Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Indonesia
IMF News, April 13, 1999
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Indonesia
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: April 13, 1999
Background and recent developments
- Prior to mid-1997, Indonesia experienced 25 years of sustained economic progress; income per capita had trebled and the number of people in poverty had fallen sharply.
- Structural weaknesses: heavy unhedged foreign borrowing by the corporate sector; poorly supervised banking system with widespread violations of legal lending limits; microeconomic policies compromised by poor governance.
- Timeline of crisis responses:
- July 1997: flotation of the Thai baht; sustained pressure on the rupiah.
- November 1997: agreement with the Fund on an economic adjustment program supported by a large official external financing package; key elements included monetary tightening, strengthening of the banking system, and structural reform measures.
- May 1998: political disturbances culminating in President Suharto’s resignation; further economic disruption and sharp rupiah depreciation.
- Late-June 1998: new stabilization package agreed with the Fund to restore macroeconomic stability, rebuild distribution system, strengthen the social safety net, and address the financial system.
- 1998/99 fiscal year outcomes:
- Output was down 16 percent on the previous year’s level, with a marked decline in investment.
- Inflation rate was about 66 percent.
- Real wages fell sharply; surveys indicated the share of the population below the poverty line rose.
Program framework and IMF financial support
- Authorities’ macroeconomic framework for 1999/2000 envisages:
- Real GDP for the year would be broadly unchanged; the economy should soon bottom out.
- Foreign reserves expected to increase to around $29 billion (five months of imports of goods and services).
- Average inflation of some 15-20 percent for the year under prudent monetary policy.
- Budget deficit projected at nearly 6 percent of GDP to help promote recovery, with increased provisions for targeted social safety net outlays.
- Bulk of the deficit financed through external borrowing from multilateral and bilateral donors.
- IMF support and arrangements:
- Initial three-year Stand-by Arrangement approved November 1997 in an amount of SDR 7.3 billion.
- July 1998: increased by SDR 1 billion.
- August 1998: undrawn amount of SDR 4.7 billion converted into an Extended Arrangement.
- March 25, 1999: Executive Board approved increase by SDR 0.7 billion.
- Total purchases by Indonesia amount to SDR 6.8 billion (about US$9.3 billion), with a further SDR 2.2 billion (about US$3 billion) available between now and November 2000.
Executive Board assessment — findings and risks
- Directors’ overall view:
- Expressed satisfaction with continued progress in implementing the program, but noted fragility due to recent political and security developments.
- Welcomed March 13, 1999 announcement of a major program of private bank recapitalization and closures and agreement with Fund staff on strengthening macroeconomic and structural policies.
- Key concerns and risks:
- Recent export performance disappointing.
- Renewed volatility of the rupiah within a more depreciated range.
- Inflation rose in December through February.
- Limited progress in corporate restructuring.
- Incidents of social unrest and uncertainties related to upcoming elections affected confidence.
- