## _wp16152

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp16152](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2016/_wp16152.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2016/_wp16152.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2016/_wp16152.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction
- Review scope:
  - Surveys gender budgeting in sub-Saharan Africa and discusses examples of prominent gender budgeting efforts in the region.
  - Countries under review: Benin, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cabo Verde, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Comoros, Congo, Dem. Rep., Congo, Rep., Cote d'Ivoire, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gabon, Gambia, The, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Kenya, Lesotho, Liberia, Madagascar, Malawi, Mali, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Niger, Nigeria, Rwanda, Sao Tome and Principe, Senegal, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, South Africa, South Sudan, Swaziland, Tanzania, Togo, Uganda, Zambia, Zimbabwe.
- Key findings:
  - Rwanda, Uganda, and South Africa have achieved some successes with gender budgeting through changes in fiscal policies or budget-making procedures, though direct causal links are difficult to establish.
  - Ministries of Finance taking the lead correlate with more effective gender budgeting (examples: Rwanda and Uganda).
  - Parliamentarians, nongovernmental organizations, and donors played catalytic roles; donors also provided financial support.
  - Many regional efforts are at initial stages or episodic.

### II. Fiscal constraints and public financial management
- Fiscal context and challenges:
  - Most sub-Saharan African budgets operate with limited revenue, on average below 25 percent of GDP.
  - Many countries have limited ability to borrow on international financial markets and budgets are stressed by global events.
- Public spending and reform opportunities:
  - Public spending on education and health for all citizens is generally insufficient, even with substantial donor support in some countries.
  - Weak or underdeveloped revenue bases constrain governments’ ability to fund public services.
  - Public financial management (PFM) reforms offer an opportunity to integrate gender-oriented goals into program-based budgeting.
- Revenue and tax design considerations:
  - Most gender budgeting efforts focus on spending allocations and public program design, but strengthening revenue bases and ensuring revenue policies contribute to gender equality goals is important.
  - Discrimination against women in the personal income tax, once common, is largely gone; scope remains to address implicit biases in indirect taxes.

### III. Gender inequality in sub-Saharan Africa: status and trends
- General trend:
  - Gender inequality in access to education, adequate health care, and paid employment remains significant, though improving in recent years.
  - Gender Development Index (GDI) has improved in almost every country over the last two decades.
  - The GDI generally ranges from 0 to 1, where a higher number implies more equality.
- Education:
  - Sub-Saharan Africa is increasing female enrollment and closing gender gaps in primary and secondary education.
  - Of the 45 countries listed in Table 1, only 12 have gross female enrollment rates above 50 percent of eligible students.
- Labor force and employment:
  - The region has a high ratio of female to male labor force participation rates compared with other developing regions, but women’s participation remains lower than men’s.
  - Women tend to be concentrated in the informal sector or subsistence agriculture and generally have inferior status in the job market.
- Maternal mortality:
  - Early 1990s regional maternal mortality ratio was over 1,000 deaths per 100,000 live births.
  - The regional maternal mortality rate is now below 500 deaths per 100,000 live births; regional average maternal mortality ratio: 477 (per 100,000).
- Selected regional averages (average 2011-2014):
  - Total revenue 24.4 (percent of GDP)
  - Total expenditure 27.3 (percent of GDP)
  - Overall balance -3.0 (percent of GDP)
  - Gross debt 41.4 (percent of GDP)
  - Education expenditure 4.0 (percent of GDP)
  - Health expenditure 3.0 (percent of GDP)
  - PEFA overall score 2.2
  - Regional average GDI (time-consistent, 2013): 0.865
  - Regional average labor force participation rate (female, ages 15-64): 44.2 (percent)
  - Regional average gross secondary enrollment (female to male ratio): 0.84

### IV. Links between gender budgeting, gender inequality, and growth
- Underlying premises:
  - Addressing gender inequality and women’s needs can have a positive influence on growth.
  - Fiscal policies influence economic and social outcomes and can therefore contribute to gender equality.
- Mechanisms:
  - Macroeconomic: fiscal policies influence growth via budget stability and sustainability.
  - Microeconomic: fiscal policies affect composition and amounts of expenditures and revenues, influencing human and physical capital accumulation and incentives to work, invest, and take risks.
  - Fiscal policies interact with regulatory and structural policies and internalize externalities.
- Evidence and research:
  - A growing number of studies survey the relationship between gender equality, women’s advancement, and economic growth; several surveys emphasize bidirectional effects.

### V. International and regional initiatives supporting gender budgeting
- Key international milestones and obligations:
  - 1979: UN adopts CEDAW.
  - 1995: Beijing Platform for Action explicitly called for gender budgeting (Paragraphs 345–346).
  - 2000: Millennium Development Goals; Goal 3 committed to promotion of gender equality and empowerment of women.
  - 2008: Southern African Development Community introduces the Protocol on Gender and Development.
  - 2014: African Union issues the Addis Ababa declaration calling upon member countries to adopt gender-sensitive planning and budgeting schemes.
  - 2015: UN adopts the Sustainable Development Goals; Goal 5 includes “adopt and strengthen sound policies and enforceable legislation for the promotion of gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls at all levels.”
- Regional instruments and expectations:
  - SADC Protocol Article 15 requires gender sensitive and responsive budgeting at micro and macro levels, including tracking, monitoring and evaluation, and recommends integrating women’s unpaid work into national accounts and budgeting.
  - Addis Ababa Declaration called for strengthening domestic resource mobilization and allocation for women’s and girls’ rights.
  - OECD/UNDP (2014) note only a minority of sub-Saharan African countries has systems for tracking spending on gender equality and a public record of allocations.
- UN Beijing Platform (Paragraphs 345–346):
  - Integrate a gender perspective in budgetary decisions and adequately finance programmes securing equality between women and men.
  - Systematically review how women benefit from public sector expenditures and adjust budgets to ensure equality of access.

