## The Benefits and Risks Associated with the Wider Integration of International Financial Markets -- Address by Shigemitsu Sugisaki

_IMF News, December 5, 1998_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [The Benefits and Risks Associated with the Wider Integration of International Financial Markets -- Address by Shigemitsu Sugisaki](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp120598)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp120598/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp120598/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp120598/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: December 5, 1998

---

### I. Introduction
- Occasion: Oman International Economic Conference, Muscat.
- Speaker: Shigemitsu Sugisaki, Deputy Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund.
- Date: December 5, 1998.
- Framing:
  - Reflection on events of the "last 12 months" as constituting one of the worst international financial crises in recent economic history.
  - Objective: draw lessons from crises in Asia and Russia and assess implications for the IMF’s policy advice and international financial architecture.

### II. Benefits and Risks of Wider Financial Integration
- Key benefits (economic theory and observed practice):
  - Free movement of capital permits more efficient global allocation of savings and directs resources toward their most efficient use.
  - Opportunities for portfolio diversification, risk sharing, and inter-temporal trade.
  - Free capital flows have helped growth and raised standards of living in countries successful in attracting and using capital.
  - Specific historical contribution: access to external savings facilitated the building of vibrant economies and modern industrial bases in parts of Asia and Latin America.
- Drivers of the 1990s surge in international financial transactions:
  - Technological change reducing costs for market participants.
  - Privatization of state assets.
  - Deregulation of financial markets in key industrial countries.
  - Growth of institutional investors.
  - Macroeconomic and structural reforms in developing countries.
- Structural change in flows:
  - Foreign direct investment and portfolio capital flows fast replaced commercial bank lending as the main source of international capital flows.
- Risks and amplification factors:
  - Increased difficulty for countries to control international capital flows due to financial innovations and international competition.
  - Increased risks to lenders, borrowers, and bystanders (contagion).
  - Necessity to adapt domestic policies to the realities of liberalized domestic and international capital markets.

### III. Assessment of Developments in Asia and Russia
- Asia: immediate cause and underlying factors
  - Immediate cause: a loss of private sector confidence triggering massive capital outflows.
  - Macroeconomic imbalances: rising and unsustainable external current account deficits; build-up of external debt—particularly short-term debt—linked to exchange rates fixed to the dollar.
  - Structural weaknesses: weak financial institutions, insufficient bank supervision, nontransparent government-bank-corporate relationships.
  - Corporate sector vulnerability: large dollar-denominated corporate debt leading to insolvency when exchange rates tumbled.
  - Market manifestations: volatility in prices and sudden market movements precipitating crisis.
- Russia (August 1998 developments)
  - Actions: de facto devaluation of the ruble; unilateral restructuring of ruble-denominated public debt; moratorium on foreign credit repayments.
  - Causes: elusive fiscal consolidation; insufficient progress on structural weaknesses; weak rule of law and governance.
  - Lesson: reforms must be home-grown and enjoy wide political support; short-term financing or arrears are no substitute for fiscal adjustment.
- Policy implications drawn from both cases:
  - Tackle serious financial imbalances and keep public debt within reasonable bounds.
  - Avoid excessive leverage, especially foreign currency debt.
  - Strengthen financial systems to safely intermediate large foreign capital inflows.
  - Increase transparency on borrower quality via systemic application of international standards in accounting, auditing, information disclosure, corporate governance, and protection of lenders and investors.
  - Reinforce market-based incentives for prudential risk management and clear burden-sharing when institutions become insolvent.
  - Improve access to information on flows of credit to emerging markets to detect excessive concentration of debt and promote prudent lender behavior.

