## Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15241.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15241.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15241.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction
- Purpose and questions:
  - Assess empirically the size, geographical sources, and transmission channels of spillovers from external shocks to Armenia.
  - Identify the relative contribution of channels: trade, remittances, tourism, external borrowing.
  - Identify the role of geographical areas: Russia, the EU, and the U.S.
  - Key questions: (i) What is the impact of global shocks on the Armenian economy? (ii) What are the countries and regional areas through which this impact takes place? (iii) What are the main transmission channels? (iv) Which economic activities in Armenia are most impacted?
- Methodology overview:
  - Uses a structural vector autoregression (SVAR) model.
  - Employs the econometric strategy proposed by Bayoumi and Swiston (2009) and Reinout, Daniel and Joel (2010): estimate a baseline SVAR capturing global GDP growth impact, then augment one channel/region at a time with sectoral and regional data.

### II. Key stylized facts and exposure
- Openness and external flows:
  - Armenia displays a relatively high degree of openness compared with peers.
  - All key external flow variables—exports, imports, remittances, and FDI—are sizeable in Armenia.
- Co-movement with global and partner activity (Cross-correlation of GDP yoy growth 2001q1–2014q1):
  - Russia: t-2 = 0.6, t-1 = 0.8, t = 0.88, t+1 = 0.73, t+2 = 0.51
  - EU: t-2 = 0.63, t-1 = 0.75, t = 0.74, t+1 = 0.62, t+2 = 0.36
  - US: t-2 = 0.62, t-1 = 0.69, t = 0.67, t+1 = 0.48, t+2 = 0.29
  - World: t-2 = 0.61, t-1 = 0.78, t = 0.81, t+1 = 0.66, t+2 = 0.39
- Historical episodes of vulnerability:
  - Global financial crisis 2008–2009 and commodity volatility 2008–2011 led to dramatic declines in remittances and capital inflows, exchange rate depreciation, a contraction of GDP by 14.1 percent in 2009, falling tax revenues, higher fiscal deficit, higher public debt, and lower international reserves.
  - Regional tensions (Russia–Ukraine escalation) and the 2014 oil price decline increased uncertainty about Russia’s economy, reduced external funding for Russian firms, and led to ruble depreciation—affecting Armenia through decelerated remittances, lower exports, and exchange rate depreciation in late 2014.

### III. Transmission channels: geography and mechanisms
- Trade (geographical structure 2010–2013):
  - EU average share in Armenian exports: 41 percent.
  - Russia share in Armenian exports: 23 percent.
  - Germany accounts for 22.5 percent of Armenian exports to the EU.
  - EU share of Armenian imports: 26 percent.
  - Russia share of Armenian imports: 18 percent.
  - Russia and other post-Soviet countries combined account for around 31 percent of Armenian imports.
- Trade (product structure 2010–2013):
  - Commodities have increased their shares in Armenian exports and imports.
  - A significant part of EU-bound exports are ores and metals.
  - Exports to Russia concentrate more on processed goods (less exposure to commodity price swings).
- Energy imports and exposure:
  - Armenia imports 80 percent of its gas from Russia (remainder from Iran via gas-for-electricity transaction).
  - Armenia has no oil refining capacity; Russian companies supply most petroleum products.
  - Despite energy import dependence, Armenia exhibits relative isolation from oil price increases because of:
    - High level of gasification (transport switching to CNG/LNG due to favorable taxation).
    - Gas typically provided through five-year agreements with Russia with pre-agreed prices.
    - Prevalence of non-hydrocarbon energy sources (nuclear, hydroelectric) for electricity generation.
- Remittances:
  - Remittances have increased significantly since 2004, especially from Russia.
  - At present, almost 90 percent of total remittances originate from Russia.
  - Remittances have been a relatively stable external financing source but exhibited significant volatility, notably during the global downturn in 2008–2009.

### IV. Empirical findings (summary)
- Overall sensitivity:
  - Strong response of Armenia’s real GDP growth to shocks to global GDP growth and commodity prices.
  - Armenia remains relatively immune to instability in international financial markets.
- Principal geographical sources of spillovers:
  - Impacts are mainly transmitted through the Russian and EU economies.
- Principal transmission channels:
  - Remittances and external borrowing are major channels.
  - Exports and tourism play a relatively low role as transmission channels.
- Role of oil price movements:
  - Russia can transform a negative impact of rising oil prices in the EU into a positive event for Armenia via stronger remittances and exports from Russia to Armenia.
- Sectoral impacts:
  - Services and construction depend most on remittances and external borrowing and are the most affected by global and regional shocks.

