## United Kingdom—2014 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement of the Mission

_IMF News, June 5, 2014_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [United Kingdom—2014 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement of the Mission](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/52/mcs060514)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/52/mcs060514/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/52/mcs060514/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/52/mcs060514/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: June 5, 2014

---

### Preliminary assessment of the macroeconomic outlook
- Date of statement: June 5, 2014; additional date noted: June 6, 2014.
- Growth and rebalancing
  - The economy has rebounded strongly and growth is becoming more balanced.
  - Growth accelerated since the second half of 2013; leading indicators suggest the recovery has momentum.
  - Early recovery driven by household expenditures; business investment has picked up more recently.
  - Net exports remain subdued.
- Inflation and productivity
  - Inflation has fallen rapidly and is just below the Bank of England’s 2 percent target.
  - Decline in inflation attributed to fading impact of administered price increases, lower import prices, and weak growth in wages and margins.
  - Productivity growth remains well below historic norms and is a key determinant of the durability of the recovery.
- Projections
  - Good macroeconomic performance is expected to persist.
  - Real GDP growth is projected to remain strong this year, then gradually return to trend rates, driven by rebalancing toward business investment and a gradual recovery in productivity.
  - Inflation is expected to revert to target.

### Risks to the outlook
- Domestic risks
  - Productivity: If productivity remains flat, growth will eventually stall; accelerating productivity would support investment, output, and real wage increases without triggering inflation.
  - Housing market: House price inflation is particularly high in London and becoming more widespread.
    - Few typical signs of a credit-led bubble so far.
    - Steady increase in the size of new mortgages compared with borrower incomes suggests households are gradually becoming more vulnerable to income and interest rate shocks.
- External risks
  - Potential disruptions from withdrawal of unconventional monetary policies in the US, shocks to growth in emerging markets and the euro area, and increased geopolitical tensions.
  - UK’s direct exposure via trade and financial channels is in some cases low, but a realization of these risks together with a repricing from current unusually low risk levels could depress asset prices and damage confidence.

### Monetary policy recommendations
- Near-term stance
  - Monetary policy should stay accommodative—for now.
  - With inflation below target, contained cost pressures, and excess supply, monetary policy should remain on hold.
  - Policy might have to be tightened quickly if costs run ahead of productivity growth, slack is absorbed, or financial stability concerns cannot be addressed otherwise.
- Normalization sequencing
  - Bank rate should be raised before reducing QE balances.
  - Rationale: raising the policy rate first is preferable to selling off assets; if normalization needed to be reversed, decreasing the policy rate would likely be less disruptive than repurchasing gilts.
- Communication
  - The prospect of normalizing monetary conditions places a premium on communication.
  - The Bank of England has taken steps toward greater transparency, including the introduction of “forward guidance”.
  - The Bank faces the challenge of reducing the risk of potential market surprises without imparting a false sense of certainty about interest rates.
  - Additional challenge: explain coordination between monetary and macroprudential policies given the Financial Policy Committee’s (FPC) role.

### Macroprudential and housing-market policy
- Role of macroprudential policy
  - Macroprudential policies should be the first line of defense against financial risks from the housing market; objective is to address systemic financial risks, not house price growth.
  - Some measures already taken:
    - Funding for Lending Scheme refocused towards businesses with emphasis on SME loans; household lending no longer eligible for additional borrowing allowances.
    - Underwriting standards for owner-occupier mortgages tightened for better borrower protection.
- Further recommended measures
  - Measures must be targeted and timely.
    - Limits on the proportion of high Loan-To-Income (LTI) mortgages any lender can issue would help contain the most pressing risks; if insufficient, outright caps on LTIs or Loan-To-Value ratios may need consideration.
    - Raising lenders' sectoral capital requirements would build additional buffers against increased exposures to the housing sector.
  - Implementation guidance:
    - Given uncertainty about lags and effectiveness, introduce measures early and gradually to allow the FPC to “calibrate” them to the risks.
- Help to Buy (HtB) program
  - HtB is enabling creditworthy lower-income households to purchase homes, especially outside London and the Southeast, and has helped unlock mortgage credit for lower-income borrowers from other sources.
  - If these flows increase significantly, the FPC and the Treasury may wish to consider whether HtB should be modified or remains necessary for the full three years of the policy.
  - As the volume of high-LTV transactions rises, the FPC will need to evaluate if the program contributes to financial risks.
- Supply-side remedies
  - Imbalances in the housing market should be addressed through supply-side remedies: house prices are rising because demand outstrips supply.
  - UK has a secular problem with inadequate housing supply, associated with planning restrictions and compounded by depressed housing starts since the financial crisis.
  - Macroprudential and monetary policies are temporary palliatives to an underlying supply problem.
  - New initiatives to spur house building are welcome, but political consensus for further reform is needed.
    - Remaining inefficiencies include constraints on brownfield and greenfield developments; tax policies that discourage economically-efficient use of property; and underdeveloped rental markets with relatively short lease terms.

