Gender Equality and the Costs of Unpaid Caregiving
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Gender Equality and the Costs of Unpaid Caregiving
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: SARAH GAMMAGE, NAZIHA SULTANA, MANON MOURON
- Published: March 1, 2019
Burden of unpaid care and economic consequences
- Responsibility for unpaid care work falls disproportionately on women and girls, limiting time for education, leisure, political participation, paid work, and other economic activities.
- Care work is significant where infrastructure is poor and publicly provided services are limited or absent (Samman, Presler-Marshall, and Jones 2016).
- The burden is particularly acute in rural settings and in aging societies.
- Consequences:
- Limits women’s engagement in market activities.
- Leads to concentration of women in low-paid, informal, or home-based work.
- Contributes to gender wage gaps and inflates numbers of the working poor.
- Securing a pathway to decent work and addressing unpaid care work are fundamental to women’s economic empowerment.
EBRD–International Center for Research on Women project: objectives and approach
- Goal: explore whether and how the private sector identifies and addresses care needs and responsibilities as factors limiting their ability to hire, retain, and promote women; forecast women’s labor force participation if care needs were better resolved by private and public sectors.
- Geographic focus (project case studies): Egypt, Kazakhstan, Romania, Turkey.
- Analytical elements:
- Review of gender gaps in time spent on paid and unpaid work; examination of social norms around who performs care.
- Examination of legislation, policies, and regulations underpinning care options (direct provision, infrastructure, subsidies, tax credits, care credits, leave policies, family-friendly working arrangements, education and health sector policies, macroeconomic policies).
- Private sector lens: attention to how legislation regulates private sector care practices and incentives for private sector involvement.
Key quantitative findings and scenarios
- Labor force participation gaps:
- Average gap in EBRD countries: 21 percent.
- Average gap in southern and eastern Mediterranean countries: 49 percent.
- Childcare price elasticities (drawing on country-specific studies):
- If the price of childcare were reduced by 50 percent, the labor supply of mothers would rise on the order of 6 to 10 percent.
- Cross-country regression result:
- Increasing the share of government expenditure on preprimary education (as a percentage of GDP) by 1 percentage point can reduce the labor force participation gap by about 10 points.
- Forecast scenario:
- A 1.5 percent of total GDP increase in expenditure on preprimary education (the highest level of investment in the EBRD region) would bring down the average labor force participation gap from 21 to 6.5 percentage points.
- Biggest gains projected in Egypt, Jordan, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Tajikistan: average gap falls to 13.5 percentage points from 49 percentage points.
Private sector costs and firm-level evidence
- Employer recognition:
- Small companies experience meaningful costs from staff turnover associated with insufficient care options that enable women to remain in the labor market after having children.
- Turkey agribusiness case (medium-sized firm of about 800 employees):
- More than 70 percent of employees are women.
- Company benefits and leave:
- 16 weeks of paid maternity leave with provisions for another six months of unpaid leave.
- Breastfeeding mothers can take an hour and a half daily to nurse a child up to a year old.
- Fathers receive five days of paid paternity leave.
- Company does not provide childcare services or subsidies.
- 2017 outcomes:
- Turnover rate: over 26 percent of all women employees.
- 91 women quit every year for care-related reasons.
- Direct cost of recruitment and training and lost productivity: almost $1 million a year, representing 14 percent of the company’s annual revenue.
- Average yearly cost of childcare for a child six months to three years old: $1,100.
- Comparison: cost of childcare is lower than total cost to firms of turnover and lost productivity.
- Small textile firm example:
- Spends $258,000 a year on childcare for employees and saves more than $800,000 as a result of lower women’s turnover.
Policy implications and recommendations
- Public and private sectors need to work together to promote gender equality by investing in care services and reducing care burdens.
- Potential private sector roles:
- Provide care services for employees (including on-site care).
- Subsidize access to care services.
- Complement and reinforce existing public sector programs.
- Policy instruments to consider:
- Direct provision of care services and care-related infrastructure.
- Subsidies, tax credits, and care credits to expand supply and increase affordability of child and dependent care.
- Labor policies and regulations: leave policies and family-friendly working arrangements.
- Education and health sector policies that shape care availability.
- Macroeconomic policies to shape fiscal space for care provision.
- Measurement and guidance needs:
- Firms need guidance on tracking full costs of failing to address care needs and how best to accommodate work-life balance policies.
- Many companies struggle to calculate costs of turnover and benefits of retention, and to track individual and collective productivity measures.
- Research agenda:
- At the community level: further research on costs and benefits of greater access to care and improved functioning of labor markets.
- At the macro level: calculation of benefits of investing in care in terms of jobs and fiscal space created.
- Political economy:
- Demonstrating economic costs and benefits of care provision is essential to changing the dialogue on investing in care and redistributing roles between market, state, and household.
- Showing that failure to resolve care deficits affects the private sector may be fundamental to designing holistic solutions that include taxation and subsidies to complement public provision.
Gender Equality and the Costs of Unpaid Caregiving — F&D Magazine, March 2019. SARAH GAMMAGE; NAZIHA SULTANA; MANON MOURON.
Content in this bundle
- التكلفة المستترة للرعاية غير مدفوعة الأجر
- Los costos ocultos del cuidado familiar no remunerado ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Marzo de 2019
- Les coûts indirects du travail domestique non rémunéré
- The Hidden Costs of Unpaid Caregiving
- Скрытые издержки неоплачиваемого ухода за членами семьи – Финансы и развитие – март 2019 года
- 无偿照护工作的隐性成本 - 金融与发展