### V. Modeling approach and identification challenges
- SVAR is used to measure Armenian GDP growth response to shocks; technique deemed powerful and robust.
- Identification challenges specific to Armenia:
  - Russia’s oil-exporting nature and the EU’s oil-import dependence complicate identifying oil-price shock transmission.
  - Armenia’s low direct exposure to oil prices plus long-term gas contracts and non-hydrocarbon electricity reduce direct oil-price effects.
- Strategy to address identification:
  - Baseline SVAR to capture global GDP growth impact; augment the baseline one channel/region at a time following Bayoumi and Swiston (2009) and Reinout, Daniel and Joel (2010).

### VI. Key quantitative statistics and episode indicators
- GDP contraction: 14.1 percent in 2009 (Armenia).
- Cross-correlation coefficients of GDP yoy growth with trading partners (2001q1–2014q1) listed above.
- Trade shares (2010–2013):
  - Exports to EU: 41 percent; to Russia: 23 percent.
  - Imports from EU: 26 percent; from Russia: 18 percent.
  - Russia and post-Soviet countries combined imports: around 31 percent.
- Energy imports: 80 percent of gas from Russia.
- Remittances: almost 90 percent originate from Russia.

### Remittances and external accounts (2010–2013)
- During 2010–2013, remittances averaged 15–20 percent of GDP.
- Remittances U.S. dollar value is:
  - 22.2 percent higher than total exports,
  - 3.7 times higher than FDI net inflows,
  - almost equal to external borrowing.
- Remittances are equivalent to 43 percent of Armenia’s total imports.
- Historical pattern: remittances growth is highly correlated with Russian nominal GDP growth; correlation reached 0.95 in 2009–2013.
- Remittances growth also shows high correlation with Armenian GDP growth.
- Source data: Central Bank of Armenia (CBA).

### Financial account and capital inflows
- Armenia has an open capital account used to finance a large external current account deficit.
- Main financial account items: FDI net inflows and external borrowing; portfolio investment negligible except Eurobond issuances in 2013 and 2015.
- FDI inflows:
  - "relatively large (around 5 percent of GDP)" historically but volatile and reduced after privatization.
  - Geographical composition of FDI stock: Russia 57 percent; France 7 percent; Argentina 6 percent; Germany 4 percent; Switzerland 3 percent.
- External borrowing:
  - Historically played a greater role than FDI in funding private and public sectors.
  - Stock of external debt is relatively large.
  - Public external debt: in principle long maturity and highly concessional, used for capital projects.
  - Banks’ external borrowing largely in the form of loans with IFIs to support access to finance.
- Transmission from external borrowing can operate through larger fiscal deficits or higher bank/household recourse to borrowing; impacts GDP via budgetary capital spending and bank lending.

### Banking system as transmission channel
- Armenian banks largely funded with domestic deposits; limited exposure to international financial markets.
- Banking system not a major recipient of FDI inflows in recent years.
- Foreign participation in bank statutory capital is large: 74.6 percent at end-2013, with Russia as the biggest shareholder.
- Operations of foreign-owned Armenian banks are small relative to parent banks, making wholesale withdrawals by parents unlikely in a stress event (though new liquidity provision may be withheld).
- Conclusion: banking channel considered limited and excluded from sensitivity analysis of Armenian economy to global/regional shocks.

### Estimation and identification techniques (SVAR framework)
- Baseline model: Structural Vector Auto-regression (SVAR) estimating impact of global shocks on Armenian non-agricultural GDP growth.
- Baseline SVAR includes three world shocks:
  - world demand shocks: changes in growth rate of an indicator of world GDP,
  - world supply shocks: changes in an indicator of international commodity prices,
  - world financial shocks: changes in international financial conditions.
- Variable ordering (following Blanchard and Quah (1989)):
  - [ world_t PΔ , world_t YΔ , world_t FΔ , Armenia_t YΔ ]′
    - world_t PΔ = change in world commodity prices indicator,
    - world_t YΔ = growth rate of indicator of world economic activity,
    - world_t FΔ = change in indicator of international financial conditions,
    - Armenia_t YΔ = growth rate in Armenia’s non-agricultural real GDP.
- Identification: Choleski factor inverse of variance-covariance matrix identifies orthogonal structural shocks; assumes Armenian non-agricultural GDP does not influence world economy.
- Decomposition approach for geographical areas and channels: follows Bayoumi and Swiston (2009).
  - Contribution of geographical area g: c_g = r − r_g (difference between baseline impulse response r and augmented response r_g that includes area g).
  - Contribution of transmission channel t: c_t = r − r_t (analogous procedure for trade, tourism, remittances, external borrowing).
  - Caveats: contributions not a precise decomposition; collinearity not fully accounted for; other areas/channels may exist.

### Sectoral analysis
- Three sectoral SVARs estimated for industry, construction and services; analogous to baseline SVAR but include sector real GDP growth rates S_t YΔ (s = services, construction, industry).
- Sectoral augmented SVARs include transmission channels one at a time to assess sectoral sensitivity.

