## _wp11127

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp11127](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/_wp11127.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/_wp11127.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/_wp11127.pdf.json)

---

### I. The relevance of government maps
- Purpose: maps reflect institutional coverage of any given government — the institutions or agencies that comprise a government sector — to improve comparability of fiscal data over time and across countries.
- Key conceptual framework:
  - Uses institutional approach from national accounts and GFSM 2001.
  - Defines three government levels: GL1 (budgetary central government), GL2 (central government = GL1 + extra-budgetary units + social security funds), GL3 (general government = GL2 + state and local governments).
  - Note: numbering GL1, GL2, GL3 inspired by M1/M2/M3 monetary concepts; social security funds in some countries may be outside legal central government but are classified as central government in the GFSY for comparability.
- Policy applications:
  - Reference points for fiscal targets and fiscal policy rules (e.g., European Excessive Debt and Deficit Procedure uses GL3).
  - IMF policy analysis and lending: common nomenclature helps define policy targets and indicators.
  - Timeliness: monthly data often available only for narrow budgetary sector (GL1); GL3 data often annual with delays — maps help estimate timely broader-level data when relationships are well defined.

### II. The IMF’s data on the structure of government (GFSY / GFSM 2001)
- Data source and format:
  - IMF’s Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (GFSY) provides institutional-level data following GFSM 2001.
  - GFSM 2001 presents government accounts in a business accounting framework (balance sheet and income statement).
  - GFSM 2001 requires separate presentation for each level of government and application of consolidation to avoid double counting.
- Database scope and limitations:
  - GFSY includes about 120 countries; maps produced for 74 countries with sufficient detail.
  - Database primarily populated with revenue and expenditure data; 36 countries currently report financial balance sheet data.
  - IMF adopted GFSM 2001 format for WEO database starting in 2010; country reports to phase in GFSM 2001 presentation starting in 2011.
- Data validation and improvement:
  - GFSY is based on official data reported by member countries and validated according to GFSM 2001 with ongoing dialogue with authorities.
  - Increased public use is expected to improve data quality via user feedback.

### III. Selected fiscal indicators and their components
- Focused indicators on maps: revenue, expenditure, net lending/net borrowing, tax effort, compensation of government employees; debt shown where available.
- Composition definitions (as presented):
  - Revenue excludes grants received from other government units (to avoid double counting).
  - Expenditure includes expense and net acquisition of non-financial assets.
  - Tax effort consists of revenue from taxes and social contributions.
  - Net Lending (+)/Borrowing (–) is not the same as GFSM 1986 “Lending minus Repayments” or “Net Lending”.
- Visual mapping: three-dimension maps for each country — institutional list, composition of GL1/GL2/GL3 in key indicators, and size relative to GDP.

