2012 Article IV Consultation with Japan: Concluding Statement of the IMF Mission
IMF News, June 12, 2012
Source details
- Canonical URL
- 2012 Article IV Consultation with Japan: Concluding Statement of the IMF Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: June 12, 2012
I. Outlook and Risks
- Recent performance and near-term projection highlights:
- Real GDP declined by ¾ percent in 2011 but grew at an annualized rate of 4¾ percent in the first quarter of 2012.
- Growth is expected to reach about 2 percent in 2012 supported by public reconstruction spending of around 1½ percent of GDP.
- For 2013, real GDP growth is projected to slow slightly to 1¾ percent.
- Headline inflation has risen modestly, but IMF staff expect inflation to remain around zero in the next two years under current policies.
- Table 1. Japan: Near-Term Projections (Calendar Year, Growth Rate)
- Real GDP: 2010 = 4.4; 2011 = -0.7; 2012 = 2.0; 2013 = 1.7
- Total domestic demand: 2010 = 2.7; 2011 = 0.1; 2012 = 2.4; 2013 = 1.4
- Net exports (contribution): 2010 = -0.8; 2011 = -0.3; 2012 = 0.3
- CPI inflation (average): 2010 = 0.0
- Current account balance (in percent of GDP): 2010 = 3.6; 2011 = 2.2
- General government primary balance: 2010 = -8.7; 2011 = -9.1; 2012 = -8.9; 2013 = -7.5
- Gross debt (in percent of GDP): 2010 = 215.3; 2011 = 229.7; 2012 = 235.8; 2013 = 241.1
- Net debt (in percent of GDP): 2010 = 112.8; 2011 = 126.6; 2012 = 135.2; 2013 = 142.7
- Source: IMF staff estimates.
- Downside risks:
- Escalation of European turmoil or sharper-than-expected slowing of China would hurt exports and growth.
- Flight to safety could cause exchange rate volatility, further appreciate the yen, depress equity prices, and weaken confidence.
- Complete closure of nuclear plants combined with an unusually hot summer could disrupt activity (mitigated by conservation efforts).
- Upside possibilities:
- Faster than expected recovery in consumer and business sentiment.
- Reopening of some nuclear power plants limiting disruption.
II. Securing Fiscal Sustainability
- Current fiscal challenges:
- Net public debt has increased nearly ten-fold over the last two decades to more than 125 percent of GDP.
- Population aging has raised social security spending; weak growth and deflation have depressed tax revenues.
- IMF staff assessment and recommended fiscal path:
- IMF staff fully support the government’s plan to raise the consumption tax rate; passage of legislation to double the rate to 10 percent in stages by 2015 is crucial.
- IMF staff estimate the authorities’ current plan (consumption tax increase, withdrawal of financial crisis stimulus, planned curbs to non-social security fiscal spending) will achieve a 5 percent of GDP improvement in the structural primary balance by 2020.
- IMF staff advise an additional 5 percent of GDP adjustment on top of current plans to achieve an overall fiscal consolidation of 10 percent of GDP over the next decade.
- This would achieve a primary surplus of about 3 percent of GDP by the early 2020s and put the public-debt-to-GDP ratio on a clear downward path.
- IMF staff recommend expenditure restraint of 2½ percent of GDP over the next decade by curbing growth in nominal spending.
- Adopting a clear timeframe for further revenue increases beyond 2015 is advised to bolster confidence.
- Possible fiscal measures and design principles (many already publicly debated):
- Increase the consumption tax to a uniform rate of at least 15 percent; use targeted transfers to lower-income households rather than multiple tax rates.
- Cut the corporate tax rate further, beyond the planned reduction to 35 percent in 2015.
- Broaden the personal income tax base, including reducing the exemption for pension income and eliminating the tax deduction for dependent spouses.
- Reduce social security spending, including: raise the pension retirement age to 67; collect contributions from dependent spouses; claw back benefits from wealthy retirees.
- Use savings to fund payroll tax reductions and targeted transfers to low-income households; introduce a uniform tax identification number.
- Projected debt outcomes under policy scenarios:
- Policy adjustment scenario: net public debt stabilizes at around 150 percent of GDP by mid decade and then falls gradually to 125 percent of GDP by 2030.
- Upside (Growth Strategy) scenario: forceful structural reforms and higher real growth and inflation could push net public-debt-to-GDP ratio to around 115 percent of GDP by 2030.
- Institutional fiscal framework recommendations:
- Adopt a medium-term budget framework with a strict overall spending limit and ministry-by-ministry spending targets; restrict supplementary budgets.
- Increase disclosure of tax expenditures.
- Consider a legally-binding fiscal rule targeting a primary surplus once consolidation is on track.
III. Raising Growth Through Structural Reforms
- Growth challenge and objective:
- Aim to raise growth from 1 to 2 percent to help reduce the public debt-to-GDP ratio; achieving this would be ambitious but has precedents in several advanced economies.
- Key constraints to growth to address:
- Decline in labor supply due to aging, low female labor force participation, domestic sector regulations, limited availability of risk capital.
- Structural reform areas and policy options:
- Increasing the labor force:
- Expand childcare facilities (including through deregulation).
- Eliminate the tax deduction for dependent spouses.
- Raise the retirement age to above 65 years.
- Introduce a uniform regular employment contract which phases in employment protection to facilitate mobility and fairness.