### Data
- Armenian dataset: real GDP (non-agricultural), real value added in services, construction and industry; balance of payments series including exports, tourism net revenues, remittances net inflows, net external borrowing by private sector.
- World/regional dataset:
  - Indicator of world economic activity: weighted average GDP of Armenia’s trading partners (weights based on shares in Armenian exports),
  - world commodity price index: IMF crude oil prices index,
  - international financial market conditions indicator: VIX,
  - real GDP series for EU, Russia and U.S.
- Sample frequency and span: quarterly, 2000Q1 to 2014Q1.
- Armenian data sources: Central Bank of Armenia and National Statistical Service of Armenia.
- World/regional data sources: IMF, WB, Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation, U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Eurostat.

### Econometric results — impulse responses to one standard deviation (SDA) shocks
- Baseline SVAR estimated with four variables: change in IMF crude oil prices index, growth rate of weighted-average world GDP, change in VIX index, growth rate of Armenia’s real non-agricultural GDP; estimation uses two lags.
- Table 3: Impulse response of Armenian real GDP (non-agricultural) growth to a one standard deviation shock (quarterly responses Q1–Q10) — values reported exactly:

  - Crude Oil (C1):
    - Q1: 0.548
    - Q2: 2.290
    - Q3: 1.555
    - Q4: 0.753
    - Q5: -0.141
    - Q6: -0.262
    - Q7: -0.243
    - Q8: -0.092
    - Q9: -0.040
    - Q10: 0.010

  - World demand (C2):
    - Q1: 1.096
    - Q2: 0.044
    - Q3: 1.914
    - Q4: 0.815
    - Q5: 0.466
    - Q6: -0.143
    - Q7: -0.094
    - Q8: -0.157
    - Q9: -0.035
    - Q10: -0.027

  - Financial volatility (C3 — VIX):
    - Q1: 0.069
    - Q2: -0.760
    - Q3: 0.027
    - Q4: 0.171
    - Q5: 0.104
    - Q6: -0.035
    - Q7: -0.046
    - Q8: -0.038
    - Q9: -0.006
    - Q10: -0.001

- Interpretation of crude oil shock:
  - Immediate positive effect; Armenian growth accelerates by 0.548 percentage points after Q1.
  - Peak impact after Q2 at 2.29 percentage points.
  - Full effect after ten quarters is about 0.01.
  - Positive response explained by: (i) oil price increases boosting Russian growth and via remittances, exports and external borrowing benefitting Armenia; (ii) Armenia’s relative isolation from direct oil price impacts; (iii) co-movement of oil and metal prices increasing Armenian mining exports.
- Interpretation of global demand shock:
  - A SDA shock of 0.42 to global demand growth leads to a 1.096 percentage point increase in Armenian growth after Q1.
  - Accumulated response after two years: 3.9 percentage points.
  - Channels: trade, remittances, tourism, FDI, bank linkages from stronger growth in EU and Russia.
- Interpretation of financial uncertainty shock:
  - Immediate effect almost zero; negative effect becomes noticeable over time.
  - Following a SDA shock to VIX, Armenia’s real GDP growth decelerates by -0.076 after Q2.
  - Accumulated effect stabilizes around -0.5.
  - Result consistent with Armenia’s low level of global financial integration.

### Geographical decomposition of spillovers (Bayoumi and Swiston approach)
- Augmented SVARs include, one at a time, growth rates of Russia, EU and US real GDP.
- Short-term (two quarters) contributions of EU and Russia to Armenia’s non-agricultural GDP growth are relatively similar in size.
- Example interpretation: a one SDA shock (0.42 percentage points) to global demand after Q1 could be split into:
  - 36 percent due to the EU,
  - 64 percentage point to Russia,
  - negligible impact from other trading partners.
- Over 8 quarters:
  - Russia accounts for almost 70 percent (or 2.7 percentage points) of spillovers from global demand shocks.
  - EU accounts for 21 percent (or 0.8 percentage points).
  - US accounts for 3 percent (or 0.1 percentage point).

### Transmission-channel decomposition of spillovers
- Augmented SVARs include, one at a time, trade (exports), tourism net revenues, remittances net inflows, and net external borrowing.
- Results indicate largest contributions from:
  - remittances: 28 percent of the spillovers from global GDP shocks,
  - external borrowing: 31 percent of the spillovers.
- Exports and tourism: smaller contributions in the range of 10 percent each.
- Illustrative interpretation: a SDA shock of 0.42 to global demand growth leads to the proportional contributions above to the total impact on Armenian non-agricultural GDP growth.

