Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate: Executive Board Meeting, June 10, 2024
Policy Papers, June 18, 2024
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate: Executive Board Meeting, June 10, 2024
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: June 18, 2024
- Series: Policy Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9798400278952.007
Evaluation scope and purpose
- Assesses the decision-making processes that guided the evolution of the application of the Fund's mandate.
- Reviews the criteria and principles used to operationalize engagement in newer policy areas.
- Examines the coherence of the Fund’s framework for engaging with partners.
Major findings
- The systematic widening of the Fund’s areas of work is posing adaptation challenges, necessitating trade-offs, and overburdening staff within a context of budgetary and expertise constraints.
- The evaluation offers a framework centered on a trilemma exposing tension between:
- the steady expansion of the Fund’s scope of work,
- its limited resources, and
- the need to maintain the high quality and value-added of its policy advice.
- Identified problems within this framework include:
- an ad hoc decision-making process for engaging in newer policy areas that lacks a longer-term strategic anchor;
- decisions on policies, resources, and risks taken in a piecemeal manner, without due consideration for crossed effects;
- several open questions regarding the depth and frequency of the Fund’s engagement in newer policy areas;
- a lack of an institutional approach to Fund partnerships.
Framework and classification of engagement
- Proposes classifying newer policy areas across a spectrum of recommended engagement, ranging from:
- signaling their macrocriticality while leaving deeper assessments to other institutions, to
- in-depth high-frequency engagement.
Main recommendations
- Four main recommendations are offered:
- (i) developing an inclusive Fund-wide institutional strategy for engagement in newer policy areas that better links decisions related to scope, resources, and risks;
- (ii) producing budget data that enables the tracking of Fund activities and operations by policy area;
- (iii) updating the 2022 Guidance Note for Surveillance to enhance the clarity of principles for engagement; and
- (iv) adopting a Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles for engagement with partners.
Open questions and implementation considerations
- Depth and frequency of engagement in newer policy areas remain unresolved.
- Need for an institutional approach to partnerships to manage crossed effects and align policy, resource, and risk decisions.
- Budgetary and expertise constraints imply trade-offs that require strategic prioritization and clearer institutional anchors.
Source: Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate: Executive Board Meeting, June 10, 2024; June 18, 2024.
Content in this bundle
- Policy Paper