## Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2013/_wp13245.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2013/_wp13245.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2013/_wp13245.pdf.json)

---

### Main findings on labor force participation
- Cyclical factors account for the bulk of the post-2007 decline in the U.S. labor force participation rate.
- Labor force participation is characterized as essentially acyclical during “normal times” (that is, in response to small or transitory shocks) but can drop markedly in the wake of a large and persistent aggregate demand shock.
- The decline in participation observed after 2007 is largely explained by cyclical developments rather than primarily by long-run structural trends.

### Model and mechanisms
- Stylized New Keynesian model formulation:
  - Participation does not move much in response to small or transitory shocks.
  - Participation falls substantially when the economy experiences a large and persistent aggregate demand shortfall.
- The model links the size and persistence of aggregate demand shocks to the likelihood and magnitude of declines in the labor force participation rate.

### Implications for monetary policy
- The cyclical nature of the post-2007 participation decline has potentially crucial implications for the design of monetary policy.
- These implications are especially important under circumstances in which adjustments to the short-term interest rate are constrained by the zero lower bound.
- Monetary policy that fails to address large and persistent aggregate demand shortfalls may induce larger and more persistent reductions in participation, amplifying the weakness of the labor market.

### Policy recommendations and considerations
- Recognize that part of the decline in participation is reversible if cyclical demand is restored, implying policy can play a role in reversing participation losses.
- In environments where the short-term nominal interest rate is constrained by the zero lower bound, monetary policy frameworks should account for the risk that prolonged aggregate demand shortfalls can depress participation and hence potential output.
- Policy design should consider actions that mitigate large and persistent demand gaps to prevent persistent participation declines and associated long-run costs.

### Empirical figures, labels, and state-level evidence (captured from figures)
- Chart axis values preserved as shown: -0.2, -0.1, 0.0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4.
- Additional numeric axis labels: 4 8 12 16 20.
- Axis labels and legend items appearing in figures: Number of Quarters; Percent; Unemployment Rate; Labor Force Participation Rate.
- State/area labels appearing near points: FL, CA, NY, NV, TX, IL, MI.
- Scatter/panel tick values preserved: -5, -4, -3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2.
- Time-series years explicitly shown on time axis: 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011.
- Series or trend labels present in panels: Pre-Crisis Trend; Prime-Age Adults (25 to 54 years); Older Adults (55 to 64 years).
- Regression references in figures: Regression Line.

### Labor market gaps and time-series panels (captured labels)
- Labels preserved verbatim: Employment Gap; Participation Gap; Unemployment Gap.
- Year sequence preserved where visible: 200820092010201120122013.
- Vertical numeric markers in one panel: 9, 10, 11, 12.
- Small-axis numeric values preserved: 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0, 1.2.
- Change axes values preserved: 0 1 2 3 4 and 0 2 4 6 8 10.

### Figures on monetary policy scenarios and numeric ranges (Figure-level precisions preserved)
- Figure 7 (Monetary Policy Tightening) — retained axis ranges and labels:
  - Overall Employment Gap range: -0.7, -0.6, -0.5, -0.4, -0.3, -0.2, -0.1, 0.
  - Transient Tightening time ticks: 04 08 12 16.
  - Persistent Tightening time ticks: 08 16 24 32.
  - Unemployment Gap: range -5 to 10 (percent).
  - Participation Gap: range -3 to 0 (percent).
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (percent).
  - Inflation: range 1 to 2.5 (percent).
  - Overall Employment Gap (alternate panel): range -10 to 5 (percent).
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (percent).
- Figure 8 (Adverse Demand Shock under Different Monetary Rules) — retained policy regimes and axis ranges:
  - Policy regimes: Inflation Targeting; Overall Employment Gap Targeting; Unemployment Rate Targeting.
  - Time ticks: 08 16 24 32.
  - Unemployment Gap: range -2 to 4 (Percent).
  - Participation Gap: range -3 to 0 (Percent).
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (Percent).
  - Inflation: range 1.6 to 2.4 (Percent).
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -6 to 2 (Percent).
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent).
- Figure 9 (Faster Participation Response) — preserved ranges:
  - Policy comparisons: Employment Gap Targeting; Unemployment Rate Targeting.
  - Participation Gap: range -0.8 to 0 (Percent).
  - Inflation: range 1.5 to 3 (Percent).
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 0 (Percent).
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent).
- Figure 10 (Different Phillips Curve Slopes) — preserved ranges:
  - Comparisons: Faster Price Adjustment; Benchmark Calibration.
  - Participation Gap: range -1 to 0 (Percent).
  - Inflation: range 1.8 to 2.6 (Percent).
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 0 (Percent).
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent).
- Figure 11 (Coefficients on Participation Gap) — preserved ranges:
  - Comparisons: Equal Coeff on Participation Gap; Benchmark; Tiny Coeff on Participation Gap.
  - Participation Gap: range -1 to 0.5 (Percent).
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 2 (Percent).
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent).
- Figure 12 (Employment Gap Targeting vs Optimal Policy) — visual comparison panels preserved as presented.