### VI. Country example — Uganda
- Context and objectives:
  - Uganda: low-income, agricultural-based developing country with significant progress in macroeconomic control and growth.
  - Primary objective of gender budgeting efforts: ensure government ministries address gender issues through normal planning and budgeting processes.
- Institutional features and history:
  - Forum for Women in Democracy (FOWODE) led first gender budgeting initiative in the late 1990s.
  - 1997 Poverty Eradication Action Plan and subsequent revisions included a gender focus; 1998–2003 Education Sector Investment Plan sought equal enrollment by 2015.
  - Gender budgeting formally adopted in 2004/05 when the Ministry of Finance, Planning, and Economic Development included gender budgeting in the Budget Call Circular.
  - Initial focus sectors: Education; Health; Agriculture; Justice, Law, and Order; Energy; Water and Sanitation.
  - Ministry produced sex-disaggregated data to inform budget discussions.
  - Budget call circular refinements: 2014/15 required sectors to submit specific actions; 2016/17 reiterates and provides separate annexes.
- Donor and joint programs:
  - Joint Programme on Gender Equality-Uganda led by UN Women and funded by DFID.
  - Reported measures: Parliament’s decision to eliminate the kerosene tax in fiscal year 2014/15 (later revoked by the President); removal of the 18 percent VAT on agricultural inputs and equipment for fiscal year 2014/15.
  - DFID final report assigned Uganda an “A” grade for achievements under the program.
- Health-related commitments and outcomes:
  - 2015/16 budget speech: government actions on maternal and child health, antenatal care, malaria prevention, HIV voluntary counseling and testing, nutritional supplements.
  - HIV testing for pregnant women: 30 percent in 2008; 95 percent in 2014.
  - Proportion of pregnant women living with HIV accessing ARVs: 33 percent in 2007; 87 percent in 2014.
- Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development initiatives:
  - Uganda Women’s Entrepreneurship Program starting fiscal year 2015/2016 for five years.
  - Introduction of a Gender and Equity Compliance Certificate into the Public Finance Management Act of 2015.
  - Capacity building for senior government officials in gender budgeting; inclusion in higher education curricula.
  - Requiring accounting officers to deliver on gender equality as a performance indicator.
  - Issuing gender mainstreaming guidelines and establishing a national coordination mechanism.
  - National Gender Multi-Sectoral Framework for monitoring and reporting.
  - Annual assessment of local government plans, programs, and budgets for gender responsiveness by the Ministry of Local Government.
  - Incentivizing well-performing local governments with increased resource allocation under unconditional grants.
  - Initiating a Value for Money Audit from a gender perspective by the Auditor General’s Office; annual audits on gender responsiveness.
- Local-level initiatives and pilots:
  - Guidelines encouraging local governments to use gender-aware budget statements and sex-disaggregated beneficiary assessments.
  - UN Joint Programme assigned gender-oriented performance indicators to all 133 local governments; indicators measure local government performance and tie central government grants to good performance.
  - Lyantonde District example: sex-disaggregated analysis, resource ownership tables, sex imbalance time-use analysis.
  - Northern Uganda pilot in 2012: one-year pilot with additional allocations for education and health and raised awareness of addressing gender concerns through the budget.
  - Village budget clubs enabled monitoring and accountability at local level.
- Findings and lessons:
  - Uganda showed improvements in education and maternal health and in strengthening justice, law, and order via national and local budgeting initiatives.
  - Key innovations: Certificate on Gender and Equity Compliance; linking intergovernmental transfers to local gender equity programs.
  - Suggested improvement: more formal assessment to guide strengthening efforts.
- Key numerical and temporal markers (preserved exactly):
  - HIV testing for pregnant women: 30 percent in 2008; 95 percent in 2014.
  - Proportion of pregnant women living with HIV accessing ARVs: 33 percent in 2007; 87 percent in 2014.
  - Fiscal year references: 2008/09; 2014/15; 2015/2016; 2016/17; FY 2011/12 – 2015/16.
  - Number of local governments assigned indicators: 133 local governments.
  - Compendium sex-disaggregated topics: more than 20 key topics.

### VII. Country example — Rwanda
- Context and institutional basis:
  - Rwanda: low-income, agricultural-based developing country with strong post-conflict progress, high growth, and macroeconomic stability.
  - Constitution of 2003: equal rights for women and men and mandates at least 30 percent women in all decision-making positions.
  - Institutions: Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion; Gender Monitoring Office; national women’s council.
- Timeline and design of initiatives:
  - 2002: First initiative led by Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion with Ministry of Finance; effort faltered due to lack of Ministry of Finance leadership and overreliance on outside experts.
  - 2008–2010: Second initiative led by Ministry of Finance with UNIFEM support; premised on every ministry integrating women’s needs into its remit.
  - 2009 onward: implementation in four pilot areas and local governments; build monitoring and evaluation systems; collect sex-disaggregated data; develop sector indicators.
  - 2010/2011: Ministry of Finance submitted the national budget with Gender Budget Statements for the four pilot sectors; first budget call circular made submission of Gender Budget Statements mandatory in pilot sectors.
- Policy priorities and coverage:
  - National Gender Policy: “Budgeting is the condition sine qua non of success of implementation of the National Gender Policy. The Policy will not succeed unless adequate resources are allocated to programmes and activities related to it” (paragraph 3.3.6).
  - Pilot sectors: health, education, agriculture, infrastructure (selected to demonstrate relevance beyond social sector).
  - Focus on recurrent and capital spending and on needs of the poor given Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy.
- Accountability, monitoring, and reporting:
  - Gender Budget Statement: key instrument for accountability enabling reporting to parliament.
  - Ministries required to submit Gender Budget Statements to Ministry of Finance; inclusion of gender analysis in Strategic Issues Papers.
  - Budget call circular asks sectors to: analyze problems and policy implications; assess incorporation into the budget; monitor execution and achievement of outputs; evaluate outcomes.
- Monitoring indicators (Gender Monitoring Office examples — Percent Male — Percent Female):
  - Government sector board membership: 73.2 — 26.8
  - High commissariat of the police: 81.0 — 19.0
  - Ministers: 72.7 — 27.2
  - Mayors of districts: 90.0 — 10.0
  - Senators: 65.4 — 34.6
  - Judges at the Supreme Court: 57.0 — 43.0
  - Civil society boards: 86.7 — 13.3
  - Agriculture staff: 66.0 — 34.0
  - Agricultural credit beneficiaries: 64.0 — 36.0
  - ICT employment: 71.1 — 28.9
  - Transport employment: 71.6 — 28.4
  - Public infrastructure jobs accessed: 74.6 — 25.4
  - Persons studying sciences and technology: 67.0 — 33.0
  - Private sector employees: 45.6 — 54.4
  - Private companies by gender of owners (Agriculture): 85.7 — 14.3; (Mining): 93.2 — 6.8; (Tourism): 71.4 — 28.6; (Manufacturing): 64.0 — 35.5
- Institutionalization and compliance:
  - From fiscal year 2011/2012, Gender Budget Statements mandatory for all central ministries.
  - Fiscal year 2013/14: Gender Monitoring Office determined all districts and almost all ministries complied with the Gender Budget Statement requirement.
  - 2013 Organic Budget Law institutionalized gender budgeting (Article 4, Article 32, Article 68 cited).
  - Gender Monitoring Office 2013/2014 report found scope for significant improvements in sex-disaggregated analysis and linkage to activities, outputs, and indicators.
- Evidence of progress and sectoral impacts:
  - Mukunda (2011): progress integrating gender budgeting into budget process; scope for sectoral improvement; Ministry of Youth and Ministry of Health commended.
  - Mirwoba (2013): randomized review of four pilot ministries, fiscal year 2010/2011:
    - Ministry of Agriculture spent almost one-third of its budget on gender-targeted outputs in that year.
    - Remaining ministries spent less than 15 percent each on gender-targeted outputs.
  - Education: supply of books and sanitation; training teachers and parents to promote girls in science and technology.
  - Health: increasing trained health personnel related to maternity services; targeted support to female-headed households; mitigation of malnutrition and malaria among expectant women and children.
- Measured outcomes and lessons:
  - Rwanda increased female to male ratios in primary, secondary, and tertiary education; tertiary nearly closed gap with comparator group.
  - Maternal mortality ratio decreased substantially between 1990 and 2013, outperforming comparators.
  - Labor force participation: little change; female to male ratio above one in 2013.
  - Lessons: Ministry of Finance leadership, multi-sector pilots, program-budgeting alignment, discretion for ministries, and establishment of Gender Monitoring Office are success factors.
  - Ongoing needs: improve sex-disaggregated data, strengthen monitoring and tracking of outcomes, address violence against women, use time use data for unpaid care work, and strengthen domestic resource mobilization.

### VIII. Appendix A — four-country snapshot (selected entries preserved exactly)
- Countries covered: Rwanda, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda
- Does the government have a gender budgeting initiative:
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes
- If yes, start year:
  - Rwanda: 2002
  - South Africa: 1998-1999
  - Tanzania: 1999
  - Uganda: 2004/2005
- Focus and coverage (sample items):
  - Spending focus on key human development (education and health): Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Spending focus on physical infrastructure: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Spending focus on justice and security: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: No; Uganda: Yes
  - Focus on revenue: Rwanda: No; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Personal income tax focus: Rwanda: No; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: No; Uganda: No
  - Gender budgeting in planning and programming: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Gender budgeting outcome report or audit: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: No; Tanzania: No; Uganda: Yes
  - Gender budgeting has constitutional standing: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: No; Tanzania: No; Uganda: No
  - Gender budgeting is incorporated in organic budget or other finance laws: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: No; Tanzania: No; Uganda: Yes
  - Ministry of Finance lead entity: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Subnational government participation: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes
  - Significant civil society participation: Rwanda: Yes; South Africa: Yes; Tanzania: Yes; Uganda: Yes

### IX. Lessons, policy implications, and suggested improvements
- Cross-cutting lessons:
  - Ministries of Finance leadership and integration with PFM and program budgeting strengthen gender budgeting effectiveness.
  - Multi-sector pilots (social, economic, infrastructure) demonstrate relevance beyond social sectors.
  - Sex-disaggregated data, monitoring, and accountability mechanisms (e.g., Gender Budget Statements, Gender Monitoring Offices) are key for implementation.
  - Civil society, parliamentarians, and donors can play catalytic roles, including financial support.
- Suggested improvements:
  - Improve sex-disaggregated data and rigorous linkage of analysis to activities, outputs, and indicators.
  - Enhance monitoring, tracking of outcomes, and targeted interventions for violence against women.
  - Strengthen domestic resource mobilization to fund public services that advance gender equality and support UN Sustainable Development Goals.
  - Conduct more formal assessments of initiatives to guide strengthening efforts.

*Source: _wp16152 — selected pages and appendix content from the provided PDF chapter/section.*

### References  ............................................................................................................

### _wp16152 - References  ............................................................................................................

### I. Introduction
- Review scope:
  - Surveys gender budgeting in sub-Saharan Africa and discusses examples of prominent gender budgeting efforts in the region.
  - Countries under review are listed in Figure 1: Benin, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cabo Verde, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Comoros, Congo, Dem. Rep., Congo, Rep., Cote d'Ivoire, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Gabon, Gambia, The, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Kenya, Lesotho, Liberia, Madagascar, Malawi, Mali, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Niger, Nigeria, Rwanda, Sao Tome and Principe, Senegal, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, South Africa, South Sudan, Swaziland, Tanzania, Togo, Uganda, Zambia, Zimbabwe; (presented visually in Figure 1).
- Key findings:
  - Rwanda, Uganda, and South Africa have achieved some successes with gender budgeting through changes in fiscal policies or budget-making procedures, though direct causal links are difficult to establish.
  - Ministries of Finance taking the lead correlate with more effective gender budgeting (examples: Rwanda and Uganda).
  - Parliamentarians, nongovernmental organizations, and donors played catalytic roles; donors also provided financial support.
  - Many regional efforts are at initial stages or episodic.

### II. Fiscal constraints and public financial management
- Fiscal context:
  - Most sub-Saharan African budgets operate with limited revenue, on average below 25 percent of GDP.
  - Many countries have limited ability to borrow on international financial markets and budgets are stressed by global events.
- Public spending and reform:
  - Public spending on education and health for all citizens is generally insufficient, even with substantial donor support in some countries.
  - Weak or underdeveloped revenue bases constrain governments’ ability to fund public services (references: Keen and Mansour, 2009; Ebeke and Ehrhart, 2013).
  - Public financial management (PFM) reforms have been undertaken; PFM reforms offer an opportunity to integrate gender-oriented goals into program-based budgeting (reference: Andrews, 2010).
- Revenue and tax design:
  - Most gender budgeting efforts focus on spending allocations and public program design, but strengthening revenue bases and ensuring revenue policies contribute to gender equality goals is important.
  - Discrimination against women in the personal income tax, once common, is largely gone; scope remains to address implicit biases in indirect taxes (references: Stotsky, 1997; Grown and Valodia, 2010).

