## 7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/_wp12145.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/_wp12145.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/_wp12145.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction — scope and approach
- Focus: quantify Brazil’s spillovers to other South American countries via trade linkages, using a multivariate VAR framework to separate Brazil-specific effects from common global factors.
- Key modelling choices:
  - Sample: quarterly data, 1990:Q1 through 2011:Q4.
  - Variables: global demand, international financial conditions (VIX), commodity prices, Brazil’s real GDP, domestic real GDP; Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, and Uruguay VARs also include Argentina’s real GDP.
  - Estimation: variables in log levels, model estimated in first differences (except VIX in levels), two lags (AIC-guided); identification via Choleski ordering: global variables (global output, VIX, commodity prices) → regional variables (Brazil, Argentina) → domestic output.
- Global variable operationalization:
  - Global demand: weighted average of real GDP of G7 and China, weights = PPP-adjusted GDPs.
  - International financial conditions: Chicago Board Options Exchange Market Volatility Index (VIX).
  - Commodity prices: broad price index, in real terms and stripped of exchange rate effects.

### II. Export linkages with Brazil — patterns and magnitudes
- Regional evolution:
  - Brazil’s share in neighboring countries’ exports doubled from 8 to 16 percent during the 1990s, then fell in the early 2000s back to early-1990s levels and remained broadly stable thereafter.
  - Trade with Brazil contributed only marginally to the deepening of intra-regional integration during the 1990s–2000s.
- Heterogeneity across countries:
  - Southern Cone (Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Bolivia, and to a lesser extent Chile) have relatively high export exposure to Brazil.
  - Current exposure (approximately):
    - Exports to Brazil represent around 20 (4) percent of total exports (GDP) for Paraguay, Uruguay and Argentina.
    - Exports to Brazil represent more than 40 (9) percent of total exports (GDP) for Bolivia.
  - Andean region (Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, Venezuela): exports to Brazil historically and currently very limited — representing today less than 3 percent of total exports and ½ percent of GDP.
- Indirect exposure:
  - Second-order (indirect) exposure — weighted average of partners’ direct exposures — increases exposures only marginally.

### III. VAR results — Brazil-idiosyncratic shocks
- Main empirical finding:
  - Brazil-specific output shocks significantly affect output in Southern Cone countries (strongest in Mercosur members); generally negligible for Andean countries (exception: Peru).
- Dynamics and magnitude:
  - Transmission is typically quick; most impact occurs within the same quarter (except Chile, where effects are small and one-quarter lagged).
  - Effects are short-lived in most countries (except Paraguay, where effects persist for three quarters).
  - Estimated Brazil shock magnitude used: one standard deviation (equivalent to 1.2–1.7 percentage points of Brazil’s quarterly GDP growth).
- Elasticities and peak cumulative impacts:
  - Paraguay: a 1 percentage point decrease in Brazil’s growth reduces output by 0.9 percent (peak cumulative impact).
  - Argentina, Bolivia, Uruguay: peak cumulative impact of about ¼ percent (per 1 percentage point Brazil growth decline).
  - Chile: peak cumulative impact smaller than the above.
  - At an 8-quarter horizon, cumulative impacts are considerably smaller than peak impacts; in Uruguay the impact fully vanishes by 8 quarters.
- Robustness notes:
  - Bolivia results should be interpreted with caution due to large changes in exposure over the period (gas exports governed by long-term contracts).
  - Peru’s sensitivity to Brazil shocks is puzzling given limited trade/financial linkages; may reflect other common factors not captured.

### IV. Brazil as amplifier of global shocks
- Methodology:
  - Follow Bayoumi and Swiston (2008): estimate VARs with and without Brazil treated as exogenous to isolate Brazil’s amplification of global shocks. Amplification = response(original model) − response(with Brazil exogenous).
- Key findings:
  - Brazil amplifies global shocks, especially financial shocks (VIX), for most Southern Cone countries.
  - Quantified example:
    - A 10 unit increase in the VIX → cumulative output decline due to the Brazilian “knock-on” effect of 0.5–0.6 percent in Argentina, Paraguay, and Uruguay.
    - The same channel produces smaller impacts, 0.3–0.4 percent, in Bolivia and Chile.
  - Amplification effects from Brazil are not statistically significant for Andean countries (except Peru).
- Interpretation:
  - Amplification effect combines: (1) sensitivity of Brazil’s output to global shocks; and (2) effect of Brazil’s output changes on neighboring countries.