### Appendix figures and data spans (preserved labels and sample descriptions)
- Appendix Figure A1: Demographic Composition of the Labor Force, 1948 to 2012 — labor force shares (percent) from 1950 to 2010 across Prime-Age Males; Prime-Age Females; Youths; Older Adults. Legend definitions preserved as in source. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.
- Appendix Figure A2: Impulse responses from a VAR estimated using quarterly data from 1948:Q1 to 2007:Q4. Prime-Age LFPR vertical scale from -0.2 to 0.4. Note: dashed lines = 95 percent confidence bands based on 10,000 Monte Carlo replications.
- Appendix Figure A3: Labor Force Participation Rates by Gender and Age. Data span: 2004:Q1 to 2013:Q1 with BLS projected linear trend for the decade ending in 2016 (BLS forecast (Nov2007)) shown as dashed line.
- Appendix Figure A4: Scatter for 40 states with more than 500,000 prime-age adults as of December 2007 (sample excludes Nevada and also Alaska, Delaware, Hawaii, Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, Wyoming, and Washington DC). Axis markers shown: Change in Unemployment 0 through 12; Change in Labor Force Participation -5 to 2.
- Appendix Figure A5: Time series from 2008 to 2013 with percent scale 0.0 to 2.5 showing Participation Gap; Marginally Attached; Discouraged series.

### Data quality and OCR/artifact notes (literal fragments preserved)
- The supplied content contains extensive nonstandard characters, control codes, and OCR artifacts (examples include sequences such as "", "", "", "", "", "").
- Large portions of Sections 3–5 are unintelligible or fragmented; literal verbatim fragments and tokens were extracted without interpretation (examples preserved exactly):
  - "'	'", "G", "D", "E", " \" ", " ( ')".
- Apparent numeric tokens and exact numeric strings reproduced exactly where visible: 7, 0, 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 23, 99, 0%4,, 1!, 2B', 3, 6.0 percent.
- Observation for downstream processing: this content unit should be treated as low-confidence textual input where fragments may contain recoverable keywords or acronyms but many sequences mix printable characters with control codes.

*Source: WP/13/245 — Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession (Sections 1–6 as supplied).*

### Section 1

### Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession

### Main findings on labor force participation
- The paper provides compelling evidence that cyclical factors account for the bulk of the post-2007 decline in the U.S. labor force participation rate.
- Labor force participation is characterized as essentially acyclical during “normal times” (that is, in response to small or transitory shocks) but can drop markedly in the wake of a large and persistent aggregate demand shock.
- The decline in participation observed after 2007 is largely explained by cyclical developments rather than primarily by long-run structural trends.

### Model and mechanisms
- The authors formulate a stylized New Keynesian model in which:
  - Participation does not move much in response to small or transitory shocks.
  - Participation falls substantially when the economy experiences a large and persistent aggregate demand shortfall.
- The model links the size and persistence of aggregate demand shocks to the likelihood and magnitude of declines in the labor force participation rate.

### Implications for monetary policy
- The cyclical nature of the post-2007 participation decline has potentially crucial implications for the design of monetary policy.
- These implications are especially important under circumstances in which adjustments to the short-term interest rate are constrained by the zero lower bound.
- Monetary policy that fails to address large and persistent aggregate demand shortfalls may induce larger and more persistent reductions in participation, amplifying the weakness of the labor market.

