Paris Club 60th Anniversary—Keynote Address by Christine Lagarde Managing Director, International Monetary Fund
IMF News, July 1, 2016
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Paris Club 60th Anniversary—Keynote Address by Christine Lagarde Managing Director, International Monetary Fund
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: July 1, 2016
Role of the Paris Club and IMF perspective
- The Paris Club is presented as "the world's forum for official sector involvement" and an "indispensable partner in debt crises."
- The IMF's principal responsibility is "to maintain the stability of the international financial system," and healthy sovereign debtors are central to this mandate.
- The Fund can only lend when debt is sustainable; therefore, "some form of debt restructuring is usually required" when sovereigns cannot meet full payment obligations.
- The Paris Club provides an established forum for official creditor coordination that helps avoid processes that could otherwise be "messy, protracted and costly" and cultivates practices (e.g., provision of "financing assurances") that enable the Fund "to lend early in support of a member in need."
- The speech emphasizes that the Paris Club's practices have been "reliably efficient" and "nimble" over time.
Ground-level contribution and historical examples
- Sovereign debt restructurings are described as inherently difficult, with urgency on the debtor side and diverse positions among creditors.
- The Paris Club's value at the operational level is its ability to "bring official creditors around a single table and deliver comprehensive consensus agreements at short notice."
- Historical and case examples cited:
- Iraq (2004) and Nigeria (2005): Club essential in resolving complex official creditor bases.
- Grenada (2015): Club moved early to provide financing assurances to the Fund ahead of an agreement with private sector creditors; the Club's early support "paved the way for Fund financing" and anchored private sector restructuring and policies to return Grenada to external viability.
- Russian Federation (post-Soviet arrears): By bringing Russia into the Club in 1997 and through extensive information sharing, a robust framework was developed for clearing arrears consistent with the Club's "comparability of treatment" principle.
- Myanmar (2013) and Poland (earlier): Club role in enabling countries' re-integration into the global economy via debt relief and support.
- HIPC Initiative: Of the "39 countries eligible or potentially eligible for HIPC Initiative assistance, 36 are receiving full debt relief from the IMF and other creditors after reaching their completion points."
Current conjunctural concerns and structural shifts in official finance
- Conjunctural concerns:
- Advanced economy debt remains high despite improvement since 2008.
- Commodity exporters were hit by the unwinding of the commodity super cycle.
- Increased uncertainty over growth prospects due to the recent slowdown in China.
- Risks related to rising private indebtedness and a tightening of global liquidity.
- Marked rise in debt vulnerabilities among some frontier economies and in small states vulnerable to natural disasters.
- Structural developments affecting official finance:
- Emergence of new global creditors: China, Brazil, India, South Africa, and Korea.
- Increased diversity in forms of sovereign financing, notably a surge in sovereign bond issuance and purchases by foreign sovereign entities (sovereign wealth funds, central banks). When claims are held for investment purposes they are "akin to private claims" and "not a concern of the Club," but they pose "opportunities and risks" for efficient resolution.
- Growing international recognition of sustainable development: fiscal assessments may need to account for future costs from depleted resources and environmental externalities; official creditors should be "increasingly conscious of this broader sustainability imperative."
Areas for further action — three priorities
- 1) Broaden membership
- "Broadening the Club's membership to include other major global official creditors is important to enhance the Club's representativeness and continued long-term relevance."
- Korea's accession is welcomed and expected to act as "a catalyst for other creditors."
- Outreach should be coupled with "an openness and willingness to adapt" while maintaining core Club principles; "careful communication and explanation of the Club's working principles and their purpose will be essential."
- 2) Continue financing innovations
- The Club should remain innovative; two recent initiatives cited as welcome:
- "Hurricane clause" in the November 2015 restructuring of Grenada: an example of a state-contingent solution for a small economy highly vulnerable to natural disasters.
- Debt-for-environment swap with Seychelles in February 2015, negotiated with close cooperation with the USA's Natural Conservancy: reduces debt burden in exchange for commitments on marine conservation.
- Ongoing work noted on proposals for countercyclical loans that would provide automatic debt service relief in bad times; the Fund "is currently examining the wider case for state-contingent financial instruments" and plans to "discuss this topic with our members in early 2017."
- 3) Address alternative forms of sovereign finance (tradable bonds held by sovereigns/entities)
- The speech distinguishes between bonds held for investment purposes (treated like private claims) and official claims extended for public policy purposes (which enjoy seniority).
- No scope is seen for treating investment-held sovereign bonds as official claims with seniority, but there may be a case for "greater information sharing, discussion and coordination among the foreign public sector entities that hold such bonds in the context of a restructuring."
- Key questions posed:
- "Can these public sector entities work together in ways that would help expedite a restructuring when one is needed, which would be a net positive for the global financial system?"
- "What role can and should the Club play in this regard?"
Concluding assessment
- The Paris Club's track record is cited as a basis for confidence in meeting future challenges despite the changing landscape of official debt restructuring.
- The Club is urged to ground responses in "discussion and dialogue among creditors," with awareness that the next session will address "the changing landscape of official debt restructuring."
Paris Club 60th Anniversary—Keynote Address by Christine Lagarde Managing Director, International Monetary Fund, July 1, 2016.