the budget year ceiling fails to discipline requests, out-year estimates receive little attention, undermining the reform premise.
- Capacity and institutional constraints:
  - MTB reform is complex, time-consuming, and requires considerable staff training and capacity building.
  - SEE countries recognize the need for capacity building in finance ministries; additional focus on strengthening institutions and training in line ministries would be beneficial.
- Interpretation caveat:
  - Reform success must be seen in light of objectives. If the main objective is establishing a credible macrofiscal framework and providing indicative guidance, many current MTB systems are reasonably successful.
  - If aiming for more complete MTB systems, there remains a long way to go.
  - Discrepancies often exist between official stated objectives and objectives actually pursued, sometimes due to donor/advisor pressure without follow-through.

### Tentative recommendations
- Establish a clear strategy and timetable for MTB reforms, and ensure the strategy is well understood and generally agreed among all stakeholders.
- Avoid attempts to replicate MTB systems from other countries; focus on approaches consistent with each country’s specific PFM priorities and institutional capabilities.
- Improve the annual budget process as a prerequisite for successful MTB reform, for instance by clearer phasing of budget decisions and developing the capacity for costing of policy proposals.
- Prepare the MTB and the annual budget through a unified development and negotiation process; ensure consistency and present them in a single document.
- Make out-year estimates the starting point for subsequent years’ budget preparation. At minimum, the MOF should provide detailed explanations for any differences between budget ceilings and previous out-year estimates.
- Invest in considerable capacity building in line ministries.

*Source: Box 1, "Medium-Term Budgeting in South East European Countries" (excerpt).*

### Appendix II explains the benchmarks that have been used in estimating the scores.

### _wp09102 - Appendix II explains the benchmarks that have been used in estimating the scores.

### Table 7 — Performance-Oriented Budget Systems in SEE Countries (benchmarks and scores)
- Program classification:
  - Alb 3, Bul 3, Bos 1, Cro 3, Kos 2, Mac 3, Mol 2, Mon 1, Rom 3, Ser 1, Slo 3
- Activity/input indicators:
  - Alb 2, Bul 2, Bos 1, Cro 2, Kos 2, Mac 3, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 2, Ser 1, Slo 3
- Output/outcome indicators:
  - Alb 1, Bul 2, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 2, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
- Align activities with objectives:
  - Alb 1, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 1, Kos 1, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 1, Rom 1, Ser 1, Slo 2
- Efficiency indicators:
  - Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 1, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1, Mol 1, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 1
- Performance informs decisions:
  - Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 1, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 1, Ser 0, Slo 1
- Direct funding-performance links:
  - Alb 0, Bul 1, Bos 0, Cro 0, Kos 0, Mac 0, Mol 0, Mon 0, Rom 0, Ser 0, Slo 1
- Score:
  - Alb 7, Bul 11, Bos 4, Cro 6, Kos 5, Mac 11, Mol 6, Mon 3, Rom 9, Ser 4, Slo 13

### Findings and interpretation (from Appendix II text)
- Most SEE countries are at an early stage of developing and implementing performance budgeting.
- A few countries are introducing elements of output-oriented budgeting; many are still struggling with the preparation of programs.
- None of the countries, except for Bulgaria and Slovenia in the Health Sector, have developed mechanisms where funds provided are directly related to the results achieved.
- Almost all countries have introduced programmatic budget classifications, but the quality varies considerably.
- In many countries, programs are designed primarily to describe an agency’s activities rather than its operational objectives.
- Significant overlap often exists between programmatic and organization classifications.
- In many places the apparent assumption has been:
  - there should be at least one program for each existing organization, and
  - at least one subprogram for each department in this organization.

*Source: _wp09102 - Appendix II explains the benchmarks that have been used in estimating the scores.*

