## _wp15288

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp15288](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15288.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15288.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15288.pdf.json)

---

### Background and motivation
- Two main policy tool types: policy rates (monetary policy) and macroprudential policy instruments.
- Policy trade-offs: monetary policy may be directed at inflation/output gaps while macroprudential tools can address financial stability concerns.
- Three views on monetary policy’s role for financial stability (Smets, 2014):
  - “no” view: monetary policy focuses only on inflation and real activity.
  - “yes” view: monetary policy should equally consider financial stability.
  - conditional view: monetary policy may sometimes deviate from traditional objectives to support financial stability if net benefits justify it (growing consensus after the GFC; IMF, 2015b).

### Data and measurement
- U.S. monetary policy shocks:
  - Identified via Coibion (2012) following Romer and Romer (2004): residuals (݉_t) from an estimated Taylor rule with time-varying parameters capture exogenous monetary policy shocks.
  - Advantage: the unanticipated part (݉_t) is relatively free of current and forecasted real-time movements in macroeconomic variables; time-varying parameters capture regime changes.
- U.S. macroprudential policy actions:
  - Source: Elliott, Feldberg, and Lehnert (2013) taxonomy (measures since 1918 to early 1990s).
  - Measures classified quarterly with a dummy: 1 = macroprudential tightening introduced in the quarter; -1 = macroprudential easing in the quarter; 0 otherwise.
  - Policy correlation with monetary policy: correlation between two policies varies between 0.15 for easing and 0.25 for tightening.
  - Macroprudential action types: (i) demand-side (limits on loans-to-value ratios, margin requirements, loan maturities, tax policies); (ii) supply-side (lending and interest rate ceilings, reserve and capital requirements, portfolio restrictions, supervisory guidance).
- Financial conditions (proxy for financial stability):
  - Approximated by growth rates of real credit and property prices.
  - Credit: IFS bank credit to the private non-financial sector or BIS bank and nonbank credit to the private nonfinancial sector.
  - Property prices: OECD and IMF real house prices.
  - All series seasonally adjusted and deflated by the CPI.
- Sample periods:
  - Monetary shocks vs. credit: 1969q3 to 2008q4.
  - Monetary shocks vs. property prices: 1970q1 to 2008q4.
  - Macroprudential measures analysis: 1960q1 to 1992q2.
- Lag specification: lag length of three years employed (results broadly similar with alternative lag specifications).

### Methodology
- Primary empirical approach: distributed lags (DL) models estimating effects of lagged exogenous monetary shocks or macroprudential dummies on growth of financial-condition variables.
  - Monetary DL specification regresses (log of) real credit or property prices growth on lagged values of exogenous monetary shocks (݉_t) plus quarterly dummies; OLS unbiased due to exogeneity of shocks.
  - Macroprudential DL specification regresses financial variables on lagged macroprudential dummies (1, -1, 0); OLS may be biased because macroprudential actions respond to credit/property price developments.
- Robustness: vector autoregression (VAR) models used as robustness checks to account for possible feedbacks and endogeneity between financial variables and macroprudential actions.
- Lag length employed: three years.

### Key empirical findings
- Relative timing and persistence:
  - Monetary shocks: significant and persistent effects on financial conditions; lags in impact are important and typically significant six quarters after the shock.
  - Macroprudential policy measures: effects generally more immediate but shorter-lasting than monetary shocks.
- Magnitudes and asymmetries:
  - Monetary policy shocks and macroprudential policy tightening measures tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Effects of both monetary policy shocks and macroprudential tightening measures tend to be larger during recessions than in expansions.
- Cross-border spillovers:
  - U.S. monetary policy shocks have significant effects on financial conditions in other countries.
  - Spillover sensitivity depends on factors underlying U.S. policy changes (exogenous vs. “growth-driven”) and recipient country characteristics and policies: effects tend to be larger for emerging markets, in countries with fixed exchange rate regimes, and in countries with higher capital account openness.
  - Exogenous U.S. monetary policy shocks can dampen financial conditions in other countries, whereas “growth-driven” monetary policy rate changes have the opposite effects.
  - Macroprudential policy measures tend to have limited spillover effects internationally; evidence of spillovers mainly through foreign bank branches or cross-border banking flows in some prior studies.
- Overall assessment:
  - Both policy sets influence financial conditions, but differ in timing, persistence, asymmetry, and cross-border reach.