### IV. Maps of governments — Australia example
- Institutional map notes (Figure 2 / GFSY 2009):
  - GL1 (Budgetary Central Government): agencies, departments, governor general’s office, judiciary, parliament.
  - GL2 (Central Government) further includes various agencies, commissions, and national universities; in Australia GL2 includes the Central Government and the Multi-jurisdictional sector (public universities in multi-jurisdictional category).
  - GL3 (General Government): GL2 plus state and local governments.
  - Local Government counts cited in the source: "Approximately 557 local government councils" and elsewhere "about 900 municipalities".
  - State Government: "6 state governments and 2 territory governments".
  - Social Security Funds: "Not applicable" for Australia.
  - Extra-budgetary units/accounts: government agencies, government commissions, government corporations, health insurance commission, and the Australian National University.
- Composition of government finance by levels (Table 2 — In percent of general government):
  - General Government: Revenue 100.0, Expenditure 100.0, Tax effort 100.0, Compensation of employees 100.0
  - Local Government: Revenue 5.6, Expenditure 6.9, Tax effort 2.9, Compensation of employees 8.2
  - State Government: Revenue 20.4, Expenditure 40.2, Tax effort 15.3, Compensation of employees 64.5
  - Central Government: Revenue 74.0, Expenditure 52.9, Tax effort 81.8, Compensation of employees 27.4
  - Social Security Funds: n/a n/a n/a n/a
  - Extrabudgetary Units: .... .... .... ....
  - Budgetary Central Gov: .... .... .... ....
  - Notes: 1. Revenue/expenditure excludes grants received from/paid to other government units. 2. Expenditure consists of expense and net acquisition of nonfinancial assets. 3. Tax effort consists of revenue from taxes and social contributions. 4. Data are included in budgetary central government.
- Government in percent of GDP (Table 3 — Australia, FY 2007/08; In percent of GDP — numeric strings preserved as in source):
  - General Government 35.1633.911.25
  - Local Government 1.962.33-0.37
  - State Government 7.1813.63-6.45
  - Central Government 26.0217.948.08
  - Notes from source:
    - GL3 revenue amounts to the equivalent of about one third of the economy.
    - Australia’s government shows an overall surplus: GL3 Net lending/borrowing positive "1.25 percent of GDP".
    - The NLB subsector components shown in italics are the contributions from each sector to the NLB of the General Government. The NLB subsector component is not the Net Lending Borrowing for that sector because grants are excluded.

### V. Key implications, summary statistics, and preliminary results
- Key implications and policy uses:
  - Explicit institutional coverage is necessary to make fiscal data meaningful and comparable across countries and over time.
  - Government maps enable more precise fiscal targets and regional fiscal rules based on comparable institutional coverage.
  - Maps enable improved estimation/timeliness methods for broader levels of government (GL3) using more timely GL1 data when relationships are well defined.
  - Maps provide benchmarks for analysts and users (academe, rating agencies) to validate and improve database reporting.
- Summary statistics on central government (GL2) as percent of general government (GL3), Fiscal Year 2008:
  - All: Revenue (Average) 88, Expenditure (Average) 79, Number of Countries 63
  - Advanced Economies: Revenue (Average) 82, Expenditure (Average) 72, Number of Countries 24
  - Developing and Emerging Economies: Revenue (Average) 91, Expenditure (Average) 83, Number of Countries 39
  - Sub-Saharan Africa: Revenue 95, Expenditure 86, Number of Countries 5
  - Asia Pacific: Revenue 93, Expenditure 88, Number of Countries 6
  - Europe: Revenue 84, Expenditure 73, Number of Countries 36
  - Middle East and Central Asia: Revenue 94, Expenditure 87, Number of Countries 9
  - Western Hemisphere: Revenue 89, Expenditure 81, Number of Countries 7
- Preliminary results by country group:
  - For advanced countries:
    - GL2 data for revenue capture about 80 percent of GL3
    - Expenditure data capture only about 70 percent of GL3
    - Expenditure levels are lower than revenue levels because part of the revenue is passed on to state and local levels of government or other institutions or agencies not included in GL2
  - For emerging and developing economies:
    - GL2 data represent a higher level of GL3: 90 percent for revenue and 80 percent for expenditure, reflecting more centralized government structures

