The Political Economy of Fossil Fuel Subsidy Removal: Evidence from Bolivia and Mexico
IMF Working Papers, November 1, 2024
Source details
- Canonical URL
- The Political Economy of Fossil Fuel Subsidy Removal: Evidence from Bolivia and Mexico
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Mariza Montes de Oca Leon, Achim Hagen, Franziska Holz
- Published: November 1, 2024
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9798400290480.001
Summary
- Research question: Impact of fossil fuel subsidy removal on presidential popularity.
- Approach: Difference-in-difference methods and a stylized probabilistic voting theoretical model.
- Empirical scope: Macro level data from two subsidy removal events in Mexico and Bolivia in the early 2010s; micro level validation using data for the Mexican subsidy removal event.
- Main headline result: Evidence of a negative impact on presidential approval following subsidy removal.
Theoretical model and predictions
- Model type: Probabilistic voting model (stylized).
- Key predictions:
- Decline in popularity is driven by high income groups if subsidies are regressive.
- Lack of trust in the government lowers popularity of the removal in all income groups.
Empirical strategy and evidence
- Macro analysis:
- Method: Difference-in-difference approaches applied to two country events (Mexico and Bolivia) in the early 2010s.
- Main macro finding: Negative impact on presidential approval associated with subsidy removal.
- Micro analysis (Mexico):
- Used micro level data for the Mexican subsidy removal event to test model predictions.
- Confirmation: Empirical micro evidence supports the model predictions regarding distributional effects (high income groups driving decline when subsidies are regressive) and the role of trust.
Policy-relevant findings and implications
- Distributional politics:
- If fossil fuel subsidies are regressive, subsidy removal can reduce political support primarily among high income groups.
- Trust and communication:
- Low trust in government amplifies unpopular reactions to subsidy removal across all income groups.
- Political economy considerations for reform:
- Policymakers should account for the income distribution of subsidy benefits and public trust when designing and announcing subsidy removal.
- Targeted measures to protect vulnerable groups and measures to build or signal trust may mitigate negative political consequences.
Content in this bundle
- Working Paper