### Impact of U.S. monetary policy shocks on credit and property prices
- Credit:
  - 0.5 percent (0.8 standard deviations) after 7 quarters of the shock.
  - about 1 percent (1.7 standard deviations) after 12 quarters.
  - A one percent point monetary policy shock starts to reduce credit after 6 quarter with the peak effect (of about 1 percent) occurring 3 years after the shock.
  - Positive monetary shock decreases credit growth by about 1.6 percent after 12 quarters; negative shocks do not have statistically significant effects (after 12 quarters).
- Property prices:
  - about 4 percent (1.1 standard deviations) after 7 quarters.
  - about 10 percent (2.7 standard deviations) after 12 quarters.
  - For property prices, the maximum effect is about 2 percent after 3 years.
- Comparative findings in the literature (preserved exactly as in source):
  - Laseen et al. (2015): a 100 increase in the monetary policy rate decreases credit growth up to one percentage point after 5 quarters, and up to 0.5 percentage point after 10 quarters of the shock.
  - Angeloni et al. (2014): a similar shock lowers real debt by about 1 percent after 5 years.
  - Jorda et al. (2015): a 100 basis point increase in the policy rate reduces mortgage loans by about 3 percent after 4 years, and has a significant, although smaller, impact on property prices; also shows a similar shock decreases the house-prices to income ratio by about 4 percent after 4 years.
  - Walentin (2014): a 100 basis point shock reduces real property prices by 4.5 percent after 14 quarters.
  - Laseen et al. (2015): similar shock lowers house prices by about 2 percent.

### Impact of macroprudential policy measures
- Bank credit:
  - reduces bank credit by about 0.2 percent after 1 quarter.
  - reduces bank credit by about 1.6 percent after 6 quarters.
  - the impact progressively decreases to disappear after 12 quarters.
- Property prices:
  - a macroprudential tightening reduces property prices by about 9.5 percent at the peak.
  - the impact decreases 7 quarters after the shock.
- Characterization:
  - The impact of macroprudential measures seems to be more immediate, but short-lasting.
  - Results broadly in line with Elliott et al. (2013): many macroprudential measures appear to reduce bank credits in the short term, but have limited effects in the long term.
  - Possible reasons for temporary effects: lags in implementation, sector-specific single measures differing from economy-wide actions, and arbitrage and circumvention (Nier et al., 2015).

### Asymmetric effects (sign of shock and business-cycle state)
- Asymmetry by sign:
  - Tightening measures (positive shocks) tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Monetary policy tightening and easing are not statistically different up to 10 quarters; after 12 quarters positive monetary shock decreases credit growth by about 1.6 percent while negative shocks do not have statistically significant effects.
  - Macroprudential tightening measures tend to have larger effects than easing measures, though differences are not always statistically significant.
- Asymmetry by growth regime:
  - Methodology: smooth transition function with parameter ߛ chosen equal to 1.5 to mimic the US business cycle properties; specification allows ߜଵ and ߜଶ to capture impacts during downturns and upturns.
  - Evidence:
    - The impact of monetary policy tends to be larger during recessions than in expansions, even though the difference is not statistically significant.
    - The effects of macroprudential measures are statistically larger during low growth than expansion.
  - Caveat: results may vary depending on measures and targeted variables; e.g., IMF (2012) show reserve and capital requirements impact are stronger during credit bursts associated with growth slowdown.