### Cumulative impact of a one SDA world demand shock on Armenian GDP growth
- The accumulated effect of a one SDA shock to global demand on Armenian economic growth stabilizes around 3.9 percentage points after the 8 quarters.
- Remittances would explain 28 percent of the impact (1.1 percentage points out of the 3.9 percentage points).
- External borrowing would explain 31 percent of the impact (1.2 percentage points out of 3.9 percentage points).
- Exports and tourism would account for only 10 percent of the total impact (0.4 percentage points each).
- The impact of remittances and external borrowing are particularly important over the longer terms, after one year or beyond.

### Sectoral responses to world demand shocks
- Construction is the sector affected the most by global shocks, followed by services and then by industry.
- Services:
  - External borrowing and remittances are the major contributors to the impact of global demand shocks on services value added growth.
  - External borrowing explains about 54 percent of the impact in services growth.
  - Remittances explain about 21 percent of the impact in services growth.
  - Contributions of exports and tourism to services are relatively small.
  - Interpretation: remittances and external borrowing strongly influence households’ disposable income; external borrowing can support consumer income through higher bank financing (partly onlent to firms and individuals).
- Construction:
  - Remittances are the major contributors to the impact of global shocks on construction activity.
  - Remittances explain almost 30 percent of the impact of global demand shocks in construction activity.
  - External borrowing accounts for 27 percent of the total impact on construction.
  - Only 5.7 percent of the impact of external demand shocks in construction growth is transmitted through exports of goods and services.
  - Interpretation: remittances played a significant role financing the pre-crisis construction boom in Armenia.
- Industry:
  - Industry shows weak reactions to changes in world GDP.
  - External borrowing accounts for 25 percent of the total impact on industry growth.
  - Exports and remittances follow as contributors, but export shocks do not play a major role.
  - Interpretation: dominance of supply shocks over demand shocks in Armenian export-oriented industries (especially mining); mining output growth depends more on international prices of metals and minerals than on growth of world demand.

### Geographical sources and overall transmission channels
- The impact of global demand shocks on Armenia is sizeable and long-lasting.
- The impact is mainly transmitted through the Russian and EU economies.
  - These two regions account for 70 and 21 percent of the total impact respectively.
- Russia plays a key role in converting a negative oil-price shock into a positive event for Armenia because:
  - Negative effects of higher oil prices on Armenia’s oil bill are more than offset by the positive effect that oil price surges usually have on Russian growth, and therefore on Armenia’s remittances, exports, financing, and economic growth.
- Overall transmission-channel decomposition:
  - Remittances explain 28 percent of total impact.
  - External borrowing explains 31 percent of total impact.
  - Exports and tourism have a low role overall.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Preparatory (before a shock hits):
  - Build and preserve macroeconomic buffers, including moderate levels of public deficit and debt, and a relatively high level of international reserves.
  - Maintain access to external borrowing from donors and preserve current access to market financing.
  - Improve the business climate, openness and connectivity to attract foreign direct investment and promote export-oriented activities.
  - Aim for greater economic diversification to reduce dependence on remittances, especially from Russia.
- Short-term (once a shock has hit):
  - With comfortable buffers, implement a moderate fiscal stimulus and monetary easing.
  - Allow for exchange rate flexibility to operate as a shock absorber, while using existing reserves to mitigate excessive exchange rate volatility given Armenia’s high level of dollarization.
  - Accelerate structural reforms to increase growth and diversify export destinations and products.
- Medium-term (after effects wane):
  - Rebuild buffers by adopting a fiscal consolidation strategy and a plan to rebuild the stock of international reserves.
  - Continue with implementation of structural reforms.

### Insights on ongoing and expected global developments
- Normalization of monetary policies in advanced economies and tightening in global financial conditions:
  - Impact on Armenia would be somewhat mitigated by Armenia’s relatively large access to external borrowing on concessional terms, low international integration of Armenian banks, and low level of external portfolio investment.
- Changes in international oil prices:
  - Not expected to have a direct impact on Armenia due to relatively high level of gasification and use of medium-term gas price agreements with Russia.
  - Indirect effects occur via trading partners: e.g., recent decline in commodity prices (especially oil) reduces Russia’s growth, which negatively affects Armenia via lower remittances and exports.
- A tightening in global financial conditions could hinder Russia’s access to international funding and thereby affect Armenia.
- A delayed recovery in the EU may also affect Armenia.