### III. Gender inequality in sub-Saharan Africa: status and trends
- General trend:
  - Gender inequality in access to education, adequate health care, and paid employment remains significant, though improving in recent years.
  - Gender Development Index (GDI) has improved in almost every country over the last two decades (Figure 2: GDI, time-consistent version).
  - Note: The GDI generally ranges from 0 to 1, where a higher number implies more equality.
- Education:
  - Sub-Saharan Africa is increasing female enrollment and closing gender gaps in primary and secondary education.
  - Stark differences exist in ratios of female to male enrollment rates at the secondary level across the region; of the 45 countries listed in Table 1, only 12 have gross female enrollment rates above 50 percent of eligible students.
- Labor force:
  - The region has a high ratio of female to male labor force participation rates compared with other developing regions, but women’s participation remains lower than men’s.
  - Women tend to be concentrated in the informal sector or subsistence agriculture and generally have inferior status in the job market.
- Maternal mortality:
  - In the early 1990s, maternal mortality ratio in the region was over 1,000 deaths per 100,000 live births.
  - The regional maternal mortality rate is now below 500 deaths per 100,000 live births, but remains excessively high.
  - Countries with prolonged civil conflict continue to struggle with higher maternal mortality rates.
- Selected regional averages and indicators (as presented in Table 2 and Table 1):
  - Regional average fiscal aggregates (average 2011-2014): Total revenue 24.4 (percent of GDP); Total expenditure 27.3 (percent of GDP); Overall balance -3.0 (percent of GDP); Gross debt 41.4 (percent of GDP); Education expenditure 4.0 (percent of GDP); Health expenditure 3.0 (percent of GDP); PEFA overall score 2.2.
  - Regional average GDI (time-consistent, 2013): 0.865.
  - Regional average labor force participation rate (female, ages 15-64): 44.2 (percent).
  - Regional average gross secondary enrollment (female to male ratio): 0.84.
  - Regional average maternal mortality ratio: 477 (per 100,000).

### IV. Links between gender budgeting, gender inequality, and growth
- Underlying premises of gender budgeting:
  - Addressing gender inequality and women’s needs can have a positive influence on growth (reference: Elborgh-Woytek, et al., 2013).
  - Fiscal policies influence economic and social outcomes and can therefore contribute to gender equality.
- Mechanisms:
  - Fiscal policies influence growth via budget stability and sustainability (macroeconomic perspective).
  - At the microeconomic level, fiscal policies affect composition and amounts of expenditures and revenues, influencing human and physical capital accumulation and incentives to work, invest, and take risks.
  - Fiscal policies interact with regulatory and structural policies and internalize externalities.
- Evidence:
  - A growing number of studies survey the relationship between gender equality, women’s advancement, and economic growth (references include World Bank, 2011; Duflo, 2012; Bandiera and Natraj, 2013; Berik, van der Meulen Rodgers, and Seguino, 2009; Cuberes and Teignier, 2014; Kabeer and Natali, 2013; OECD, 2012).
  - Several surveys emphasize bidirectional effects: gender inequality affects growth, and growth affects gender inequality.

### V. International and regional initiatives supporting gender budgeting
- Key international milestones and obligations (Box 1 timeline):
  - 1979: The UN adopts the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).
  - 1995: The Beijing Platform for Action adopted at the Fourth International Conference for Women; explicitly called for gender budgeting (Paragraphs 345–346).
  - 2000: The UN adopts the Millennium Development Goals; Goal 3 committed countries to promotion of gender equality and empowerment of women, target equal enrollment for males and females at all education levels.
  - 2008: The Southern African Development Community introduces the Protocol on Gender and Development.
  - 2014: The African Union issues the Addis Ababa declaration calling upon member countries to adopt gender-sensitive planning and budgeting schemes.
  - 2015: The UN adopts the Sustainable Development Goals; Goal 5: “adopt and strengthen sound policies and enforceable legislation for the promotion of gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls at all levels.”
- Regional instruments and expectations:
  - SADC Protocol on Gender and Development (Article 15) requires gender sensitive and responsive budgeting at micro and macro levels, including tracking, monitoring and evaluation, and recommends integrating women’s unpaid work into national accounts and budgeting.
  - Addis Ababa Declaration called for adoption of gender-sensitive planning and budgeting and strengthening domestic resource mobilization and allocation for women’s and girls’ rights.
  - OECD/UNDP (2014) note only a minority of sub-Saharan African countries has systems for tracking spending on gender equality and a public record of allocations.
- UN Beijing Platform for Action explicit guidance:
  - Paragraph 345: integrate a gender perspective in budgetary decisions and adequately finance programmes securing equality between women and men.
  - Paragraph 346: systematically review how women benefit from public sector expenditures and adjust budgets to ensure equality of access.

### VI. Country example: Uganda (selected content)
- Context:
  - Uganda is a low-income, agricultural-based developing country with significant progress in macroeconomic control and growth (reference: IMF, 2015b).
- Objectives and outcomes of gender budgeting efforts:
  - Primary objective: ensure government ministries address gender issues through normal planning and budgeting processes.
  - Achieved some success in education and health and in strengthening justice, law, and order via national and local budgeting initiatives.
- Institutional features:
  - Efforts reflect collaboration among ministries, parliamentarians, NGOs, and donors.
  - Ministries of Finance have mandated that social welfare or women’s development ministries/levels of government address gender gaps and women’s needs in their budgets.
- Notes:
  - The country example is presented as part of a set of prominent country efforts; Rwanda and South Africa are noted elsewhere as also achieving some successes.

*Source: _wp16152 - References (selected pages 3–10) from the provided PDF content.*

### Appendix A provides basic data on the prominent gender budgeting efforts in the region.

### _wp16152 - Appendix A provides basic data on the prominent gender budgeting efforts in the region.

### Background and early initiatives
- Forum for Women in Democracy (FOWODE) led Uganda’s first gender budgeting initiative in the late 1990s (Budlender, 2002).
- FOWODE coordinated with the Parliamentary Budget Office and budget officers and organized workshops for legislators and technocrats (Tanzarn, 2008, p. 16).
- FOWODE commissioned national and district level research focusing on women’s needs; three key sector-wide approaches centered on education, health, and agriculture.
- One goal was to improve maternal health; under a sector-wide approach with the Ministry of Health, FOWODE worked to introduce “mama kits” for safe deliveries (Tanzarn, 2008, p. 17).