### Robustness checks and alternative specifications
- Controlling jointly for monetary and macroprudential shocks over common period (1969q3 to 1992q2) via equation (7):
  - Confirms monetary policy shocks have significant and persistent effects on credit; macroprudential measures have significantly larger short-term but much less persistent effects.
  - Suggests monetary policy might still need to be used to contain persistent financial risks if macroprudential measures are not fully effective (Agur and Demertzis, 2013).
- VAR and hybrid VAR specifications:
  - Inclusion of lags and feedback effects shows responses of real credit to monetary policy shocks and to macroprudential measures are generally not statistically significantly different from baseline ARDL estimates.

### Cross-country spillovers of U.S. monetary policy
- General spillovers:
  - An exogenous 100 basis points increase in the U.S. monetary policy rate typically contracts the level of real credit in other countries by about 1 percent after 12 quarters.
  - No evidence of spillover effects associated with U.S. macroprudential policies (over 1960Q1-1992Q2 in the sample used).
- Heterogeneity by country type:
  - Emerging market economies: about 1.3 percent after 12 quarter of the shock.
  - Advanced economies: about 0.8 percent after 12 quarter of the shock.
  - Impact on emerging markets is larger than the domestic impact of monetary policy for the United States (citation: Eichengreen and Gupta, 2013).
- Role of country-specific characteristics (results from specification (9)):
  - Fixed (pegged) exchange rate regimes: 1 percent (statistically significant).
  - Flexible exchange rates (floaters): 0.4 percent (statistically significant difference reported).
  - Higher capital account openness: 0.8 percent.
  - Impact similar and not statistically significantly different across countries with different degree of market capitalization.
- “Growth-driven” vs. exogenous U.S. monetary policy shocks (specification (11)):
  - Exogenous monetary shocks reduce credit by about 1 percent at the peak.
  - “Growth-driven” shocks increase credit in other countries:
    - 0.2 percent after one quarter.
    - about 1 percent after 12 quarters.
- Caveats:
  - Reverse causality is less of an issue for spillovers but omitted global factors may still affect results.
  - Increasing financial integration since the sample period may amplify macroprudential spillovers in the future.

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Main empirical findings:
  - Monetary policy shocks have significant and persistent effects on financial conditions and can attenuate long-term financial instability.
  - Macroprudential measures have immediate but significantly shorter-lasting effects.
  - Tightening measures (monetary and macroprudential) tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Effects tend to be larger during recessions than expansions.
  - U.S. monetary policy shocks have spillover effects that are larger for emerging economies, for countries with fixed exchange rate regimes, and for countries with higher capital account openness; effects are independent from degree of market capitalization.
  - Exogenous increases in U.S. policy rates dampen credit abroad, while “growth-driven” increases tend to raise credit abroad.
  - General macroprudential measures tend to have limited spillover effects on other countries in the historical sample, though increasing cross-border linkages could amplify such effects going forward.
- Policy implications:
  - Use of dual toolset:
    - Monetary policy can affect long-term financial instability and operates with persistent, lagged effects.
    - Macroprudential tools can be used for more immediate, targeted interventions to address financial vulnerabilities without necessarily altering the longer-run monetary stance.
  - Costs and benefits:
    - When confronting trade-offs between traditional monetary objectives and financial stability, policymakers should weigh the longer-lasting but lagged impact of monetary policy against the quicker, shorter-lived impacts of macroprudential measures.
  - International considerations:
    - U.S. monetary policy actions—particularly exogenous shocks—have meaningful spillovers, suggesting attention to global implications, especially for emerging markets, fixed-exchange-rate economies, and financially open countries.
    - Macroprudential measures appear to be more domestically contained, limiting unintended cross-border effects.
  - Decision guidance:
    - The decision on extending monetary policy objectives to include financial stability concerns should be preceded by a careful costs and benefits analysis for each country.
    - Given the persistence of monetary policy effects, monetary policy may still be required to contain persistent financial risks if macroprudential measures are not fully effective.

