## Lessons from Keynes

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Lessons from Keynes](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/06/book-reviews-lessons-from-keynes-douglas-a-irwin)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/06/book-reviews-lessons-from-keynes-douglas-a-irwin/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/06/book-reviews-lessons-from-keynes-douglas-a-irwin/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/06/book-reviews-lessons-from-keynes-douglas-a-irwin/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Authors: DOUGLAS IRWIN
- Published: June 3, 2024

---

### Overview
- Book under review: Keynes’s The Economic Consequences of the Peace (published in 1919).
- Review author: DOUGLAS IRWIN; publication: F&D Magazine; date: June 2024.
- Reviewed volume: Keynes’s Economic Consequences of the Peace after 100 Years — Polemics and Policy, Edited by Patricia Clavin, Giancarlo Corsetti, Maurice Obstfeld, and Adam Tooze; Cambridge University Press; Cambridge, UK; 2024; 451 pp., $155.
- The reviewed volume grew out of a conference marking the 100th anniversary of Keynes’s 1919 tract (100th anniversary in 2019).

### Key arguments and themes
- Keynes’s 1919 tract is remembered for:
  - A scathing indictment of the Paris Peace Conference and the reparations demanded of Germany.
  - Lamenting the bygone era of pre-1914 globalization.
  - Vivid sketches of principal protagonists, including Georges Clemenceau, David Lloyd George, and Woodrow Wilson.
- Major enduring claims highlighted:
  - Keynes argued that demanding heavy reparations from Germany would make any kind of European recovery impossible.
  - Keynes’s analysis included the transfer problem and claims about Germany’s inability to pay.
- Historians’ and economists’ assessments:
  - Modern historians have been “generally quite critical of Keynes” and believe that he “just got a lot wrong.”
  - Historians view Versailles as a flawed or incomplete success rather than a total failure.
  - Harold James and Andrew Koger: “The Paris Peace Conference failed fundamentally in its objective of creating a durable and just world order.”
  - The review concludes: Keynes was probably wrong about Germany’s capacity to pay but right about the political consequences of attempting to extract large reparations.

### Contents and contributions of the edited volume
- Structure and scope:
  - The volume contains 16 substantive chapters.
  - Contributors include historians, political scientists, economists, and economic historians.
  - The editors frame the book as “a concerted reflection on the terrible events and the underlying factors that a hundred years ago undermined decades of unprecedented economic globalization, destroyed empires, and redefined the balance of power among regions and countries.”
- Notable chapters and topics:
  - Michael Cox: sets out reasons Keynes wrote the book and its reception.
  - Peter Clarke: assesses views of Keynes’s critics on reparations.
  - Simon Hinrichsen: compiles data on past indemnities and reparations to contextualize the Germany/World War I case.
  - Other chapters address:
    - Responses to Keynes’s book in Sweden, France, and Türkiye.
    - Keynes as a foreign exchange trader.
    - Interwar international trade politics.
    - The gold standard and the tripartite monetary agreement of 1936.
    - The evolution of the international monetary system since 1919.
    - The evolution of Keynes’s thinking on the international economy from 1919 to Bretton Woods.

### Historical trajectory and policy implications
- Historical consequences emphasized:
  - The 1920s and 1930s were “terrible decades” of economic and political turmoil, culminating in another world war in the early 1940s.
  - Only after World War II was Keynes’s vision of strong international economic institutions providing stability finally realized.
- Policy lessons drawn:
  - The international system reflects a mix of economics and geopolitics.
  - The political damage of attempting to extract large reparations from a defeated power can be long-lasting even if actual payments are limited.
  - With the rise of economic nationalism and concerns about international security today, the volume serves as a sobering reminder of the stakes involved.

### Exact figures, dates, and counts in the source
- Original Keynes book publication year: 1919.
- 100th anniversary of The Economic Consequences: 2019.
- Edited volume publication year: 2024.
- Edited volume length and price: 451 pp., $155.
- Number of substantive chapters in the edited volume: 16.
- Year the reparations figure was set: 1921.
- Year of Germany’s hyperinflation leading to a revised reparations schedule: 1923.
- Tripartite monetary agreement year mentioned: 1936.
- Decades described as marked by turmoil: the 1920s and 1930s.
- Period of subsequent world war referenced: the early 1940s.

*Source: F&D Magazine — Lessons from Keynes, DOUGLAS IRWIN, June 2024.*

---

## Content in this bundle

- **Book Reviews: Lessons from Keynes**
  - [Book Reviews: Lessons from Keynes (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/06/books-irwin.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [Book Reviews: Lessons from Keynes (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/06/books-irwin.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}

---

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/06/book-reviews-lessons-from-keynes-douglas-a-irwin_