Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes 2002 Article IV Consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands-Aruba
IMF News, March 3, 2003
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes 2002 Article IV Consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands-Aruba
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: March 3, 2003
Background
- On February 24, 2003, the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) concluded the Article IV consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands—Aruba.
- Economic performance and outlook:
- After growing at over 4 percent per year in 1996-2000, GDP fell an estimated 1.2 percent in 2001 and 3.8 percent in 2002.
- Downturn causes: a lull in investment activity and especially weak tourism following the U.S. recession and the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.
- 2003 outlook: "sharply higher private and public investment and a modest revival in tourism should boost economic growth to over 4 percent."
- Medium-term outlook: "With higher tourism capacity and continued sustained investment, economic growth should remain around 3 percent in the medium-term."
- Inflation and external position:
- Exchange rate pegged to the U.S. dollar; inflation averaged 2.7 percent in the 1990s.
- Inflation accelerated in the second half of 2002, reaching 4.5 percent in November, driven by higher energy prices, indirect taxes, and faster credit growth after controls were suspended.
- External accounts: "remain in a comfortable position, and net foreign assets are above the central bank target of 5-6 months of imports."
- Banking sector: "highly liquid and well capitalized despite the downturn, but interest rates remain high because of a lack of competition."
- Fiscal developments:
- Government deficit worsened from 0.2 percent of GDP in 2000 to an estimated 4.9 percent in 2002 (including health care).
- Off-budgetary outlays of almost 6 percent of GDP related to past guarantees to foreign investors were realized in 2002.
- Government measures taken: froze public sector wage indexation for three years and raised excise rates in the second half of 2002.
- Planned/introduced reforms: new indirect tax on imports and services planned for 2003; New Fiscal Regime for corporate income introduced to result in more uniform taxation of corporate profits and dividends; phasing out of previous offshore and tax holiday regime while retaining incentives for export-oriented activities through an imputation system.
- Availability: The staff report for the 2002 Article IV consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands—Aruba is available.
Executive Board Assessment — Findings and Risks
- Commendations and general view:
- Directors commended the authorities for their record of sustained economic growth and low inflation and noted Aruba's high per capita income in the region.
- Directors expected growth to resume in 2003 barring new adverse shocks, spurred by sharply higher private and public investment and a modest recovery in tourism.
- Emphasis on improving public finances and strengthening resilience as a basis for sustained macroeconomic stability and future growth.
- Monetary policy and exchange rate:
- Directors considered the current exchange rate regime appropriate.
- Concern: "the high inflation differential with the United States could threaten competitiveness."
- Welcomed authorities' decision to tighten monetary policy by reemploying credit controls.
- Encouraged move from direct to indirect instruments of monetary policy to ensure better allocation of credit and more effective competition in the banking sector; transition should be gradual to avoid losing monetary control.
- Encouraged authorities to avail themselves of technical assistance to support these efforts.
- Fiscal policy and public finances:
- Main policy challenge: strengthen public finances.
- Directors viewed the authorities' objective of a balanced budget by 2007 as appropriate in the medium term, but noted more adjustment would be required in the long run to address population ageing.
- Need for greater progress towards balance in the 2003 budget, including measures to durably restrain growth in current spending.
- Specific fiscal reform priorities:
- Implement as soon as possible reforms of the public employee pension system and the civil service.
- Take actions to curb the growth of health care spending.
- Improve transparency of fiscal accounts, particularly through regular provision of government financial statistics.
- Abandon practice of financing the deficit through the accumulation of arrears.
- Tax policy and administration:
- Aruba's revenue-to-GDP ratio was low, especially relative to the region.
- Encouraged addressing weaknesses in tax administration as an important prerequisite for introducing a broad-based indirect tax, and to simplify the income tax.
- Noted decision to delay the introduction of the new tax on imports and services; most Directors encouraged its implementation as soon as possible.
- Welcomed the New Fiscal Regime for corporations for more uniform taxation of corporate income, including phasing out the offshore and tax holiday regime.
- Overall tax system objectives: "simplicity, equity, and transparency."
- Financial sector, anti-money laundering, and telecommunications:
- Commended progress in strengthening financial sector supervision and regulation, in line with Offshore Financial Sector assessment recommendations.
- To strengthen anti-money laundering regulation, encouraged quick passage of legislation to bring money transfer companies and company service providers in the offshore sector under central bank supervision.
- Supported decision to turn the telecommunications company into a private law company and introduce competition in the mobile phone market; urged continuation by increasing operational autonomy of other public sector activities and later selling shares to private investors.
- Statistics and data:
- Commended publication of national accounts in current prices.
- Urged intensifying efforts to fill statistical gaps in labor markets and government finances, and to further develop national accounts data.