### APPENDIX I. Summary Statistics
- Scope and sample:
  - Note: Statistics for the log year on year change of each financial indicator. Period: 1969q3 - 2008q4
  - Advanced economies sampled: Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, Greece, Israel, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Singapore, Sweden, Switzerland
  - Emerging countries sampled: Brazil, Colombia, India, Malaysia, Mexico, Thailand, and Uruguay
  - Source: BIS, Haver, IFS-IMF, and authors’ calculations
- Key summary statistics (log year-on-year changes):
  - Bank credit
    - USA: Mean 0.49; Standard Deviation 0.60
    - Advanced Economies: Mean 1.52; Standard Deviation 2.64
    - Emerging Countries: Mean 1.84; Standard Deviation 5.92
  - Property prices
    - USA: Mean 1.66; Standard Deviation 3.71
    - Advanced Economies: Mean 2.06; Standard Deviation 7.68
    - Emerging Countries: Mean 0.31; Standard Deviation 7.70
- Data sources and variable definitions (selected):
  - Bank credit to the private non-financial sector: CPI deflated Claims to the private sector from International Financial Statistics (codes XXX22D..ZK... , XXX22s..ZK... and XXX22D..ZF...)
  - Capital account openness: measured by an update Chinn-Ito (2013) financial openness index.
  - CPI: Non-harmonised Consumer price index obtained from IFS through Haver Analytics (code PC)
  - Credit from all sectors to the private non-financial sector: outstanding amount of credit at the end of the reference quarter from the Bank for International Settlements; borrowers include non-financial corporations, households and NPISHs; covers loans and debt securities; series adjusted for breaks by the BIS
  - Exchange regimes: those identified by Reinhart and Rogoff (2004)
  - Real house price index: series adjusted for inflation using CPI; series from the Real Estate Markets Module of the IMF Research Department; advanced economies data obtained from the OECD Housing Prices Database
  - US Monetary policy shocks: exogenous innovations in the U.S. federal funds rate identified by Coibion (2012) as the residuals from an estimated Taylor rule with time-varying parameters
  - Macroprudential policy actions: dates identified by Elliott et al. (2013) using a narrative approach; Data is available from 1918 to 1992.
  - Market capitalization: defined as the period average of the stock market value; data taken from the World Bank Development Indicators
- Summary of macroprudential tools (examples and countercyclical use):
  - Tools affecting demand for credit: Loan-to-value ratios; Margin requirements; Loan maturities; Tax policy and incentives (examples and historical dates provided in source).
  - Tools affecting supply of credit: Lending rate ceilings; Interest rate ceilings; Reserve requirements; Capital requirements; Portfolio restrictions; Supervisory pressure (examples and historical dates provided in source).

*Source: IMF working paper chapter: "1. Monetary and Macroprudential Policies Actions in the United States ..................................7"*

### 1. Monetary and Macroprudential Policies Actions in the United States ..................................7

### 1. Monetary and Macroprudential Policies Actions in the United States ..................................7

### Background and motivation
- Two main policy tool types: policy rates (monetary policy) and macroprudential policy instruments.
- Policy trade-offs: monetary policy may be directed at inflation/output gaps while macroprudential tools can address financial stability concerns.
- Three views on monetary policy’s role for financial stability (Smets, 2014):
  - “no” view: monetary policy focuses only on inflation and real activity.
  - “yes” view: monetary policy should equally consider financial stability.
  - conditional view: monetary policy may sometimes deviate from traditional objectives to support financial stability if net benefits justify it (growing consensus after the GFC; IMF, 2015b).

