## 1. Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2010/_wp10202.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2010/_wp10202.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2010/_wp10202.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction and background
- International fuel prices increased more than fourfold between end-2003 and mid-2008, with most of the increase occurring during 2007 and the first half of 2008.
- Review synthesizes country studies (20 countries from Africa, Asia, the Middle East, and Latin America) undertaken between 2005 and 2009; 16 by the IMF and 2 by the World Bank.
- Welfare impacts are recalculated for a common retail fuel price increase of $0.25 per liter; impacts for other price changes can be obtained by scaling accordingly.
- Median retail price increase across the sample between end-2003 and mid-2008 was $0.56; values ranged from $0.02 in the Middle East to $0.66 in Africa.
- Pass-through (change in retail price ÷ change in import cost) varied substantially:
  - Median pass-through was less than 100 percent in all regions.
  - Pass-through exceeded 100 percent in four countries: El Salvador, Madagascar, Mozambique, and Senegal.
  - Pass-through was less than 50 percent in five countries: Gabon, Bolivia, Peru, India, and Indonesia.
  - Regional median pass-through was lowest in the Middle East and highest in Africa.

### Country case studies — key contextual points
- Sample covers diverse pricing changes: subsidy reforms, tax increases, and increases in previously low taxes.
- High initial domestic prices were, on average, associated with larger subsequent domestic price increases (consumption-weighted averages for gasoline, diesel, and kerosene).
- Even substantial domestic retail price increases often did not fully pass through international price increases.

### Methodology (how impacts are estimated)
- Two channels of welfare impact:
  - Direct: higher prices paid by households for fuels used for cooking, heating, lighting, and private transport.
  - Indirect: higher production and distribution costs leading to higher prices for other goods and services.
- Direct impacts computed from household survey data as budget shares (expenditure on each fuel product ÷ total household consumption).
  - Budget share interpretation: a doubling of a fuel price produces a welfare loss equal to the budget share for that fuel (absent demand response); the $0.25 per liter impact is calculated by scaling budget shares to reflect initial retail prices.
  - Estimates interpreted as short-run impacts or upper bounds because no substitution or demand response is modeled.
- Indirect impacts estimated by modeling price pass-through to other goods and services using input-output structures; key modeling assumptions:
  - Goods are non-traded.
  - Domestic production technologies exhibit constant returns to scale.
  - Demand is completely price inelastic.
- Total impact for each household = direct impact + indirect impact.
- Distributional analysis: households ranked into welfare quintiles (consumption per capita or per adult equivalent). A distribution is "progressive" if percentage welfare loss increases with household consumption and "regressive" if the opposite.
- Caveats:
  - Comprehensiveness of total consumption measures differs across country surveys.
  - Not all fuel products are covered in all studies; main fuel products are covered in most countries.
  - Low access rates for a fuel (e.g., electricity, LPG) imply reported average impacts may understate impacts on users.

### Empirical findings — magnitudes and composition of impacts (for a $0.25 per liter increase)
- Average total (direct + indirect) welfare impact across the sample: 5.9 percent decline in household real incomes.
- Regional range of average total impacts:
  - South and Central America: 3.8 percent
  - Middle East: 9.6 percent
- Composition (aggregate patterns):
  - On average the indirect impact accounts for over one-half of the total impact.
  - Indirect effect share by region:
    - Over 60 percent of total impact in Africa and in South and Central America.
    - Less than 45 percent of total impact in Asia and the Middle East.
  - Indirect impact arises predominantly from changes in the price of diesel (used mainly as an intermediate product in transport and other sectors).
- Selected averages and product-level direct effects (percent of total household consumption for a $0.25 per liter increase):
  - All regions (average) — Direct by product:
    - Gasoline: 0.3
    - Kerosene: 1.1
    - LPG: 0.3
    - Electricity: 1.1
    - Indirect: 2.8
    - Total: 3.3 6.2
  - Regional product examples (percent of total household consumption for a $0.25 per liter increase):
    - Africa (average): Direct gasoline 0.2, kerosene 1.2, LPG 0.2, electricity 0.4; Indirect 2.0; Total 3.8 and 5.7.
    - South & Central America (average): Direct gasoline 0.2, kerosene 0.2, LPG 0.3, electricity 0.8; Indirect 1.4; Total 2.4 and 3.8.
    - Asia and Pacific (average): Direct gasoline 0.3, kerosene 1.6, LPG 0.3, electricity 1.7; Indirect 3.9; Total 2.1 and 5.9.
    - Middle East & Central Asia (average): Direct gasoline 1.4, kerosene 0.7, LPG 1.0, electricity 2.7; Indirect 5.8; Total 4.2 and 9.6.
- Notes on composition:
  - Kerosene relatively more important in Africa due to lower electricity access; kerosene much less important in the Middle East due to more extensive electricity access.
  - Low access rates mean average impacts for a product can understate impacts on users.

### Electricity and LPG consumption patterns (selected country examples)
- Burkina Faso:
  - Electricity access rate: 10.0
  - Electricity share in total consumption — All Households: 0.4
  - Electricity share in total consumption — Households with Access: 4.4
  - LPG access rate: 5.2
  - LPG share in total consumption — All Households: 0.1
  - LPG share in total consumption — Households with Access: 2.1
- El Salvador:
  - Electricity access rate: 87.8
  - Electricity share in total consumption — All Households: 2.7
  - Electricity share in total consumption — Households with Access: 3.0
  - LPG access rate: 67.8
  - LPG share in total consumption — All Households: 0.8
  - LPG share in total consumption — Households with Access: 1.1
- Note: Access rate is the share of households with positive expenditures in the specific energy product.

### Indirect impact composition across consumption categories
- Indirect impact estimated as budget-share weighted average of price changes across consumption categories (food, non-food excluding direct fuel consumption, and transport).
- On average:
  - Non-food price increases account for just over 50 percent of the indirect impact.
  - Food price increases account for nearly 40 percent of the indirect impact.
  - Transport services absorb on average 3.3 percent of household budgets but account for nearly 10 percent of the indirect impact due to high energy intensity.

### Distributional outcomes
- Total, direct, and indirect welfare impacts are approximately distributionally neutral: percentage decrease in welfare is very similar across income groups (aggregated across the sample).
- Direct impacts vary by fuel product:
  - Gasoline and electricity price increases: progressive.
  - Kerosene price increases: regressive.
- Low-income households face larger welfare losses in absolute terms relative to their low initial consumption levels and thus have greater difficulty absorbing these losses.
- Targeting considerations:
  - Effectiveness of lower fuel prices to protect low-income households depends on the share of total benefits accruing to lower-income households.
  - If substantial benefit leakage to higher-income households occurs, alternative social protection measures may be more effective.

### Subsidy incidence and leakage
- Average shares of total subsidy benefits by consumption quintile (Table 5, In percent):
  - Bottom: 7.1
  - 2nd: 11.4
  - 3rd: 16.2
  - 4th: 22.5
  - Top: 42.8
  - All households: 100.0
- Direct subsidy incidence by fuel (Table 5, In percent):
  - Gasoline: Bottom 3.0; Top 61.3; All households 100.0
  - Kerosene: Bottom 19.0; Top 20.6; All households 100.0
  - LPG: Bottom 3.8; Top 53.8; All households 100.0
- Leakage summary:
  - On average, the top income quintile receives about six times more in subsidies than the bottom quintile.
  - For gasoline and LPG, the top income quintile receives 20 and 14 times that of the bottom quintile, respectively.
  - Even for kerosene, where the poorest receive a relatively higher share, there is substantial leakage to higher income groups.

### Fiscal cost-effectiveness comparisons
- Cost to the budget of transferring one dollar to the poorest 20 percent via gasoline subsidies: around 33 dollars (i.e., $1/0.03).
- Cost to the budget of transferring one dollar via kerosene subsidies: around 5 dollars (i.e., $1/0.19).
- Example safety net program efficiency (text example):
  - If 15 out of every 100 dollars allocated are absorbed by administrative costs and 80 percent of the remaining 85 dollars reaches the poor (i.e., 68 percent of total), then:
    - Cost-benefit ratio = 1.5 dollars (i.e., $1/0.68), substantially lower than subsidy-based approaches above.

### Electricity lifeline tariff limitations (El Salvador illustration)
- Share of households not connected to the grid:
  - All households: 12.6 percent
  - Bottom quintile: 31.5 percent
  - Table 6 No Consumption by quintile — Bottom 31.5; 2nd 13.8; 3rd 9.0; 4th 5.9; Top 2.5; All households 12.6
- Consumption distribution (percent of households in each quintile):
  - Consumption between 1 and 49 kWh: All households 20.1 (Bottom 27.2; 2nd 30.3; 3rd 18.4; 4th 13.9; Top 10.9)
  - Consumption between 50 and 99 kWh: All households 31.8 (Bottom 30.6; 2nd 35.2; 3rd 37.8; 4th 32.3; Top 22.8)
  - Consumption more than 99 kWh: All households 35.6 (Bottom 10.8; 2nd 20.7; 3rd 34.7; 4th 47.8; Top 63.9)
- Implication: lifeline tariffs miss many poor households because some are not connected and many low-income households consume above lifeline thresholds.

### Policy implications and recommended reform strategies
- Subsidies are poorly targeted: maintaining low fuel prices results in badly targeted subsidies with substantial leakage to higher income groups.
- Primary policy directions:
  - Replace universal fuel subsidies with targeted measures to protect poor households’ real incomes.
  - Where effective social safety nets exist: expand budgetary allocations to these programs to protect the poor while containing fiscal cost.
  - Where effective safety nets do not exist: adopt a gradual reform approach if fiscal conditions allow; maintain kerosene subsidies short-term and expand existing programs that can be scaled up quickly with improved targeting, such as:
    - School meals, reduced education and health user fees, subsidized mass urban transport, cash transfers to vulnerable groups, subsidies for water and electricity consumption below a threshold.
    - Expand education, health, and infrastructure (roads, electrification) expenditures.
- Public information campaigns should:
  - Highlight inefficiencies and fiscal costs of subsidies and the benefits of reform (efficiency, fiscal sustainability, economic growth).
  - Emphasize that retail prices reflect international price fluctuations and that appropriate pass-through incentivizes efficient consumption.
  - Educate on the role of fuel tax revenues in financing priority public expenditures and the importance of transparently recording subsidies on-budget.
  - Stress that higher income groups capture most subsidy benefits and that subsidies encourage smuggling, shortages, black markets, and corruption.
- Pricing regime recommendations:
  - First-best: fully liberalized fuel pricing with appropriate regulation to ensure competition.
  - Interim: adopt automatic pricing mechanisms, but recognize their fragility during sharp international price increases.
  - Improve automatic mechanisms by incorporating smoothing rules to:
    - Reduce magnitude of retail price changes compared to full pass-through.
    - Ensure full pass-through over the medium term.
    - Avoid long periods of fixed domestic prices that necessitate large later adjustments.