### V. Variance decomposition — importance of Brazil for output volatility
- At an 8-quarter horizon, fraction of GDP variance explained by Brazil’s spillovers (selected):
  - Paraguay: 16 percent.
  - Argentina: 10 percent.
  - Uruguay: 6 percent (but Argentina explains about 20 percent of Uruguay’s variance).
  - Bolivia and Chile: about 5 percent.
  - Andean region (excluding Peru): negligible share attributable to Brazil.

### VI. Impact of Brazilian real depreciations
- Stylized evidence from January 1999 real depreciation:
  - Exports to Brazil collapsed mostly before the depreciation and either stabilized or recovered afterward.
  - Suggests expansionary effects on Brazil’s domestic demand/output largely offset substitution effects on neighbors’ exports.
  - This pattern holds even when bilateral real exchange rates moved sharply and some partners could not adjust nominally.
- VAR tests including real effective exchange rates (REER) of Brazil and neighbor:
  - A real effective exchange rate shock in Brazil has no statistically significant effect on output in most smaller neighboring economies.
  - Interpretation: expansionary impact of Brazil’s real depreciation on Brazil’s output tends to compensate any negative substitution effect in most Southern Cone economies.
  - Exception: Uruguay — Brazil’s real depreciation did not lead to a statistically significant change in Uruguay’s REER, but domestic output in Uruguay declined on impact (statistically significant), possibly reflecting liability dollarization and currency mismatches in the early part of the sample.
- Figure A.7 details (August 1998 to December 2000, series indexed to August 1998 = 100):
  - Series shown (by panel): Exports to Brazil (US$, August 1998=100); Exports to the rest of the world (US$, August 1998=100); Bilateral real exchange rate.
  - Countries represented: Argentina, Paraguay, Chile, Uruguay.
  - Annotation: “A decline reflects a real depreciation of the Brazilian real with respect to the other countries' currencies.”
  - Chart timeframe markers: Aug, Oct, Dec, Feb, Apr, Jun across 1998–2000.
  - Data and measurement notes: Export values measured in US$ and indexed to August 1998 = 100.
  - Statistical precision note present: 1.6 percentage points) ± 1.5 standard errors.

### VII. Conclusions — policy-relevant takeaways
- Geographic heterogeneity:
  - Southern Cone countries (Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, Uruguay) have sizeable export linkages with Brazil and are subject to meaningful spillovers from Brazil’s idiosyncratic shocks and from Brazil’s amplification of global shocks.
  - Andean countries generally experience negligible spillovers from Brazil, consistent with weak trade linkages; observed business-cycle comovement likely reflects common global shocks rather than Brazil-origin spillovers.
- Real depreciation concerns:
  - No evidence that sharp depreciations of the Brazilian real have significant negative effects on neighbor output; expansion in Brazil tends to offset substitution effects in most cases.
- Implication for policymakers:
  - Countries in the Southern Cone should monitor Brazil’s domestic cycle and its sensitivity to global financial conditions (VIX), as both direct and amplification channels can transmit sizable shocks.
  - For Andean countries, policy focus on common global exposures may be more relevant than Brazil-specific spillovers.

*Source: _wp12145 - 7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors (IMF Working Paper content provided).*

### References .............................................................................................................

### _wp12145 - References

### Tables
- 1. Business Cycle Comovement with Large Neighbors, 1990:Q1-2011:Q4 .......................4
- 2. Cumulative Impact on Output.......... ...........................................................................11

### Figures
- 1. Latin America’s Large Neighbors, 2010 ..........................................................................3
- 2. South America: Exports of Goods by Region, 1990-2010 ...............................................6
- 3. South America: Intra-Regional Exports of Goods 1990-2010 .........................................6
- 4. South America’s Exports: Exposure to Brazil, 1990-2010 ...............................................7
- 5. Export Performance in Brazil’s Neighbors, 1990-2011 ...................................................7
- 6. Output Response to a Shock to Brazil’s Output .............................................................10
- 7. Output Response to a VIX Shock: Brazil’s Amplifying Role ........................................12
- 8. Variance Decomposition of Output ................................................................................13
- 9. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone 
         Neighbors  ..............................................................................................................14
- 10. Responses to a Shock to Brazil’s Real Exchange Rate ...................................................15