### Data and measurement
- U.S. monetary policy shocks:
  - Identified via Coibion (2012) following Romer and Romer (2004): residuals (݉_t) from an estimated Taylor rule with time-varying parameters capture exogenous monetary policy shocks.
  - Advantage: the unanticipated part (݉_t) is relatively free of current and forecasted real-time movements in macroeconomic variables; time-varying parameters capture regime changes.
- U.S. macroprudential policy actions:
  - Source: Elliott, Feldberg, and Lehnert (2013) taxonomy (measures since 1918 to early 1990s).
  - Measures classified quarterly with a dummy: 1 = macroprudential tightening introduced in the quarter; -1 = macroprudential easing in the quarter; 0 otherwise.
  - Policy correlation with monetary policy: correlation between two policies varies between 0.15 for easing and 0.25 for tightening.
  - Macroprudential action types: (i) demand-side (limits on loans-to-value ratios, margin requirements, loan maturities, tax policies); (ii) supply-side (lending and interest rate ceilings, reserve and capital requirements, portfolio restrictions, supervisory guidance).
- Financial conditions (proxy for financial stability):
  - Approximated by growth rates of real credit and property prices.
  - Credit: IFS bank credit to the private non-financial sector or BIS bank and nonbank credit to the private nonfinancial sector.
  - Property prices: OECD and IMF real house prices.
  - All series seasonally adjusted and deflated by the CPI.
- Sample periods:
  - Monetary shocks vs. credit: 1969q3 to 2008q4.
  - Monetary shocks vs. property prices: 1970q1 to 2008q4.
  - Macroprudential measures analysis: 1960q1 to 1992q2.
- Lag specification: lag length of three years employed (results broadly similar with alternative lag specifications).

### Methodology
- Primary empirical approach: distributed lags (DL) models (similar to Romer and Romer (2010)) estimating effects of lagged exogenous monetary shocks or macroprudential dummies on growth of financial-condition variables.
  - Monetary DL specification regresses (log of) real credit or property prices growth on lagged values of exogenous monetary shocks (݉_t) plus quarterly dummies; OLS unbiased due to exogeneity of shocks.
  - Macroprudential DL specification regresses financial variables on lagged macroprudential dummies (1, -1, 0); OLS may be biased because macroprudential actions respond to credit/property price developments.
- Robustness: vector autoregression (VAR) models used as robustness checks to account for possible feedbacks and endogeneity between financial variables and macroprudential actions.

### Key empirical findings
- Relative timing and persistence:
  - Monetary shocks have significant and persistent effects on financial conditions; lags in impact are important and typically significant six quarters after the shock.
  - Macroprudential policy measures produce effects that are generally more immediate but shorter-lasting than monetary shocks.
- Magnitudes and asymmetries:
  - Monetary policy shocks and macroprudential policy tightening measures tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Effects of both monetary policy shocks and macroprudential tightening measures tend to be larger during recessions than in expansions.
- Cross-border spillovers:
  - U.S. monetary policy shocks have significant effects on financial conditions in other countries.
  - Spillover sensitivity depends on:
    - Factors underlying U.S. policy changes (exogenous vs. “growth-driven”).
    - Recipient country characteristics and policies: effects tend to be larger for emerging markets, in countries with fixed exchange rate regimes, and in countries with higher capital account openness.
  - Exogenous U.S. monetary policy shocks can dampen financial conditions in other countries, whereas “growth-driven” monetary policy rate changes have the opposite effects.
  - Macroprudential policy measures tend to have limited spillover effects internationally; evidence of spillovers mainly through foreign bank branches or cross-border banking flows in some prior studies.
- Overall assessment:
  - Both policy sets influence financial conditions, but differ in timing, persistence, asymmetry, and cross-border reach.

### Policy-relevant implications (from findings)
- Use of dual toolset:
  - Monetary policy can affect long-term financial instability and operates with persistent, lagged effects.
  - Macroprudential tools can be used for more immediate, targeted interventions to address financial vulnerabilities without necessarily altering the longer-run monetary stance.
- Costs and benefits:
  - When confronting trade-offs between traditional monetary objectives and financial stability, policymakers should weigh the longer-lasting but lagged impact of monetary policy against the quicker, shorter-lived impacts of macroprudential measures.
- International considerations:
  - U.S. monetary policy actions—particularly exogenous shocks—have meaningful spillovers, suggesting attention to global implications, especially for emerging markets, fixed-exchange-rate economies, and financially open countries.
  - Macroprudential measures appear to be more domestically contained, limiting unintended cross-border effects.

