## Behind the Veil of Tariff Fixation

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Behind the Veil of Tariff Fixation](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2025/09/point-of-view-behind-the-veil-of-tariff-fixation-michael-pettis)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2025/09/point-of-view-behind-the-veil-of-tariff-fixation-michael-pettis/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2025/09/point-of-view-behind-the-veil-of-tariff-fixation-michael-pettis/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/publications/fandd/issues/2025/09/point-of-view-behind-the-veil-of-tariff-fixation-michael-pettis/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Authors: MICHAEL PETTIS
- Published: September 3, 2025

---

### Key thesis: broaden conception of trade policy
- Tariffs are visible, quantifiable, politicizable, and easy to weaponize, but they are a poor proxy for trade policy as a whole.
- Trade imbalances are consequences of internal economic structure—how income is distributed, how much households spend relative to what businesses produce—not just border measures.
- Fixing trade imbalances requires changing how countries structure their economies and shifting power and resources toward those whose spending drives sustainable demand.

### Mechanism: income transfer is the essence of trade intervention
- A tariff is a tax on imports that shifts income from consumers to producers by making foreign goods more expensive, reducing the household share of GDP and lowering consumption relative to production.
- Any policy that changes the balance between household consumption and total output also affects the balance between domestic saving and domestic investment, and therefore functions as trade policy.
- Examples of equivalent income-transfer mechanisms:
  - Tariff: taxes consumption, subsidies production.
  - Currency policy (undervalued exchange rate): makes imports more expensive and exports cheaper, subsidizing production and taxing consumption.
  - Financial repression (suppressing interest rates where banking serves supply side): acts as a tax on net savers (household sector) and a credit subsidy for net borrowers (producing sector).

### Policy instruments beyond tariffs that shape trade balances
- Fiscal decisions, regulatory structures, labor policies, and institutional norms can redistribute income in ways that alter trade outcomes.
- Tax and regulatory policies, including direct or indirect subsidies to strategic industries and infrastructure built for manufacturing clusters, change incentives similarly to protectionism without appearing as trade interventions.
- Labor-market structures and social institutions (example: the hukou system in China) can depress wages and reduce household consumption, thereby affecting trade balances.
- Policies that encourage environmental degradation, restrict labor organizing, hold down minimum wages, or reduce bargaining power of workers suppress wage growth and limit consumption relative to productivity growth, producing trade-surplus effects quietly.

### Analytical implications and interpretation
- Persistent trade surpluses in low-tariff economies can reflect deliberate or de facto domestic choices favoring production over consumption (institutional structures, saving incentives, export-oriented industrial policies).
- A narrow focus on tariffs distracts from underlying drivers and risks counterproductive responses; tariffs in deficit economies may, paradoxically, help force down imbalances and promote freer trade.
- As John Maynard Keynes argued at Bretton Woods in 1944, a diversified economy running persistent trade surpluses is usually sufficient evidence of trade-distorting interventions—regardless of whether those distortions are tariffs.

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Move beyond surface-level tariff debates toward examining internal allocation of income and the domestic policies that privilege producers over consumers.
- Rebalance power and resources toward households and actors whose spending supports sustainable demand.
- Recognize currency policy, financial-sector regulation, labor-market institutions, tax and subsidy regimes, and industrial policy as central elements of trade policy that merit scrutiny and, where appropriate, reform.

*Michael Pettis, F&D Magazine, September 2025*

---

## Content in this bundle

- **Pettis**
  - [Pettis (Markdown version)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2025/09/pettis.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [Pettis (PDF)](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2025/09/pettis.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}

---

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2025/09/point-of-view-behind-the-veil-of-tariff-fixation-michael-pettis_