- Increase immigration (broaden the recently introduced “points-based” system) to meet labor shortages in sectors such as long-term nursing care.
- Raising productivity and encouraging investment:
- Ease regulations limiting development of services (health, old-age care); reform electricity and agricultural sectors.
- Encourage inward and outward FDI and pursue high-quality free trade agreements with key Asian and European partners; join the Trans Pacific Partnership to catalyze regional integration and reforms in services and agriculture.
- Improving financial intermediation:
- Scale down government-backed guarantees for SME loans; phase out the temporary SME Financial Facilitation Act by March 2013.
- Reduce the role of the government in channeling credit (including by fully privatizing Japan Post).
- Encourage asset-based lending (inventories and accounts receivable).
- With reform and financial strengthening, public pension funds could become an additional source of investment capital.
IV. Exiting Deflation
- Deflation’s impact:
- Mild deflation for over a decade has lowered private investment and consumption, sustained high real interest rates, raised real debt levels, reduced tax revenue, and complicated containment of real spending—contributing to rising public-debt-to-GDP.
- Policy mix needed:
- A comprehensive package: powerful monetary easing, structural reforms to boost confidence and domestic demand, and strong medium-term fiscal consolidation to facilitate additional monetary accommodation.
- Assessment of Bank of Japan (BoJ) actions:
- IMF staff welcome BoJ measures: adoption in February of a medium to long-term price stability goal of 1 percent; sizeable asset purchases over the past year.
- IMF staff inflation projection and view on easing:
- IMF staff project inflation to rise to ½ percent in 2014 and to reach 1 percent only by 2017, even after recent easing.
- The asset purchase program could be expanded substantially beyond current plans to increase the likelihood of achieving the 1 percent inflation goal by end 2014 under the IMF staff’s outlook.
- Extending the maturity of Japanese Government Bond (JGB) purchases beyond 3 years could reduce medium-term lending rates.
- Purchases of private assets (corporate bonds, equities, highly-rated securitized SME loans) could stimulate activity by boosting asset prices.
- Communication enhancements for the BoJ:
- Extend its inflation forecast to 3 years or beyond to better guide expectations.
- Clarify willingness to react effectively to changes in the baseline economic outlook.
- Emphasize that the 1 percent inflation goal is not a ceiling; a higher inflation rate could be allowed when food and energy prices rise temporarily or the consumption tax rate is increased.
- Once inflation nears 1 percent, consider increasing the inflation goal to create a larger buffer against deflationary shocks.
V. Policy Response to a Downside Scenario
- Monetary policy:
- Further easing of monetary policy would be advisable if growth worsens sharply.
- Fiscal policy:
- Fiscal policy could play a role but is constrained by limited fiscal space.
- Maintain the medium-term fiscal target while allowing automatic stabilizers to work.
- In a severe downturn, small and targeted fiscal measures could be introduced as long as JGB yields remain low.
- It would not be advisable to delay legislation to increase the consumption tax given its importance as a signal of commitment to consolidation.
- Financial market disruptions:
- If markets are disrupted by heightened global turmoil, authorities could provide additional liquidity to affected markets and consider tailored actions to address market disruptions.
VI. Financial Policies to Safeguard Stability
- FSAP update broad findings:
- Financial system has remained stable amid recent global strains.
- Financial regulation and supervision have been effective in encouraging large banks to strengthen capital positions and building resilience of insurers.
- Direct exposures to peripheral European countries are small; non-performing loans remain low.
- Swift liquidity injection and coordinated central bank action lowered dollar funding costs in late 2011.
- Key financial sector vulnerabilities:
- Banks’ core profitability remains low.
- Large holdings of JGBs (about one-fifth of banks’ total assets) raise interest rate risk concerns.
- Sizable equity holdings expose major banks and non-life insurers to equity price declines.
- In an unlikely prolonged growth shock combined with a sharp rise in government bond yields, financial stability might be challenged.
- Expansion of Japanese financial institutions abroad (notably in emerging Asia) presents supervisory challenges to monitor cross-border exposures.
- FSAP Update recommendations:
- Risk monitoring:
- Put in place thematic risk assessments to monitor readiness to manage systemic risks.
- BOJ and Financial Services Agency (FSA) should intensify information sharing and oversight of systemically relevant financial institutions, markets, and infrastructure.
- Prudential framework:
- Tighten large exposure limits on bank lending and raise capital requirements for domestic-oriented banks.
- Encourage regional and shinkin banks to improve profitability to enhance their growth-supporting role and build resilience.
- For insurers, base solvency assessment on an economic valuation, taking into account the full time horizon of insurance contracts.
- FSA should review adequacy of skills and resources given the global regulatory reform agenda.
- Strengthen supervision of private pension funds.
- Crisis resolution:
- Explore improvements in the crisis resolution framework to ensure orderly resolution for systemically-important nonbank financial institutions.
Mission Concluding Statement. June 12, 2012. 2012 Article IV Consultation with Japan: Concluding Statement of the IMF Mission.
Content in this bundle
References
- Japan and the IMF
- Mission Concluding Statements
- https://www.imf.org/external/mmedia/view.aspx?vid=1685946162001
- Press Release: IMF Team Completes the 2012 Article IV Consultation Discussions with Japan
- Japan: Solid Recovery, But Europe Dampens Outlook
- PRESS CENTER
- Article IV
- https://www.imf.org/en/home