### Fiscal policy assessment and recommendations
- Recent fiscal stance and flexibility
  - While adhering to the medium-term framework, the government has shown welcome flexibility in its fiscal program.
  - Despite allowing automatic stabilizers to operate fully in response to slower-than-expected growth, the deficit has been nearly halved since 2009.
  - The government has reoriented expenditures from current to capital to support longer-term growth.
- Near-term judgment
  - The planned fiscal adjustment this year is appropriate.
  - The ½ percentage point of GDP reduction in the cyclically-adjusted primary balance in FY2014/15 addresses the need to strengthen public finances without unduly dragging on growth.
- Medium-term guidance
  - Fiscal policy should aim to put debt on a firmly declining path while supporting long-term growth and safeguarding social needs.
  - Consolidation should balance expenditure and revenue measures, considering equity and efficiency.
    - Spending-side: prioritize delivery of quality health and education services, and infrastructure; consider wider use of means testing for social benefits; entitlement reforms could yield budgetary savings and improve labor supply incentives.
    - Revenue-side: consider reducing tax expenditures (such as VAT zero-ratings) and greater reliance on Pigouvian taxes (including those on carbon and congestion).
  - Continue and publicize analysis of distributional impacts of consolidation to enable informed public discussion.

### Financial-sector resilience, regulation, and resolution
- Capital and liquidity
  - The Bank of England’s 2013 capital-building exercise has helped boost banks’ health and ability to lend.
  - Major UK banks’ common equity tier 1 ratios on a fully-loaded Basel-III basis now exceed 9 percent.
  - Liquidity indicators have improved with a further reduction in wholesale funding; market valuations have risen, and bank borrowing costs have declined.
- Profitability and emerging risks
  - Outlook for profitability is mixed.
  - Profitability for some major banks is weighed down by conduct-related and restructuring costs and headwinds to investment banking returns.
  - New domestic and external risks have surfaced.
- Stress testing
  - The 2014 stress tests will offer a timely assessment of major banks’ vulnerabilities.
  - The European Banking Authority’s adverse scenario and the UK-specific scenario complement each other to enable robust assessment of resilience.
  - Success depends on maintaining improved coordination between macro- and micro-prudential authorities; clear communication about capital definitions, hurdle rates and any required capital actions by banks (including capital planning frameworks); and sufficiently-disaggregated disclosure of results.
  - Authorities plan to extend the concurrent stress testing framework over the medium term to systemic entities beyond the major UK banks.
- Shadow banking and monitoring
  - Strengthening monitoring of risks in the shadow banking system is critical given the size of local and global shadow banking activity routed through the UK and the associated risk of outward financial spillovers.
  - These efforts are particularly relevant in the context of global underpricing of risk and a build-up of vulnerabilities outside the banking system.
- Regulatory architecture and oversight
  - The new structure of the FPC, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and the Financial Conduct Authority has functioned relatively smoothly over the last year.
  - Maintaining strong coordination across bodies and ensuring coherent communication will be vital to avoid regulatory uncertainty.
  - Given the Bank of England’s significantly expanded mandate, maintaining strong and effective oversight arrangements is important.
- Sterling Monetary Framework and backstops
  - Reforms to the Bank of England’s Sterling Monetary Framework will strengthen buffers against shocks; stronger liquidity backstops should allow solvent UK banks to ride out temporary funding stresses.
  - Easier access to backstops could increase banks’ appetite for risk-taking unless supervision is commensurately strengthened; this consideration should guide decisions on offering backstops to systemic nonbanks.
- Resolution and Too-Important-To-Fail
  - Measures to address Too-Important-To-Fail institutions are advancing but not complete.
  - Progress includes ring-fencing of banks’ retail operations, new bail-in and other resolution powers for the Bank of England, and development of resolution strategies and plans for systemically important banks.
  - Remaining tasks:
    - Clear strategy for systemic entities outside the ring fence.
    - Maintain momentum on cross-border cooperation for resolution of global banks, including international agreement on gone-concern loss-absorbing capacity.
    - Ensure an appropriately-stringent leverage ratio to add robustness to the regulatory capital framework.
  - Emphasized requirement: implement the agenda to ensure international consistency of national reforms and guard against regulatory arbitrage.

*International Monetary Fund: United Kingdom—2014 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement of the Mission*

---


## References

- [United Kingdom and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/GBR/index.htm)
- [Mission Concluding Statements](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)
- [PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)
- [Article IV](https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/aa/aa04.htm)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/52/mcs060514_
