Scaling Up the Single Market to Boost Productivity
IMF News, November 14, 2024
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Scaling Up the Single Market to Boost Productivity
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 14, 2024
Overview
- Speaker: Mr. Alfred Kammer, Director of the European Department at the IMF.
- Event: Launch of the Fall 2024 Regional Economic Outlook for Europe at the House of the Euro in Brussels.
- Date: November 14, 2024.
- Central message: A productivity revival in Europe is feasible and largely within Europe’s own control; a deeper single market and better integration within it are key to strengthening growth and resilience.
Growth outlook and near-term developments
- A recovery is underway but modest:
- Preliminary Q3 growth: euro area expanded by 0.4 percent (quarter-on-quarter) and the EU by 0.3 percent (quarter-on-quarter).
- Baseline outlook: continued modest increase in growth into 2025 for both advanced European economies and the Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe region.
- Main drivers of the rebound: private consumption and investment, supported by steadily growing disposable incomes and easing of financial tightness.
- Key near-term headwind: elevated uncertainty from escalating geoeconomic tensions and uncertainty about domestic and trade policies, which has reduced household spending and firm investment.
Firm- and sector-level findings on productivity
- Long-run gap:
- Europe’s per capita income is about 30 percent lower than that of the U.S., largely due to a sizable productivity gap that opened up in the last two and a half decades.
- Leading large firms:
- Non-tech listed firms’ annualized productivity growth over the last two decades: Europe 0.9 percent versus U.S. 2.6 percent.
- Tech listed firms since the mid-2000s: Europe declined at an annualized rate of 0.3 percent versus U.S. growth of 1.5 percent.
- R&D intensity in tech firms: Europe around 3 to 4 percent of sales in recent years, U.S. around 12 percent of sales in 2023.
- Business dynamism and young firms:
- U.S. top-performing young firms (highest decile of employment growth) make up around six times the share of total employment of their European counterparts.
- European micro-firms account for 20 percent of total employment—twice as much as in the U.S.
- Some European countries exhibit low exit rates of unsuccessful firms, contributing to an overabundance of small mature firms.
Structural impediments identified
- Market fragmentation and trade barriers:
- EU intramarket trade intensity (cross-border trade between member countries in ratio to the EU’s GDP) is less than half the trade intensity between U.S. states.
- Estimated tariff-equivalent costs of selling goods across EU member states: around 45 percent; across U.S. states: about 15 percent.
- Estimated tariff-equivalent costs for services across EU member states: about 110 percent on average.
- Deeper market integration (lowering intra-EU trade barriers to U.S. states’ levels) could increase the level of productivity by almost 7 percent in the long term.
- Financing structure and innovation funding:
- For a given firm size, U.S.-listed firms rely twice as much on equity financing as EU-listed firms.
- Limited access to equity markets in Europe makes R&D and intangible investments more vulnerable to shocks.
- Venture capital: in the past decade, VC investments in the EU represented only about one-fourth of what it represents for the U.S. economy.
- Empirical finding: venture capital injections lead recipient European firms to double their intangible investments within a year.
Human capital and firm scaling
- Regional labor quality is highly correlated with births of high-growth young firms.
- Conditional on establishment, easing financing constraints is critical for promising young firms to scale—especially for those investing heavily in intangible capital such as R&D.
- Workers’ costs of migrating between EU countries are about eight times higher than for migration between U.S. states, limiting talent agglomeration and innovation clusters.
Policy recommendations and reform priorities
- Short-term:
- Reduce elevated uncertainty through a smooth loosening path for monetary policy.
- Implement the new fiscal rules to ensure buffers are in place when future shocks hit.
- Medium- and long-term structural reforms to durably lift potential growth:
- Deepen the single market to expand firms’ market access by:
- Addressing underinvestment in border infrastructure.
- Opening up protected sectors.
- Pursuing further services trade liberalization.
- Harmonizing regulations to lower regulatory costs of operating across borders.
- Advance the EU capital markets union to better harness Europe’s savings and increase availability of equity financing for firms of all sizes.
- Ease barriers to labor mobility, for example through greater pension portability, to promote talent agglomeration.
- Easing administrative barriers to entry to foster business creation, especially in services.
- Make tax and regulatory incentives for small firms temporary to incentivize firm growth.
- Support tertiary education and address skills mismatches to foster idea creation and technology adoption.
- Overall imperative: the EU must find common ground for removing barriers to goods, services, capital, and labor flows within the single market; progress will strengthen productivity, income per capita, and economic resilience.
Key quantitative takeaways
- Q3 preliminary growth: euro area 0.4 percent (quarter-on-quarter); EU 0.3 percent (quarter-on-quarter).
- Europe’s per capita income gap with U.S.: about 30 percent lower.
- Non-tech annualized productivity growth (last two decades): Europe 0.9 percent; U.S. 2.6 percent.
- Tech annualized productivity change since mid-2000s: Europe −0.3 percent; U.S. 1.5 percent.
- R&D intensity of tech firms: Europe 3 to 4 percent of sales; U.S. around 12 percent of sales in 2023.
- EU intra-EU goods trade tariff-equivalent: around 45 percent; across U.S. states: about 15 percent.
- Services trade tariff-equivalent across EU member states: about 110 percent.
- Potential productivity gain from lowering intra-EU trade barriers to U.S. states’ level: almost 7 percent in the long term.
- VC investment in EU (past decade): about one-fourth of U.S. level.
- Effect of venture capital injections: recipient European firms double their intangible investments within a year.
- Share of employment in micro-firms in Europe: 20 percent—twice U.S. level.
- Relative migration cost of workers: about eight times higher across EU countries than across U.S. states.
Source: Scaling Up the Single Market to Boost Productivity, Launch of the Fall 2024 Regional Economic Outlook for Europe, November 14, 2024, IMF Communications Department.
Content in this bundle
- reoeurnote1