### National policy frameworks and plans
- 1997: Uganda began implementing its Poverty Eradication Action Plan; the second revision came in 2000 and the third in 2004, each including a gender focus in implementation strategies (Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development, 2014, p. 14).
- 1998–2003 Education Sector Investment Plan sought to equalize enrollment of boys and girls in primary and secondary school by 2015 and to substantially increase female enrollment in tertiary education and in science and technology programs.
- 2008/09 Ministry of Education and Sports’ Policy Statement measures:
  - separate latrines for boys and girls in all newly constructed schools;
  - revision of school curricula to identify and eliminate gender stereotypes;
  - appointment of senior women to support adolescent girls and girls in post-conflict areas in the north;
  - affirmative action for hiring and promoting women (Tanzarn, 2008, p. 27).
- National Development Plan covering 2010-2015 replaced the third Poverty Eradication Action Plan and focused on growth, employment, and human development; one objective was to promote gender equality and women’s empowerment, including promoting and conducting gender budgeting and gender responsive monitoring and evaluation (National Development Plan, 2013, p. 284).
- Government review of the 2013 Plan noted progress in:
  - improved access to water, health, and education services for women;
  - reduced time spent by women and children fetching water;
  - increased equality in primary schooling for girls and boys;
  - gradual improvements in births attended by skilled medical personnel and in health facilities;
  - reduction in unmet needs for contraception and family planning;
  - maternal mortality progress has stalled in recent years (Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development, 2014, p. 14).

### Budget institutionalization and guidance
- Gender budgeting was formally adopted in 2004/05 when the Ministry of Finance, Planning, and Economic Development included gender budgeting in the Budget Call Circular; guidelines were attached as an annex for sector ministries and local governments.
- Initial focus sectors: Ministries of Education; Health; Agriculture; Justice, Law, and Order; Energy; and Water and Sanitation.
- The Ministry produced sex-disaggregated data to inform budget discussions.
- The budget call circular was refined over recent fiscal years to require specific actions to address gender inequality in Budget Framework Papers (Dietl et al., 2014).
- 2014/15 budget call circular required sectors to submit specific actions; the 2016/17 budget call circular reiterates this and provides separate annexes with instructions.
- Budget call circular directives:
  - demonstrate how ministries, departments, agencies, and local governments are promoting gender equality and related Sustainable Development Goals;
  - identify targets related to gender equality and measure progress by collecting data disaggregated by sex, age, disability, and geographic location.

### Donor and joint programs; assessments
- Joint Programme on Gender Equality-Uganda, led by UN Women and funded by the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development, aimed to bring stakeholders together to support government gender equality goals (Joint Programme on Gender Equality, 2014).
- Measures cited under the Joint Programme:
  - Parliament’s decision to eliminate the kerosene tax in fiscal year 2014/15 (later revoked by the President).
  - Parliament removed the 18 percent value added tax (VAT) on agricultural inputs and equipment for fiscal year 2014/15 (benefiting farmers, majority women) (UN Joint Programme, 2014, p. 20).
- Uganda Bureau of Statistics compiled documentation on sex-disaggregated data collected by ministries; the Compendium shows sex-disaggregated data are available for more than 20 key topics such as education, water use, poverty, crime, and labor force participation.
- DFID final report assigned Uganda an “A” grade for achievements under the program, specifically citing progress on increasing girls’ education and addressing violence against women (DFID, 2015).

### Health-related budget commitments and outcomes
- 2015/16 budget speech specific measures:
  - “Government will directly seek to address the health of mothers and children. Providing comprehensive antenatal care and malaria prevention for pregnant women, in addition to HIV voluntary counseling and testing services and nutritional supplements, will go a long way in this quest.”
  - Government “[i]ncreased the proportion of pregnant women living with HIV accessing Anti-Retro Viral treatment (ARVs) from 33 percent in 2007 to 87 percent in 2014 as a result of increased testing for HIV in pregnant women from 30 percent in 2008 to 95 percent in 2014.”

### Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development activities and PFM linkages
- Initiatives and legislative measures:
  - Initiating a Uganda Women’s Entrepreneurship Program implemented over a period of five years starting from fiscal year 2015/2016 to improve access to financial services for women and equip them with skills.
  - Introducing a Gender and Equity Compliance Certificate into the Public Finance Management Act of 2015; the Act calls upon all ministries, departments, and agencies to ensure budget frameworks and Ministerial Policy statements address gender-oriented goals, and the certificate would be issued to reflect this.
  - Instituting capacity building for senior government officials in gender budgeting; institutions of higher learning including these courses in curricula.
  - Requiring all accounting officers to deliver on gender equality and women’s empowerment as a performance indicator.
  - Issuing gender mainstreaming guidelines and establishing a national coordination mechanism for systematic integration of gender equality and women’s empowerment issues in development plans, policies, programs, and the budget.
  - Establishing a National Gender Multi-Sectoral Framework for monitoring implementation and reporting on international and regional Gender Equality and Women’s Empowerment goals.
  - Developing sector-specific gender policies and strategies within government institutions and establishing Gender Working Technical Committees.
  - Conducting an annual assessment of local government plans, programs, and budgets for gender responsiveness through the Ministry of Local Government; allocation of resources for gender equality and women’s empowerment goals is a key indicator.
  - Incentivizing well-performing local governments with increased resource allocation under unconditional grants from the central government.
  - Initiating a Value for Money Audit from a gender perspective by the Auditor General’s Office; annual audits for sectors and local governments on gender responsiveness.

### Local-level initiatives and pilots
- Ministry of Local Government established guidelines encouraging local governments to use gender-aware budget statements and sex-disaggregated beneficiary assessments (Ministry of Gender, Labour, and Social Development/Ministry of Local Government, 2005, p. 11).
- UN Joint Programme developed gender-oriented performance indicators and assigned them to all 133 local governments in Uganda; as of fiscal year 2014/15, indicators measure local government performance in planning and using resources for gender equality and tie central government grants to good performance.
- Local government progress reported: keeping girls in school, responding to violence against women, and improving water supply (UN Joint Programme, 2014, p. 10).
- Example: Lyantonde District Local Government Five Year District Development Plan for FY 2011/12 – 2015/16 includes sex-disaggregated analysis, resource ownership tables showing men own and control household resources, and a sex imbalance analysis of time spent on unpaid work.
- Northern Uganda local-level gender budgeting pilot in 2012 (one-year pilot) through UNDP, Government of Japan, Uganda Ministry of Gender, Labour, and Social Development, Parliamentary Budget Office, and others; evaluation found additional allocations for education and health programs related to women and raised awareness of addressing gender concerns through the budget (Mugisha Baine, 2013).
- Village budget clubs: FOWODE involvement; clubs allow local citizens to monitor public resources and hold government accountable. Example in Kabale: mixed-gender club that decided priority sectors and monitored program delivery, uncovering issues such as incomplete “mama kits” and lack of emphasis on indigenous crops. Clubs provided women a platform to advocate for maternal health, infrastructure, education, and other issues.

