Boom-Bust Cycles in Housing: The Changing Role of Financial Structure
IMF Working Papers, October 1, 2005
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Boom-Bust Cycles in Housing: The Changing Role of Financial Structure
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Calvin Schnure
- Published: October 1, 2005
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9781451862195.001
Summary and central finding
- The mortgage market structure prior to the Savings and Loan crisis contributed to volatility in real housing activity, which amplified volatility in housing prices.
- The development of a national, market-based system of securitized mortgage finance has damped the housing boom-bust cycle.
- Deviations of actual housing prices from values forecast by a model based on economic fundamentals (pricing errors) have fallen significantly since the mid-1980s.
- Tests indicate that the change in financial market structure played a primary role in improving pricing efficiency relative to the reduction of inflation over the same period.
Empirical approach and tests
- The study tests whether pricing errors (deviations of actual housing prices from model-forecasted values) responded to changes in financial structure.
- Comparative tests evaluate the relative importance of:
- Change in financial market structure (rise of a national, market-based securitized mortgage system).
- Reduction of inflation over the period examined.
- Results attribute a primary role to market structure in reducing pricing errors.
Key thematic findings
- Housing market vulnerability:
- Pre-Savings and Loan crisis mortgage market structure increased volatility in housing activity and prices.
- Financial innovation and dampening effects:
- Securitization and a national market-based mortgage finance system reduced boom-bust dynamics.
- Pricing efficiency:
- Pricing errors declined significantly since the mid-1980s, consistent with improved efficiency from market-structure changes.
Policy implications and takeaways
- Market structure reforms that promote national, market-based securitized mortgage finance can reduce housing price volatility and improve pricing efficiency.
- Monitoring the interaction between financial structure and macroeconomic factors (such as inflation) is important to understand sources of housing-market instability.
Calvin Schnure, "Boom-Bust Cycles in Housing: The Changing Role of Financial Structure", October 1, 2005.