*Source: Authors’ estimates and calculations, using Central Bank of Armenia, Armenia’s National Statistical Service, IMF, WB, Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation, U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, and Eurostat data as described in the text.*

### Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers.......................................................23

### Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers

### I. Introduction
- Purpose and questions:
  - Assess empirically the size, geographical sources, and transmission channels of spillovers from external shocks to Armenia.
  - Identify the relative contribution of channels: trade, remittances, tourism, external borrowing.
  - Identify the role of geographical areas: Russia, the EU, and the U.S.
  - Key questions: (i) What is the impact of global shocks on the Armenian economy? (ii) What are the countries and regional areas through which this impact takes place? (iii) What are the main transmission channels? (iv) Which economic activities in Armenia are most impacted?
- Methodology overview:
  - Uses a structural vector autoregression (SVAR) model.
  - Employs the econometric strategy proposed by Bayoumi and Swiston (2009) and Reinout, Daniel and Joel (2010): estimate a baseline SVAR capturing global GDP growth impact, then augment one channel/region at a time with sectoral and regional data.

### II. Key stylized facts and exposure
- Openness and external flows:
  - Armenia displays a relatively high degree of openness compared with peers (Table 1).
  - All key external flow variables—exports, imports, remittances, and FDI—are sizeable in Armenia.
- Co-movement with global and partner activity (Table 2: Cross-correlation of GDP yoy growth 2001q1–2014q1):
  - Russia: t-2 = 0.6, t-1 = 0.8, t = 0.88, t+1 = 0.73, t+2 = 0.51
  - EU: t-2 = 0.63, t-1 = 0.75, t = 0.74, t+1 = 0.62, t+2 = 0.36
  - US: t-2 = 0.62, t-1 = 0.69, t = 0.67, t+1 = 0.48, t+2 = 0.29
  - World: t-2 = 0.61, t-1 = 0.78, t = 0.81, t+1 = 0.66, t+2 = 0.39
- Historical episodes of vulnerability:
  - Global financial crisis 2008–2009 and commodity volatility 2008–2011 led to dramatic declines in remittances and capital inflows, exchange rate depreciation, a contraction of GDP by 14.1 percent in 2009, falling tax revenues, higher fiscal deficit, higher public debt, and lower international reserves.
  - Regional tensions (Russia–Ukraine escalation) and the 2014 oil price decline increased uncertainty about Russia’s economy, reduced external funding for Russian firms, and led to ruble depreciation—affecting Armenia through decelerated remittances, lower exports, and exchange rate depreciation in late 2014.

### III. Transmission channels: geography and mechanisms
- Trade (geographical structure 2010–2013):
  - EU average share in Armenian exports: 41 percent.
  - Russia share in Armenian exports: 23 percent.
  - Germany accounts for 22.5 percent of Armenian exports to the EU.
  - EU share of Armenian imports: 26 percent.
  - Russia share of Armenian imports: 18 percent.
  - Russia and other post-Soviet countries combined account for around 31 percent of Armenian imports.
- Trade (product structure 2010–2013):
  - Commodities have increased their shares in Armenian exports and imports.
  - A significant part of EU-bound exports are ores and metals.
  - Exports to Russia concentrate more on processed goods (less exposure to commodity price swings).
- Energy imports and exposure:
  - Armenia imports 80 percent of its gas from Russia (remainder from Iran via gas-for-electricity transaction).
  - Armenia has no oil refining capacity; Russian companies supply most petroleum products.
  - Despite energy import dependence, Armenia exhibits relative isolation from oil price increases because of:
    - High level of gasification (transport switching to CNG/LNG due to favorable taxation).
    - Gas typically provided through five-year agreements with Russia with pre-agreed prices.
    - Prevalence of non-hydrocarbon energy sources (nuclear, hydroelectric) for electricity generation.
- Remittances:
  - Remittances have increased significantly since 2004, especially from Russia.
  - At present, almost 90 percent of total remittances originate from Russia.
  - Remittances have been a relatively stable external financing source but exhibited significant volatility, notably during the global downturn in 2008–2009.

### IV. Empirical findings (summary)
- Overall sensitivity:
  - Strong response of Armenia’s real GDP growth to shocks to global GDP growth and commodity prices.
  - Armenia remains relatively immune to instability in international financial markets.
- Principal geographical sources of spillovers:
  - Impacts are mainly transmitted through the Russian and EU economies.
- Principal transmission channels:
  - Remittances and external borrowing are major channels.
  - Exports and tourism play a relatively low role as transmission channels.
- Role of oil price movements:
  - Russia can transform a negative impact of rising oil prices in the EU into a positive event for Armenia via stronger remittances and exports from Russia to Armenia.
- Sectoral impacts:
  - Services and construction depend most on remittances and external borrowing and are the most affected by global and regional shocks.

### V. Modeling approach and identification challenges
- SVAR is used to measure Armenian GDP growth response to shocks; technique deemed powerful and robust.
- Identification challenges specific to Armenia:
  - Russia’s oil-exporting nature and the EU’s oil-import dependence complicate identifying oil-price shock transmission.
  - Armenia’s low direct exposure to oil prices plus long-term gas contracts and non-hydrocarbon electricity reduce direct oil-price effects.
- Strategy to address identification:
  - Baseline SVAR to capture global GDP growth impact; augment the baseline one channel/region at a time following Bayoumi and Swiston (2009) and Reinout, Daniel and Joel (2010).

### VI. Key quantitative statistics and episode indicators (as reported)
- GDP contraction: 14.1 percent in 2009 (Armenia).
- Cross-correlation coefficients of GDP yoy growth with trading partners (2001q1–2014q1) listed under Section II.
- Trade shares (2010–2013):
  - Exports to EU: 41 percent; to Russia: 23 percent.
  - Imports from EU: 26 percent; from Russia: 18 percent.
  - Russia and post-Soviet countries combined imports: around 31 percent.
- Energy imports: 80 percent of gas from Russia.
- Remittances: almost 90 percent originate from Russia.

_Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers (extracted from _wp15241 - Annex I: Brief Review of Literture on Spillovers) _

### 2009. During 2010–2013, remittances averaged 15–20 percent of GDP, with a U.S. dollar value

### _wp15241 - 2009. During 2010–2013, remittances averaged 15–20 percent of GDP, with a U.S. dollar value

### Remittances and external accounts
- During 2010–2013, remittances averaged 15–20 percent of GDP.
- Remittances U.S. dollar value is:
  - 22.2 percent higher than total exports,
  - 3.7 times higher than FDI net inflows,
  - almost equal to external borrowing.
- Remittances are equivalent to 43 percent of Armenia’s total imports.
- Historical pattern: remittances growth is highly correlated with Russian nominal GDP growth; correlation reached 0.95 in 2009–2013.
- Remittances growth also shows high correlation with Armenian GDP growth.
- Source data: Central Bank of Armenia (CBA).

### Financial account and capital inflows
- Armenia has an open capital account used to finance a large external current account deficit.
- Main financial account items: FDI net inflows and external borrowing; portfolio investment negligible except Eurobond issuances in 2013 and 2015.
- FDI inflows:
  - "relatively large (around 5 percent of GDP)" historically but volatile and reduced after privatization.
  - Geographical composition of FDI stock (percent shares noted in text): Russia 57 percent; France 7 percent; Argentina 6 percent; Germany 4 percent; Switzerland 3 percent.
- External borrowing:
  - Historically played a greater role than FDI in funding private and public sectors.
  - Stock of external debt is relatively large.
  - Public external debt: in principle long maturity and highly concessional, used for capital projects.
  - Banks’ external borrowing largely in the form of loans with IFIs to support access to finance.
- Transmission from external borrowing can operate through larger fiscal deficits or higher bank/household recourse to borrowing; impacts GDP via budgetary capital spending and bank lending.

### Banking system as transmission channel
- Armenian banks largely funded with domestic deposits; limited exposure to international financial markets.
- Banking system not a major recipient of FDI inflows in recent years.
- Foreign participation in bank statutory capital is large: 74.6 percent at end-2013, with Russia as the biggest shareholder.
- Operations of foreign-owned Armenian banks are small relative to parent banks, making wholesale withdrawals by parents unlikely in a stress event (though new liquidity provision may be withheld).
- Conclusion: banking channel considered limited and excluded from sensitivity analysis of Armenian economy to global/regional shocks.

### Estimation and identification techniques (SVAR framework)
- Baseline model: Structural Vector Auto-regression (SVAR) estimating impact of global shocks on Armenian non-agricultural GDP growth.
- Baseline SVAR includes three world shocks:
  - world demand shocks: changes in growth rate of an indicator of world GDP,
  - world supply shocks: changes in an indicator of international commodity prices,
  - world financial shocks: changes in international financial conditions.
- Variable ordering (following Blanchard and Quah (1989)):
  - [ world_t PΔ , world_t YΔ , world_t FΔ , Armenia_t YΔ ]′
    - world_t PΔ = change in world commodity prices indicator,
    - world_t YΔ = growth rate of indicator of world economic activity,
    - world_t FΔ = change in indicator of international financial conditions,
    - Armenia_t YΔ = growth rate in Armenia’s non-agricultural real GDP.
- Identification: Choleski factor inverse of variance-covariance matrix identifies orthogonal structural shocks; assumes Armenian non-agricultural GDP does not influence world economy.
- Decomposition approach for geographical areas and channels: follows Bayoumi and Swiston (2009).
  - Contribution of geographical area g: c_g = r − r_g (difference between baseline impulse response r and augmented response r_g that includes area g).
  - Contribution of transmission channel t: c_t = r − r_t (analogous procedure for trade, tourism, remittances, external borrowing).
  - Caveats: contributions not a precise decomposition; collinearity not fully accounted for; other areas/channels may exist.

### Sectoral analysis
- Three sectoral SVARs estimated for industry, construction and services; analogous to baseline SVAR but include sector real GDP growth rates S_t YΔ (s = services, construction, industry).
- Sectoral augmented SVARs include transmission channels one at a time to assess sectoral sensitivity.