### Findings and comparative indicators
- Figure 3 comparisons (described): Uganda moved from lagging comparators in 1990 in education enrollment and maternal mortality ratio to exceeding the comparator group in the latest period of data except in secondary education enrollment.
- Progress on labor force participation: female to male ratio fell in Uganda, in contrast to the comparator group.
- Gender Development Index improved more than the comparator group’s index; the Gender Inequality Index moved about the same.

### Key statistics and exact numeric values preserved from the content
- 2008: HIV testing for pregnant women at 30 percent.
- 2014: HIV testing for pregnant women at 95 percent.
- 2007: proportion of pregnant women living with HIV accessing ARVs was 33 percent.
- 2014: proportion of pregnant women living with HIV accessing ARVs was 87 percent.
- Fiscal year references: 2008/09; 2014/15; 2015/2016; 2016/17; FY 2011/12 – 2015/16.
- Number of local governments assigned indicators: 133 local governments.
- More than 20 key topics in Compendium of Concepts and Definitions on Gender Statistics.

*Appendix A content on Uganda’s gender budgeting efforts as provided in the source PDF.*

### introduction of gender budgeting (marked by a vertical line in the figures).  Uganda

### _wp16152 - introduction of gender budgeting (marked by a vertical line in the figures).  Uganda

### Uganda — Trends and outcomes following introduction of gender budgeting
- The vertical line in figures marks the start of gender budgeting in the education sector with the start of the Education Sector Investment plan in 1998, and in the health sector marked by the start of FOWODE’s initiative to improve maternal health in 1999.
- Educational enrollment (female to male ratio):
  - Uganda continued to make progress on equalizing the number of boys and girls enrolled in primary, secondary, and tertiary education, measured in percent of the relevant population, following the introduction of gender budgeting.
  - There was some evidence of an increased rate of change following introduction of gender budgeting, though causality is not asserted.
  - Females still have lower enrollment in secondary and tertiary education in the latest data.
  - Uganda made improvements in the female to male ratio of primary, secondary, and tertiary enrollment; it lags regional counterparts in secondary, but outperforms in tertiary enrollment.
- Maternal mortality:
  - The decline in the maternal mortality ratio that began before gender budgeting continued in the years following.
  - Uganda’s reduction in the maternal mortality ratio was somewhat better than comparator countries.
- Labor force participation and gender indices:
  - Uganda saw a slight decrease in both the female and the ratio of female to male labor force participation rate, while its counterparts saw an increase.
  - Uganda started off at a higher level of overall gender inequality than its counterparts in 1990, but outperformed them by 2013.
- Comparator group definition and index interpretation:
  - SALIDCs represents: Benin, Cameroon, Comoros, Ethiopia, Gambia, Ghana, Kenya, Lesotho, Madagascar, Mozambique, Rwanda, Sao Tome Principe, Senegal, Tanzania, Togo, and Zambia.
  - A higher Gender Development Index indicates greater gender equality, while a higher Gender Inequality Index implies greater inequality.
- Sources for Uganda figures and estimates:
  - World Bank, World Development Indicators; Stotsky et al. (2016); IMF staff estimates.

### Uganda — Lessons and policy implications
- Key lessons:
  - Governments can address gender-oriented goals through the budget by setting clear and well thought-out priorities across sectors.
  - Use of the budget at national and subnational levels to address gender-oriented gaps and women’s needs in education and health demonstrates the positive role government can play, even though progress remains slow.
- Innovative practices in Uganda:
  - Introduction of the Certificate on Gender and Equity Compliance to monitor sectoral compliance with gender-oriented goals.
  - Linking of intergovernmental transfers to local governments to programs on gender equity.
- Suggested improvement:
  - Uganda’s efforts would benefit from more formal assessment as a guide to strengthening its efforts.

### Rwanda — institutional framework and gender-budgeting initiatives
- Country context:
  - Rwanda is a low-income, agricultural-based developing country that made impressive progress after civil conflict in the 1990s and has enjoyed high growth and macroeconomic stability in recent years.
- Constitutional and institutional basis:
  - The Constitution of 2003 includes equal rights for women and men and mandates at least 30 percent women in all decision-making positions.
  - Women constitute about two-thirds of the lower house of parliament and are well represented in judiciary and cabinet positions, and as provincial governors, district council members, and mayors in charge of social affairs.
  - The Constitution provides basis for gender-responsive laws including inheritance, land, property rights, and protection against gender-based violence.
  - Institutions established: Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion, Gender Monitoring Office, and a national women’s council.
- Timeline of gender-budgeting initiatives:
  - 2002: First initiative led by the Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion with the Ministry of Finance and support from the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development. Developed gender budget statements to be incorporated into program budgets. The initiative faltered due to the Ministry of Finance not leading, overreliance on outside experts, and insufficient local capacity building.
  - 2008–2010: Second initiative led by the Ministry of Finance with support from UNIFEM (now UN Women). Premised on every ministry being responsible for integrating women’s needs into its remit. Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion and the Gender Monitoring Office provided oversight and support. Emphasis on building local capacity and linking to public financial management reforms toward program budgeting.
  - 2009 onward (second phase beginning in 2009): Ensure implementation in four pilot areas and local governments, build monitoring and evaluation systems, collect sex-disaggregated data, and develop sector indicators.
  - 2010/2011: Ministry of Finance submitted the national budget with Gender Budget Statements for the four pilot sectors following the first budget call circular that made submission of Gender Budget Statements mandatory in pilot sectors and required other sectors to demonstrate gender integration.
- Policy design and priorities:
  - Underlying National Gender Policy: “Budgeting is the condition sine qua non of success of implementation of the National Gender Policy. The Policy will not succeed unless adequate resources are allocated to programmes and activities related to it” (National Gender Policy, paragraph 3.3.6).
  - Pilot sectors chosen: health, education, agriculture, and infrastructure—selected because they account for a substantial share of the budget and to demonstrate relevance beyond the social sector.
  - Focus on both recurrent and capital spending and on addressing needs of the poor given the Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy.
- Accountability instruments and requirements:
  - Gender Budget Statement as the key instrument for accountability, enabling government agencies to report to parliament.
  - Ministries and agencies required to submit Gender Budget Statements to the Ministry of Finance; statements could lead to additions or changes in activities to “make them more gender-sensitive.”
  - Agencies required to include analysis of gender-oriented goals in Strategic Issues Papers for program discussions.
  - Budget agencies asked to report on differences in civil service employment with respect to sex and level in the civil service.
  - The budget call circular asked sectors to follow the multi-step approach used in gender budgeting elsewhere: analysis of problems and policy implications; assessment of incorporation into the budget; monitoring execution and achievement of outputs; evaluation of outcomes.