### Practical country experiences with mitigating measures (selected measures taken)
- Gabon (gasoline and diesel prices up 26 percent in March 2007):
  - Resumed National Social Guarantee Fund cash payments; new census of lower-income households.
  - Increased assistance to single mothers and microcredit funding for disadvantaged rural women.
  - Free electricity and water up to limited quantities for households below thresholds.
  - Waived school enrollment fees; provided free textbooks to primary pupils.
  - Accelerated PRSP investments in rural health, electrification, and drinking water; expanded mass public transport (27 buses).
- Ghana (domestic fuel prices up 50 percent in February 2005):
  - Eliminated fees for attending primary and junior-secondary school.
  - Extra funds for primary health care in poorest areas; expanded mass urban transport and rural electrification investment.
- Mozambique (fuel prices up 38 percent in 2008):
  - Increased budget allocations to social protection programs (Direct Social Support, Social benefits Through Work, Income Generation and Community Development).
  - Increased Food Subsidy Program cash benefits (minimum benefit 70 MT → 100 MT; maximum 140 MT → 300 MT).
  - Expanded National Institute for Social Protection branches from 19 to 30.
- Indonesia (large price increases 2005 and 2008):
  - Temporary cash transfer program to 19 million poor families using existing databases (2005); similar program in 2008 for seven months.
  - Reallocated some savings to education, health, and infrastructure programs benefiting low- and middle-income households.
  - Reduced kerosene subsidies in conjunction with an LPG promotion program.
- Jordan (gradual subsidy reduction from 2005; full liberalization Feb 2008 with price increases of 33–76 percent):
  - Increased minimum wage; higher wage increases for low-paid government employees.
  - One-time bonus to low-income government employees and pensioners.
  - Maintained electricity lifeline tariff; near-universal electricity access.
  - Cash transfers to low-income non-government workers and pensioners; plan to increase funding to the National Aid Fund and improve safety net design with World Bank assistance.

### Additional operational considerations
- Automatic pricing mechanisms have often been weakened or abandoned during periods of sharp international price increases (examples: Ghana, Indonesia).
- Incorporating smoothing rules into automatic mechanisms can reduce political pressure and the risk of reintroducing subsidies after sharp price shocks.
- Subsidy reform may need complementary institutional reforms to develop effective targeting, benefit delivery systems, and public communication strategies.

### Appendix — pass-through, adjustment factors, and distribution tables (selected figures)
- Regional medians (Pass-through, Gasoline / Diesel / Kerosene / Average):
  - Africa: 89 / 85 / 79 / 82
  - Central & South America: 53 / 54 / 30 / 54
  - Asia & the Pacific: 81 / 71 / 57 / 74
  - Middle East: 11 / 8 / 6 / 2
  - All regions: 64 / 69 / 55 / 58
- Selected country pass-through and retail price increase examples (end-2003 to mid-2008):
  - Madagascar: Pass-through average 140; Retail price change examples 0.20 / 0.42 / -2.5; Retail price levels 0.97 / 1.09 / 0.75 / 0.98; Other indicators 247 / 184
  - Mozambique: Pass-through average 120; Retail price change examples 0.11 / 0.25 / -0.9; Retail price levels 1.04 / 0.90 / 0.83 / 0.91; Other indicators 177 / 151
  - El Salvador: Pass-through average 109; Retail price change examples 0.02 / 0.09 / -0.5; Retail price levels 0.71 / 0.90 / 0.82; Other indicators 186 / 169
  - India: Pass-through average 30; Retail price change examples 0.05 / -0.47 / 4.4; Retail price levels 0.29 / 0.31 / 0.03 / 0.26; Other indicators 42 / 184
  - Indonesia: Pass-through average 31; Retail price change examples -0.24 / -0.77 / 4.3; Retail price levels 0.21 / 0.26 / 0.14 / 0.22; Other indicators 140 / 513
- Adjustment factors by fuel product (selected country values; Gasoline / Kerosene / Diesel / LPG):
  - Cameroon: 0.40 / 0.92 / 0.48 / 0.44
  - Gabon: 0.29 / 0.59 / 0.38 / 0.34
  - Ghana: 0.96 / 1.42 / 1.02 / 0.99
  - India: 0.28 / 1.23 / 0.46 / 0.37
  - Indonesia: 0.69 / 1.79 / 1.12 / 0.90
  - Jordan: 0.53 / 1.25 / 1.29 / 0.91
- Distribution of impacts by region for a $0.25 per liter price increase (Total Impact; percent impacts by quintile — Bottom / 2 / 3 / 4 / Top / All Households):
  - Africa Total Impact: 5.8 / 5.6 / 5.5 / 5.6 / 6.0 / 5.7
  - South & Central America Total Impact: 3.7 / 3.6 / 3.8 / 4.0 / 3.9 / 3.7
  - Asia and Pacific Total Impact: 5.5 / 5.9 / 6.2 / 6.5 / 6.3 / 5.9
  - Middle East & Central Asia Total Impact: 12.0 / 10.5 / 10.3 / 9.6 / 8.8 / 9.6
  - All Regions Total Impact: 6.4 / 6.2 / 6.2 / 6.3 / 6.4 / 6.2
- Distribution of subsidy benefits by consumption group (All Regions aggregate shares, In percent):
  - Total Impact shares: 7.1 / 11.4 / 16.2 / 22.5 / 42.8 / 100.0
  - Gasoline: 3.0 / 5.7 / 9.7 / 19.4 / 61.3 / 100.0
  - Kerosene: 19.0 / 19.7 / 20.6 / 20.1 / 20.6 / 100.0
  - LPG: 3.8 / 7.6 / 12.6 / 20.8 / 53.8 / 100.0
  - Indirect Impact: 7.3 / 11.7 / 16.3 / 22.6 / 42.0 / 100.0
- Pass-through of international price changes (2004–2008) — regional medians to Mid-2008:
  - Africa: 81
  - Central & South America: 54
  - Asia & the Pacific: 74
  - Middle East: (entries vary)
  - All regions: 58

*Source: Based on the IMF staff review of country studies titled "Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases" (derived from country study data presented in the source PDF).*