### Appendix Figures
- 1. South America: Exports of Goods by Region, 1990-2010 (Percent of Total Exports) ..16
- 2. South America: Exports of Goods by Region, 1990-2010 (Percent of GDP) ................17
- 3. Output Response to a Shock to Global Output ...............................................................18
- 4. Output Response to a Shock to the VIX  ........................................................................18
- 5. Output Response to a Shock to Commodity Prices ........................................................19
- 6. Output Response to a Shock to Argentina’s Output .......................................................19

*Source: _wp12145 - References (PDF).*

### 7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone

### 7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors

### I. Introduction — scope and approach
- Focus: quantify Brazil’s spillovers to other South American countries via trade linkages, using a multivariate VAR framework to separate Brazil-specific effects from common global factors.
- Key modelling choices:
  - Sample: quarterly data, 1990:Q1 through 2011:Q4.
  - Variables: global demand, international financial conditions (VIX), commodity prices, Brazil’s real GDP, domestic real GDP; Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, and Uruguay VARs also include Argentina’s real GDP.
  - Estimation: variables in log levels, model estimated in first differences (except VIX in levels), two lags (AIC-guided); identification via Choleski ordering: global variables (global output, VIX, commodity prices) → regional variables (Brazil, Argentina) → domestic output.
- Global variable operationalization:
  - Global demand: weighted average of real GDP of G7 and China, weights = PPP-adjusted GDPs.
  - International financial conditions: Chicago Board Options Exchange Market Volatility Index (VIX).
  - Commodity prices: broad price index, in real terms and stripped of exchange rate effects.

### II. Export linkages with Brazil — patterns and magnitudes
- Regional evolution:
  - Brazil’s share in neighboring countries’ exports doubled from 8 to 16 percent during the 1990s, then fell in the early 2000s back to early-1990s levels and remained broadly stable thereafter.
  - Trade with Brazil contributed only marginally to the deepening of intra-regional integration during the 1990s–2000s.
- Heterogeneity across countries:
  - Southern Cone (Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Bolivia, and to a lesser extent Chile) have relatively high export exposure to Brazil.
  - Current exposure (approximately):
    - Exports to Brazil represent around 20 (4) percent of total exports (GDP) for Paraguay, Uruguay and Argentina.
    - Exports to Brazil represent more than 40 (9) percent of total exports (GDP) for Bolivia.
  - Andean region (Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, Venezuela): exports to Brazil historically and currently very limited — representing today less than 3 percent of total exports and ½ percent of GDP.
- Indirect exposure:
  - Second-order (indirect) exposure — weighted average of partners’ direct exposures — increases exposures only marginally.

### III. VAR results — Brazil-idiosyncratic shocks
- Main empirical finding:
  - Brazil-specific output shocks significantly affect output in Southern Cone countries (strongest in Mercosur members); generally negligible for Andean countries (exception: Peru).
- Dynamics and magnitude:
  - Transmission is typically quick; most impact occurs within the same quarter (except Chile, where effects are small and one-quarter lagged).
  - Effects are short-lived in most countries (except Paraguay, where effects persist for three quarters).
  - Estimated Brazil shock magnitude used: one standard deviation (equivalent to 1.2–1.7 percentage points of Brazil’s quarterly GDP growth).
- Elasticities and peak cumulative impacts:
  - Paraguay: a 1 percentage point decrease in Brazil’s growth reduces output by 0.9 percent (peak cumulative impact).
  - Argentina, Bolivia, Uruguay: peak cumulative impact of about ¼ percent (per 1 percentage point Brazil growth decline).
  - Chile: peak cumulative impact smaller than the above.
  - At an 8-quarter horizon, cumulative impacts are considerably smaller than peak impacts; in Uruguay the impact fully vanishes by 8 quarters.
- Robustness notes:
  - Bolivia results should be interpreted with caution due to large changes in exposure over the period (gas exports governed by long-term contracts).
  - Peru’s sensitivity to Brazil shocks is puzzling given limited trade/financial linkages; may reflect other common factors not captured.

### IV. Brazil as amplifier of global shocks
- Methodology:
  - Follow Bayoumi and Swiston (2008): estimate VARs with and without Brazil treated as exogenous to isolate Brazil’s amplification of global shocks. Amplification = response(original model) − response(with Brazil exogenous).
- Key findings:
  - Brazil amplifies global shocks, especially financial shocks (VIX), for most Southern Cone countries.
  - Quantified example:
    - A 10 unit increase in the VIX → cumulative output decline due to the Brazilian “knock-on” effect of 0.5–0.6 percent in Argentina, Paraguay, and Uruguay.
    - The same channel produces smaller impacts, 0.3–0.4 percent, in Bolivia and Chile.
  - Amplification effects from Brazil are not statistically significant for Andean countries (except Peru).
- Interpretation:
  - Amplification effect combines: (1) sensitivity of Brazil’s output to global shocks; and (2) effect of Brazil’s output changes on neighboring countries.