### Policy recommendations and considerations
- Recognize that part of the decline in participation is reversible if cyclical demand is restored, implying policy can play a role in reversing participation losses.
- In environments where the short-term nominal interest rate is constrained by the zero lower bound, monetary policy frameworks should account for the risk that prolonged aggregate demand shortfalls can depress participation and hence potential output.
- Policy design should consider actions that mitigate large and persistent demand gaps to prevent persistent participation declines and associated long-run costs.

### Metadata and classification
- Authors: Christopher J. Erceg and Andrew T. Levin
- Working Paper: WP/13/245
- Publication date: July 2013
- JEL Classification Numbers: E24, E32, E52, J21
- Keywords: labor force participation, unemployment, and monetary policy rules

*Source: WP/13/245 — Labor Force Participation and Monetary Policy in the Wake of the Great Recession (Section 1).*

### Section 2

### _wp13245 - Section 2

### Unemployment Rate and Labor Force Participation Rate (figures and labels)
- Chart axes values shown: -0.2, -0.1, 0.0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4
- Additional numeric axis labels: 4 8 12 16 20
- Axis labels and legend items appearing in figures: Number of Quarters; Percent; Unemployment Rate; Labor Force Participation Rate
- Mentioned series or markers: Regression Line
- State/area labels appearing near points: FL, CA, NY, NV, TX, IL

### Changes in Unemployment and Labor Force Participation (scatter / panel)
- Horizontal/vertical tick values visible: -5, -4, -3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2
- Numeric sequence displayed on one axis: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 01345678910 (as shown)
- Points or annotations: FL, CA, NY, NV, TX, IL
- Regression reference: Regression Line

### Changes in Unemployment and Disability Rate (figures and labels)
- Axis numeric values shown: 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0, 1.2
- Axis tick marks: 0 2 4 6 8 10 (appearing on change axes)
- State labels near plotted points: MI, NV, NY, FL, CA, TX, IL
- Regression reference: Regression Line
- Specific plotted-marker label: NV

### Time-series panels (labor market by age groups)
- Years explicitly shown on time axis: 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
- Series or trend labels present:
  - Pre-Crisis Trend
  - Prime-Age Adults (25 to 54 years)
  - Older Adults (55 to 64 years)
- Vertical numeric markers in one panel: 9, 10, 11, 12
- Additional small-axis numeric values: 0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0, 1.2
- Change axes values also displayed: 0 1 2 3 4 and 0 2 4 6 8 10

### Miscellaneous numeric labels and annotations visible in Section 2
- Isolated numeric strings appearing in figures/text: 2.!, -0. 2, -0. 1
- Other repeated figure legends and labels observed: "Number of Quarters", "Percent", "Regression Line", "Change in Unemployment", "Change in Labor Force Participation", "Change in Disability Rate"
- Regional/state abbreviations repeatedly present as point identifiers: FL, CA, NY, NV, TX, IL, MI

*Source: _wp13245 - Section 2*

### Section 3

### _wp13245 - Section 3

### Labor market gaps and chart labels
- Employment Gap
- Participation Gap
- Unemployment Gap
- Pe rce nt
- 0
- 200820092010201120122013

### Chart axis and annotation text captured in the section
- Pe rce nt 0
- 0"  .	= >		 	 =  	 
- 0
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 200820092010201120122013

### Repeated labels and typographic fragments
- '	'
- "
- ::  89 
- % 
-  C4
- 5-  	3
- JD
- G

### Visible readable phrases related to methodology and presentation
- Employment Gap Participation Gap Unemployment Gap
- 0%4, 
- 0%4, 
- 
- 

*Source: _wp13245 - Section 3*

### Section 4

### _wp13245 - Section 4

### Observed tokens and labels
- '	'
- '
- '  
- D
- G
- K0
- K	
- E
- A
- TSI
- ' (
- '
- '
- '
- '
- "'
- "
- "
- :$

### Numeric and symbol occurrences (preserved exactly as in source)
- K0  1
- 0
- 1
- 5
- 7  "
- 6.0 percent of GDP (note: exact numeric phrase not present as cohesive sentence in supplied text; included only if present verbatim)
- 0"(" 1
- 1 ==+$
- 5
- 1
- 1
- 3
- 4
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 0  1  
- 9$
- ==9$
- :$

### Repeated structural patterns
- Frequent short labeled tokens separated by control characters and punctuation (for example: sequences beginning with single quotes, control bytes, and short uppercase letters).
- Multiple occurrences of isolated single-letter labels followed by control sequences (for example: D, E, A, G).
- Numerous occurrences of the symbol sequences "G" and variations thereof.
- Recurrent embedded bracketed fragments like (, (, (, and (.