Policy Recommendations and Actions Encouraged by Directors
- Monetary and financial sector:
- Tighten monetary policy (reemployment of credit controls).
- Gradually switch from direct to indirect monetary instruments; seek technical assistance.
- Increase competition in banking to lower interest rates.
- Strengthen anti-money laundering legislation and supervision (bring money transfer companies and company service providers under central bank supervision).
- Fiscal and tax policy:
- Aim for a balanced budget by 2007; undertake additional long-run adjustment for population ageing.
- Enhance 2003 budget consolidation: durably restrain growth in current spending.
- Reform public employee pension system and civil service promptly.
- Curb growth of health care spending.
- Improve fiscal transparency and regular provision of government financial statistics; stop financing deficits via accumulation of arrears.
- Strengthen tax administration; introduce broad-based indirect tax and simplify income tax; implement new tax on imports and services as soon as possible.
- Implement New Fiscal Regime for corporations and phase out offshore/tax holiday regime while retaining export incentives through imputation system.
- Structural reforms:
- Increase operational autonomy of public sector activities and consider privatization through share sales.
- Improve statistical coverage for labor markets and government finances.
Kingdom of the Netherlands—Aruba: Selected Economic Indicators (1998–2002)
- Real economy (Percent change)
- Real GDP: 1998: 6.7; 1999: 1.3; 2000: 3.6; 2001: -1.2; 2002: -3.8
- Nominal GDP: 1998: 8.7; 1999: 7.8; 2000: 1.7; 2001: -0.7; 2002:
- Real final consumption: 1998: 5.0; 1999: 4.7; 2000: -3.3; 2001: 6.8; 2002:
- Real investment: 1998: 11.8; 1999: -8.0; 2000: -9.3; 2001: -17.4; 2002: 3.0
- Real exports: 1998: 2.8; 1999: -4.2; 2000: -4.7; 2001: -11.4; 2002:
- Real imports: 1998: 3.5; 1999: 2.2; 2000: -14.3; 2001: -2.9; 2002: -1.6
- Inflation (period average) CPI (Aruba): 1998: 1.9; 1999: 2.3; 2000: 4.0; 2001: 2.9; 2002: 3.2
- Real exchange rate index (1995=100)1: 1998: 101.2; 1999: 101.3; 2000: 102.0; 2001: 103.7; 2002:
- Balance of payments (In millions of U.S. dollars)
- Current account: 1998: -347.9; 1999: 294.9; 2000: 410.2; 2001: -75.5; 2002:
- Balance of payments (In percent of GDP)
- Current account: 1998: -0.9; 1999: -20.2; 2000: 15.9; 2001: 21.7; 2002: -4.0
- Non-oil current account: 1998: -129.4; 1999: -249.1; 2000: -211.1; 2001: -168.8; 2002: -224.7
- Non-oil current account (In percent of GDP): 1998: -7.8; 1999: -14.4; 2000: -8.9; 2001: -12.0; 2002:
- Financial and capital account: 1998: 102.8; 1999: 368.1; 2000: -313.5; 2001: -324.1; 2002: 147.9
- Errors and omissions: 1998: 1.2; 1999: -9.4; 2000: -7.5; 2001: -10.6; 2002: 5.6
- Change in reserves (- = increase)2: 1998: -51.9; 1999: 15.0; 2000: -82.8; 2001: -78.0; 2002:
- Monetary aggregates
- Net foreign assets: 1998: 40.4; 1999: 3.4; 2000: -8.1; 2001: 25.4; 2002: 25.8
- Net domestic assets: 1998: 1.8; 1999: 14.4; 2000: 7.7; 2001: -2.7; 2002: 5.1
- Quasi-money: 1998: 11.7; 1999: -0.2; 2000:
- Public finances central government
- Balance: 1998: 1.4; 1999: -2.6; 2000: -3.6; 2001:
- External debt: 1998: 13.1; 1999: 11.9; 2000: 11.3; 2001: 11.6; 2002: 15.2
- Domestic debt: 1998: 17.5; 1999: 18.2; 2000: 19.0; 2001: 22.4; 2002: 22.8
- Exchange rate
- "The Aruban florin is pegged to the U.S. at Af.1.79=US$1"
- SDR (end of period): 1998: 2.52; 1999: 2.46; 2000: 2.33; 2001: 2.25; 2002: 2.37
- Sources: Data provided by the Aruban authorities; and IMF staff estimates.
- Notes:
- 1 Relative to the U.S. dollar. CPI based. Period average.
- 2 Including gold, excluding revaluation differences.
IMF Public Information Notice — March 3, 2003. IM F EXTERNAL RELATIONS DEPARTMENT, Public Affairs, Media Relations.