### Data
- Armenian dataset: real GDP (non-agricultural), real value added in services, construction and industry; balance of payments series including exports, tourism net revenues, remittances net inflows, net external borrowing by private sector.
- World/regional dataset:
  - Indicator of world economic activity: weighted average GDP of Armenia’s trading partners (weights based on shares in Armenian exports),
  - world commodity price index: IMF crude oil prices index,
  - international financial market conditions indicator: VIX,
  - real GDP series for EU, Russia and U.S.
- Sample frequency and span: quarterly, 2000Q1 to 2014Q1.
- Armenian data sources: Central Bank of Armenia and National Statistical Service of Armenia.
- World/regional data sources: IMF, WB, Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation, U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Eurostat.

### Econometric results — impulse responses to one standard deviation (SDA) shocks
- Baseline SVAR estimated with four variables: change in IMF crude oil prices index, growth rate of weighted-average world GDP, change in VIX index, growth rate of Armenia’s real non-agricultural GDP; estimation uses two lags.
- Table 3: Impulse response of Armenian real GDP (non-agricultural) growth to a one standard deviation shock (quarterly responses Q1–Q10) — values reported exactly:

  - Crude Oil (C1):
    - Q1: 0.548
    - Q2: 2.290
    - Q3: 1.555
    - Q4: 0.753
    - Q5: -0.141
    - Q6: -0.262
    - Q7: -0.243
    - Q8: -0.092
    - Q9: -0.040
    - Q10: 0.010

  - World demand (C2):
    - Q1: 1.096
    - Q2: 0.044
    - Q3: 1.914
    - Q4: 0.815
    - Q5: 0.466
    - Q6: -0.143
    - Q7: -0.094
    - Q8: -0.157
    - Q9: -0.035
    - Q10: -0.027

  - Financial volatility (C3 — VIX):
    - Q1: 0.069
    - Q2: -0.760
    - Q3: 0.027
    - Q4: 0.171
    - Q5: 0.104
    - Q6: -0.035
    - Q7: -0.046
    - Q8: -0.038
    - Q9: -0.006
    - Q10: -0.001

- Interpretation of crude oil shock:
  - Immediate positive effect; Armenian growth accelerates by 0.548 percentage points after Q1.
  - Peak impact after Q2 at 2.29 percentage points.
  - Full effect after ten quarters is about 0.01.
  - Positive response explained by: (i) oil price increases boosting Russian growth and via remittances, exports and external borrowing benefitting Armenia; (ii) Armenia’s relative isolation from direct oil price impacts; (iii) co-movement of oil and metal prices increasing Armenian mining exports.
- Interpretation of global demand shock:
  - A SDA shock of 0.42 to global demand growth leads to a 1.096 percentage point increase in Armenian growth after Q1.
  - Accumulated response after two years: 3.9 percentage points.
  - Channels: trade, remittances, tourism, FDI, bank linkages from stronger growth in EU and Russia.
- Interpretation of financial uncertainty shock:
  - Immediate effect almost zero; negative effect becomes noticeable over time.
  - Following a SDA shock to VIX, Armenia’s real GDP growth decelerates by -0.076 after Q2.
  - Accumulated effect stabilizes around -0.5.
  - Result consistent with Armenia’s low level of global financial integration.

### Geographical decomposition of spillovers (Bayoumi and Swiston approach)
- Augmented SVARs include, one at a time, growth rates of Russia, EU and US real GDP.
- Short-term (two quarters) contributions of EU and Russia to Armenia’s non-agricultural GDP growth are relatively similar in size.
- Example interpretation: a one SDA shock (0.42 percentage points) to global demand after Q1 could be split into:
  - 36 percent due to the EU,
  - 64 percentage point to Russia,
  - negligible impact from other trading partners.
- Over 8 quarters:
  - Russia accounts for almost 70 percent (or 2.7 percentage points) of spillovers from global demand shocks.
  - EU accounts for 21 percent (or 0.8 percentage points).
  - US accounts for 3 percent (or 0.1 percentage point).

### Transmission-channel decomposition of spillovers
- Augmented SVARs include, one at a time, trade (exports), tourism net revenues, remittances net inflows, and net external borrowing.
- Results indicate largest contributions from:
  - remittances: 28 percent of the spillovers from global GDP shocks,
  - external borrowing: 31 percent of the spillovers.
- Exports and tourism: smaller contributions in the range of 10 percent each.
- Illustrative interpretation: a SDA shock of 0.42 to global demand growth leads to the proportional contributions above to the total impact on Armenian non-agricultural GDP growth.