### Box 2: Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries

### Box 2: Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries

### Country-by-country status of program/performance budgeting
- Albania: Ministries required to define missions and programs, describe a policy for each program, set policy objectives for three years, set policy standards, and provide program expenditure and investment plans. Programs and main indicators are included in the MTBP document. Most program data are activity-related. There is no structured collection of data on performance or efficiency, or systematic use of this for decision-making.
- Bosnia and Herzegovina: Budget organizations present spending programs with the budget, but there is no formalized program classification structure. There is no systematic collection or use of performance indicators in the budget process.
- Bulgaria: National Assembly, Council of Ministries, all ministries and all state agencies have developed a program structure including performance information (output and outcome indicators with target values). Budgets are appropriated according to programs and economic classifications, but accounting systems do not allow proper tracking by program. Budget regulations provide for systematic production and collection of performance data.
- Croatia: Program structure established. Ongoing efforts to introduce programmatic budgeting have had limited impact. No clear link between government priorities and budget allocations; little emphasis on spending efficiency. Work to establish performance indicators started in 2008.
- Kosovo: Program structure exists but is largely organizational. Budget documents give some references to broad objectives and activity targets, but do not define specific performance or efficiency indicators. No systematic reporting on performance.
- Macedonia: Program structure established. Since 2005, all budget users required to prepare strategic plans and submit them with the budget circular. So far there are no performance indicators. Suggestion: sector budget estimates could be based on specific activities, not just programs, to separate costs of existing and new activities.
- Moldova: Program structure now covers most ministries. Programs are based on different conceptual approaches and are often activity descriptions. Development of sector and ministry strategies will provide inputs to the budget program structure, which needs further development.
- Montenegro: Program structure introduced for several budget units, but budgeting has not yet changed for these units. Program classification not introduced in the Treasury accounting system.
- Romania: Program structure established for all institutions and entities. For the 2007 budget, MOPF issued updated budget circular requiring ministries to provide information on strategies, outcomes, efficiency and performance information; compliance mixed and data quality generally unsatisfactory. For the 2008 budget, requirements compromised due to government reorganization. No clear links between results and budget decisions.
- Serbia: Program structure for five pilot ministries established in the 2007 budget with plans to extend subsequently. Introduction of performance indicators and performance orientation is a long term effort.
- Slovenia: Program structure established. Budget contains a number of activity indicators, but limited focus on results and performance information is not systematically used in the budget process. MOF task force developing example performance budgets for some agencies and programs. Purchaser-provider system for hospital financing exists; much hospital financing still based on traditional cost recovery, but fees for service become more important each year.

### Common patterns and indicator quality
- All countries have developed some activity and input indicators; these primarily describe traditional activities because programs tend to be based on organizations.
- Three countries (Bulgaria, Macedonia and Slovenia) have developed reasonably comprehensive indicators for outputs, but there are few outcome indicators.
- Frequent mislabeling: the term “outputs” is often used for indicators that describe activities rather than true outputs (example: number of controls carried out vs. number of errors discovered or improvements in financial management quality).
- Result chains are often unclear: missing elements and unclear relationships make it difficult to see whether and how current activities contribute to stated objectives.
- Difficulty in defining and systematically assessing efficiency indicators; ad-hoc attempts exist but no comprehensive, systematic approach in any SEE country.
- Anecdotal evidence that performance information may have some impact on decisions in a few countries, but observance and enforcement of requirements to include performance information in budget submissions is often weak and information can be ignored during decision-making.
- Advanced performance-based payment examples limited to health sector case payment schemes in two countries: Bulgaria and Slovenia. Health authorities report positive impacts on productivity and resource allocation, but challenges exist with price-setting mechanisms and incentives for suboptimization and misreporting.

### Implementation challenges
- Common obstacles across countries:
  - Capacity shortages, especially in line ministries.
  - Reluctance of staff to adopt changes.
  - Underestimation of time and resources required.
  - Existence of more pressing priorities or more basic reforms to be put in place.
- Unclear purpose of reforms: in many countries reforms are ad hoc with unclear objectives, excessive activity focus and unclear result chains.
- Conceptual confusion: outputs confused with activities; difficulties operationalizing outcomes and efficiency even in countries with more established performance focus.
- Reluctance to accept responsibility for results that managers do not control, compounded by legalistic traditions and risk aversion.
- Misconception that budgets will be allocated mechanistically on the basis of performance compared to targets; in most sectors performance information is only part of the basis for decision-making.
- Unrealistic, short-term action plans: plans often limited to one to two years, leading to several consecutive short-term plans with little achieved. Recommendation: favor a realistic long-term strategy covering five-to-ten-year period.
- Premature reforms: minimum requirement for introducing output/outcome budgeting is a well-functioning input budget system. No examples of rapid transition from ineffective input systems to well-functioning performance budgets.
- Need for parallel reforms in public sector management and human resource practices; managers require authority and autonomy to act on performance incentives.
- Need for effective accounting, reporting, internal control and internal audit mechanisms; some OECD countries view accounting reform, including accrual accounting, as a pre-requisite for performance budgeting.
- Reforms often broad but shallow: many countries establish program structures and input/activity indicators but fail to progress toward actual program performance assessment.
- Recommendation for a narrower, deeper approach: focus on select budget programs well suited for performance budgeting where outputs are well defined, easy to observe and measure, and quality can be monitored. Health sector financing schemes in Bulgaria and Slovenia are cited as examples.

### Policy implications and recommended sequencing
- Minimum prerequisites:
  - Well-functioning input budget systems before embarking on output/outcome reforms.
  - Adequate arrangements for accounting, reporting, internal control and internal audit to ensure managerial accountability.
  - Reforms in public administration and human resource management to grant necessary authority and autonomy to managers.
- Clarify purpose of performance budgeting reforms and ensure stakeholder understanding.
- Where pre-requisites exist, develop complete performance budget mechanisms for select sectors rather than trying to cover all sectors simultaneously.
- Adopt comprehensive long-term strategies and action plans; performance budget reforms will always take several years.
- Define basic concepts and approaches clearly and secure common agreement among stakeholders, including line ministries and agencies.
- Define how and to what extent managers will be held responsible for results; annual performance evaluations should use elements from different parts of the result chain, not just final outcomes.
- Establish clear frameworks for how performance information will influence future funding decisions; combine performance indicators with specific analysis and judgment for most programs, while recognizing a few programs may allow direct performance-funding links.

