Kuwait-2011 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement
IMF News, May 9, 2011
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Kuwait-2011 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: May 9, 2011
I. Introduction
- IMF mission visited Kuwait during April 27–May 9 to hold discussions for the 2011 Article IV consultation.
- Discussions focused on: near-term economic policies; medium-term fiscal reform; a strategy for sustained economic growth; and measures to maintain financial stability.
- Mission engaged government and central bank officials, a parliamentarian, and private sector representatives.
II. Recent Developments
- Growth and activity
- Real GDP growth in 2010 is estimated at 3.3 percent (oil growth of 3.2 percent; non-oil growth of 3.4 percent).
- Bank lending to the private sector increased modestly; higher lending of 3.3 percent to productive sectors partly offset by reduced credit to real estate and financial sectors.
- KSE index declined by over 6 percent in 2011 through May 5; equity prices declined across all sectors since late January.
- Kuwait increased oil production to assist in stabilizing the global oil market.
- Fiscal position
- Government expenditure in FY2010/11—excluding energy-related subsidies and recapitalization of social security—is estimated to have increased by 21½ percent.
- Half of this growth attributable to the Amiri grant (KD 1,000 cash transfer to each Kuwaiti citizen; equivalent to almost 3 percent of 2010 GDP).
- Oil export receipts increased by 19 percent in 2010.
- Fiscal and external surpluses in 2010 are estimated at about 21 and 29 percent of GDP, respectively (compared to 28 and 24 percent in 2009).
- Inflation
- Headline inflation increased in 2010, driven primarily by higher international food prices.
- Average food inflation about 8½ percent in 2010 (3¼ percent in 2009).
- Non-food inflation around 3 percent in 2010.
- Banking and Investment Companies (ICs)
- Local banks’ profits increased by 70 percent in 2010; capital adequacy strengthened.
- Banks’ share prices rose over 40 percent in 2010.
- ICs posted losses on average in 2010 (lower than 2009), with unresolved debt restructuring for some ICs.
- Nonfinancial corporate sector leverage and resilience improved in 2010, except in the real estate sector.
- KIA announced establishment of a KD1bn portfolio ($3.6bn or 2 percent of 2011 GDP) for investment in local commercial real estate.
III. Economic Outlook and Risks
- Baseline projections for 2011
- Real GDP projected to increase by about 5.2 percent (oil GDP about 3.6 percent; non-oil GDP just over 6 percent).
- Inflation projected to pick up in 2011 to about 6 percent.
- Broad money projected to increase by about 16 percent; credit to private sector rising by over 6 percent.
- Fiscal balance expected to improve by almost 6 percentage points to 26½ percent of GDP in 2011, despite projected growth of 12 percent in 2011/12 expenditure.
- External current account balance projected to increase to 34½ percent of GDP.
- Domestic risks
- Primary domestic downside risk: significant shortfall in meeting DP spending targets due to red tape, bureaucratic hurdles, and political gridlock.
- Further deterioration or delayed restructuring of ICs could increase banking sector provisions and weigh on banks’ profitability.
- Regional and external risks
- Deterioration in regional political/economic environment (particularly Bahrain and Egypt) could affect Kuwait via: (i) losses on Kuwaiti investment in the GCC and MENA region affecting ICs; (ii) direct exposure of Kuwaiti banks to the region; (iii) tighter and more costly external funding.
- Regional risks may be accompanied by higher oil prices, which would mitigate impacts on Kuwait.
- Fiscal and current account breakeven oil prices at $51 and $35 per barrel, respectively; these remain significantly lower than current prices at the time of the mission.
- Sustained decline in oil prices tied to a derailed global recovery could affect prospects for government expenditure.
IV. Policy Discussions
A. Strategy for Sustained Economic Growth
- General
- Development Plan (DP) emphasizes investment in health, education, infrastructure, and preparing Kuwaiti nationals for private sector employment.
- Implementation weaknesses and distortions need addressing to achieve DP objectives.
