## How can Europe Pay for Things it Cannot Afford?

_IMF News, November 4, 2025_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [How can Europe Pay for Things it Cannot Afford?](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2025/11/04/sp110425-ak-how-can-europe-pay-for-things-it-cannot-afford)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/news/articles/2025/11/04/sp110425-ak-how-can-europe-pay-for-things-it-cannot-afford/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/news/articles/2025/11/04/sp110425-ak-how-can-europe-pay-for-things-it-cannot-afford/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/news/articles/2025/11/04/sp110425-ak-how-can-europe-pay-for-things-it-cannot-afford/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Published: November 4, 2025

---

### Baseline outlook and context
- IMF October forecast: euro area growth projections for 2025 raised to 1.2 percent.
- Medium-term growth outlook described as "mediocre"; EU GDP per capita is nearly 30 percent below that of the U.S.
- Preliminary flash estimate for Q3 broadly confirms the modest outlook.
- Recent shocks and policy shifts: pandemic, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, shifting trade policies, front-loading of exports to the U.S. now reversing, and rising tariff pressures on export profits.

### Major constraints to higher growth
- Structural Barriers:
  - Intra-EU trade barriers remain significant—44 percent for goods and 110 percent for services.
  - Regulatory frictions limit cross-border mobility of capital and labor.
  - Absence of a unified energy market keeps costs high and undermines energy security and resilience.
- Demographic Headwinds:
  - By 2050, over two-thirds of EU countries will see a decline in their working-age population.
- Investment Gaps:
  - Large investment shortfalls in several countries, especially in the CESEE region, are depressing labor productivity and growth.
  - Need for EU-level and domestic reforms to deepen capital markets and incentivize private investment.

### Emerging fiscal pressures and quantified spending demands
- New and rising spending demands:
  - Additional spending in defense, energy security, pensions, and health care estimated at 4½ percent of GDP by 2040 in Advanced Europe including the UK but excluding CESEE economies (AE excl CESEE).
  - Estimated additional spending at 5½ percent of GDP in CESEE countries.
- Rising bond yields are pushing up interest costs.
- Mediocre medium-term growth and constrained labor supply weigh on revenues and increase upward pressure on debt levels.

### Fiscal sustainability simulations and key numeric results
- Under current policies, simulations show public debt on a steeply-increasing path over the next 15 years, with average debt ratios across European countries reaching 130 percent by 2040.
- Sustainable reference debt path used in simulations: does not exceed 90 percent of GDP over the longer term.
- Sustainability gap implied: by 2040, average debt ratios could exceed sustainable levels by 40 percentage points.
- Closing the gap via conventional fiscal consolidation alone:
  - Required deficit reduction: almost 1 percent of GDP per year for five years, a cumulative 5 percent of GDP.
  - Historical precedent: successful past European consolidation campaigns yielded cumulative savings of just about 3 percent of GDP over 3-4 years.
- Impact of moderate reform package:
  - Reduces cumulative adjustment needs from around 5 to just above 3.5 percent of GDP.
  - Brings the average debt path one third of the distance to the sustainable path.
  - About three-quarters of European countries would still need to consolidate even after these reforms.
  - The average adjustment implied exceeds commitments in Medium-Term Fiscal and Structural Plans; submitted and signed off plans would fall about 2 percent of GDP short of the IMF estimates.
- Remaining hard cases:
  - Around one-quarter of European countries would still need to consolidate by more than one percent of GDP per year for five years after implementing the "moderate" reforms.
- Potential savings from deeper structural change:
  - If all European countries reduced the share of public financing in health, education, pensions, infrastructure and energy security to the OECD average, they could save up to 3 percent of GDP on average.
- Timing cost of delay:
  - Delaying the reform and consolidation package by 5 years would raise the required fiscal adjustment by another 1½ percent of GDP.

### Policy package and reform priorities (moderate and beyond)
- Moderate reform package components highlighted:
  - Growth-enhancing domestic reforms that close one quarter of the gap with top-performers.
  - First steps to deepen the single market and increase the EU budget for public goods such as innovation and defense, financed through joint borrowing.
  - Pension reforms to stabilize spending.
  - Measures to catalyze private investment through public investment banks.
- Additional policy options and structural measures:
  - Larger reform drive could significantly close Europe’s GDP per capita gap with the U.S., reducing the need for fiscal consolidation.
  - For high-debt countries: rethinking the scope of publicly financed services; increasing private financing while protecting the most vulnerable.
  - Introducing modest user fees for some services (e.g., health care) while maintaining free access for low-income groups.
  - Large tax reforms designed progressively, particularly relevant for CESEE countries with more room for revenue mobilization.
  - Privatization of SOEs as an option to create fiscal space without unduly hurting those least able to bear costs.

### Implementation principles and political economy
- No silver bullets: most countries will need a mix of reforms and fiscal consolidation.
- Stop "muddling through": tinkering at the margins will not keep debt sustainable and risks political backlash.
- Implementation success depends on:
  - Clear communication and broad stakeholder dialogue emphasizing economic and social benefits of avoiding a disorderly correction.
  - Bundling policies to share benefits and distribute burdens fairly.
  - Careful sequencing to avoid overwhelming burdens on populations.
- Urgency: time is short—delay substantially increases the fiscal price of adjustment.

*Speech by Alfred Kammer, Director, IMF European Department, House of the Euro, Brussels, November 4, 2025.*

---


## References

- [Alfred Kammer](https://www.imf.org/en/About/senior-officials/Bios/alfred-kammer)
- [Belgium and the IMF](http://www.imf.org/external/country/BEL/index.htm)
- [Speeches](https://www.imf.org/en/news/searchnews)
- [PRESS CENTER](http://presscenter.imf.org/)
- [https://www.imf.org/en/home](https://www.imf.org/en/home)

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2025/11/04/sp110425-ak-how-can-europe-pay-for-things-it-cannot-afford_