### IV. Applications, further research, and conclusions
- Timeliness and periodicity considerations:
  - The GFSY presents comprehensive annual data covering 12-month periods.
  - These comprehensive data are typically published with a delay of about a year.
  - For forward looking fiscal policy analysis and forecasts, monthly or quarterly data are often more relevant than annual data.
  - Trade-off: comprehensiveness versus timeliness.
  - Comprehensive annual data such as the GFSY can serve as a benchmark or as a basis for developing estimation models for high-frequency (monthly or quarterly) fiscal data.
- Research extensions and ongoing work:
  - Time series analysis to explore patterns and changes over time.
  - A research project is underway to analyze historical trends for cross sections of countries.
  - The research highlights data gaps that can be used to develop a strategy for enhancing the completeness of the database.
- Conclusions:
  - Maps of government are available for 74 countries that regularly provide data to the GFSY.
  - In total, there are 120 countries in the database and some information on the structure of government is available for each of these, although not all provide sufficient or sufficiently timely data to produce meaningful government maps.
  - Introduced terminology GL1, GL2, and GL3 to represent three main levels of government in ascending order of institutional coverage.
  - GL3 is the most relevant institutional coverage for the data for most countries because it captures government activities in a comprehensive way.
  - Assembling GL3 data is often time-consuming, compromising timeliness and usefulness for policy analysis; more timely data are often available for less comprehensive levels (GL1 or GL2).
  - Government maps can be used to develop estimation techniques including for estimates of GL3.
  - The work on government maps could be expanded to incorporate data on government assets and liabilities.
  - Maps can be used to enhance the timeliness of some data, particularly state and local government data which tend to be available with relatively large delays.
  - Time series analysis of how maps change over time is helpful in setting benchmarks for estimating missing data for individual countries and for country groups.

### Key statistics and data notes
- GDP = Australian dollars 1,187,213 million
- Revenue/Expenditure excludes grants received from/paid to other government units
- Expenditure consists of expense and net acquisition of nonfinancial assets
- An ellipsis (...) means the absence of data, and a notation (n/a) means that the subsector does not exist
- The NLB subsector components shown in italics are the contributions from each sector to the NLB of the General Government. The NLB subsector component is not the Net Lending Borrowing for that sector because grants are excluded
- Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (2009)

*Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (2009); content as presented in the source PDF.*

### Bibliography ...........................................................................................................

### _wp11127 - Bibliography ...........................................................................................................

### I. The relevance of government maps
- Purpose: maps reflect institutional coverage of any given government — the institutions or agencies that comprise a government sector — to improve comparability of fiscal data over time and across countries.
- Key conceptual framework:
  - Uses institutional approach from national accounts and GFSM 2001.
  - Defines three government levels: GL1 (budgetary central government), GL2 (central government = GL1 + extra-budgetary units + social security funds), GL3 (general government = GL2 + state and local governments).
  - Note: numbering GL1, GL2, GL3 inspired by M1/M2/M3 monetary concepts; social security funds in some countries may be outside legal central government but are classified as central government in the GFSY for comparability.
- Policy applications:
  - Reference points for fiscal targets and fiscal policy rules (e.g., European Excessive Debt and Deficit Procedure uses GL3).
  - IMF policy analysis and lending: common nomenclature helps define policy targets and indicators.
  - Timeliness: monthly data often available only for narrow budgetary sector (GL1); GL3 data often annual with delays — maps help estimate timely broader-level data when relationships are well defined.

### II. The IMF’s data on the structure of government (GFSY / GFSM 2001)
- Data source and format:
  - IMF’s Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (GFSY) provides institutional-level data following GFSM 2001.
  - GFSM 2001 presents government accounts in a business accounting framework (balance sheet and income statement).
  - GFSM 2001 requires separate presentation for each level of government and application of consolidation to avoid double counting.
- Database scope and limitations:
  - GFSY includes about 120 countries; maps produced for 74 countries with sufficient detail.
  - Database primarily populated with revenue and expenditure data; 36 countries currently report financial balance sheet data.
  - IMF adopted GFSM 2001 format for WEO database starting in 2010; country reports to phase in GFSM 2001 presentation starting in 2011.
- Data validation and improvement:
  - GFSY is based on official data reported by member countries and validated according to GFSM 2001 with ongoing dialogue with authorities.
  - Increased public use is expected to improve data quality via user feedback.