*Source: IMF working paper chapter: "1. Monetary and Macroprudential Policies Actions in the United States ..................................7"*

### 0.5 percent (0.8 standard deviations) after 7 quarters of the shock and by about 1 percent

### 0.5 percent (0.8 standard deviations) after 7 quarters of the shock and by about 1 percent

### Impact of U.S. monetary policy shocks on credit and property prices
- Credit:
  - 0.5 percent (0.8 standard deviations) after 7 quarters of the shock.
  - about 1 percent (1.7 standard deviations) after 12 quarters.
  - A one percent point monetary policy shock starts to reduce credit after 6 quarter with the peak effect (of about 1 percent) occurring 3 years after the shock.
  - Positive monetary shock decreases credit growth by about 1.6 percent after 12 quarters; negative shocks do not have statistically significant effects (after 12 quarters).
- Property prices:
  - about 4 percent (1.1 standard deviations) after 7 quarters.
  - about 10 percent (2.7 standard deviations) after 12 quarters.
  - For property prices, the maximum effect is about 2 percent after 3 years.
- Comparative findings in the literature (reported results preserved exactly as in source):
  - Laseen et al. (2015): a 100 increase in the monetary policy rate decreases credit growth up to one percentage point after 5 quarters, and up to 0.5 percentage point after 10 quarters of the shock.
  - Angeloni et al. (2014): a similar shock lowers real debt by about 1 percent after 5 years.
  - Jorda et al. (2015): a 100 basis point increase in the policy rate reduces mortgage loans by about 3 percent after 4 years, and has a significant, although smaller, impact on property prices; also shows a similar shock decreases the house-prices to income ratio by about 4 percent after 4 years.
  - Walentin (2014): a 100 basis point shock reduces real property prices by 4.5 percent after 14 quarters.
  - Laseen et al. (2015): similar shock lowers house prices by about 2 percent.

### Impact of macroprudential policy measures
- Bank credit:
  - reduces bank credit by about 0.2 percent after 1 quarter.
  - reduces bank credit by about 1.6 percent after 6 quarters.
  - the impact progressively decreases to disappear after 12 quarters.
- Property prices:
  - a macroprudential tightening reduces property prices by about 9.5 percent at the peak.
  - the impact decreases 7 quarters after the shock.
- Characterization:
  - The impact of macroprudential measures seems to be more immediate, but short-lasting.
  - Results broadly in line with Elliott et al. (2013): many macroprudential measures appear to reduce bank credits in the short term, but have limited effects in the long term.
  - Possible reasons for temporary effects: lags in implementation, sector-specific single measures differing from economy-wide actions, and arbitrage and circumvention (Nier et al., 2015).

### Asymmetric effects (sign of shock and business-cycle state)
- Asymmetry by sign:
  - Tightening measures (positive shocks) tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Monetary policy tightening and easing are not statistically different up to 10 quarters; after 12 quarters positive monetary shock decreases credit growth by about 1.6 percent while negative shocks do not have statistically significant effects.
  - Macroprudential tightening measures tend to have larger effects than easing measures, though differences are not always statistically significant.
- Asymmetry by growth regime:
  - Methodology: smooth transition function with parameter ߛ chosen equal to 1.5 to mimic the US business cycle properties; specification allows ߜଵ and ߜଶ to capture impacts during downturns and upturns.
  - Evidence:
    - The impact of monetary policy tends to be larger during recessions than in expansions, even though the difference is not statistically significant.
    - The effects of macroprudential measures are statistically larger during low growth than expansion.
  - Caveat: results may vary depending on measures and targeted variables; e.g., IMF (2012) show reserve and capital requirements impact are stronger during credit bursts associated with growth slowdown.

### Robustness checks and alternative specifications
- Controlling jointly for monetary and macroprudential shocks over common period (1969q3 to 1992q2) via equation (7):
  - Confirms monetary policy shocks have significant and persistent effects on credit; macroprudential measures have significantly larger short-term but much less persistent effects.
  - Suggests monetary policy might still need to be used to contain persistent financial risks if macroprudential measures are not fully effective (Agur and Demertzis, 2013).
- VAR and hybrid VAR specifications:
  - Inclusion of lags and feedback effects shows responses of real credit to monetary policy shocks and to macroprudential measures are generally not statistically significantly different from baseline ARDL estimates.

