Interview: Jamaica’s former central bank governor Brian Wynter – IMF F&D
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Interview: Jamaica’s former central bank governor Brian Wynter – IMF F&D
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: OLGA STANKOVA
- Published: September 1, 2020
Background and overview
- Jamaica historically struggled with fiscal deficits, high public debt, and damagingly high inflation.
- Recent successes in stabilizing the economy occurred before the COVID-19 crisis.
- Brian Wynter served as governor of the Bank of Jamaica during 2009–19 and led monetary policy reforms emphasizing price stability, a flexible exchange rate, and reserve accumulation.
- The Bank of Jamaica launched a communications campaign, using reggae music, to explain inflation targeting to a public accustomed to focusing on the exchange rate.
Fiscal reform and central bank independence
- Fiscal rules were first established in 2010 and refined in 2014.
- IMF-supported programs Wynter participated in aimed to:
- Address fiscal problems and unstable debt dynamics.
- Help bring inflation under control.
- Avoid misalignments in the exchange rate.
- Wynter’s view:
- An important complement to fiscal rules is central bank independence within an inflation-targeting framework and a flexible exchange rate.
- If the Bank of Jamaica receives a mandate for inflation and greater independence as proposed in new legislation, it will need to explain policy decisions—e.g., raising interest rates when the government advocates cuts—to the public.
Exchange rate regime choice and monetary targeting
- Past practice: Jamaica professed a flexible exchange rate but operated de facto like a crawl-like peg.
- Experience with monetary targeting:
- In the 1990s, targeting monetary aggregates did not work: variables did not perform and the link to inflation broke down.
- Wynter references that studies in other countries show similar results.
- Policy implication:
- The exchange rate regime is a deep policy choice; policy toolkits must be compatible with that choice.
- Wynter judges Jamaica better placed to build resilience and prosperity with a flexible exchange rate.
Integrating policy tools (interest rates, FX intervention, macroprudential measures, capital controls)
- Preconditions and sequencing:
- Small open economies like Jamaica need many years to develop each component well before meaningful integration is possible.
- Fiscal and labor policies must be fitted into any unified macro framework.
- Priority: fix large fiscal deficits first before overemphasizing integrated policy-tool frameworks.
- Persistence and getting one thing right at a time, in the right sequence, underpin successful reforms.
Foreign exchange intervention: rules and discretion
- Central banks should have simple and clear rules about foreign exchange intervention to reassure stakeholders.
- Implementation caveats:
- Rules are not black and white; central banks must preserve discretion.
- Central banks need the ability to move the market decisively and to disrupt behavior that privatizes gains and socializes losses.
- Safeguarding the market against opportunistic behavior is a central bank responsibility.
Communication and building public support
- Role of communication:
- Wynter emphasizes that communication is central in a democratic context; the central bank’s relationship with the public is vital.
- He revised his view: previously thought machinery was 60–70 percent and communication 10 percent of focus; he now assigns communication 30 or 40 percent.
- Poor communication cannot be offset by technical correctness; effective communication is necessary for policy success.
- Practical experience:
- The Bank of Jamaica used reggae music, TV and radio ads, and billboards (e.g., portraying inflation as a monster) to communicate policy goals.
- Wynter notes he has not yet seen the full payoff from these efforts; ultimate payoff is better public understanding and attention to policy decisions.
- A persistent challenge is convincing the public that the central bank is not primarily there to prevent exchange rate movements.
Remaining challenges and outlook
- The “finish line” on the reform path is not yet in sight.
- Key remaining tasks:
- Consolidate fiscal reforms and debt dynamics.
- Continue to build central bank independence and public understanding of inflation targeting.
- Overcome systemic bias toward a more rigid exchange rate.
- Wynter expresses confidence that Jamaica can complete these difficult reforms, drawing on past implementation successes.
Interview: Jamaica’s former central bank governor Brian Wynter – IMF F&D
Content in this bundle
- Mantener el rumbo ● Finanzas y Desarrollo ● Septiembre de 2020
- En première ligne : Garder le cap
- Interview: Jamaica’s former central bank governor Brian Wynter – IMF F&D