### III. Selected fiscal indicators and their components
- Focused indicators on maps: revenue, expenditure, net lending/net borrowing, tax effort, compensation of government employees; debt shown where available.
- Composition definitions (as presented):
  - Revenue excludes grants received from other government units (to avoid double counting).
  - Expenditure includes expense and net acquisition of non-financial assets.
  - Tax effort consists of revenue from taxes and social contributions.
  - Net Lending (+)/Borrowing (–) is not the same as GFSM 1986 “Lending minus Repayments” or “Net Lending”.
- Visual mapping: three-dimension maps for each country — institutional list, composition of GL1/GL2/GL3 in key indicators, and size relative to GDP.

### IV. Maps of governments — Australia example
- Institutional map notes (Figure 2 / GFSY 2009):
  - GL1 (Budgetary Central Government): agencies, departments, governor general’s office, judiciary, parliament.
  - GL2 (Central Government) further includes various agencies, commissions, and national universities; in Australia GL2 includes the Central Government and the Multi-jurisdictional sector (public universities in multi-jurisdictional category).
  - GL3 (General Government): GL2 plus state and local governments.
  - Local Government counts cited in the source: "Approximately 557 local government councils" and elsewhere "about 900 municipalities" (both appear in the source text).
  - State Government: "6 state governments and 2 territory governments" (as presented).
  - Social Security Funds: "Not applicable" for Australia.
  - Extra-budgetary units/accounts: government agencies, government commissions, government corporations, health insurance commission, and the Australian National University (as listed).
- Composition of government finance by levels (Table 2 — In percent of general government):
  - General Government: Revenue 100.0, Expenditure 100.0, Tax effort 100.0, Compensation of employees 100.0
  - Local Government: Revenue 5.6, Expenditure 6.9, Tax effort 2.9, Compensation of employees 8.2
  - State Government: Revenue 20.4, Expenditure 40.2, Tax effort 15.3, Compensation of employees 64.5
  - Central Government: Revenue 74.0, Expenditure 52.9, Tax effort 81.8, Compensation of employees 27.4
  - Social Security Funds: n/a n/a n/a n/a
  - Extrabudgetary Units: .... .... .... ....
  - Budgetary Central Gov: .... .... .... ....
  - Notes: 1. Revenue/expenditure excludes grants received from/paid to other government units. 2. Expenditure consists of expense and net acquisition of nonfinancial assets. 3. Tax effort consists of revenue from taxes and social contributions. 4. Data are included in budgetary central government.
- Government in percent of GDP (Table 3 — Australia, FY 2007/08; In percent of GDP — numeric strings preserved as in source):
  - General Government 35.1633.911.25
  - Local Government 1.962.33-0.37
  - State Government 7.1813.63-6.45
  - Central Government 26.0217.948.08
  - Notes from source:
    - GL3 revenue amounts to the equivalent of about one third of the economy.
    - Australia’s government shows an overall surplus: GL3 Net lending/borrowing positive "1.25 percent of GDP" (appears as part of the General Government numeric string above).
    - Italic figures in the source are contributing factors of GL3’s Net Lending/Borrowing; GL3 grants cancel out.

### V. Key implications and policy uses (as emphasized in the source)
- Explicit institutional coverage is necessary to make fiscal data meaningful and comparable across countries and over time.
- Government maps enable:
  - More precise fiscal targets and regional fiscal rules based on comparable institutional coverage.
  - Improved estimation/timeliness methods for broader levels of government (GL3) using more timely GL1 data when relationships are well defined.
  - Benchmarks for analysts and users (academe, rating agencies) to validate and improve database reporting.

*Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook data and accompanying text as presented in the supplied PDF content.*

### 1. GDP = Australian dollars 1,187,213 million

### _wp11127 - 1. GDP = Australian dollars 1,187,213 million

### Key statistics and data notes
- GDP = Australian dollars 1,187,213 million
- Revenue/Expenditure excludes grants received from/paid to other government units
- Expenditure consists of expense and net acquisition of nonfinancial assets
- An ellipsis (...) means the absence of data, and a notation (n/a) means that the subsector does not exist
- The NLB subsector components shown in italics are the contributions from each sector to the NLB of the General Government. The NLB subsector component is not the Net Lending Borrowing for that sector because grants are excluded.
- Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (2009)

### D. Some Preliminary Results
- For advanced countries:
  - GL2 data for revenue capture about 80 percent of GL3
  - Expenditure data capture only about 70 percent of GL3
  - Expenditure levels are lower than revenue levels because part of the revenue is passed on to state and local levels of government or other institutions or agencies not included in GL2
- For emerging and developing economies:
  - GL2 data represent a higher level of GL3: 90 percent for revenue and 80 percent for expenditure, reflecting more centralized government structures
- Table 4. Summary Statistics on Government Maps — Revenue and Expenditure of Central Government (GL2) in percent of General Government (GL3), Averages by Country Groups, Fiscal Year 2008:
  - All: Revenue (Average) 88, Expenditure (Average) 79, Number of Countries 63
  - Advanced Economies: Revenue (Average) 82, Expenditure (Average) 72, Number of Countries 24
  - Developing and Emerging Economies: Revenue (Average) 91, Expenditure (Average) 83, Number of Countries 39
  - Sub-Saharan Africa: Revenue 95, Expenditure 86, Number of Countries 5
  - Asia Pacific: Revenue 93, Expenditure 88, Number of Countries 6
  - Europe: Revenue 84, Expenditure 73, Number of Countries 36
  - Middle East and Central Asia: Revenue 94, Expenditure 87, Number of Countries 9
  - Western Hemisphere: Revenue 89, Expenditure 81, Number of Countries 7
- Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (2009)

### IV. Applications and Further Research
- Fiscal policy analysis should specify the level of government to enhance rigor and cross-country comparability of data
- Timeliness and periodicity considerations:
  - The GFSY presents comprehensive annual data covering 12-month periods
  - These comprehensive data are typically published with a delay of about a year
  - For forward looking fiscal policy analysis and forecasts, monthly or quarterly data are often more relevant than annual data
  - Trade-off: comprehensiveness versus timeliness
  - Comprehensive annual data such as the GFSY can serve as a benchmark or as a basis for developing estimation models for high-frequency (monthly or quarterly) fiscal data
- Research extensions and ongoing work:
  - Time series analysis to explore patterns and changes over time
  - A research project is underway to analyze historical trends for cross sections of countries
  - The research highlights data gaps that can be used to develop a strategy for enhancing the completeness of the database

### V. Conclusions
- Coverage and availability:
  - Maps of government are available for 74 countries that regularly provide data to the GFSY
  - In total, there are 120 countries in the database and some information on the structure of government is available for each of these, although not all provide sufficient or sufficiently timely data to produce meaningful government maps
- Terminology and institutional coverage:
  - Introduced terminology GL1, GL2, and GL3 to represent three main levels of government in ascending order of institutional coverage
  - Statistical definitions: GL1 = budgetary, GL2 = central, GL3 = general government
  - GL3 is the most relevant institutional coverage for the data for most countries because it captures government activities in a comprehensive way
  - Assembling GL3 data is often time-consuming, compromising timeliness and usefulness for policy analysis
  - More timely data are often available for less comprehensive levels (GL1 or GL2)
  - Government maps can be used to develop estimation techniques including for estimates of GL3
- Additional observations and applications:
  - Some countries are highly centralized and GL2 and GL3 indicators are virtually identical; in others, lower levels of government have large roles
  - Government maps are useful for defining fiscal policy goals and how these are assigned to various levels of government
  - Maps are useful in defining or monitoring fiscal rules
  - The work on government maps could be expanded to incorporate data on government assets and liabilities
  - Maps can be used to enhance the timeliness of some data, particularly state and local government data which tend to be available with relatively large delays
  - Time series analysis of how maps change over time is helpful in setting benchmarks for estimating missing data for individual countries and for country groups

*Source: Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (2009); content as presented in the source PDF.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/_wp11127.pdf_