*Source: _wp13245 - Section 4 (PDF filename: _wp13245 - Section 4).*

### Section 5

### _wp13245 - Section 5

### OCR/artifact note
- The supplied content unit contains extensive nonstandard characters, control codes, and OCR artifacts (for example, sequences such as "", "", "", "", "", "").
- Large portions of the text are unintelligible or fragmented; the following subsections present literal verbatim fragments and tokens extracted from the supplied content without interpretation.

### Extracted literal fragments (verbatim)
- "'	'"
- "G"
- "D"
- "E"
- " \" "
- " 		 	"
- " ( ')"
- "\"' "
- " "
- " $"
- "("$" 	"
- "  E \""
- " '"
- " "
- " "
- " "
- " ("

### Apparent numeric tokens and exact numeric strings (verbatim)
- 7
- 0
- 1
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 23
- 99
- 0%4,
- 0
- 0
- 1!
- 1&
- 2B'
- 2
- 3
- 4""
- 4
- 4&
- 5
- 5
- 6.0 percent (no explicit reliable full phrase; appears not contiguous — listed here only if present verbatim elsewhere)
- 6)
- 7 
- 9
- 9
- 9
- 23
- 29	!	:
- 99

(Note: numeric tokens are reproduced exactly as they appear in the supplied content, including embedded control characters or punctuation.)

### Repeated motifs and structural tokens (verbatim)
- Repeated token: "'	'" appears extensively throughout the content.
- Repeated token: "E" appears repeatedly.
- Repeated motif: sequences starting with "" and "" frequently precede fragments.
- Punctuation-like tokens and markers: "", "", "", "$", "@", "&", "*", ">" appear interspersed with fragments.

### Observations relevant for ingestion and downstream processing
- The unit appears to be severely corrupted by encoding or OCR errors; many sequences mix printable characters with control codes. Downstream systems should treat this unit as low-confidence textual input.
- Literal fragments above may contain recoverable keywords or acronyms (for example, repeated patterns like "G" or "D"), but no coherent sentences or policy findings are present in the supplied text.
- Exact numeric tokens are preserved above for numeric-fidelity requirements; their contextual meaning cannot be established from the supplied content.

*Source: _wp13245 - Section 5 (supplied content unit)*

### Section 6

### _wp13245 - Section 6

### Monetary Policy Tightening: Transient vs Persistent
- Figure 7: Monetary Policy Tightening
  - Chart elements and axes labels preserved as presented:
    - Overall Employment Gap range: -0.7, -0.6, -0.5, -0.4, -0.3, -0.2, -0.1, 0
    - Transient Tightening (time axis ticks shown as 04 08 12 16)
    - Persistent Tightening (time axis ticks shown as 08 16 24 32)
    - Unemployment Gap: range -5 to 10 (percent)
    - Participation Gap: range -3 to 0 (percent)
    - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (percent) [axes ticks shown 0 2 4? — labels preserved as in figures]
    - Inflation: range 1 to 2.5 (percent)
    - Overall Employment Gap (alternate panel): range -10 to 5 (percent)
    - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (percent)

### Adverse Demand Shock under Different Monetary Rules
- Figure 8: Adverse Demand Shock under Different Monetary Rules
  - Three policy regimes shown: Inflation Targeting; Overall Employment Gap Targeting; Unemployment Rate Targeting
  - Axis ticks/time markers: 08 16 24 32
  - Unemployment Gap: range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Participation Gap: range -3 to 0 (Percent)
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Inflation: range 1.6 to 2.4 (Percent)
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -6 to 2 (Percent)
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent)

- Figure 9: Adverse Demand Shock under Different Rules: Faster Participation Response
  - Policy comparisons: Employment Gap Targeting; Unemployment Rate Targeting
  - Axis ticks/time markers: 08 16 24 32
  - Unemployment Gap: range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Participation Gap: range -0.8 to 0 (Percent)
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Inflation: range 1.5 to 3 (Percent)
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 0 (Percent)
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent)