### 1. Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases ................................................9

### 1. Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases

### Introduction and background
- International fuel prices increased more than fourfold between end-2003 and mid-2008, with most of the increase occurring during 2007 and the first half of 2008.
- The review synthesizes country studies (20 countries from Africa, Asia, the Middle East, and Latin America) undertaken between 2005 and 2009; 16 by the IMF and 2 by the World Bank.
- To allow cross-country comparison, welfare impacts are recalculated for a common retail fuel price increase of $0.25 per liter. The welfare impact of any specific price increase can be obtained by scaling accordingly.
- Median retail price increase across the sample between end-2003 and mid-2008 was $0.56; values ranged from $0.02 in the Middle East to $0.66 in Africa.
- Pass-through (change in retail price ÷ change in import cost) varied substantially:
  - Median pass-through was less than 100 percent in all regions.
  - Pass-through exceeded 100 percent in four countries: El Salvador, Madagascar, Mozambique, and Senegal.
  - Pass-through was less than 50 percent in five countries: Gabon, Bolivia, Peru, India, and Indonesia.
  - Regional median pass-through was lowest in the Middle East and highest in Africa.

### Country case studies — key contextual points
- Sample covers a diverse set of pricing changes: some countries implemented subsidy reforms; others increased taxes or raised existing low taxes.
- High initial domestic prices were, on average, associated with larger subsequent domestic price increases (consumption-weighted averages for gasoline, diesel, and kerosene used in comparisons).
- Even substantial domestic retail price increases in many cases did not fully pass through the increases in international prices.

### Methodology (how impacts are estimated)
- Two channels of welfare impact:
  - Direct: higher prices paid by households for fuels used for cooking, heating, lighting, and private transport.
  - Indirect: higher production and distribution costs leading to higher prices for other goods and services.
- Direct impacts computed from household survey data as budget shares: expenditure on each fuel product divided by total household consumption.
  - Budget share interpretation: a doubling of a fuel price produces a welfare loss equal to the budget share for that fuel (absent demand response); the $0.25 per liter impact is calculated by scaling budget shares to reflect initial retail prices.
  - Estimates are interpreted as short-run impacts or upper bounds because no substitution or demand response is modeled in the country studies.
- Indirect impacts estimated by modeling price pass-through to other goods and services using input-output structures; key modeling assumptions:
  - Goods are non-traded.
  - Domestic production technologies exhibit constant returns to scale.
  - Demand is completely price inelastic.
- Total impact for each household = direct impact + indirect impact.
- Distributional analysis: households ranked into welfare quintiles (consumption per capita or per adult equivalent). A distribution is "progressive" if percentage welfare loss increases with household consumption and "regressive" if the opposite.
- Caveats:
  - Comprehensiveness of total consumption measures differs across country surveys.
  - Not all fuel products are covered in all studies; main fuel products are covered in most countries.
  - Low access rates for a fuel (e.g., electricity, LPG) imply the reported average impacts may understate impacts on users.

### Empirical findings — magnitudes and composition of impacts (for a $0.25 per liter increase)
- Average total (direct + indirect) welfare impact across the sample: 5.9 percent decline in household real incomes (presented in the text).
- Regional range of average total impacts:
  - South and Central America: 3.8 percent
  - Middle East: 9.6 percent
- Composition (aggregate patterns):
  - On average the indirect impact accounts for over one-half of the total impact.
  - Indirect effect share by region:
    - Over 60 percent of total impact in Africa and in South and Central America.
    - Less than 45 percent of total impact in Asia and the Middle East.
  - Indirect impact arises predominantly from changes in the price of diesel (used mainly as an intermediate product in transport and other sectors).
- Selected averages and product-level direct effects (as reported in the country-study aggregation, in percent of total household consumption for a $0.25 per liter increase):
  - All regions (average) — Direct by product:
    - Gasoline: 0.3
    - Kerosene: 1.1
    - LPG: 0.3
    - Electricity: 1.1
    - Indirect: 2.8
    - Total: 3.3 6.2
  - Note: The table in the source presents product-level and region-level disaggregations; the indirect effect and total impacts reported above follow from those tabulations.
- Examples of country/region variation from Table 1 (values are percent of total household consumption for a $0.25 per liter increase):
  - Africa (average): Direct gasoline 0.2, kerosene 1.2, LPG 0.2, electricity 0.4; Indirect 2.0; Total 3.8 and 5.7 appear as grouped entries in the table.
  - South & Central America (average): Direct gasoline 0.2, kerosene 0.2, LPG 0.3, electricity 0.8; Indirect 1.4; Total 2.4 and 3.8.
  - Asia and Pacific (average): Direct gasoline 0.3, kerosene 1.6, LPG 0.3, electricity 1.7; Indirect 3.9; Total 2.1 and 5.9.
  - Middle East & Central Asia (average): Direct gasoline 1.4, kerosene 0.7, LPG 1.0, electricity 2.7; Indirect 5.8; Total 4.2 and 9.6.
- Notes on composition:
  - Kerosene is relatively more important in Africa due to lower household access to electricity; kerosene is much less important in the Middle East due to more extensive electricity access.
  - Low access rates mean that average impacts for a product can understate impacts on users (see electricity and LPG patterns).

### Electricity and LPG consumption patterns (Table 2 — percent)
- Burkina Faso:
  - Electricity access rate: 10.0
  - Electricity share in total consumption — All Households: 0.4
  - Electricity share in total consumption — Households with Access: 4.4
  - LPG access rate: 5.2
  - LPG share in total consumption — All Households: 0.1
  - LPG share in total consumption — Households with Access: 2.1
- El Salvador:
  - Electricity access rate: 87.8
  - Electricity share in total consumption — All Households: 2.7
  - Electricity share in total consumption — Households with Access: 3.0
  - LPG access rate: 67.8
  - LPG share in total consumption — All Households: 0.8
  - LPG share in total consumption — Households with Access: 1.1
- Note: Access rate is the share of households with positive expenditures in the specific energy product.

### Indirect impact composition across consumption categories
- Indirect impact estimated as budget-share weighted average of price changes across consumption categories (food, non-food excluding direct fuel consumption, and transport).
- On average:
  - Non-food price increases account for just over 50 percent of the indirect impact.
  - Food price increases account for nearly 40 percent of the indirect impact.
  - Transport services absorb on average 3.3 percent of household budgets but account for nearly 10 percent of the indirect impact due to high energy intensity.

### Distributional outcomes
- Total, direct, and indirect welfare impacts are approximately distributionally neutral: percentage decrease in welfare is very similar across income groups (aggregated across the sample as presented).
- Targeting considerations:
  - The effectiveness of lower fuel prices as a means to protect low-income households depends on the share of total benefits that accrue to lower-income households.
  - If substantial benefit leakage to higher-income households occurs, alternative social protection measures may be more effective.

### Methodological caveats and interpretation
- Estimates should be interpreted as short-run impacts or upper bounds because:
  - No substitution or demand response is modeled in the direct-impact calculations.
  - The indirect-impact model assumes demand is completely price inelastic.
- Non-traded goods assumption is less problematic for the indirect channel because a large component of the indirect effect comes from domestic transport costs.
- Differences in household survey coverage across countries limit emphasis on cross-country level comparisons of budget shares; focus is on patterns across fuels and income groups.

*Source: Based on the IMF staff review of country studies titled "Direct and Indirect Welfare Impacts of Fuel Price Increases" (derived from country study data presented in the source PDF).*

### Appendix Table 3 disaggregates across regions). However, in the case of the direct effect,

### _wp10202 - Appendix Table 3 disaggregates across regions). However, in the case of the direct effect,

### Key empirical findings on impacts of a $0.25 per liter fuel price increase
- Average decrease in household real incomes: about 5.9 percent.
- Over half of this impact arises from the indirect impact of higher fuel prices on the prices of other goods and services consumed by households.
- Distributional patterns:
  - The distribution of the total, direct, and indirect welfare impact are approximately neutral (welfare loss similar across income groups).
  - Direct impacts vary substantially by fuel product:
    - Gasoline and electricity price increases: progressive.
    - Kerosene price increases: regressive.
  - Low-income households face larger welfare losses in absolute terms relative to their low initial consumption levels and thus have greater difficulty absorbing these losses.

### Subsidy incidence and leakage
- Average shares of total subsidy benefits by consumption quintile (Table 5, In percent):
  - Bottom: 7.1
  - 2nd: 11.4
  - 3rd: 16.2
  - 4th: 22.5
  - Top: 42.8
  - All households: 100.0
- Direct subsidy incidence by fuel (Table 5, In percent):
  - Gasoline: Bottom 3.0; Top 61.3; All households 100.0
  - Kerosene: Bottom 19.0; Top 20.6; All households 100.0
  - LPG: Bottom 3.8; Top 53.8; All households 100.0
- Leakage summary:
  - On average, the top income quintile receives about six times more in subsidies than the bottom quintile.
  - For gasoline and LPG, the top income quintile receives 20 and 14 times that of the bottom quintile, respectively (text statement).
  - Even for kerosene, where the poorest receive a relatively higher share, there is substantial leakage to higher income groups.

### Fiscal cost-effectiveness comparisons
- Cost to the budget of transferring one dollar to the poorest 20 percent via gasoline subsidies: around 33 dollars (i.e., $1/0.03).
- Cost to the budget of transferring one dollar via kerosene subsidies: around 5 dollars (i.e., $1/0.19).
- Example safety net program efficiency (text example):
  - If 15 out of every 100 dollars allocated are absorbed by administrative costs and 80 percent of the remaining 85 dollars reaches the poor (i.e., 68 percent of total), then:
    - Cost-benefit ratio = 1.5 dollars (i.e., $1/0.68), which is substantially lower than the subsidy-based approaches above.

### Electricity lifeline tariff limitations (El Salvador illustration)
- Share of households not connected to the grid:
  - All households: 12.6 percent
  - Bottom quintile: 31.5 percent
  - (Table 6, In percent: No Consumption by quintile — Bottom 31.5; 2nd 13.8; 3rd 9.0; 4th 5.9; Top 2.5; All households 12.6)
- Consumption distribution of households (In percent of households in each quintile):
  - Consumption between 1 and 49 kWh: All households 20.1 (quintile breakdown: Bottom 27.2; 2nd 30.3; 3rd 18.4; 4th 13.9; Top 10.9)
  - Consumption between 50 and 99 kWh: All households 31.8 (quintile breakdown: Bottom 30.6; 2nd 35.2; 3rd 37.8; 4th 32.3; Top 22.8)
  - Consumption more than 99 kWh: All households 35.6 (quintile breakdown: Bottom 10.8; 2nd 20.7; 3rd 34.7; 4th 47.8; Top 63.9)
- Implication: lifeline tariffs miss many poor households because some are not connected and many low-income households consume above lifeline thresholds (possibly due to larger family sizes).