### Cross-country spillovers of U.S. monetary policy
- General spillovers:
  - An exogenous 100 basis points increase in the U.S. monetary policy rate typically contracts the level of real credit in other countries by about 1 percent after 12 quarters.
  - No evidence of spillover effects associated with U.S. macroprudential policies (over 1960Q1-1992Q2 in the sample used).
- Heterogeneity by country type:
  - Advanced vs. Emerging:
    - Emerging market economies: about 1.3 percent after 12 quarter of the shock.
    - Advanced economies: about 0.8 percent after 12 quarter of the shock.
    - Impact on emerging markets is larger than the domestic impact of monetary policy for the United States (citation: Eichengreen and Gupta, 2013).
- Role of country-specific characteristics (results from specification (9)):
  - Fixed (pegged) exchange rate regimes: 1 percent (statistically significant).
  - Flexible exchange rates (floaters): 0.4 percent (statistically significant difference reported).
  - Higher capital account openness: 0.8 percent.
  - Impact similar and not statistically significantly different across countries with different degree of market capitalization.
- “Growth-driven” vs. exogenous U.S. monetary policy shocks (specification (11)):
  - Exogenous monetary shocks reduce credit by about 1 percent at the peak.
  - “Growth-driven” shocks increase credit in other countries:
    - 0.2 percent after one quarter.
    - about 1 percent after 12 quarters.
  - Interpretation: exogenous policy tightening dampens foreign financial conditions; policy rate changes driven by positive U.S. economic conditions can boost external demand and financial variables abroad.
- Caveats:
  - Reverse causality is less of an issue for spillovers but omitted global factors may still affect results.
  - Increasing financial integration since the sample period may amplify macroprudential spillovers in the future.

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Main empirical findings:
  - Monetary policy shocks have significant and persistent effects on financial conditions and can attenuate long-term financial instability.
  - Macroprudential measures have immediate but significantly shorter-lasting effects.
  - Tightening measures (monetary and macroprudential) tend to have larger effects than easing measures.
  - Effects tend to be larger during recessions than expansions.
  - U.S. monetary policy shocks have spillover effects that are larger for emerging economies, for countries with fixed exchange rate regimes, and for countries with higher capital account openness; effects are independent from degree of market capitalization.
  - Exogenous increases in U.S. policy rates dampen credit abroad, while “growth-driven” increases tend to raise credit abroad.
  - General macroprudential measures tend to have limited spillover effects on other countries in the historical sample, though increasing cross-border linkages could amplify such effects going forward.
- Policy implication emphasized:
  - The decision on extending monetary policy objectives to include financial stability concerns should be preceded by a careful costs and benefits analysis for each country.
  - Given the persistence of monetary policy effects, monetary policy may still be required to contain persistent financial risks if macroprudential measures are not fully effective.

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15288.pdf*

### APPENDIX I. Summary Statistics

### _wp15288 - APPENDIX I. Summary Statistics

### Summary statistics: scope and sample
- Note: Statistics for the log year on year change of each financial indicator. Period: 1969q3 - 2008q4
- Advanced economies sampled: Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, Greece, Israel, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Singapore, Sweden, Switzerland
- Emerging countries sampled: Brazil, Colombia, India, Malaysia, Mexico, Thailand, and Uruguay
- Source: BIS, Haver, IFS-IMF, and authors’ calculations

### Key summary statistics (log year-on-year changes)
- Bank credit
  - USA: Mean 0.49; Standard Deviation 0.60
  - Advanced Economies: Mean 1.52; Standard Deviation 2.64
  - Emerging Countries: Mean 1.84; Standard Deviation 5.92
- Property prices
  - USA: Mean 1.66; Standard Deviation 3.71
  - Advanced Economies: Mean 2.06; Standard Deviation 7.68
  - Emerging Countries: Mean 0.31; Standard Deviation 7.70