### IV. Architecture of the International Monetary System
- Context: Proposals discussed by the IMF’s Interim Committee in October 1998.
- Private sector role:
  - Private sector must be part of both prevention and resolution of financial crises.
  - IMF and official financing cannot and should not substitute for private sector financing.
  - Crisis options: reach voluntary agreements with private creditors or, as a last resort, introduce capital controls.
  - IMF will further study market-based mechanisms to cope with sudden shifts in investor sentiment.
  - Agreement to broaden, under certain conditions and case-by-case, policy allowing IMF financial assistance to countries in external arrears to private creditors.
- Capital account liberalization:
  - Emphasis on an orderly and well-sequenced liberalization process.
  - Introducing or tightening capital controls is not always appropriate; temporary breathing space may be outweighed by long-term damage to investor confidence and resource allocation distortions.
  - IMF will review experiences with temporary impediments to capital movements and circumstances when they may be appropriate.
- Transparency and standards:
  - IMF contributing through greater openness about its policies and publishing more external evaluations.
  - Need to develop and disseminate internationally accepted standards in fiscal transparency, monetary and financial policies, corporate governance, accountancy, and insolvency regimes.
  - Requires close collaboration between the IMF and other international financial institutions.
- Overall message: not "business as usual" but a fundamental change in the international monetary system is called for.

### V. Implications for the Middle East and Northern Africa (MENA)
- Status of reforms in MENA:
  - Progress over the last decade in trade and exchange regime liberalization and, to a lesser extent, integration into the international financial system.
  - Advanced stages: GCC countries, Lebanon, Yemen (trade liberalization and capital account convertibility).
  - Other progress: Maghreb countries, Egypt, Jordan—elimination of import and exchange restrictions, lowering import tariffs, adoption of current account convertibility.
  - Liberalization of inward capital movements and gradual relaxation of outward capital flow controls in recent years.
- Financial integration and market development:
  - MENA financial systems generally less integrated into international financial markets, except Lebanon, GCC countries, and to a lesser extent Egypt and Morocco.
  - Efforts: strengthen financial intermediation, promote market-based mechanisms, modernize banking practices, adopt international supervision standards, build equity market infrastructure (Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia, Jordan, GCC).
  - Early payoffs: mobilizing domestic savings and enhancing attractiveness to international investors, but more time and effort needed for significant growth and employment effects.
- Policy choices in response to Asian crisis lessons:
  - Two paths:
    - Halt or reverse liberalization claiming risks outweigh benefits.
    - Continue reforms while managing a smooth transition to capital account liberalization with adequate safeguards.
  - Author’s assessment: halting liberalization is a recipe for low growth, high unemployment, and lost opportunities; staying on sidelines is not a viable solution for countries with daunting economic challenges.
- Strengths in the region to leverage:
  - Progress in reducing fiscal and current account deficits.
  - Relatively low inflation rates compared to past years.
  - General reduction in external debt.
  - In GCC: sizable official foreign assets, soundness and strength of financial intermediaries, low external indebtedness of official and corporate sectors.
- Recommended measures for MENA:
  - Strengthen domestic financial systems via enhanced prudential regulation and supervision in parallel with opening sectors to foreign participation and competition.
  - Deepen capital markets to improve liquidity, diversify financing sources, and avoid asset price inflation when opening stock markets to foreign investors.
  - Maintain sound macroeconomic management to enhance confidence and fundamentals.
  - Address unsustainable fiscal and current account deficits timely and credibly; reduce rising total public debt where present.
  - Monetary authorities to vigilantly monitor credit developments to prevent asset price inflation and deterioration of bank portfolios.
  - Establish strong track records of openness and provision of economic and financial information; improve data dissemination to build accountability, transparency, and good governance.
  - Sequencing of capital account liberalization: generally liberalize foreign direct investment first; liberalize portfolio investment gradually as domestic financial systems strengthen and macroeconomic fundamentals improve.
- GCC-specific note:
  - Recent terms-of-trade shock (decline in oil prices) affected non-oil activity growth and worsened fiscal and external current account balances in 1998, and probably in 1999.
  - Policy response: prompt and determined reforms to reduce financial imbalances, maintain private sector confidence, and further economic diversification.

### VI. Conclusion
- Root causes: domestic policy shortcomings and weaknesses in international monetary architecture drove the Asian crisis and recent turbulence.
- Task ahead: address these shortcomings and weaknesses so the international community can continue to reap benefits of free capital movements with minimal risks.

*Address by Shigemitsu Sugisaki, Deputy Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund, to the Oman International Economic Conference, Muscat, December 5, 1998.*

---


## References

- [PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp120598_