### Policy implications and recommended reform strategies
- Subsidies are poorly targeted: maintaining low fuel prices results in a badly targeted subsidy with substantial leakage to higher income groups.
- Primary policy directions:
  - Replace universal fuel subsidies with targeted measures to protect poor households’ real incomes.
  - Where effective social safety nets exist: expand budgetary allocations to these programs to protect the poor while containing fiscal cost.
  - Where effective safety nets do not exist: adopt a gradual reform approach if fiscal conditions allow; maintain kerosene subsidies short-term and expand existing programs that can be scaled up quickly (with improved targeting), such as:
    - School meals, reduced education and health user fees, subsidized mass urban transport, cash transfers to vulnerable groups, subsidies for water and electricity consumption below a threshold.
    - Expand education, health, and infrastructure (roads, electrification) expenditures.
- Public information campaigns should:
  - Highlight inefficiencies and fiscal costs of subsidies and the benefits of reform (efficiency, fiscal sustainability, economic growth).
  - Emphasize that retail prices reflect international price fluctuations and that appropriate pass-through incentivizes efficient consumption.
  - Educate on the role of fuel tax revenues in financing priority public expenditures (education, health, infrastructure) and the importance of transparently recording subsidies on-budget.
  - Stress that higher income groups capture most subsidy benefits and that subsidies encourage smuggling, shortages, black markets, and corruption.
- Pricing regime recommendations:
  - First-best: fully liberalized fuel pricing with appropriate regulation to ensure competition.
  - Interim: adopt automatic pricing mechanisms, but recognize their fragility during sharp international price increases.
  - Improve automatic mechanisms by incorporating smoothing rules to:
    - Reduce magnitude of retail price changes compared to full pass-through.
    - Ensure full pass-through over the medium term.
    - Avoid long periods of fixed domestic prices that necessitate large later adjustments.

### Practical country experiences with mitigating measures (selected measures taken)
- Gabon (gasoline and diesel prices up 26 percent in March 2007):
  - Resumed National Social Guarantee Fund cash payments; new census of lower-income households.
  - Increased assistance to single mothers and microcredit funding for disadvantaged rural women.
  - Free electricity and water up to limited quantities for households below thresholds.
  - Waived school enrollment fees; provided free textbooks to primary pupils.
  - Accelerated PRSP investments in rural health, electrification, and drinking water; expanded mass public transport (27 buses).
- Ghana (domestic fuel prices up 50 percent in February 2005):
  - Eliminated fees for attending primary and junior-secondary school.
  - Extra funds for primary health care in poorest areas; expanded mass urban transport and rural electrification investment.
- Mozambique (fuel prices up 38 percent in 2008):
  - Increased budget allocations to social protection programs (Direct Social Support, Social benefits Through Work, Income Generation and Community Development).
  - Increased Food Subsidy Program cash benefits (minimum benefit 70 MT → 100 MT; maximum 140 MT → 300 MT).
  - Expanded National Institute for Social Protection branches from 19 to 30.
- Indonesia (large price increases 2005 and 2008):
  - Temporary cash transfer program to 19 million poor families using existing databases (2005); similar program in 2008 for seven months.
  - Reallocated some savings to education, health, and infrastructure programs benefiting low- and middle-income households.
  - Reduced kerosene subsidies in conjunction with an LPG promotion program.
- Jordan (gradual subsidy reduction from 2005; full liberalization Feb 2008 with price increases of 33–76 percent):
  - Increased minimum wage; higher wage increases for low-paid government employees.
  - One-time bonus to low-income government employees and pensioners.
  - Maintained electricity lifeline tariff; near-universal electricity access.
  - Cash transfers to low-income non-government workers and pensioners; plan to increase funding to the National Aid Fund and improve safety net design with World Bank assistance.

### Additional operational considerations
- Automatic pricing mechanisms have often been weakened or abandoned during periods of sharp international price increases (examples: Ghana, Indonesia).
- Incorporating smoothing rules into automatic mechanisms can reduce political pressure and the risk of reintroducing subsidies after sharp price shocks.
- Subsidy reform may need complementary institutional reforms to develop effective targeting, benefit delivery systems, and public communication strategies.

*Source: Authors’ calculations and computations based on country reviews and country studies (excerpts provided).*