- DP implementation—authorities should ensure:
- (i) enhancement of the business environment, streamlined procedures, and needed legislative base for efficient project screening and implementation;
- (ii) establishment of appropriate project design with internal rates of return and a proper framework for risk sharing between public and private sectors;
- (iii) adequate outcomes via viability evaluation and regular productivity reviews, including qualitative targets on health and education;
- (iv) accounting for absorptive capacity and supply constraints to avoid resurgence of inflation;
- (v) avoidance of buildup of excessive private sector leverage.
- Pursue initiatives to diversify financing channels, including development of a corporate debt market.
- Labor sector policies—issues and recommendations
- Generous public sector compensation raises reservation wages of nationals, undermining private sector employment objectives.
- Administrative measures (minimum sectoral quotas) are largely ineffective and create distortions.
- Consistent labor sector policies and containment of wage bill growth needed to align incentives and limit recurring increases in current expenditure.
B. Medium-term Fiscal Reform
- Key observations
- Fiscal distortions (large subsidies; low non-oil revenue contribution) likely to be exacerbated as growth picks up.
- Domestic subsidies cost over 20 percent of total expenditure; oil-related subsidies account for about 95 percent of subsidies.
- Growth strategy based on input subsidies, low taxation, and rapid current expenditure growth implies high and inefficient transfers of oil resources to the non-oil economy.
- Government current expenditures have expanded rapidly—wages, subsidies, transfers—increasing breakeven prices and fiscal vulnerability.
- Policy options (medium-to-long-term)
- Reforms to the tax system: welcome planned introduction of a VAT in 2013 (in conjunction with planned GCC-wide VAT); priority should be placed on VAT implementation over comprehensive income tax since VAT already provides broad-based taxation.
- Gradual reduction of untargeted subsidies, complemented by efficient and well-targeted safety nets (use census results to establish such systems).
- Containment of growth in the public sector wage bill; adopt a public sector wage policy to support increased Kuwaiti participation in private sector and fiscal sustainability.
- Adoption of a fiscal rule for medium-term fiscal management would be useful.
C. Near-term Macroeconomic Policy Mix
- Fiscal policy
- Continued fiscal stimulus expected to support non-oil recovery but should be moderated if overheating emerges.
- Non-oil fiscal deficit estimated to have increased by close to 6½ percentage points in FY2010/11 with a projected decrease of 1 percentage point in FY2011/12.
- Planned capital expenditure increases have strong contemporaneous impact on non-oil growth due to high fiscal multipliers and support medium/long-term diversification.
- Continued fiscal stimulus appropriate given modest non-oil GDP recovery, weak private investment, and moderate non-food inflationary pressures; moderate expenditure if overheating signs appear.
- Progress toward establishment of a macro-fiscal unit at the Ministry of Finance and plans to move to performance-based budgeting welcomed.
- Monetary policy and exchange rate
- Monetary policy expected to remain accommodative, reflecting the basket peg and low global interest rates.
- CBK adjusted policy rates in line with domestic credit conditions and low global rates; sizable public sector deposits remained in the banking system.
- Exchange rate movements can offset some pass-through of commodity price increases but limited by large weight of U.S. dollar in the currency basket.
- Preliminary assessment: dinar broadly in line with fundamentals—equilibrium real exchange rate approach suggests moderate undervaluation in the range of 0–10 percent; macroeconomic balance approach implies overvaluation of 13.5 percent; external sustainability approach suggests overvaluation of 9.1 percent—on balance, broadly in line.
- Macroprudential policy
- Fiscal policy should be first line of defense to manage the financial cycle associated with the oil cycle.
- Given the basket peg, macroprudential policies are particularly important.
- Kuwait has macroprudential tools that could be time-varying; authorities ready to consider other macroprudential measures if needed.
D. Bolstering Financial Sector Monitoring and Regulation
- Banking sector performance
- Capital adequacy ratio increased to 19 percent in 2010 from 17 percent in 2009.
- Leverage ratios average 13 percent.
- Credit growth virtually flat in 2010; NPL ratio dropped to 8.9 percent after write-offs of fully-provisioned loans; ROE reached 9.1 percent.
- Significant precautionary provisioning maintained in 2010 and 2011.