### Rwanda — Monitoring, indicators, and reporting (Table 3 highlights)
- Key Gender Indicators Collected by the Gender Monitoring Office (Indicator — Percent Male — Percent Female):
  - Government Sector:
    - Percentage of men and women on boards of directors in public institutions: 73.2 — 26.8
    - Percentage of men and women in the high commissariat of the police: 81.0 — 19.0
    - Percentage of men and women ministers: 72.7 — 27.2
    - Percentage of men and women mayors of districts: 90.0 — 10.0
    - Percentage of men and women senators: 65.4 — 34.6
    - Percentage of men and women judges at the Supreme Court: 57.0 — 43.0
    - Percentage of men and women members on boards of directors of civil society organizations: 86.7 — 13.3
  - Agriculture Sector:
    - Staff in agriculture institutions: 66.0 — 34.0
    - Agricultural credit beneficiaries: 64.0 — 36.0
  - Infrastructure Sector:
    - Persons employed within ICT companies: 71.1 — 28.9
    - Number of persons employed in the transport sector: 71.6 — 28.4
    - Number of persons accessing jobs in public infrastructure: 74.6 — 25.4
    - Persons studying sciences and technology: 67.0 — 33.0
  - Private Sector:
    - Percentage of employees: 45.6 — 54.4
    - Number and percentage of private companies by gender of owners:
      - a. Agriculture: 85.7 — 14.3
      - b. Mining: 93.2 — 6.8
      - c. Tourism: 71.4 — 28.6
      - d. Manufacturing: 64.0 — 35.5
- Reporting guidance for agencies (from the 2010/2011 budget addendum):
  - Select output by sub-program, and describe the problem, focusing on gender-oriented aspects if present.
  - Identify which outputs need to be achieved to address gender- or women-related needs, taken from the medium-term expenditure framework structure.
  - Identify which activities the ministry and agencies would need to carry out to achieve the identified output.
  - Specify indicators to measure each output, and where available, in terms of sex-disaggregated data.
  - Indicate the allocated budget for the sub-program and where applicable the budget for the gender-oriented activities.
- Strength noted:
  - Requirement of consistency between activities and program budgeting is a strength of the initiative.
- Sources for Rwanda material:
  - Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, Gender Monitoring Office, and related official documents cited in the source text.

*Source: IMF staff text extracted from the provided chapter/section.*

### Box 2. Example of Gender Budgeting Statement on Land Planning and Management

### Box 2. Example of Gender Budgeting Statement on Land Planning and Management

### Programme and Policy Example
- PROGRAMME: PLANNING, ADMINISTRATION AND MANAGEMENT OF LAND  
- SUB-PROGRAMME: PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT OF LAND  
- Gender issue identified: many women unaware of legal right to administer and manage land; denied management rights and revenues from sale of husbands' property.
- Policy measure: property will be registered in the name of both spouses—husband and wife.
- Output/activity: Register all landholdings.
- Indicator: All landholdings in the District are registered in the name of husbands and their wives.
- Budget (RFW): 10,549,095

### Institutionalization and Compliance
- From fiscal year 2011/2012, Gender Budget Statements made mandatory for all ministries at central level.
- For fiscal year 2013/14: Gender Monitoring Office determined that all districts and almost all ministries complied with the Gender Budget Statement requirement.
- 2013: Organic Budget Law institutionalized gender budgeting (Article 4, Article 32, Article 68 cited); Gender Monitoring Office 2013/2014 report found scope for significant improvements:
  - Most ministries and districts respected criteria on sub-program selection.
  - Relatively few provided appropriate analysis backed by sex-disaggregated data.
  - Relatively few properly linked analysis to activities, outputs, and indicators.

### Implementation at Local Government Level and Gaps
- Rwanda required local governments to divide services into those with specific gender-oriented goals and those without.
- Gender Monitoring Office findings:
  - Scope for improving identification of indicators, tracking, and monitoring outcomes.
  - Most districts have no interventions to address violence against women, despite increased prevalence over time.
- Gender Monitoring Office established as accountability mechanism for gender budgeting implementation.

### Evidence of Progress and Sectoral Impacts
- Study findings cited:
  - Mukunda (2011): Rwanda making progress integrating gender budgeting into budget process; scope for improvement at sectoral level. Ministry of Youth and Ministry of Health commended for quality of Gender Budget Statements.
  - Mirwoba (2013): randomized sample review of four pilot ministries, fiscal year 2010/2011:
    - Ministry of Agriculture spent almost one-third of its budget on gender-targeted outputs in that year (largest share of the four sectors).
    - Remaining ministries spent less than 15 percent each on gender-targeted outputs.
  - Education programs noted: supply of books and sanitation, training teachers and parents to promote girls in science and technology.
  - Health programs noted: increasing trained health personnel related to maternity services; program directed to female-headed households accessing subsidized health care; mitigation of malnutrition and malaria among expectant women and children.

### Measured Outcomes and Comparative Trends
- Figures and trend summaries (1990–2012 / to 2013):
  - Educational enrollment (female to male ratio): Rwanda increased female to male ratios in primary, secondary, and tertiary education; tertiary nearly closed gap with comparator group.
  - Maternal mortality ratio (modeled estimate, per 100,000 live births): Rwanda had almost double the maternal mortality ratio of comparator group in 1990, but by 2013 had made more progress than comparators.
  - Labor force participation (ages 15–64): little change in rates in Rwanda; female to male ratio was above one in 2013.
  - Gender indices: Rwanda performs better than regional comparators on Gender Development Index and Gender Inequality Index; improved more than comparators.

### Attribution and Timing
- Figures 7 and 8 compare pre- and post-introduction of the second gender budgeting initiative (dated to start with the second initiative led by Ministry of Finance in 2008):
  - Females closed the gap with males in primary and secondary enrollment, with some evidence of faster closure in secondary enrollment after introduction.
  - Maternal mortality ratio decreased both before and after introduction of gender budgeting.