### Appendix Table 1. Fuel Pr

### _wp10202 - Appendix Table 1. Fuel Pr

### Pass-through and retail price increases by region and country (end-2003 to mid-2008)
- Regional medians (Pass-through, Gasoline / Diesel / Kerosene / Average):
  - Africa: 89 / 85 / 79 / 82
  - Central & South America: 53 / 54 / 30 / 54
  - Asia & the Pacific: 81 / 71 / 57 / 74
  - Middle East: 11 / 8 / 6 / 2
  - All regions: 64 / 69 / 55 / 58
- Example country entries (Pass-through; Retail price increase, end-2003 (US$ per liter); mid-2008 (US$ per liter); Average tax rate (in percent change) where provided):
  - Burkina Faso: 49 / 66 / 60 / 60 ; 0.28 / 0.19 / 1.1 ; 0.64 / 0.72 / 0.60 / 0.67 ; 45 / 74
  - Cameroon: 58 / 51 / 55 / 54 ; 0.20 / 0.09 / 1.1 ; 0.64 / 0.61 / 0.52 / 0.61 ; 42 / 78
  - Central African Rep.: 52 / 59 / 51 / 55 ; 0.50 / 0.47 / 0.4 ; 0.74 / 0.80 / 0.59 / 0.73 ; 30 / 55
  - Congo, Rep. of: 50 / 38 / 14 / 35 ; 0.12 / -0.20 / 2.2 ; 0.57 / 0.45 / 0.26 / 0.43 ; 30 / 93
  - Gabon: 64 / 46 / 10 / 42 ; 0.33 / 0.06 / 2.2 ; 0.65 / 0.54 / 0.21 / 0.50 ; 37 / 92
  - Ghana: 92 / 86 / 79 / 87 ; 0.04 / -0.12 / 3.0 ; 0.56 / 0.63 / 0.57 / 0.60 ; 191 / 220
  - Madagascar: 161 / 146 / 101 / 140 ; 0.20 / 0.42 / -2.5 ; 0.97 / 1.09 / 0.75 / 0.98 ; 247 / 184
  - Mali: 76 / 55 / 43 / 58 ; 0.29 / 0.14 / 1.7 ; 0.72 / 0.61 / 0.49 / 0.61 ; 42 / 75
  - Mozambique: 154 / 114 / 106 / 120 ; 0.11 / 0.25 / -0.9 ; 1.04 / 0.90 / 0.83 / 0.91 ; 177 / 151
  - Senegal: 139 / 154 / ... / 151 ; 0.17 ; 0.74 / -2.0 ; 1.08 / 1.30 / ... / 1.27 ; 125 / 101
  - Bolivia: 11 / 12 / ... / 12 ; 0.18 / -0.48 / 11.4 ; 0.10 / 0.12 / ... / 0.11 ; 20 / 173
  - El Salvador: 106 / 112 / ... / 109 ; 0.02 / 0.09 / -0.5 ; 0.71 / 0.90 / ... / 0.82 ; 186 / 169
  - Honduras: 53 / 87 / 30 / 70 ; 0.07 / -0.16 / 3.4 ; 0.32 / 0.68 / 0.21 / 0.51 ; 124 / 170
  - Peru: 30 / 33 / 49 / 33 ; 0.16 / -0.26 / 2.6 ; 0.32 / 0.35 / 0.47 / 0.35 ; 34 / 103
  - Bangladesh: 106 / 62 / 67 / 68 ; -0.08 / -0.36 / 1.5 ; 0.67 / 0.46 / 0.51 / 0.49 ; 183 / 280
  - Cambodia: 112 / 69 / 73 / 79 ; 0.03 / -0.15 / 2.4 ; 0.76 / 0.54 / 0.57 / 0.59 ; 134 / 177
  - India: 36 / 37 / 2 / 30 ; 0.05 / -0.47 / 4.4 ; 0.29 / 0.31 / 0.03 / 0.26 ; 42 / 184
  - Indonesia: 34 / 34 / 17 / 31 ; -0.24 / -0.77 / 4.3 ; 0.21 / 0.26 / 0.14 / 0.22 ; 140 / 513
  - Sri Lanka: 81 / 47 / 46 / 54 ; -0.08 / -0.46 / 3.5 ; 0.50 / 0.34 / 0.35 / 0.38 ; 138 / 273
  - Jordan: 83 / 101 / 101 / 95 ; -0.18 / -0.20 / -1.0 ; 0.56 / 0.80 / 0.80 / 0.72 ; 330 / 337
  - Lebanon: 57 / 124 / 115 / 94 ; 0.02 / 0.01 / 0.2 ; 0.38 / 0.98 / 0.91 / 0.72 ; 210 / 194

- Note: Average pass-through and price increases are weighted by fuel consumption shares. Regional observations are group medians based on larger country samples: Africa (43 countries), Central and South America (31 countries), Asia and the Pacific (15 countries), Middle East (12 countries). [...] indicates information not available.

### Adjustment factors by fuel product (appendix table 2)
- Purpose: Factor adjustments indicate how fuel product budget shares need to be adjusted to calculate the impact of a $0.25 per liter increase in fuel prices. Values less the one indicate that a doubling of fuel prices would result in a greater than $0.25 per liter price increase. The factor for LPG is a weighted average of those for gasoline and diesel.
- Selected country factor values (Gasoline / Kerosene / Diesel / LPG):
  - Cameroon: 0.40 / 0.92 / 0.48 / 0.44
  - Gabon: 0.29 / 0.59 / 0.38 / 0.34
  - Central African Republic: 0.24 / 0.45 / 0.27 / 0.26
  - Senegal: 0.25 / 0.28 / 0.28 / 0.27
  - Ghana: 0.96 / 1.42 / 1.02 / 0.99
  - Mali: 0.36 / 0.59 / 0.58 / 0.47
  - Congo: 0.30 / 0.49 / 0.45 / 0.37
  - Burkina Faso: 0.29 / 0.57 / 0.40 / 0.35
  - Madagascar: 0.27 / 0.42 / 0.32 / 0.30
  - Bolivia: 0.54 / 0.71 / 0.52 / 0.53
  - Peru: 0.27 / 0.27 / 0.27 / 0.27
  - El Salvador: 0.38 / ... / 0.41 / 0.39
  - Honduras: 0.36 / 0.53 / 0.47 / 0.42
  - Bangladesh: 0.54 / 0.86 / 0.86 / 0.70
  - Sri Lanka: 0.33 / 0.95 / 0.88 / 0.61
  - Cambodia: 0.40 / 0.62 / 0.55 / 0.47
  - India: 0.28 / 1.23 / 0.46 / 0.37
  - Indonesia: 0.69 / 1.79 / 1.12 / 0.90
  - Jordan: 0.53 / 1.25 / 1.29 / 0.91
  - Lebanon: 0.35 / 0.67 / 0.72 / 0.54

### Distribution of impacts by region for a $0.25 per liter price increase (appendix table 3)
- Note: Impacts presented by consumption quintiles (Bottom / 2 / 3 / 4 / Top / All Households); values are percent impacts.
- Africa (Total Impact; Total Direct Impact; Indirect Impact):
  - Total Impact: 5.8 / 5.6 / 5.5 / 5.6 / 6.0 / 5.7
  - Total Direct Impact: 2.1 / 1.6 / 1.5 / 1.3 / 1.4 / 2.0
  - Indirect Impact: 3.5 / 3.7 / 3.7 / 3.9 / 4.0 / 3.8
  - Components (Gasoline / Kerosene / LPG / Electricity) shown in table for quintiles and All Households.
- South & Central America:
  - Total Impact: 3.7 / 3.6 / 3.8 / 4.0 / 3.9 / 3.7
  - Total Direct Impact: 0.5 / 0.6 / 0.6 / 0.6 / 0.7 / 1.4
  - Indirect Impact: 2.7 / 2.4 / 2.4 / 2.4 / 2.3 / 2.4
- Asia and Pacific:
  - Total Impact: 5.5 / 5.9 / 6.2 / 6.5 / 6.3 / 5.9
  - Total Direct Impact: 2.2 / 2.1 / 2.1 / 2.2 / 2.1 / 3.8
  - Indirect Impact: 2.4 / 2.6 / 2.6 / 2.6 / 2.2 / 2.1
- Middle East & Central Asia:
  - Total Impact: 12.0 / 10.5 / 10.3 / 9.6 / 8.8 / 9.6
  - Total Direct Impact: 2.8 / 2.7 / 3.0 / 2.9 / 2.4 / 5.4
  - Indirect Impact: 6.1 / 5.0 / 4.6 / 4.2 / 4.2 / 4.2
- All Regions:
  - Total Impact: 6.4 / 6.2 / 6.2 / 6.3 / 6.4 / 6.2
  - Direct Impact: 2.8 / 2.7 / 2.7 / 2.8 / 2.9 / 2.8
  - Indirect Impact: 3.6 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.3

