Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses the Fund's Role Regarding Cross-Border Capital Flows
IMF News, January 5, 2011
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses the Fund's Role Regarding Cross-Border Capital Flows
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: January 5, 2011
Background
- Publication identifiers and dates:
- The Fund's Role Regarding Cross-Border Capital Flows — November 15, 2010.
- Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses the Fund's Role Regarding Cross-Border Capital Flows — January 5, 2011.
- Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 11/1.
- The Executive Board discussion took place on December 17, 2010.
- Context and purpose:
- Capital flows have grown to dominate international transactions for many countries, notably amongst advanced economies but also increasingly for emerging markets.
- The stability of the international monetary system lies at the core of the Fund’s mandate.
- The staff paper discussed ways the Fund could assist members in framing a coherent approach to capital flows that supports growth and stability and protects the integrity of the international monetary system.
- A broad agenda for future work is proposed.
Executive Board Assessment — key findings
- General assessment:
- Directors welcomed the timely discussion on the Fund’s role on cross-border capital flows.
- Capital flows have conferred substantial benefits by facilitating efficient resource allocation across countries.
- Prolonged episodes of high volatility have presented serious policy challenges.
- Volatile capital flows played a key role in the recent crisis, both in increasing vulnerabilities and in transmitting shocks across borders.
- Considering the Fund’s mandate to oversee international monetary stability, Directors agreed on the need to strengthen the Fund’s role regarding international capital flows.
- Surveillance and policy advice:
- Directors called for further work to advance bilateral and multilateral surveillance and policy advice for member countries, based on extensive analytical work and taking into account country-specific circumstances and relevant experiences.
- Analytical priorities:
- Substantial analytical work is needed to develop a coherent Fund view and inform policy guidance on capital flows.
- Critical elements of analytical work include:
- Gaining a better understanding of the key drivers of capital flows.
- Understanding developments in global liquidity.
- Examining the relationship between global liquidity, domestic policies, and global financial stability.
- Analytical work should also help develop a clear view on whether, and if so which, macroprudential measures, microprudential measures, and/or capital controls might be appropriate in different circumstances.
- Directors welcomed work under way on Cross-Cutting Themes from Recent Country Experiences with Capital Flows as a basis for elaborating the Fund’s view on how to deal with capital inflows.
Policy guidance, rules, and country-specific considerations
- No universal rules:
- Directors observed that, despite complex interdependences and channels for policy spillovers created by capital flows, there are no universal “rules of the road” governing such flows.
- This contrasts with arrangements governing trade in goods and services or international monetary arrangements.
- Need for a coherent Fund view:
- Directors saw merit in developing a coherent Fund view on capital flows and the policies that affect them.
- Such a view could help establish guidelines for the purposes of the Fund’s surveillance on capital account and possibly other policies affecting capital flows.
- Guidelines should:
- Leave sufficient room for country-specific circumstances.
- Acknowledge the difference between countries with open capital accounts and those that have yet to liberalize.
- Be intended to provide guidance on the scope of existing obligations under Article IV.
Multilateral dialogue and spillovers
- Directors welcomed efforts to foster multilateral dialogue and policy coordination over cross-border capital flows.
- Observations on policy spillovers:
- Macroeconomic, financial, and capital account policies designed to address domestic concerns can have significant effects on other countries by generating or curtailing capital flows, or acting to divert them to third countries.
- Members may take divergent approaches in addressing tensions created, and these approaches could have effects on others.
- Fund role:
- The Fund has an important role in drawing attention to potential spillovers and the possible implications for the international monetary system as a whole.
- Directors supported efforts by the Fund to analyze and disseminate lessons from cross-country experiences and to foster dialogue with both originators and recipients of cross-border capital flows.
Data, collaboration, and institutional considerations
- Data gaps:
- Most Directors agreed that filling data gaps—through existing initiatives where possible—will strengthen surveillance of cross-border flows.
- Directors called for the Fund to collaborate with other institutions, such as the Bank for International Settlements, the Financial Stability Board, and national authorities, in meeting this goal.
- Legal framework:
- Directors expressed a wide range of views regarding amendment of the Articles of Agreement to provide a more complete and consistent legal framework for addressing issues related to capital flows.
- While a number of Directors were open to considering an amendment of the Articles in the future, most felt it would be premature to initiate a discussion on this step without further analysis and practical experience.
Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 11/1 — The Fund's Role Regarding Cross-Border Capital Flows (December 17, 2010 / January 5, 2011).