### V. Variance decomposition — importance of Brazil for output volatility
- At an 8-quarter horizon, fraction of GDP variance explained by Brazil’s spillovers (selected):
  - Paraguay: 16 percent.
  - Argentina: 10 percent.
  - Uruguay: 6 percent (but Argentina explains about 20 percent of Uruguay’s variance).
  - Bolivia and Chile: about 5 percent.
  - Andean region (excluding Peru): negligible share attributable to Brazil.

### VI. Impact of Brazilian real depreciations
- Stylized evidence from January 1999 real depreciation:
  - Exports to Brazil collapsed mostly before the depreciation and either stabilized or recovered afterward.
  - Suggests expansionary effects on Brazil’s domestic demand/output largely offset substitution effects on neighbors’ exports.
  - This pattern holds even when bilateral real exchange rates moved sharply and some partners could not adjust nominally.
- VAR tests including real effective exchange rates (REER) of Brazil and neighbor:
  - A real effective exchange rate shock in Brazil has no statistically significant effect on output in most smaller neighboring economies.
  - Interpretation: expansionary impact of Brazil’s real depreciation on Brazil’s output tends to compensate any negative substitution effect in most Southern Cone economies.
  - Exception: Uruguay — Brazil’s real depreciation did not lead to a statistically significant change in Uruguay’s REER, but domestic output in Uruguay declined on impact (statistically significant), possibly reflecting liability dollarization and currency mismatches in the early part of the sample.

### VII. Conclusions — policy-relevant takeaways
- Geographic heterogeneity:
  - Southern Cone countries (Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, Uruguay) have sizeable export linkages with Brazil and are subject to meaningful spillovers from Brazil’s idiosyncratic shocks and from Brazil’s amplification of global shocks.
  - Andean countries generally experience negligible spillovers from Brazil, consistent with weak trade linkages; observed business-cycle comovement likely reflects common global shocks rather than Brazil-origin spillovers.
- Real depreciation concerns:
  - No evidence that sharp depreciations of the Brazilian real have significant negative effects on neighbor output; expansion in Brazil tends to offset substitution effects in most cases.
- Implication for policymakers:
  - Countries in the Southern Cone should monitor Brazil’s domestic cycle and its sensitivity to global financial conditions (VIX), as both direct and amplification channels can transmit sizable shocks.
  - For Andean countries, policy focus on common global exposures may be more relevant than Brazil-specific spillovers.

*Source: _wp12145 - 7. Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors (IMF Working Paper content provided).*

### 1.6 percentage points) ± 1.5 standard errors. Time horizon in quarters.

### _wp12145 - 1.6 percentage points) ± 1.5 standard errors. Time horizon in quarters.

### Figure A.7 — Real Exchange Rate Depreciation in Brazil: Export Performance in Southern Cone Neighbors
- Chart timeframe: August 1998 to December 2000 (series indexed to August 1998 = 100).
- Series shown (by panel):
  - Exports to Brazil (US$, August 1998=100).
  - Exports to the rest of the world (US$, August 1998=100).
  - Bilateral real exchange rate (series plotted alongside exports).
- Countries represented:
  - Argentina
  - Paraguay
  - Chile
  - Uruguay
- Key annotation from figure:
  - “A decline reflects a real depreciation of the Brazilian real with respect to the other countries' currencies.”
- Visual behavior implied by figure labeling:
  - Export series fluctuate between values shown on axes such as 50, 70, 90, 110, 120, and 100 depending on panel and date markers (Aug, Oct, Dec, Feb, Apr, Jun across 1998–2000).
  - Time markers explicitly shown: Aug, Oct, Dec, Feb, Apr, Jun, Aug, Oct, Dec across 1998, 1999, 2000.

### Data and measurement notes
- Export values measured in US$ and indexed to August 1998 = 100.
- Time horizon referenced elsewhere in the content: “Time horizon in quarters.”
- Statistical precision statement present in header: “1.6 percentage points) ± 1.5 standard errors.”

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/_wp12145.pdf*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/_wp12145.pdf_