*Source: Authors’ estimates and calculations, using Central Bank of Armenia, Armenia’s National Statistical Service, IMF, WB, Federal State Statistics Service of the Russian Federation, U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, and Eurostat data as described in the text.*

### 1.1 percentage point increase in Armenian economic growth after the first quarter. The

### _wp15241 - 1.1 percentage point increase in Armenian economic growth after the first quarter. The

### Cumulative impact of a one SDA world demand shock on Armenian GDP growth
- The accumulated effect of a one SDA shock to global demand on Armenian economic growth stabilizes around 3.9 percentage points after the 8 quarters.
- Remittances would explain 28 percent of the impact (1.1 percentage points out of the 3.9 percentage points).
- External borrowing would explain 31 percent of the impact (1.2 percentage points out of 3.9 percentage points).
- Exports and tourism would account for only 10 percent of the total impact (0.4 percentage points each).
- The impact of remittances and external borrowing are particularly important over the longer terms, after one year or beyond.

### Sectoral responses to world demand shocks
- Construction is the sector affected the most by global shocks, followed by services and then by industry.
- Services:
  - External borrowing and remittances are the major contributors to the impact of global demand shocks on services value added growth.
  - External borrowing explains about 54 percent of the impact in services growth.
  - Remittances explain about 21 percent of the impact in services growth.
  - Contributions of exports and tourism to services are relatively small.
  - Interpretation: remittances and external borrowing strongly influence households’ disposable income; external borrowing can support consumer income through higher bank financing (partly onlent to firms and individuals).
- Construction:
  - Remittances are the major contributors to the impact of global shocks on construction activity.
  - Remittances explain almost 30 percent of the impact of global demand shocks in construction activity.
  - External borrowing accounts for 27 percent of the total impact on construction.
  - Only 5.7 percent of the impact of external demand shocks in construction growth is transmitted through exports of goods and services.
  - Interpretation: remittances played a significant role financing the pre-crisis construction boom in Armenia.
- Industry:
  - Industry shows weak reactions to changes in world GDP.
  - External borrowing accounts for 25 percent of the total impact on industry growth.
  - Exports and remittances follow as contributors, but export shocks do not play a major role.
  - Interpretation: dominance of supply shocks over demand shocks in Armenian export-oriented industries (especially mining); mining output growth depends more on international prices of metals and minerals than on growth of world demand.

### Geographical sources and overall transmission channels
- The impact of global demand shocks on Armenia is sizeable and long-lasting.
- The impact is mainly transmitted through the Russian and EU economies.
  - These two regions account for 70 and 21 percent of the total impact respectively.
- Russia plays a key role in converting a negative oil-price shock into a positive event for Armenia because:
  - Negative effects of higher oil prices on Armenia’s oil bill are more than offset by the positive effect that oil price surges usually have on Russian growth, and therefore on Armenia’s remittances, exports, financing, and economic growth.
- Overall transmission-channel decomposition:
  - Remittances explain 28 percent of total impact.
  - External borrowing explains 31 percent of total impact.
  - Exports and tourism have a low role overall.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Preparatory (before a shock hits):
  - Build and preserve macroeconomic buffers, including moderate levels of public deficit and debt, and a relatively high level of international reserves.
  - Maintain access to external borrowing from donors and preserve current access to market financing.
  - Improve the business climate, openness and connectivity to attract foreign direct investment and promote export-oriented activities.
  - Aim for greater economic diversification to reduce dependence on remittances, especially from Russia.
- Short-term (once a shock has hit):
  - With comfortable buffers, implement a moderate fiscal stimulus and monetary easing.
  - Allow for exchange rate flexibility to operate as a shock absorber, while using existing reserves to mitigate excessive exchange rate volatility given Armenia’s high level of dollarization.
  - Accelerate structural reforms to increase growth and diversify export destinations and products.
- Medium-term (after effects wane):
  - Rebuild buffers by adopting a fiscal consolidation strategy and a plan to rebuild the stock of international reserves.
  - Continue with implementation of structural reforms.

### Insights on ongoing and expected global developments
- Normalization of monetary policies in advanced economies and tightening in global financial conditions:
  - Impact on Armenia would be somewhat mitigated by Armenia’s relatively large access to external borrowing on concessional terms, low international integration of Armenian banks, and low level of external portfolio investment.
- Changes in international oil prices:
  - Not expected to have a direct impact on Armenia due to relatively high level of gasification and use of medium-term gas price agreements with Russia.
  - Indirect effects occur via trading partners: e.g., recent decline in commodity prices (especially oil) reduces Russia’s growth, which negatively affects Armenia via lower remittances and exports.
- A tightening in global financial conditions could hinder Russia’s access to international funding and thereby affect Armenia.
- A delayed recovery in the EU may also affect Armenia.

*Source: Authors’ calculations and analysis in the provided IMF working paper content.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15241.pdf_