### Distribution of subsidy benefits by consumption group (appendix table 4)
- Note: Shares of subsidy benefits by consumption quintile (Bottom / 2 / 3 / 4 / Top / All Households = 100.0)
- Africa (Total Impact and components; percentage shares across quintiles):
  - Total Impact: 7.8 / 11.5 / 15.3 / 21.2 / 44.2 / 100.0
  - Total Direct Impact: 8.0 / 10.6 / 13.7 / 19.6 / 48.1 / 100.0
  - Gasoline: 2.2 / 4.1 / 6.5 / 17.2 / 70.0 / 100.0
  - Kerosene: 15.8 / 17.6 / 20.6 / 20.7 / 25.3 / 100.0
  - LPG: 3.1 / 6.6 / 11.1 / 20.8 / 58.3 / 100.0
  - Indirect Impact: 6.7 / 10.9 / 15.7 / 22.3 / 44.4 / 100.0
- South & Central America:
  - Total Impact: 5.2 / 10.8 / 17.3 / 24.8 / 41.8 / 100.0
  - Total Direct Impact: 4.2 / 9.4 / 15.2 / 22.1 / 44.9 / 100.0
  - Gasoline: 4.2 / 8.6 / 14.8 / 22.2 / 50.2 / 100.0
  - Kerosene: 31.7 / 24.7 / 19.8 / 16.2 / 7.6 / 100.0
  - LPG: 3.2 / 8.4 / 15.4 / 23.3 / 46.0 / 100.0
  - Indirect Impact: 5.9 / 11.1 / 16.5 / 23.2 / 42.3 / 100.0
- Other Regions (aggregate shown in table):
  - Total Impact: 7.6 / 12.1 / 17.3 / 22.8 / 40.2 / 100.0
  - Total Direct Impact: 8.5 / 12.5 / 13.4 / 17.7 / 49.7 / 100.0
  - Gasoline: 4.2 / 8.6 / 14.8 / 22.2 / 50.2 / 100.0
  - Kerosene: 15.0 / 18.7 / 20.8 / 23.1 / 22.6 / 100.0
  - LPG: 4.5 / 5.7 / 8.1 / 11.8 / 70.0 / 100.0
  - Indirect Impact: 9.2 / 13.0 / 16.6 / 22.0 / 39.3 / 100.0
- All Regions (aggregate):
  - Total Impact: 7.1 / 11.4 / 16.2 / 22.5 / 42.8 / 100.0
  - Total Direct Impact: 7.1 / 10.7 / 14.0 / 19.9 / 47.6 / 100.0
  - Gasoline: 3.0 / 5.7 / 9.7 / 19.4 / 61.3 / 100.0
  - Kerosene: 19.0 / 19.7 / 20.6 / 20.1 / 20.6 / 100.0
  - LPG: 3.8 / 7.6 / 12.6 / 20.8 / 53.8 / 100.0
  - Indirect Impact: 7.3 / 11.7 / 16.3 / 22.6 / 42.0 / 100.0

### Pass-through of international price changes (2004–2008) (appendix table 5)
- Note: Pass-through, End-2003 Base (Percent) to successive years and to mid-2008. Regional medians:
  - Africa: To 2004 / To 2005 / To 2006 / To 2007 / To Mid-2008 = 142 / 108 / 140 / 88 / 81
  - Central & South America: 155 / 121 / 124 / 94 / 54
  - Asia & the Pacific: 88 / 84 / 105 / 80 / 74
  - Middle East: 0 / 53 / 32 (entries shown)
  - All regions: 100 / 102 / 122 / 80 / 58
- Selected country examples (End-2003 base pass-through percent to mid-2008 where listed):
  - Burkina Faso: 175 / 119 / 135 / 77 / 60
  - Cameroon: 123 / 83 / 136 / 80 / 54
  - Congo, Rep. of: 66 / 145 / 143 / 105 / 87
  - Madagascar: 228 / 138 / 183 / 146 / 140
  - Mozambique: 222 / 311 / 60 / 148 / 119
  - Senegal: 226 / 120 / 169 / 172 / 151
  - Bolivia: 53 / 37 / 33 / 18 / 12
  - El Salvador: 168 / 132 / 109 / 119 / 109
  - Honduras: 191 / 134 / 108 / 83 / 70
  - Peru: 142 / 102 / 105 / 82 / 33
  - Bangladesh: 177 / 49 / 37 / 67 / 68
  - Cambodia: 193 / 136 / 159 / 122 / 79
  - India: 85 / 74 / 78 / 47 / 30
  - Indonesia: 66 / 111 / 66 / 63 / 31
  - Sri Lanka: 85 / 76 / 82 / 59 / 54
  - Jordan: 285 / 91 / 46 / 72 / 95
  - Lebanon: 73 / 46 / 62 / 75 / 94

*Source: Dataset provided by Coady and others (2010).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2010/_wp10202.pdf_
