Central Banks Can Fend Off Financial Turmoil and Still Fight Inflation
IMF Blog, June 5, 2023
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Central Banks Can Fend Off Financial Turmoil and Still Fight Inflation
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Tobias Adrian, Gita Gopinath, Pierre-Olivier Gourinchas
- Published: June 5, 2023
Overview
- Authors: Tobias Adrian, Gita Gopinath, Pierre-Olivier Gourinchas.
- Date: June 5, 2023.
- Core claim: Recent events show central banks and policymakers can contain sizable financial stress without abandoning efforts to fight inflation, but trade-offs between price and financial stability become harder when inflation is high.
- Empirical examples cited: collapse of Silicon Valley Bank and other US regional banks; Credit Suisse in Switzerland; Bank of England’s intervention following the UK government’s tax-cut proposal last September.
Handling modest financial stress
- Key reasoning:
- Past monetary tightening has often generated modest financial stress that did not preclude achieving price and financial stability simultaneously.
- If modest stress weakens aggregate demand unexpectedly, central banks can adjust the policy rate path to keep output and inflation broadly on track.
- Policy tools and actions:
- Hold or slow the pace of policy rate increases (example: US Federal Reserve held rates in the early 1990s amid a looming credit crunch despite inflation above desired levels).
- Use non-policy-rate tools:
- Emergency lending at the discount window.
- Emergency liquidity facilities.
- Loosening macroprudential tools, where available.
- Rationale: Relatively standard financial stability tools—without additional fiscal support—can suffice for modest rises in financial stress, allowing monetary policy to focus on inflation.
Challenges of heightened financial stress
- Dynamics and risks:
- Modest stresses can evolve into nonlinear feedback loops and systemic crisis, potentially accelerated by technology and social media.
- Rapidly rising interest rates have stressed balance sheets via declining values of fixed-income assets and higher funding costs.
- Required policy responses:
- Forceful, timely financial policies including various forms of liquidity support, asset purchases, or direct capital injections.
- These interventions, if sufficiently forceful, can free monetary policy to continue focusing on inflation.
- Limits of central banks:
- Central banks can extend broad-based liquidity to solvent banks but cannot resolve insolvent firms or insolvent borrowers; governments must address insolvency issues.
- Aggressive financial interventions often require committing sizable fiscal resources.
- Illustrative episode:
- Korea: default of a real estate developer last September led to sharp disruptions in short-term funding markets; government implemented market support measures including a corporate bond-buying program while the Bank of Korea provided substantial liquidity support—actions that allowed the central bank to raise its policy rate to pursue inflation objectives.
- When fiscal space or political support is lacking:
- Central banks may prudently slow rate hikes to reduce nonlinear financial risks, tolerating a somewhat slower return of inflation to target.
- Communication risks: reduced focus on inflation can heighten crisis perceptions and risk "financial dominance"; high bar advised before shifting reaction functions.
- Preferred course: rely on financial policies or restore fiscal support rather than changing monetary reaction function.
When the financial crisis is acute
- Priority shift:
- In a systemic crisis with a sharp downturn expected, restoring financial stability should be prioritized.
- Central banks with high credibility could ease monetary policy and indicate flexibility on the time frame for returning inflation to target.
- In practice, a crisis would likely exert substantial downward pressure on inflation, re-aligning monetary and financial objectives.
- Emerging market constraints:
- Emerging markets with weaker macro policy frameworks face capital flight and currency depreciation-inflation spirals, constraining scope to ease.
- Such countries may need to maintain a nominal anchor and use capital flow management measures, but a strong international safety net is vital to mitigate prolonged severe crises.
Supporting nonbanks
- Challenge:
- Nonbank financial institutions (insurance firms, pension funds, investment funds) have grown in importance and may be critical during stress.
- Central bank liquidity typically flows through banks and may not reach nonbanks.
- Nonbanks are often less well capitalized and subject to weaker prudential regulation and supervision.
- Policy considerations:
- In heightened or acute stress, central banks may need to provide liquidity to nonbanks, as during the global financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic.
- The bar for lending to nonbanks should be higher than for banks due to greater risks to central bank balance sheets and moral hazard concerns.
Key takeaways
- Recent forceful responses to heightened financial stress in Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States helped reduce financial instability and allowed central banks to maintain their inflation-fighting stance.
- Taxonomy for policy responses:
- Modest financial stress: use financial stability tools and keep monetary policy focused on inflation, adjusting rate path if demand weakens unexpectedly.
- Heightened financial stress: deploy aggressive financial interventions, with fiscal support where insolvency issues arise; consider prudence in rate hikes if fiscal backing is absent.
- Acute systemic crisis: prioritize financial stability, potentially easing monetary policy if credibility allows; emerging markets face more constrained options and rely on international safety nets.
- Communication and credibility are critical when adjusting monetary reaction functions during stress; the bar for tolerating slower disinflation should be high.
Source: Central Banks Can Fend Off Financial Turmoil and Still Fight Inflation, June 5, 2023.