### Data sources and variable definitions
- Bank credit to the private non-financial sector: CPI deflated Claims to the private sector from International Financial Statistics (codes XXX22D..ZK... , XXX22s..ZK... and XXX22D..ZF...)
- Capital account openness: measured by an update Chinn-Ito (2013) financial openness index, available at http://graduateinstitute.ch/home/study/academicdepartments/international-economics/md4stata/datasets/chinn_ito.html
- CPI: Non-harmonised Consumer price index obtained from IFS through Haver Analytics (code PC)
- Credit from all sectors to the private non-financial sector: outstanding amount of credit at the end of the reference quarter from the Bank for International Settlements; borrowers include non-financial corporations, households and NPISHs; covers loans and debt securities; series adjusted for breaks by the BIS
- Exchange regimes: those identified by Reinhart and Rogoff (2004), available at http://www.carmenreinhart.com/data/browse-by-topic/topics/11/
- Real house price index: series adjusted for inflation using CPI; series from the Real Estate Markets Module of the IMF Research Department; advanced economies data obtained from the OECD Housing Prices Database
- US Monetary policy shocks: exogenous innovations in the U.S. federal funds rate identified by Coibion (2012) as the residuals from an estimated Taylor rule with time-varying parameters; approach distinguishes innovations to the central bank’s rule (policy shocks) from changes in the rule itself
- Macroprudential policy actions: dates identified by Elliott et al. (2013) using a narrative approach that distinguishes between tools that affect the demand for credit and those that affect its supply (Table below). Data is available from 1918 to 1992.
- Market capitalization: defined as the period average of the stock market value; data taken from the World Bank Development Indicators

### Summary of macroprudential tools (examples and countercyclical use)
- Macroprudential tools affecting demand for credit
  - Loan-to-value ratios: State laws 1941-52 (consumer); National Banking Act and Federal Reserve Act (OCC) 1950-2 (housing); Federal Reserve Regulation W (consumer credit) 1950, 1955 (FHA); Federal Reserve Regulation X (housing credit); Federal Housing Administration lending rules
  - Margin requirements: Fed. Reserve Reg. T and U (stock margins) 1934-1974 (Fed); Clearinghouse rules (stock and futures margins)
  - Loan maturities: State laws 1941-52 (consumer); National Banking Act and Federal Reserve Act 1950-2 (housing); Federal Reserve Regulations W and X 1950, 1955 (FHA); Federal Housing Administration lending rules
  - Tax policy and incentives: Mortgage interest deductions and credits 1951, 1975, 1981 (housing); Investment tax credit (ITC) 1960s-1970s (ITC)
- Macroprudential tools affecting supply of credit
  - Lending rate ceilings: State usury laws; Federal Housing Administration lending rules
  - Interest rate ceilings: Deposit rates (Federal Reserve Regulation Q) 1966, 1969, 1973-4; Other liabilities (Federal Reserve Regulation Q)
  - Reserve requirements: State laws 1936-1991 (Federal Reserve); Savings and loan regulations 1960s-1970s (FHLBB); Commercial banks (Fed. Reserve Regulation D) 1980 (Credit Control Act invoked); Special marginal reserve requirements; Special asset-based reserve requirements
  - Capital requirements: State laws 1980s (savings and loans); Savings and loan regulations 1985-6 (farm/energy banks); Commercial banks and holding companies
  - Portfolio restrictions: State laws 1941-5, 1951-2 (wartime controls); National Banking Act and Fed. Reserve Act (OCC) 1947 (credit restraint); Savings and loan regulations 1965-74 (foreign credit restraint); Special voluntary credit restraint programs 1966 (business credit); 1980 (Special Credit Restraint)
  - Supervisory pressure: Measures to promote credit availability in recession 1938, 1991, 1993 (promote); Measures to discourage excess in booms 1920s, 1995, 2000s (discourage)
- Note: examples of usage are not meant to line up with examples of tools in the second column. Source: Elliott, Feldberg, and Lehnert (2013)

*Source: _wp15288 - APPENDIX I. Summary Statistics*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/_wp15288.pdf_
