## Spain: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2016 Article IV Mission

_IMF News, December 13, 2016_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Spain: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2016 Article IV Mission](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2016/12/13/ms121316-spain-staff-concluding-statement-of-article-iv-mission)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2016/12/13/ms121316-spain-staff-concluding-statement-of-article-iv-mission/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2016/12/13/ms121316-spain-staff-concluding-statement-of-article-iv-mission/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2016/12/13/ms121316-spain-staff-concluding-statement-of-article-iv-mission/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: December 13, 2016

---

### Economic outlook and risks
- Recovery described as "impressive" with strong job creation; private consumption, exports, and investment are the main drivers.
- Tailwinds supporting growth: European Central Bank’s accommodative monetary policy, fiscal relaxation.
- Real GDP and employment growth remain well above the euro area average despite prolonged domestic political uncertainty.
- Current account is projected to record its fourth consecutive annual surplus.
- Private sector balance sheets—including those in the banking system—have continued to strengthen; access to credit has improved; real estate prices have edged up.
- Remaining vulnerabilities and structural weaknesses:
  - Unemployment is "still very high," especially long-term and youth joblessness.
  - Widespread use of temporary contracts for new jobs.
  - Elevated public debt, lingering private sector debt overhang, and a large negative net international investment position.
- Growth trajectory and projections:
  - Spain expanded at a vigorous 3.2 percent rate in 2015 with "the same growth rate expected for 2016."
  - Real GDP growth is projected to moderate to 2.3 percent next year.
  - Over the medium term, prospects are expected to slow further due to feeble productivity growth and high structural unemployment.

### Fiscal policy: Resuming growth-friendly and inclusive consolidation
- Assessment:
  - Headline fiscal deficits have continued to narrow, but for the second consecutive year the deficit will likely be higher than originally planned, implying a structural loosening of the fiscal stance in 2015–16.
  - Building on large fiscal measures adopted over 2010-13, adjustment can be more measured but should be steady and underpinned by well-defined policy actions.
- Recommendation:
  - An annual fiscal adjustment of the structural primary balance of about 0.5 percent of GDP is recommended to balance preserving the recovery and ensuring long-term sustainability of public finances.
  - The fiscal measures adopted for 2017 are described as an important step toward reaching the deficit target and public debt reduction.
- Revenue-side options:
  - Gradually reduce value-added tax exemptions to bring collection more in line with other EU countries.
  - Scope to raise excise duties and environmental levies—especially given low energy prices.
  - Tackle inefficiencies and special treatments in the tax system.
  - Shift from direct to indirect taxation in combination with earlier reductions in corporate and personal income tax rates.
- Expenditure-side options:
  - Conduct thorough expenditure reviews—particularly in health and education—to gauge efficiency gains.
  - Properly shield vulnerable groups and enhance efficiency of programs that directly support employment and growth, such as active labor market policies (ALMP) and public research and development spending.
- Regional finances:
  - Regional financing framework remains a risk to fiscal targets.
  - Recommended reforms: improve regions’ incentives to comply with fiscal targets, more automatic and stricter enforcement, provide regions greater power to mobilize own revenues.
  - Consider introduction of performance-based transfers to strengthen incentives for reforms (e.g., Market Unity Law implementation and ALMP).

### Labor market: Tackling long-term unemployment and labor market rigidities
- Recent performance:
  - Employment growing at more than 3 percent annually.
  - Almost 1.1 million jobs created over the past two years, supported by wage moderation and labor market reforms.
  - Unemployment has come down about 8 percentage points from its peak but remains very high at around 19 percent.
  - Almost 60 percent of the unemployed have been jobless for more than a year; a large share are low-skilled and previously occupied in construction.
- Key problems:
  - Temporary contracts still make up the largest share of new jobs, exacerbating labor market duality and inhibiting human capital investment and productivity.
  - Active labor market programs (ALMP) have had limited impact for long-term unemployed and low-skilled youth.
- Policy priorities:
  - Promote job creation for the long-term unemployed and low-skilled youth as an immediate priority.
  - Urgent improvements to ALMPs, particularly through better coordination with regional governments.
  - Consolidate the range of hiring subsidies into better-targeted subsidy schemes.
  - Make permanent contracts more attractive for employers; provide greater legal and administrative certainty over dismissals; allow firms more control and flexibility over working conditions.

### Structural reforms: Boosting firm productivity and growth
- Core challenge: weak productivity tied to a corporate landscape dominated by small firms that are less productive, innovative, and export-oriented than European peers.
- Impact of prior reforms:
  - Earlier labor and product market reforms are estimated to boost productivity growth by about 0.5 percentage point annually over the next five years.
  - Despite this, productivity growth would need to be raised to sustain real GDP growth above 2 percent over the medium term.
- Recommended reforms:
  - Adjust public policies to foster good regulation and competition (expedite implementation of the Market Unity Law; advance liberalization of professional services).
  - Support innovation by enhancing private R&D investment and increasing efficiency of public R&D spending.
  - Revisit regulations that have created a "small business trap."
  - Improve access to non-bank (typically equity) financing for frontier innovation.
- Timing note: These reforms tend to have particularly high payoff when implemented during a cyclical recovery.

### Financial sector: Continuing to strengthen the capacity to support growth
- Current position:
  - Banking system stronger due to better asset quality, stronger capital and funding positions, and reduced debt overhangs.
  - Banks have progressed at different speeds; overall NPLs and foreclosed assets remain sizeable though much lower than in some EU countries.
  - Banks face challenges from low profitability and new regulatory initiatives.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Sustain a job-rich economic recovery to strengthen domestic demand and private sector balance sheets.
  - Ensure adequate provisioning and further improve efficiency—possibly through mergers.
  - Boost non-interest income and further increase high-quality capital to enhance resilience and support sufficient credit provision as demand picks up.

### Toward a comprehensive medium-term strategy
- Summary assessment:
  - Reforms undertaken during the crisis have increased resilience and enabled a strong recovery.
  - Remaining challenges are mostly structural and call for a comprehensive medium-term strategy.
- Priority areas with potentially high payoff and broad-based political support:
  - Enhance active labor market policies (ALMP) to lower long-term and youth unemployment.
  - Reform regional public finances to safeguard public finances.
  - Strengthen innovation and education policies to lift productivity.
- Additional measures:
  - Go further with labor and product market reforms to complement the medium-term strategy.

*Source: Spain: Staff Concluding Statement of the 2016 Article IV Mission (December 13, 2016).*

---


## References

- [Spain and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/ESP/index.htm)
- [Mission Concluding Statements](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)
- [PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2016/12/13/ms121316-spain-staff-concluding-statement-of-article-iv-mission_