Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Concludes 2008 Article IV Consultation with the Republic of Estonia
IMF News, March 10, 2009
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Concludes 2008 Article IV Consultation with the Republic of Estonia
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: March 10, 2009
Background and Economic Developments
- Estonia’s economy was already decelerating when the global financial crisis erupted, following an outstanding performance since the early 1990s that ended in a strong credit boom and overheating in 2005-07.
- Pre-crisis imbalances and developments:
- Real estate market surged; real estate prices are now more than 20 percent below peak levels.
- Output growth rose well above potential in 2005-07 and began declining in late 2007, turning strongly negative in 2008.
- Inflation reached double-digits in mid-2008 due to demand pressures and external/internal shocks, and is now decelerating sharply.
- The external current account deficit nearly halved between 2007 and 2008, driven largely by a demand-driven compression of imports and a drop in income outflows (fall in profits to foreign-owned companies and banks).
- Exports continued to grow modestly despite an appreciation of the real exchange rate, aided by improved terms of trade and a recovery of oil transit trade with Russia.
- Drivers of the recession:
- Domestic demand contraction dominated the downturn as the credit crunch squeezed investment and declining consumer confidence reduced consumption.
- Stock market index, which had soared in 2006, dropped below its pre-boom level.
Labor Market and Wages
- Real wages continued to run ahead of productivity growth in 2008, compressing profits from their (exceptionally strong) 2006-07 level.
- Nominal wage growth slowed from over 20 percent in 2007 to about 15 percent in 2008; reports of cancelled or reduced bonuses were noted.
- Unemployment and labor slack:
- Unemployment rate jumped by more than 2 percentage points in the third quarter of 2008 to above 6 percent.
- Evidence of a shrinking number of vacancies and widespread layoffs indicates large forthcoming slack in the labor market.
- Structural policy note:
- Executive Directors supported the new labor contract law intended to reduce labor market rigidities and improve the social safety net.
Financial Sector Resilience and Risks
- Banking sector structure and external support:
- Estonia’s banks are almost entirely owned by large Nordic groups with centralized liquidity management.
- Banks have had access to liquidity through their parents (albeit at higher prices) and benefited from liquidity support and guarantees by home country authorities.
- Eesti Pank and the Sveriges Riksbank concluded an arrangement to allow expanded provision of liquidity to subsidiaries of Swedish banks if needed.
- Capitalization and asset quality:
- Strong profits in recent years strengthened banks’ buffers; regulatory limits are conservative.
- Nonperforming loans (NPLs) more than tripled in 2008, though from a very low level, undermining expected profit.
- Regulatory and liquidity measures:
- Authorities took decisive steps to strengthen the bank resolution framework and financial safety nets, including regional safety net cooperation agreements.
- Changes to the deposit guarantee scheme were welcomed as reducing incentives for bank runs.
- The swap agreement between the Estonian and Swedish central banks was endorsed as underpinning a framework for emergency liquidity assistance to large banks.
- Directors supported continued regional coordination of supervisory activities and exchange of information.
Fiscal Position and Policy Recommendations
- Fiscal history and recent changes:
- Estonia’s track record of fiscal surpluses allowed accumulation of fiscal reserves crucial for stability in the global crisis.
- Large structural expenditure increases, particularly in the wage bill and pensions over 2007-08, contributed to driving the general government balance into deficit in 2008, the first such deficit since the beginning of the decade.
- These expenditure patterns, together with the recession, risk setting the stage for continued deficits over the medium term absent corrective measures.
- Authorities’ fiscal measures and IMF assessment:
- Planned substantial fiscal restraint in 2009 aimed to keep the fiscal deficit within the Maastricht ceiling of 3 percent of GDP; Directors commended this stance.
- Important steps to rein in the fiscal deficit included:
- A freeze on the wage bill for 2009-10 (to signal wage moderation in the private sector).
- Cuts in operational expenditures.
- Postponement of previously agreed tax reductions and pension increases.
- Directors encouraged achieving a modest structural fiscal surplus over the medium term and supported the authorities’ intention to review medium-term expenditures and revenue policies.
- Directors’ view on macroeconomic trade-offs:
- The fiscal stance was considered necessary to support the currency board and would have only a modest impact on activity given the open economy.
Executive Board Assessment and Policy Priorities
- Overall assessment:
- Directors commended progress in economic convergence and deepening ties with the European Union.
- Considerable financial buffers had been built, but sizable vulnerabilities accumulated following the domestic consumption and housing boom fueled by high credit growth.
- With global deleveraging, Estonia had entered a severe recession that would test flexibility and resilience.
- Policy priorities for recovery:
- Revival of foreign and domestic demand.
- Continued financial stability.
- Prudent macroeconomic management to support recovery.
- Exchange rate and euro accession:
- Directors agreed the currency board arrangement has served Estonia well by anchoring expectations and policies.
- Contagion risks have heightened; Directors considered that euro accession would provide a safer haven.
- Staff assessment: the real effective exchange rate is somewhat overvalued, but competitiveness is projected to remain adequate as real wage increases are aligned with productivity.
- Structural policies:
- Directors stressed the importance of market flexibility to facilitate real adjustment, including reallocation of resources from the non-traded to the tradable sector and from low wage to high-value added activities.
Republic of Estonia: Selected Economic Indicators (annual unless noted)
- Real Economy (in units as indicated)
- Real GDP growth (in percent): 2003: 7.1; 2004: 7.5; 2005: 9.2; 2006: 10.4; 2007: 6.3
- Average HICP inflation (in percent): 2003: 1.4; 2004: 3.0; 2005: 4.1; 2006: 4.4; 2007: 6.7
- Unemployment rate (ILO definition, percent): 2003: 10.0; 2004: 9.7; 2005: 7.9; 2006: 5.9; 2007: 4.7
- Domestic saving (in percent of GDP): 2003: 21.9; 2004: 22.6; 2005: 24.2; 2006: 19.8; 2007: (not listed)
- Domestic investment (in percent of GDP): 2003: 33.2; 2004: 34.3; 2005: 34.2; 2006: 38.6; 2007: 37.9
- Public Finance (in percent of GDP)
- General government balance: 2003: 2.5; 2004: 1.6; 2005: 3.3
- General government debt excluding government assets held abroad: 2003: 5.6; 2004: 5.0; 2005: 4.3
- General government debt including government assets held abroad 3/: 2003: 0.3; 2004: -2.4; 2005: -2.7; 2006: -3.1; 2007: -4.7
- Money and credit (changes in percent)
- Base money: 2003: 14.6; 2004: 24.0; 2005: 33.0; 2006: 30.7
- Broad money: 2003: 10.9; 2004: 15.8; 2005: 41.9; 2006: 28.2; 2007: 13.5
- Domestic credit to nongovernment: 2003: 27.0; 2004: 31.2; 2005: 33.4; 2006: 41.6
- Balance of Payments
- Goods and nonfactor services (percent of GDP): 2003: -7.4; 2004: -6.4; 2005: -11.8; 2006: -11.3
- Current account (percent of GDP): 2003: -11.7; 2004: -10.0; 2005: -16.7; 2006: -18.1
- Gross international reserves (euro, millions): 2003: 1098; 2004: 1317; 2005: 1647; 2006: 2128; 2007: 2217
- Exchange Rate
- Exchange rate regime: currency board arrangement
- Exchange rate parity: EEK 15.6466=Є1
- Real effective exchange rate (percent change, period average; appreciation (+)): 2003: 2.4; 2004: 1.8; 2005: 4.6
Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 09/33 — March 10, 2009; IMF Executive Board conclusion of the 2008 Article IV Consultation with the Republic of Estonia.