- Liquidity appears adequate based on stable deposit base and significant public sector deposits.
- Investment Companies (ICs)
- ICs remain precarious: continued losses in 2010 originating mostly from equities and real estate investment.
- External financing accounts for approximately 25 percent of ICs’ liabilities as of December 2010.
- Sector remains highly dependent on foreign financing despite deleveraging.
- Setbacks in debt restructuring; potential for consolidation constrained by family business groups and judicial/structural impediments.
- Stress test findings
- Banking sector can withstand significant shocks; under most adverse scenario maximum recapitalization need would not exceed 2 percent of GDP to restore CAR to statutory 12 percent.
- Single-factor tests underscore vulnerability to real estate and equity exposure, but recapitalization needs appear manageable.
- ICs in stress test sample (11 listed ICs with 29 percent share of total ICs’ assets) show very limited capacity to withstand shocks; under severe scenario (20 to 66 percent default rates) capital of eight out of eleven ICs could be wiped out.
- Regulatory and supervisory progress and recommendations
- New ICs regulations issued by CBK in June 2010 setting limits on liquidity, leverage, and foreign exposure.
- CMA issued full bylaws and expected to assume supervisory role in September 2011.
- MoU between CBK and CMA being drafted to delineate supervisory responsibilities over ICs.
- Core team set up to strengthen macroprudential supervision; progress on analytical tools: quarterly off-site surveillance, stress tests, and early warning system.
- Recommendations:
- Finalize MoU to close gaps and limit overlap, ensuring efficient oversight architecture.
- CMA should ensure adequate staffing (quantity and quality) commensurate with development stage and instrument sophistication.
- CBK should monitor compliance with 2012 quantitative regulations for ICs and ensure restructuring progress.
- Establish a special resolution regime (SRR) for financial institutions and special courts to adjudicate restructuring/exits expeditiously.
- AML/CFT
- AML/CFT framework started in 2002 but needs strengthening, particularly: criminalization of financing of terrorism, structure/functions of FIU, and AML/CFT supervisory system.
- Authorities to draw on recommendations of assessment report adopted in June 2011; a new AML/CFT Law complying with FATF 40+9 recommendations needs to be adopted urgently.
V. Other Issues
- Statistics and data
- CBK publishes comprehensive monetary and financial statistics; progress in improving BOP compilation, coverage, and periodicity with IMF TA; IIP and external debt data still provided with lag.
- CSO organizational changes eliminated long CPI compilation lags; national accounts at constant prices delayed with latest data covering 2007.
- Authorities encouraged to provide financial and institutional support to CSO to improve quality and frequency of statistics.
Key numerical findings and projections (selected)
- Real GDP growth: 2010 = 3.3 percent; 2011 projection = about 5.2 percent.
- Oil growth 2010 = 3.2 percent; non-oil growth 2010 = 3.4 percent.
- Headline food inflation 2010 = about 8½ percent; non-food inflation ~3 percent in 2010.
- Government expenditure FY2010/11 (excluding energy-related subsidies and social security recapitalization) estimated increase = 21½ percent.
- Amiri grant: KD 1,000 per Kuwaiti citizen (about US$3,600; equivalent to almost 3 percent of 2010 GDP).
- Oil export receipts increased by 19 percent in 2010.
- Fiscal and external surpluses 2010 ≈ 21 percent and 29 percent of GDP, respectively.
- 2011 projections: fiscal balance improving to 26½ percent of GDP; external current account to 34½ percent of GDP.
- Broad money projected increase in 2011 ≈ 16 percent; private sector credit rising by over 6 percent.
- Banking sector: capital adequacy ratio 2010 = 19 percent (from 17 percent in 2009); ROE 2010 = 9.1 percent; NPL ratio 2010 = 8.9 percent.
- ICs external financing share ≈ 25 percent as of December 2010.
- Stress test: maximum bank recapitalization need under adverse scenario ≤ 2 percent of GDP.
- Kuwaiti Investment Authority local commercial real estate portfolio: KD1bn ($3.6bn or 2 percent of 2011 GDP).
International Monetary Fund staff concluding statement, May 9, 2011.