### Conclusions and strategic options
- Over the last 15 years SEE countries achieved important improvements in public financial management, with positive impacts on fiscal outcomes and transparency. Priority has been establishing basic building blocks; improvements in fiscal control and financial discipline have been impressive.
- Advanced reforms (medium-term budgeting and performance budgeting) are at earlier stages; many reforms have stalled or proceeded at low pace and so far had limited impacts.
- Sector reforms have improved outcomes and productivity in places (e.g., health sector), but general PFM systems have not yet contributed significantly to these improvements.
- Formal adoption of reform mechanisms (medium-term budget documents, programmatic budget structures with some indicators) is widespread, but quality, validity and usefulness are often weak; MTB content often updated ad-hoc with little impact on annual decisions beyond the budget year.
- Top-down dimensions (macrofiscal frameworks, high-level program structures) have been more successful than bottom-up dimensions (sector strategies, activity costing, performance indicators).
- More progress has been made in medium-term budgeting than performance-oriented budgeting because incentives are stronger and MTB models are clearer.
- Three fundamental strategic options for countries:
  - Continue current approach accepting long-term visibility of results;
  - Increase resource allocations to try to accelerate implementation;
  - Abandon some reforms and reallocate resources to activities with highest or most immediate payoff.
- Practical guidance:
  - Adopt realistic reform strategies with clear objectives, timetables and strong country ownership; recognize cultural and administrative change may take 10 or 20 years.
  - Avoid too many parallel and overly broad reforms.
  - Consider focusing on medium-term budgeting first where it is less challenging, then on performance budgeting in targeted sectors (education, health).
  - Use results to inform decisions about reform continuation, cancellation or radical restructuring rather than automatically extending unsuccessful programs.

*Source: Box 2, _wp09102 - Box 2: Performance-Oriented Budgeting in South East European Countries*

### Appendix I: Categorization of Medium-Term Budget Systems

### Appendix I: Categorization of Medium-Term Budget Systems

### Medium-term macrofiscal framework
- 0: None
- 1: Prepared annually
- 2: Bi-annual update
- 3: Continuously updated and reconciled with budget

### Expenditure ceilings
- 0: None
- 1: By
- 2: By organization, binding year 2
- 3: By organization, binding all years

### Costed sector programs
- 0: Costing by economic classification
- 1: Costing of overall program
- 2: Costing of main subprograms
- 3: Full costing of individual policies

### Separation of existing and new spending
- 0: No separation
- 1: Costing of new initiatives, no adjustment of costs for existing policies
- 2: Costing of new initiatives, some adjustment of costs for existing policies
- 3: Detailed forward estimates system

### Coordination of current and capital spending in MTB
- 0: Budget does not identify current cost implications of capital budget
- 1: Lump sums for maintenance of existing capital identified in MTB
- 2: Lump sums for operation costs for new investments in MTB
- 3: Detailed allocation of maintenance and operation costs for capital

### Multiyear budget negotiations
- 0: Budget negotiations only cover budget year
- 1: Some discussion beyond budget year
- 2: Key spending items explicitly covered
- 3: Focus on whole MTB period

### Coordination of MTB and annual budget
- 0: Only annual budget
- 1: Annual budget separate from MTB
- 2: MTB updated to be consistent with annual budget
- 3: Annual budget and MTB completely integrated

### Additional page number reference
- 33

### Appendix II: Categorization of Performance-Oriented Budget Systems

### Program classification
- 0: None
- 1: Pilot programs
- 2: Broad coverage
- 3: Complete coverage

### Activity and input indicators
- 0: None
- 1: Indicators for some programs
- 2: Indicators for most programs
- 3: Complete coverage

### Output and outcome indicators
- 0: None
- 1: Indicators for some programs
- 2: Indicators for most programs
- 3: Complete coverage

### Activities aligned with objectives
- 0: No
- 1: Clear activity – objective linkages for some programs
- 2: Clear activity – objective linkages for most programs
- 3: Complete definition of activity – objective links

### Performance informs decisions
- 0: No
- 1: Ad-hoc, anecdotal evidence
- 2: Performance information integrated in budget process
- 3: Consistent rules performance-related budget decisions

### Efficiency indicators
- 0: None
- 1: Indicators for some programs
- 2: Indicators for most programs
- 3: Complete coverage

### Performance determines funding
- 0: No
- 1: Pilot purchaser – provider mechanisms
- 2: Extensive use of purchaser – provider systems
- 3: Performance-based funding of all applicable budget sectors

*Source: _wp09102 - Appendix I: Categorization of Medium-Term Budget Systems*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/_wp09102.pdf_
