{
  "title": "Fiscal policy in advanced economies: fiscal adjustment, efficiency and growth",
  "publication": "IMF News, March 12, 2016",
  "sourceUrl": "https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212",
  "canonical": "https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212",
  "overlayPath": "/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/index.md",
  "summary": "Two main channels when fiscal tightening affects growth:",
  "authors": [
    "Carlo Cottarelli Director"
  ],
  "publishDate": "2016-03-12",
  "sections": [
    {
      "heading": "Short-term interactions between fiscal policy and growth",
      "content": "- Two main channels when fiscal tightening affects growth:\n  - Risk of fiscal crisis from weak fiscal stance; weak fiscal accounts are a necessary condition for trouble (except in rare pure contagion cases).\n  - Aggregate demand channel: fiscal tightening reduces aggregate demand; evidence indicates fiscal multipliers during fiscal contractions are likely to be positive on average and larger when output is below potential.\n- Trade-off: not enough tightening can be bad (via crisis risk); too much tightening can be bad (via demand collapse). Fiscal policy should be \"just right\" and paced with cyclical conditions.\n- Empirical magnitudes and illustrative results:\n  - On average for advanced countries a one percentage point of GDP reduction in discretionary spending leads to 0.7 percentage point reduction in the deficit (assuming a fiscal multiplier of 1 with respect to the initial discretionary tightening).\n  - Charts and regressions show fiscal multipliers are larger when output is below potential."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Feedbacks from growth to fiscal accounts (three channels)",
      "content": "- Automatic stabilizers and revenues:\n  - A growth deceleration reduces tax revenues and increases spending for unemployment benefits, weakening the immediate deficit improvement from discretionary tightening.\n- Effect on the public debt to GDP ratio:\n  - When the fiscal multiplier is high and the initial stock of debt is high, a one-year fiscal tightening can increase the debt ratio because the numerator (debt) falls less in percentage terms while the denominator (GDP) falls more.\n- Market reactions and interest rates:\n  - Short-term growth slowdowns increase spreads and interest rates; markets focus on short-term growth, possibly because they infer weaker political/economic commitment.\n  - Econometric results (5-year CDS spreads, first 9 months of 2011) indicate higher primary balances lower spreads; higher debt increases spreads; lower growth increases spreads nonlinearly, with spreads rising faster as growth declines."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Implications of tightening for spreads and sustainability",
      "content": "- Interaction effects:\n  - For sufficiently large fiscal multipliers and sufficiently strong fiscal tightening, fiscal consolidation can be accompanied by higher spreads.\n  - Higher interest rates undermine sustainability by increasing deficits and by weakening political support for continued adjustment.\n- Policy takeaway for sequencing and support:\n  - Countries under pressure that must frontload adjustment need adequate financing (firewalls) to keep interest rates down while adjustment takes effect."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Policy recommendations for short-run adjustment",
      "content": "- For countries with fiscal space:\n  - Decide pace of adjustment in light of cyclical conditions; avoid excessive frontloading during uncertain recoveries; aim for steady progress.\n  - Define clear medium-term adjustment plans to anchor public finances (noted that the United States and Japan had not done so).\n- For countries under pressure:\n  - Frontloaded measures may be inevitable, but should be complemented by financing mechanisms to prevent adverse market reactions."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Long-term interactions: macro channels (debt and potential growth)",
      "content": "- Empirical relationship between high public debt and lower potential growth:\n  - Multiple studies find a threshold effect around 80-90 percent of GDP beyond which higher public debt lowers potential growth.\n  - IMF estimate: an increase by 10 percentage points of the debt to GDP ratio lowers potential growth by about 0.17 percent.\n  - Example implication: difference in potential growth between debt ratio 120 percent and 60 percent is about one percentage point.\n- Concern about rising prevalence of high-debt countries:\n  - Share of GDP produced by countries with high debt increased from 19 percent in 2007 to 81 percent in 2010."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Long-term interactions: micro channels (taxes, spending composition, and efficiency)",
      "content": "- Revenue-side recommendations to improve efficiency and growth implications:\n  - Where tax and contribution rates are high (e.g., continental Europe), lowering them can benefit growth; where rates are low (e.g., Japan, United States), spending-only adjustments would force cuts in productive spending.\n  - Shift from labor taxation to consumption taxation (VAT) can help competitiveness (\"fiscal devaluation\"), though long-term growth gains depend on wage rigidities.\n  - Eliminate tax expenditures (preferential treatments) to raise revenue and reduce distortions; multiple VAT rates are highlighted as inefficient and regressive in aggregate.\n  - Raise taxes correcting externalities (carbon taxation; a VAT-like tax on financial institutions rather than a financial transaction tax).\n  - Increase property (real estate) taxation as a less distortionary base.\n  - Strengthen fight against tax evasion to improve equity and reduce distortions.\n  - Revenue-raising potential: computed possibility to raise revenues by several percentage points of GDP—at least three in the average of advanced countries—through combined measures (cuts in tax expenditure, externality taxes, property taxation, reduction in tax evasion).\n- Spending-side recommendations for efficiency and growth:\n  - Avoid across-the-board cuts; use spending reviews to protect effective programs and cut ineffective ones.\n  - Areas for scrutiny include:\n    - Subsidies: averaging about 1 percent of GDP in the OECD and rising to 2 percent or more in Austria, Belgium, Denmark and Switzerland.\n    - Military spending: increased since 2000 by about 1 percentage point of GDP in the average of advanced countries.\n    - Public sector wages: grew faster than private sector wages in several advanced countries in the ten years before the crisis.\n    - Non-mean-tested social welfare programs: in the OECD, less than 10 percent of this spending is means tested.\n    - Pension spending: demographic pressures make cuts difficult in many countries, though reforms (example: Italy) can reduce pension spending over time; increasing retirement age is growth-conducive via higher labor force participation."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Debt dynamics, quantitative examples, and the importance of growth",
