Tackling High Inflation in Emerging Markets
IMF News, May 17, 2023
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Tackling High Inflation in Emerging Markets
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Gita Gopinath
- Published: May 17, 2023
Introduction
- Speech delivered by Gita Gopinath, First Deputy Managing Director, IMF, at the Annual Conference of the Central Bank of Brazil, Brasilia, May 17, 2023.
- Focus: how emerging markets (EMs) navigate high, multi-decade inflation amid global monetary tightening.
- Four key questions addressed:
- Why have EMs performed well despite rapid tightening by advanced economies (AEs)?
- What strategy is appropriate to bring core inflation back to targets?
- How should EM central banks respond to financial stresses and tradeoffs with price stability?
- How can fiscal policy support the fight against inflation?
Solid EM Performance Amid Rising Rates
- Empirical observation:
- EMs on average tightened monetary policy starting in mid-2021, earlier than AEs.
- Capital outflows from Latin America have been far smaller than during the Taper Tantrum of 2013.
- Factors underpinning resilience:
- Reforms over the last couple decades lowered credit and currency risks.
- EM central banks improved monetary policy frameworks and increased independence.
- Many EMs moved to greater exchange rate flexibility and flexible inflation targeting.
- Higher policy transparency reduced investor flight during global tightening.
- Central banks’ past success in delivering low inflation helped anchor long-term inflation expectations.
- Financial stability improvements: better-capitalized banks, stronger regulatory/supervisory and macroprudential frameworks.
- Structural reforms: development of local currency bond markets and sizeable FX reserve buffers.
- Improved fiscal frameworks supporting debt sustainability.
- Cautionary note:
- Considerable downside risks from further monetary policy tightening remain; current benign conditions could change.
Inflation Outlook
- Market expectations:
- Markets expect headline inflation to decline fairly quickly to target across EMs and for central banks to begin cutting rates later this year.
- Reality and risks:
- Inflation in many EMs has been unexpectedly high and persistent, with consistent upside surprises.
- Goods inflation has declined sharply or turned negative; services inflation remains strong.
- Labor markets have not cooled substantially; wage growth remains robust in many EMs.
- Concerns that potential output and employment may have fallen since the pandemic, increasing upward pressure on labor costs and inflation.
- Few historical precedents for large declines in very high inflation without significant economic slowdown.
Risk Management Strategy for Monetary Policy
- Drivers of inflation persistence and upside risks:
- Monetary transmission appears less forceful than expected; activity remains relatively strong and unemployment near historic lows.
- Demand rotation from goods to services; services demand is less interest-rate sensitive and more labor intensive.
- Potential output and employment may be lower post-pandemic; supply-chain bottlenecks persist.
- Risk of wage-price dynamics changing if high inflation persists—firms passing on costs and workers seeking compensation.
- EM-specific vulnerabilities: less well-anchored expectations, more prevalent wage and price indexation, higher passthrough of exchange rate and energy shocks to core inflation.
- Modeling insight:
- Structural/New Keynesian model with backward indexation: persistence parameter iP and output gap x.
- Optimal policy implies more aggressive response (pushing output below potential) when inflation persistence is high.
- Passive policy rules calibrated to low persistence can allow inflation to rise much more and require deeper downturns later if corrected belatedly.
- Policy recommendation:
- Central banks should maintain tight policy stances and react aggressively to upside inflation surprises given the possibility of high persistence.
Monetary Policy and Financial Stress
- Differences in stress channels:
- EMs face higher credit and exchange-rate risk, and sovereign vulnerabilities can trigger banking stress; exposure heightened by foreign-currency borrowing, especially short-term.
- Tools available to EM central banks:
- Ex-ante: macroprudential tools and preemptive CFM/MPMs.
- In-stress: longer-term discount window lending, repos, asset purchases, FX lending, and central bank swap lines.
- Past experience: many EMs provided liquidity support during COVID effectively.
- Caveats and tradeoffs:
- Expanding central bank balance sheets while fighting inflation risks confusing policy stance, increasing credit/maturity risk, and political concerns about “picking winners and losers.”
- Interventions should be temporary, targeted, and held to a high bar.
- Analytical guidance:
- The Fund’s integrated policy framework (IPF) helps identify when FX intervention (FXI) and capital-flow management (CFM) measures may improve policy tradeoffs.
- Choice of tools should be guided by market depth, nature of shocks, and analysis of frictions:
- Allow flexible exchange rate if FX markets are reasonably deep and shocks are fundamentals-oriented.
- Stronger case for FXI if FX market depth is low and external investor-sentiment shocks prevail, mindful of intertemporal tradeoffs and potential compromise of FX liquidity provision.
Fiscal Policy and Inflation
- Role for fiscal policy:
- Fiscal authorities should prioritize the most vulnerable while scaling back broad-based fiscal support not warranted in a high inflation environment.
- Fiscal consolidation can help lower inflation without requiring interest rates to rise as much.
- Model-based scenario (stylized two-country DSGE):
- Two approaches to lowering inflation calibrated to produce essentially identical GDP effects:
- Monetary tightening lowers demand via higher interest rates and currency appreciation; increases government debt because of higher debt servicing and worse primary balance.
- Fiscal consolidation cools demand without higher interest rates (interest rates fall somewhat) and the currency tends to depreciate; government debt falls.
- A one-percentage-point-of-GDP fiscal expansion would force heavier monetary tightening to curb inflation or cause inflation to rise and risk de-anchoring.
- Risks of weak fiscal positions:
- Higher public debt in EMs raises vulnerability to sovereign default and tends to raise sovereign spreads.
- Weak fiscal positions can heighten the sovereign-bank nexus and risk of fiscal dominance, complicating monetary policy.
- IMF research shows deteriorating fiscal positions in EMs tend to put upward pressure on long-term inflation expectations.
- Policy recommendation:
- Fiscal restraint mitigates the challenge of bringing down inflation and reduces financial vulnerabilities that complicate monetary policy.
Conclusion and Policy Priorities
- Main conclusions:
- Markets may be too optimistic about how easily inflation will decline in EMs; upside inflation risks are sizeable.
- Central banks must remain resolute in keeping policies tight; insufficient tightening now could require more painful actions later.
- Fiscal restraint supports monetary policy and helps reduce financial vulnerabilities.
- Financial tools can improve policy tradeoffs if used judiciously, temporary, and targeted.
- Institutional priorities for EM authorities:
- Refine and strengthen monetary, fiscal, and financial policy frameworks.
- Maintain central bank independence and enhance transparency and communication.
- Continue building robust monetary and financial frameworks that allow countercyclical policies and help navigate future tightening episodes.
Source: "Tackling High Inflation in Emerging Markets," Gita Gopinath, Speech at Annual Conference of the Central Bank of Brazil, May 17, 2023.