## Good, Bad or Ugly? On the Effects of Fiscal Rules with Creative Accounting

_IMF Working Papers, October 1, 2000_

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Good, Bad or Ugly? On the Effects of Fiscal Rules with Creative Accounting](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/wp/issues/2016/12/30/good-bad-or-ugly-on-the-effects-of-fiscal-rules-with-creative-accounting-3830)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/en/publications/wp/issues/2016/12/30/good-bad-or-ugly-on-the-effects-of-fiscal-rules-with-creative-accounting-3830/index.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/en/publications/wp/issues/2016/12/30/good-bad-or-ugly-on-the-effects-of-fiscal-rules-with-creative-accounting-3830/index.json)
- [Bundle manifest](/en/publications/wp/issues/2016/12/30/good-bad-or-ugly-on-the-effects-of-fiscal-rules-with-creative-accounting-3830/bundle-manifest.json)

## Bibliographic details
- Authors: Gian M Milesi-Ferretti
- Published: October 1, 2000
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9781451858563.001

---

### Summary
- Research question: Do fiscal rules likely lead to fiscal adjustment, or do they encourage the use of “creative accounting”?
- Approach: A model in which fiscal rules are imposed on “measured” fiscal variables that can differ from “true” variables because of a margin for creative accounting.
- Key mechanism: The probability of detecting creative accounting depends on its size and the transparency of the budget.
- Focus: The model studies the effects on fiscal policy of different rules, separates structural from cyclical effects, and examines dependence on the underlying fiscal distortion and the degree of budget transparency.

### Model and Mechanism
- Measured versus true fiscal variables: Fiscal rules bind measured variables; governments may manipulate the margin between measured and true variables.
- Detection probability: A function of (a) the size of creative accounting and (b) the transparency of the budget.
- Effects analyzed:
  - Structural effects versus cyclical effects of fiscal rules.
  - Interaction with underlying fiscal distortion.
  - Interaction with degree of budget transparency.
- Government behavior: Allows for different government types and preferences (e.g., myopic government) and incorporates a loss function framework.

### Main Findings (as described)
- Fiscal rules can induce either fiscal adjustment or increased use of creative accounting depending on model parameters.
- Higher budget transparency reduces the probability that creative accounting goes undetected for a given size of manipulation.
- The net impact of fiscal rules on true fiscal outcomes depends on:
  - The design of the rule (which measured variables are constrained).
  - The underlying fiscal distortion faced by the government.
  - The degree of budget transparency.
- Structural versus cyclical decomposition matters for assessing the true fiscal stance under rules subject to creative accounting.

### Policy Implications
- Design fiscal rules carefully to minimize incentives for creative accounting by:
  - Choosing measured variables that closely track true fiscal positions.
  - Enhancing budget transparency to increase detection probability for manipulations.
- Consider underlying fiscal distortions when evaluating expected effectiveness of a rule.
- Account for both structural and cyclical effects when monitoring compliance and assessing fiscal adjustment.

---

## Content in this bundle

- **Good, Bad or Ugly? On The Effects of Fiscal Rules with Creative Accounting - WP/00/172**
  - [Good, Bad or Ugly? On The Effects of Fiscal Rules with Creative Accounting - WP/00/172 (Markdown version)](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2000/_wp00172.pdf.md){rel="alternate" type="text/markdown"}
  - [Good, Bad or Ugly? On The Effects of Fiscal Rules with Creative Accounting - WP/00/172 (PDF)](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2000/_wp00172.pdf){rel="external" type="application/pdf"}

---

_Source: https://www.imf.org/en/publications/wp/issues/2016/12/30/good-bad-or-ugly-on-the-effects-of-fiscal-rules-with-creative-accounting-3830_