- Figure 10: Adverse Demand Shock w/Different Phillips Curve Slopes
  - Comparisons: Faster Price Adjustment; Benchmark Calibration
  - Axis ticks/time markers: 08 16 24 32
  - Unemployment Gap: range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Participation Gap: range -1 to 0 (Percent)
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Inflation: range 1.8 to 2.6 (Percent)
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 0 (Percent)
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent)

- Figure 11: Different Coefficients on Participation Gap under Employment Gap Targeting
  - Comparisons: Equal Coeff on Participation Gap; Benchmark; Tiny Coeff on Participation Gap
  - Axis ticks/time markers: 08 16 24 32
  - Unemployment Gap: range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Participation Gap: range -1 to 0.5 (Percent)
  - Nominal Interest Rate (APR): range -2 to 4 (Percent)
  - Inflation: range 1.8 to 2.6 (Percent)
  - Overall Employment Gap: range -4 to 2 (Percent)
  - Potential Real Interest Rate (APR): range -6 to 2 (Percent)

- Figure 12: Comparison of Employment Gap Targeting and Optimal Policy
  - Policy lines shown: Optimal Policy; Benchmark (Taylor Rule)
  - Visual comparison panels preserved as in source (no numeric series explicitly tabulated in text)

### Appendix Figures — Demographics and Labor Force Participation Dynamics
- Appendix Figure A1: The Demographic Composition of the Labor Force, 1948 to 2012
  - Depicts labor force shares (percent) from 1950 to 2010 across demographic groups:
    - Prime-Age Males
    - Prime-Age Females
    - Youths
    - Older Adults
  - Note: solid area = share of prime-age males (25 to 54 years old); horizontal-dashed = prime-aged females (25 to 54 years); diagonal-dashed = youths (16 to 24 years); vertical-dashed = older adults (55 years and above). Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.

- Appendix Figure A2: The Cyclical Dynamics of the LFPR During “normal Times” by Age Group
  - Impulse responses from a VAR estimated using quarterly data from 1948:Q1 to 2007:Q4
  - Panels for:
    - Prime-Age LFPR (25 to 54 years): vertical scale from -0.2 to 0.4
    - Youth LFPR (16 to 24 years)
    - Older Adults LFPR (55 years & above)
    - Unemployment Rate
  - Note: solid line = response to an orthogonalized unemployment rate shock of one standard deviation; dashed lines = 95 percent confidence bands based on 10,000 Monte Carlo replications.

- Appendix Figure A3: Labor Force Participation Rates by Gender and Age
  - Panels for:
    - Males, 16 to 24 Years; Females, 16 to 24 Years
    - Males, 25 to 54 Years; Females, 25 to 54 Years
    - Males, 55 Years and Older; Females, 55 Years and Older
  - Data span: 2004:Q1 to 2013:Q1 with BLS projected linear trend for the decade ending in 2016 (BLS forecast (Nov2007)) shown as dashed line. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  - Example axis values shown in panels:
    - Ranges including 30 to 66 and 42 to 92 for different panels (percent)

- Appendix Figure A4: Data from Larger States (excluding Nevada) Regarding Unemployment and Labor Force Participation of Prime-Age Adults
  - Scatter plot note:
    - Vertical axis: change in the labor force participation rate for prime-age adults (25 to 54 years) between 2007 and 2012
    - Horizontal axis: change in the unemployment rate for that demographic group between 2007 and 2010
    - Observations: 40 states that had more than 500,000 prime-age adults as of December 2007 (sample excludes Nevada and also Alaska, Delaware, Hawaii, Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, Wyoming, and Washington DC)
    - The dashed line depicts the regression obtained using these 40 data points.
  - Axis markers shown: Change in Unemployment 0 through 12; Change in Labor Force Participation -5 to 2

- Appendix Figure A5: Gauging the Degree of Attachment to the Labor Force
  - Time series from 2008 to 2013 with percent scale 0.0 to 2.5
  - Series shown:
    - Participation Gap (solid line): deviation between actual LFPR and its trend path as projected by the BLS in November 2007
    - Marginally Attached (short-dashed): post-2007 changes in the incidence of individuals who are “marginally attached” to the labor force (share of civilian noninstitutionalized population aged 16 and above)
    - Discouraged (long-dashed): post-2007 changes in the incidence of “discouraged” job-seekers (definition preserved as in source)

*Source: _wp13245 - Section 6 (figures and notes as presented in the supplied PDF).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2013/_wp13245.pdf_
