## Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Romania

_IMF News, October 6, 1998_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Romania](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/pn9879)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/pn9879/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/pn9879/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/pn9879/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: October 6, 1998

---

### Background
- Executive Board concluded the Article IV consultation with Romania on September 15, 1998.
- Inflation developments:
  - Inflation declined from more than 5 percent to less than 1 percent per month in August 1998.
  - Monetary policy consistent with a depreciation of the leu of only 1–2 percent per month.
  - Net foreign assets of the National Bank of Romania have remained largely unchanged.
- Balance of payments and external sector:
  - Real appreciation of the leu and upward pressure on the fiscal deficit led to stagnant exports and rising imports.
  - External current account deficit increased from an already high level; preservation of overall balance of payments equilibrium required tight monetary conditions and relatively high interest rates.
- Output and growth:
  - GDP is set to contract by about 4 percent in 1998, having fallen by nearly 7 percent in 1997.
- Fiscal developments:
  - A transfer of government securities to two banks in late 1997 caused a projected rise in budgetary interest payments of 1.7 percent of GDP in 1998.
  - Tax changes effective early 1998 (reductions in wage and profit taxes; increases in value added and excise taxes) entail a net revenue loss of about 1.5 percent of GDP in 1998.
  - 1998 budget approved in May targeted a general government deficit of 3.6 percent of GDP, unchanged from 1997; assumed offsets from higher privatization proceeds and better revenue collections that failed to materialize.
  - Authorities rectified the 1998 budget, reducing appropriations by about 2 percent of GDP compared to the original budget and targeting a deficit of 4 percent of GDP in 1998.
  - The rectified budget assumes an improvement in revenues during the second half of 1998 by about 2 percent of GDP.
- Structural reform progress:
  - Liberalization of foreign exchange and treasury bill markets, closure of the NBR’s rediscount window, shift to market-based reserve money management, and price and trade liberalization in agriculture increased reliance on market mechanisms.
  - Little progress in restructuring state-owned enterprises and state banks; privatization, restructuring, and enforcement of financial discipline are well behind schedule.
  - Enterprise arrears have increased, particularly to utilities and the budget, contributing to a considerable decline in credit to the non-government sector.

### Executive Board Assessment
- General assessment:
  - Directors welcomed the National Bank of Romania’s focus on inflation control and the increased reliance on market forces.
  - Directors warned the underlying policy mix was unsustainable because lack of fiscal support was overburdening monetary policy.
  - Structural reforms generally had not advanced since the Executive Board's review of the Stand-by Arrangement, especially in enterprise and banking sectors.
- Macroeconomic policy recommendations:
  - Exchange rate policy helped bring down inflation but required high real interest rates in the face of an increased current account deficit.
  - To prevent a third year of economic recession in 1999, it was urgent to unburden monetary policy through fiscal tightening.
  - Current turmoil in international capital markets significantly limited the authorities' room for maneuver.
  - Structural reforms are crucial to allow productivity increases and improve competitiveness.
- Fiscal policy recommendations:
  - Directors noted the proposed rectified budget for 1998 would likely relax rather than tighten fiscal policy; they urged basing the rectified budget on realistic revenue assumptions.
  - Rectified budget should be calibrated to ensure a sustained reduction in the fiscal deficit to reduce the current account deficit to a sustainable level.
  - Fiscal policies for 1999 should be formulated in a medium-term framework taking account of stabilization and reform objectives.
  - A significant increase in revenues is essential; there is scope for improving tax collections, but Directors doubted that strengthening revenue could be secured without an increase in tax rates.
  - Directors called on authorities to reconsider the decision to introduce a temporary import surcharge.
  - Reliance on ad hoc expenditure cuts is not viable; burden had fallen mainly on capital expenditure and reform-related outlays.
  - Several costly programs and policies in the pipeline were incompatible with fiscal constraints; some Directors urged curtailing planned military expenditures.
- Structural reform priorities:
  - Welcome for liberalization of foreign exchange market and switch to market-based instruments for reserve money management and placement of treasury bills.
  - Urged priority for privatization of large enterprises, restructuring or closure of unviable entities, and enforcement of financial discipline, including addressing enterprise arrears.
  - Correction of enterprise problems considered a necessary prerequisite for tackling banking sector difficulties.
  - Particular concern about ailing state banks; importance of developing and implementing a banking sector restructuring plan.
- Conditionality of Fund support:
  - Fund stands ready to continue support, but such support would require up-front structural reforms and adequate fiscal consolidation.
  - Authorities should develop concrete plans and mobilize political resolve to implement reforms despite anticipated resistance.
  - Reform process expected to be protracted because of social costs, but deep-seated structural problems require bold action.
  - Directors emphasized the considerable potential for foreign direct investment to facilitate reform once a critical mass of reforms is in place.

