## Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues — IMF F&D

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues — IMF F&D](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2020/12/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2020/12/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2020/12/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2020/12/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Authors: BINYAMIN APPELBAUM
- Published: December 1, 2020

---

### Overview
- Author: BINYAMIN APPELBAUM.
- Publication: F&D Magazine, December 2020.
- Central claim: Economics must make room for insights from other disciplines and treat distributional issues as central to policy analysis rather than peripheral or merely normative questions.

### Key findings and assertions
- "We live in an age of material abundance and social disquietude."
- A quarter millennium of industrial revolution has produced "almost 8 billion people and enough wealth for every one of them to live lives of unprecedented comfort."
- The problem is distribution: "The rise of economic inequality in the developed world is weighing on growth and straining the fabric of liberal democracy."
- Past half century has generated extensive data; past decade has seen "a clear surge of interest and engagement" among younger economists on distributional questions.
- Many economists remain constrained by:
  - enduring doubts about the importance of distributional issues;
  - reluctance to engage in what they see as normative questions;
  - disregard for other forms of knowledge and lack of diversity in the profession.
- The field’s long-standing indifference has "come at the particular expense of minorities."
- Diversity in the profession may yield different conclusions; it may also produce "greater confusion" as new voices challenge old certitudes, which the author regards as informative.

### Evidence on inequality and growth
- Recent studies, including work by Jonathan D. Ostry and colleagues at the IMF (Ostry, Loungani, and Berg 2019), "find that high levels of inequality actually impede growth."
- Historical example: mainstream economists in the 1980s favored eliminating minimum wage laws; in 1987 the New York Times editorialized in favor of eliminating minimum wage laws citing "a virtual consensus among economists that the minimum wage is an idea whose time has passed." Subsequent empirical work by two economists reversed that efficiency argument.
- Trade liberalization example: advocacy based on net benefits often deferred distributional remedies; Joseph Stiglitz: "The argument was always that the winners could compensate the losers. But the winners never do."
- Firm relocation example: Huffy built about "2 million bikes a year" in Celina, Ohio, until it moved production to China in "1998" to meet Walmart’s demand for cheaper bikes; Celina workers lost jobs and promised help "went largely unkept."

### Equity versus efficiency — normative limits of economic advice
- Traditional position: economists as "the partisan advocate for efficiency" (Charles Schultze).
- Tension: advocating efficiency alone can implicitly devalue distributional arguments and mask normative judgments.
- Paul Romer (2020) recommended that economists should "say ‘No’ when government officials look to economists for an answer to a normative question," reflecting a desire to limit normative overreach.
- Appelbaum’s counterpoint: normative judgments cannot be avoided; treating distribution as secondary facilitates its exclusion from public debate.
- A genuine concern about distribution requires treating distribution "as a primary goal of policy, not as a by-product that requires remediation."

### Cross-pollination and interdisciplinary integration
- Cross-pollination has enriched economics: psychology, demography (spatial dimension), and history of economic ideas are cited as productive influences.
- The goal should not be a "hybrid super social science" but to "leave space for other perspectives."
- Psychological research documents that "economic inequality mimics the effects of absolute poverty on physical and mental health," a finding that does not fit easily into economic models but should inform policy alongside economic analysis.
- Gustav Ranis argued that economists prioritize efficiency over political stability and distributional equity; Ranis suggested reversing this priority order so that people view policies as equitable and stable before supporting efficiency measures.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Economists should:
  - emphasize the importance of distribution in guidance to policymakers;
  - ensure other kinds of knowledge are considered alongside economic analysis;
  - avoid treating distributional issues as segregable or purely political questions to be deferred to politicians.
- When advocating policies with net benefits (for example, trade deals), economists should include credible mechanisms to ensure a broad distribution of benefits rather than assuming compensation by winners will occur.
- Persuasion matters: "no matter how well you think you understand the world, you still need to persuade others to listen."

### Select references cited in the text
- Ostry, Jonathan D., Prakash Loungani, and Andrew Berg. 2019. Confronting Inequality: How Societies Can Choose Inclusive Growth.
- Romer, Paul. 2020. "The Dismal Kingdom: Do Economists Have Too Much Power?" Foreign Affairs (March/April).
- Boushey, Heather. 2019. Unbound: How Inequality Constricts Our Economy and What We Can Do about It.
- Payne, Keith B. 2017. The Broken Ladder: How Inequality Affects the Way We Think, Live, and Die.

*Content based on "Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues" — F&D Magazine, December 2020.*

---

## Content in this bundle

- **وجهة نظر - قضايا التوزيع مهمة**
  - [وجهة نظر - قضايا التوزيع مهمة (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/ar/appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [وجهة نظر - قضايا التوزيع مهمة (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/ar/appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues – IMF F&D**
  - [Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues – IMF F&D (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [Economics Can’t Avoid Distributional Issues – IMF F&D (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **La distribución importa ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Diciembre de 2020**
  - [La distribución importa ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Diciembre de 2020 (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/es/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [La distribución importa ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Diciembre de 2020 (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/es/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **L’importance de la distribution de la richesse**
  - [L’importance de la distribution de la richesse (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/fr/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [L’importance de la distribution de la richesse (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/fr/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **Вопросы распределения – Финансы и развитие – декабрь 2020 года**
  - [Вопросы распределения – Финансы и развитие – декабрь 2020 года (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/ru/appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [Вопросы распределения – Финансы и развитие – декабрь 2020 года (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/ru/appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **分配至关重要 - 金融与发展 - 国际货币基金组织季刊**
  - [分配至关重要 - 金融与发展 - 国际货币基金组织季刊 (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/zh/appelbaum.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [分配至关重要 - 金融与发展 - 国际货币基金组织季刊 (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/zh/appelbaum.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}
- **sdn1402 - Executive Summary**
  - [sdn1402 - Executive Summary (Markdown version)](/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2014/sdn1402.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [sdn1402 - Executive Summary (PDF)](/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2014/sdn1402.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}

---

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2020/12/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum_
