## Transcript of Press Call on the Publication of the 2019 China Article IV Staff Report

_IMF News, August 13, 2019_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Transcript of Press Call on the Publication of the 2019 China Article IV Staff Report](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2019/08/13/tr08092019-transcript-of-the-press-conference-on-china-article-iv-consultations-report)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2019/08/13/tr08092019-transcript-of-the-press-conference-on-china-article-iv-consultations-report/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2019/08/13/tr08092019-transcript-of-the-press-conference-on-china-article-iv-consultations-report/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2019/08/13/tr08092019-transcript-of-the-press-conference-on-china-article-iv-consultations-report/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: August 13, 2019

---

### Key messages from opening remarks (James Daniel, Mission Chief for China)
- Growth moderated in 2018, and, so far, in 2019, reflecting financial regulatory strengthening and softening external demand.
- Financial deleveraging and reduced interconnectedness between banks and non-banks have helped contain the buildup of financial risks, but vulnerability has remained elevated, and progress on rebalancing is mixed.
- A moderate slowdown is expected in 2019, and uncertainty around trade tensions remains high; risks are tilted to the downside.
- The 2019 consultation focused on shifting from high speed to high quality growth in a highly uncertain environment by stabilizing the economy while continuing deleveraging and strengthening rebalancing.

### Five key policy elements recommended
- Adjust macroeconomic policies to allow for a more flexible exchange rate.
  - Already announced policy measure should be sufficient to stabilize growth in 2019.
  - Given the recent increase in tariffs, a small fiscal expansion could be appropriate, which should be on budget, centrally financed, pro-rebalancing, and targeted to low income households to help maximize the multiplier effect, and contribute to lower poverty and inequality.
- Improve external policies and frameworks.
  - Work constructively with trading partners to better address shortcomings and enable an international trade system that can more readily adapt to economic changes in this national environment.
  - The global economy would benefit from a more open, stable, transparent, rules-based international trade system.
  - China would benefit from further opening up and other structural reforms that enhance competition.
- Continue strengthening the financial sector.
  - Fully implement announced regulatory reforms.
  - Strengthen bank capitol, especially for smaller banks.
  - Enhance macroprudential tools to address vulnerabilities from rising household debt.
  - Develop a clear resolution regime to facilitate exit of weak banks.
  - Remove implicit guarantees and harden the budget constraint for state-owned enterprises to improve credit allocation.
- Boost competition.
  - Open up nonstrategic sectors, particularly services, to private and foreign enterprise.
  - Unify product markets across localities within China.
- Modernize policy frameworks.
  - Eventually move to a single policy rate in the monetary policy framework.
  - Reduce the misalignment of center-local fiscal responsibilities.
  - Further improve transparency and statistics.

### Exchange rate and external sector assessments
- The 2018 average value of the RMB was assessed as "broadly in line with medium term fundamentals and desirable policies" (i.e., not significantly over or undervalued).
- The IMF supports increased exchange rate flexibility for China and has encouraged authorities to continue along this path.
- Estimates in the staff report suggest little FX intervention by the PBC (see report, paragraph eight).
- Reserves have fallen since 2015 (noted as observable context for past intervention estimates).
- A more flexible, market-determined exchange rate would:
  - Give monetary policy more room to address domestic conditions.
  - Help absorb external shocks, including tariff shocks.

### Numerical estimates on tariff impacts (as discussed in Q&A)
- Estimate cited in the report: If tariffs on the remaining 300 billion in Chinese imports to the United States were increased to 25%, it would cut eight tenths off of Chinese growth in the following 12 months. (Reported figure: 0.8)
- The 10% increase already imposed was estimated to take off 0.3 from growth. (Reported figure: 0.3)
- James Daniel’s "back of the envelope" theoretical escalation from 10% to 25% was estimated at 0.5. (Reported figure: 0.5)
- These estimates depend heavily on financial market impacts and confidence effects.

### Other factual points and clarifications from Q&A
- The IMF conducts multilateral assessments of members’ exchange rates and external sector policies as part of its external sector report, typically published in mid-summer; the Article IV assessment is done once a year.
- The staff report compared average effective exchange rates between Article IV cycles and noted that the estimate for May 2019 showed the yuan had depreciated about 0.2% relative to the prior Article IV average. (Reported figure: 0.2%)
- The IMF has strongly encouraged Chinese authorities to publish data on FX intervention.
- Discussions between the IMF and the U.S. Treasury on a range of issues are ongoing.
- Monetary policy advice: increasingly focus monetary policy on domestic conditions, with the exchange rate allowed to play more of a role in absorbing external shocks.
- If tariffs were significantly increased, a small, targeted, on-budget fiscal expansion could be appropriate to stabilize growth and support low-income households.

---


## References

- [People's Republic of China and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/CHN/index.htm)
- [IMF Policy Advice -- A Factsheet](https://www.imf.org/en/about/factsheets/imf-surveillance)
- [Transcripts](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)
- [PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2019/08/13/tr08092019-transcript-of-the-press-conference-on-china-article-iv-consultations-report_