### Romania: Selected Economic Indicators, 1993–97
- Real economy (Percentage growth):
  - Real GDP: 1993: 1.5; 1994: 3.9; 1995: 7.1; 1996: -6.6; 1997: (not listed in table body)
  - Consumer prices (Dec./Dec.): 1993: 295.5; 1994: 61.7; 1995: 27.8; 1996: 56.9; 1997: 151.6
  - Consumer prices (period average): 1993: 256.1; 1994: 136.7; 1995: 32.3; 1996: 38.8; 1997: 154.8
  - Unemployment rate (e.o.p. in percent): 1993: 10.4; 1994: 10.9; 1995: 8.9; 1996: 6.3; 1997: 8.8
- Public finance; general government budget (Percent of GDP):
  - Balance: 1993: -0.4; 1994: -1.9; 1995: -2.6; 1996: -4.0; 1997: -3.6
  - Revenues: 1993: 33.9; 1994: 32.1; 1995: 31.9; 1996: 30.1; 1997: 30.7
  - Expenditures: 1993: 34.2; 1994: 34.5; 1995: 34.1; 1996: 34.3; 1997: (value not listed)
- Money and credit (Percentage growth, unless otherwise indicated):
  - Broad money1: 1993: 141.0; 1994: 138.1; 1995: 71.6; 1996: 66.0; 1997: 75.9
  - NBR interest rates (e.o.p; in percent)2: 1993: 416.0; 1994: 78.0; 1995: 67.0; 1996: 66.9; 1997: 138.8
- Balance of payments (Billions of US$, unless otherwise indicated):
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 1993: -4.7; 1994: -1.7; 1995: -4.9; 1996: -7.4; 1997: -6.7
  - Exports: 1993: 4.9; 1994: 6.1; 1995: 7.9; 1996: 8.1; 1997: 8.4
  - Imports: 1993: 6.0; 1994: 6.6; 1995: 9.5; 1996: 10.6; 1997: (value not listed)
  - Gross external debt: 1993: 4.3; 1994: 5.5; 1995: 6.9; 1996: 10.3; 1997: (value not listed)
  - Gross reserves (in months of imports): 1993: 2.0; 1994: 3.8; 1995: 2.4; 1996: 4.4; 1997: (value not listed)
    - Of which NBR: 1993: 0.1; 1994: 1.1; 1995: 0.4; 1996: 0.6; 1997: 2.5
  - External debt/GDP (in percent): 1993: 16.1; 1994: 18.4; 1995: 19.2; 1996: 25.2; 1997: 29.8
  - Debt service ratio (in percent): 1993: 6.2; 1994: 9.2; 1995: 13.7; 1996: 20.2; 1997: (value not listed)
- Exchange rate:
  - Lei per US$ (e.o.p): 1993: 1,141; 1994: 1,774; 1995: 2,558; 1996: 3,750; 1997: 7,985
  - REER (e.o.p; CPI-based191=100): 1993: 102; 1994: 106; 1995: 93; 1996: 101; 1997: 119
  - REER (e.o.p; ULC-based191=100): 1993: 84; 1994: 81; 1995: 72; 1996: 66; 1997: (value not listed)
- Notes:
  - For 1997, foreign currency components are valued at end-1996 exchange rates.
  - NBR interest rate series is a weighted NBR average; from 1997 it is the interbank rate.

*IMF Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Romania, October 6, 1998.*

---


## References

- [Romania and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/ROU/index.htm)
- [Public Information Notices](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)
- [Article IV](https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/aa/aa04.htm)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/pn9879_
