Human Stories behind an Era-Defining Crisis
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Human Stories behind an Era-Defining Crisis
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: PRAKASH LOUNGANI
- Published: March 3, 2026
Overview
- Title reviewed: 1929 — Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History–and How It Shattered a Nation
- Author of book reviewed: Andrew Ross Sorkin
- Reviewed by: PRAKASH LOUNGANI, director of the applied economics master’s program at Johns Hopkins University.
- Publication: F&D Magazine, March 2026.
- Book publication details: Penguin Random House, New York, NY, 2025, 592 pp., $35.
- Central claim highlighted: The characters, issues, and policy choices of 1929 “appear to echo our present moment,” Sorkin writes.
Key narrative elements and portraits
- The story is told through the eyes of Charles Mitchell, president of National City Bank (a precursor of Citibank), who promoted widespread stock purchase and borrowing.
- Vivid individual portraits and anecdotes:
- Herbert Hoover is described as someone who “liked to part his hair just slightly to the left of center” and as the first president to have a phone on his desk, used partly to keep abreast of Wall Street.
- Sketches of three US presidents: Warren G. Harding, Calvin Coolidge, and Herbert Hoover.
- Andrew Mellon is presented as treasury secretary under Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover.
- Winston Churchill is depicted as dependent on US patrons and stock market winnings to maintain his lifestyle.
- Archival material illuminates tussles between the White House and the Federal Reserve, with the White House often worried the Fed would snuff out the stock market boom by raising interest rates.
- Senator Carter Glass plays a prominent role; his name is attached to post-1929 financial legislation (Glass-Steagall Act) that brought separation of commercial and investment banking.
Historical outcomes and contrasts with later crises
- The 1929 crash was followed by policy missteps cited in the review:
- The Smoot-Hawley tariff.
- The abandonment of the gold standard.
- Consequence noted: Those policy mistakes “triggered a worldwide depression.”
- Contrast with later episodes:
- The bursting of the dot-com bubble in the 2000s had a far more modest impact on the economy.
- Uncertainty highlighted about a potential AI bubble: “We don’t know if the collapse of the AI bubble will follow in the tracks of the 1929 or dot-com crash.”
Limits of the book’s lessons and author’s conclusion
- Strengths: Deep, granular narrative on the personalities and actions surrounding the 1929 crash; engaging archival detail.
- Limitations: The review finds the book less successful in providing a blueprint for predicting or understanding future crashes—“each crisis is unique and spreads misery in its own way.”
- Sorkin’s concluding admonition quoted in full: “the antidote to irrational exuberance is humility—the humility to know that no system is foolproof, no market fully rational, and no generation exempt. The greater the heights of our certainty, the longer and harder we fall.”
Human Stories behind an Era-Defining Crisis — PRAKASH LOUNGANI, F&D Magazine, March 2026.
Content in this bundle
- Books Loungani