Industrial Policy Can Lift Productivity—but Comes With Risks and Trade-offs
IMF Blog, November 25, 2025
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Industrial Policy Can Lift Productivity—but Comes With Risks and Trade-offs
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Shekhar Aiyar, Mehdi Benatiya Andaloussi
- Published: November 25, 2025
Context and purpose
- Governments across both advanced and emerging market economies have increasingly rolled out new support for targeted companies and industries over the past decade and a half.
- Industrial policy is used for goals including boosting productivity growth, protecting manufacturing jobs, improving self-dependence and the resilience of supply chains, and developing “infant” industries to diversify the economy.
- The blog summarizes analytical findings from Chapter 3 of the October 2025 World Economic Outlook, “Industrial Policy: Managing Trade-Offs to Promote Growth and Resilience.”
Impact on targeted sectors
- Effectiveness depends on industry-specific characteristics that can be hard to determine in advance.
- Simulations show industrial policy can help boost domestic sectors when productivity scales up with output (learning-by-doing or scale efficiencies).
- Instruments: a mix of subsidies and trade protections can promote domestic production in strategic industries.
- Potential dynamic gains:
- Early support can deliver long-lasting productivity improvements in sectors that become more efficient with experience.
- Production costs decrease as volume grows, enabling learning and potential global competitiveness.
- Significant trade-offs and limits:
- Consumers can face higher prices for a prolonged period.
- Governments can incur substantial budgetary costs.
- Success is not guaranteed if companies are technologically too far behind, learn slowly, or lack access to large markets (for example through exports).
- Empirical findings:
- Direct subsidies to an industry are associated with about a 0.5 percent improvement in value added and 0.3 percent higher total factor productivity three years after implementation, reflecting higher capital accumulation and employment.
- These improvements are modest compared with sample average industry value added growth of 6.5 percent per year and total factor productivity growth of about 4 percent per year.
- Earlier IMF analysis reaffirms that larger gains can come from structural reforms to improve the overall business environment and better enable credit access for all firms.
- Industrial policy is associated with better economic outcomes in targeted industries, particularly in countries with strong institutions, but the gains are small.
Aggregate impacts and risks
- Multi-sector, multi-country model outcomes:
- Employment, productivity and output improve in targeted industries.
- Resources drawn away from untargeted sectors cause those sectors to shrink and lose productivity.
- This reallocation can produce misallocation of resources and potentially dampen aggregate productivity, leaving the economy worse off despite gains in priority sectors.
- Other risks:
- Wasteful spending, especially when debt is elevated and fiscal space limited.
- Cross-country spillovers and potential retaliation by trading partners (not the chapter’s focus but noted).
Policy design and calibration recommendations
- Carefully design and implement industrial policy with explicit recognition and management of trade-offs.
- Weigh the opportunity cost of industrial policy against economy-wide reforms that can often boost outcomes without precise sector targeting or large fiscal costs.
- Include mechanisms for regular evaluation and recalibration of industrial policy measures.
- Underpin policies with a strong institutional and macroeconomic framework.
- Encourage market discipline through vigorous domestic and international competition.
- Prioritize fiscal sustainability and economic efficiency to increase the likelihood that industrial policy delivers on its promise.
Based on Chapter 3 of the October 2025 World Economic Outlook, “Industrial Policy: Managing Trade-Offs to Promote Growth and Resilience.” Authors of the chapter include Shekhar Aiyar, Hippolyte Balima, Mehdi Benatiya Andaloussi, Thomas Kroen, Rafael Machado Parente, Chiara Maggi, Yu Shi, and Sebastian Wende, with research assistance from Shrihari Ramachandra and Yarou Xu. Blog published November 25, 2025.
Content in this bundle
- Chapter 3