### Lessons from Rwanda
- Embedding gender budgeting into national and subnational budgetary processes is feasible and can address identified gender gaps.
- Successful elements in Rwanda:
  - Leadership and constructive approach from government and Ministry of Finance.
  - Selection of pilots across social, economic, and infrastructure sectors for comprehensive coverage.
  - Matching gender budgeting format to program-budgeting approach.
  - Discretion for ministries to identify critical gender issues and appropriate responses.
  - Establishment of the Gender Monitoring Office as an accountability mechanism.
- Ongoing needs:
  - Improve sex-disaggregated data and rigorous linkage of analysis to activities, outputs, and indicators.
  - Enhance monitoring, tracking of outcomes, and interventions for violence against women.
  - Strengthen analytical basis for setting and meeting gender-oriented goals, including use of time use data to capture unpaid care work impacts.
  - Strengthen domestic resource mobilization to fund public services that advance gender equality and support UN Sustainable Development Goals.

*Source: Box 2, "_wp16152 - Example of Gender Budgeting Statement on Land Planning and Management_"*

### References

### _wp16152 - References

### Major referenced works and institutional reports
- African Union, 2003, Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa (the Maputo Protocol).
- Andrews, Matthew, 2010, “How Far Have Public Financial Management Reforms Come in Africa?” HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series, RWP10-018.
- Bandiera, Oriana and Ashwini Natraj, 2013, “Does Gender Inequality Hinder Development and Economic Growth? Evidence and Policy Implications,” The World Bank Research Observer, Vol. 28, pp. 2-21.
- Berg, Andrew, Norbert Funke, Alejandro Hajdenberg, Victor Lledo, Rolando Ossowski, Martin Schindler, Antonio Spilimbergo, Shamsuddin Tareq, and Irene Yackovlev, 2009, “Fiscal Policy in Sub-Saharan Africa in Response to the Impact of the Global Crisis,” International Monetary Fund Staff Position Note 09/10.
- Elborgh-Woytek, Katrin, Monique Newiak, Kalpana Kochhar, Stefania Fabrizio, Kangni Kpodar, Philippe Wingender, Benedict J. Clements, and Gerd Schwartz, 2013, “Women, Work, and the Economy: Macroeconomic Gains from Gender Equity,” Staff Discussion Notes 13/10.
- Gonzales, Christian, Sonali Jain-Chandra, Kalpana Kochhar, Monique Newiak, and Tlek Zeinullayev, 2015, “Catalyst for Change: Empowering Women and Tackling Income Inequality,” IMF Staff Discussion Note, SDN 15/20.
- McKinsey Global Institute, 2015, The Power of Parity: How Advancing Women’s Equality Can Add $12 Trillion to Global Growth, September.
- United Nations, 1995, “Platform for Action,” Fourth World Congress on Women.
- United Nations, 2015, Transforming our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, A/RES/70/1.
- Multiple IMF country reports and working papers cited (examples include IMF Country Report No. 14/338, No. 14/343, No. 14/120, No. 15/175; IMF Policy Paper: Fiscal Policy and Long-Term Growth; IMF Working Papers 16/151, 16/149, 16/21).

### Thematic emphasis across the references
- Gender-responsive budgeting and gender budgeting implementation guides, practitioner manuals, and country studies (examples: Budlender et al., Budlender & Hewitt, Elson, Sharp).
- Analyses of gender gaps and macroeconomic impacts (examples: Duflo 2012; Elborgh-Woytek et al. 2013; Cuberes & Teignier 2014).
- Country-specific gender budgeting and gender equality assessments (examples: Tanzania Strategic Country Gender Assessment; Rwanda Gender Responsive Budgeting Programme; Uganda National Household Survey 2012/2013).
- Donor, UN, and multilateral program evaluations and progress reports related to Gender-Responsive Budgeting (examples: DFID Project Completion Review; UNIFEM evaluation units; UN Joint Programme on Gender Equality—Uganda).
- Taxation and gender equity studies (examples: Budlender, Casale, and Valodia 2010; Stotsky 1997; Ssewanyana et al. 2010).

### Appendix A — Gender Budgeting in Sub-Saharan Africa Data Template (four-country snapshot)
- Countries covered: Rwanda, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda

- Does the government have a gender budgeting initiative
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- If yes, start year
  - Rwanda: 2002
  - South Africa: 1998-1999
  - Tanzania: 1999
  - Uganda: 2004/2005

- If any, end year
  - Rwanda: ended; year unknown
  - South Africa: (blank)
  - Tanzania: (blank)
  - Uganda: (blank)

- Supported by international organizations or bilateral aid agencies
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Tied to MDGs or national development plan or gender equality strategy
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Focus on spending
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Spending focus on key human development (education and health)
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Spending focus on physical infrastructure (transport, water, electricity, and energy)
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Spending focus on justice and security (violence against women, judicial assistance)
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: Yes

- Spending focus on jobs, entrepreneurship, wages etc
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Structural reforms in spending (subsidies, transfers, incentive or distributional objectives)
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Focus on revenue
  - Rwanda: No
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Personal income tax focus
  - Rwanda: No
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: No

- Other tax focus, including general or selective sales and trade
  - Rwanda: No
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Broad statement of goals of Minister of Finance
  - Rwanda: No
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: No

- Gender budgeting statement in budget documentation
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Gender budgeting circular or related to instruct the bureaucracy
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Gender budgeting in planning and programming
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Gender budgeting outcome report or audit
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: Yes

- Explicit reporting on gender equality spending
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: Yes

- Gender budgeting has constitutional standing
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: No

- Gender budgeting is incorporated in organic budget or other finance laws
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: No
  - Tanzania: No
  - Uganda: Yes

- Ministry of Finance lead entity
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Other ministries play consequential role and which
  - Rwanda: Yes; Ministry of Gender and Family Promotion; Ministry of Finance; Gender Monotoring Office
  - South Africa: Yes; The National Department of Finance (National Treasury); The Ministry of Women, Children, and People with Disabilities
  - Tanzania: Yes; Ministry of Community Development, Gender and Children; The Ministry of Finance
  - Uganda: Yes; Ministry of Finance, Planning, and Economic Development; The Ministry of Gender, Labour and Social Development; The Ministry of Local Government; The ministry of Education

- Subnational government participation
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

- Significant encouragement or participation of civil society
  - Rwanda: Yes
  - South Africa: Yes
  - Tanzania: Yes
  - Uganda: Yes

*Source: _wp16152 - References*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2016/_wp16152.pdf_