      "content": "- Debt-stabilizing primary surplus and sensitivity to growth:\n  - Solving the debt dynamics equation shows the debt-stabilizing primary surplus is a decreasing function of the growth rate and the effect is larger for higher initial debt stocks.\n  - Numerical examples:\n    - If debt ratio is 40 percent of GDP, a one point loss in potential growth requires an increase in the primary balance of 0.4 percentage of GDP.\n    - If debt ratio is 100 percent of GDP, a one point loss in potential growth requires the primary to improve by 1 percentage point.\n  - Incorporating empirical effect of growth on the primary balance:\n    - For debt ratio of 100 percent, a one percent increase in growth lowers the primary fiscal need by 1.7 percent of GDP (not just 1.0 percent).\n  - Illustrative cumulative outcome:\n    - A country starting with debt ratio 100 percent and tax to GDP ratio of 40 percent would lower its debt by almost 30 percentage points after 10 years if growth were increased by a single percentage point (and if additional revenues were saved).\n- Historical evidence:\n  - Post-World-War-II episodes: 35 episodes in advanced economies where debt/GDP fell continuously by at least 10 percentage points cumulative; only one case (Italy 1994–2004) occurred with real GDP growth below 2 percent.\n  - 60 instances of continuous improvement in cyclically adjusted primary balance over three or more years; only a handful occurred with growth below 2 percent."
    },
    {
      "heading": "Conclusions and overarching policy implications",
      "content": "- Stabilizing public debt at high post-crisis levels would penalize potential growth; there is a need to lower public debt over time.\n- Strong medium-term growth is critical for successful fiscal adjustment; product, service, and labor market reforms are part of the fiscal adjustment toolkit.\n- Structural fiscal reforms must consider economic efficiency: reduce tax expenditures, fight evasion, shift taxation from labor to consumption, increase property taxation; on spending, prioritize cuts in non-targeted social spending, subsidies, and military spending.\n- Equity considerations matter: growth that benefits only a few is not sustainable.\n- A virtuous circle is possible: pro-growth fiscal adjustments, structural reforms, and lower debt can boost growth, which in turn facilitates fiscal adjustment — potentially making it feasible to bring public debt back below 60 percent of GDP over the medium term.\n\nCarlo Cottarelli — Fiscal policy in advanced economies: fiscal adjustment, efficiency and growth; presentation given at the Milan Catholic University on March 13, 2012 (speech text dated March 12, 2012).\n\n---\n\n\n References\n\n- Italy and the IMF\n- Japan and the IMF\n- United States and the IMF\n- Speeches\n- PRESS CENTER\n- https://www.imf.org/en/home\n\nSource: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212"
    }
  ],
  "bullets": [
    "[Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/index.md)",
    "[Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/index.json)",
    "[Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/bundle-manifest.json)",
    "Authors: Carlo Cottarelli Director",
    "Published: March 12, 2016",
    "Two main channels when fiscal tightening affects growth:",
    "Trade-off: not enough tightening can be bad (via crisis risk); too much tightening can be bad (via demand collapse). Fiscal policy should be \"just right\" and paced with cyclical conditions.",
    "Empirical magnitudes and illustrative results:",
    "Automatic stabilizers and revenues:",
    "Effect on the public debt to GDP ratio:",
    "Market reactions and interest rates:",
    "Interaction effects:",
    "Policy takeaway for sequencing and support:",
    "For countries with fiscal space:",
    "For countries under pressure:",
    "Empirical relationship between high public debt and lower potential growth:",
    "Concern about rising prevalence of high-debt countries:",
    "Revenue-side recommendations to improve efficiency and growth implications:",
    "Spending-side recommendations for efficiency and growth:",
    "Debt-stabilizing primary surplus and sensitivity to growth:",
    "Historical evidence:",
    "Stabilizing public debt at high post-crisis levels would penalize potential growth; there is a need to lower public debt over time.",
    "Strong medium-term growth is critical for successful fiscal adjustment; product, service, and labor market reforms are part of the fiscal adjustment toolkit.",
    "Structural fiscal reforms must consider economic efficiency: reduce tax expenditures, fight evasion, shift taxation from labor to consumption, increase property taxation; on spending, prioritize cuts in non-targeted social spending, subsidies, and military spending.",
    "Equity considerations matter: growth that benefits only a few is not sustainable.",
    "A virtuous circle is possible: pro-growth fiscal adjustments, structural reforms, and lower debt can boost growth, which in turn facilitates fiscal adjustment — potentially making it feasible to bring public debt back below 60 percent of GDP over the medium term.",
    "[Italy and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/ITA/index.htm)",
    "[Japan and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/JPN/index.htm)",
    "[United States and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/USA/index.htm)",
    "[Speeches](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)",
    "[PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)",
    "[https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)"
  ],
  "alternates": {
    "markdown": "/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/index.md",
    "json": "/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/index.json",
    "bundleManifest": "/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp031212/bundle-manifest.json"
  },
  "generatedAtUtc": "2026-09-27T09:28:11.702Z"
}
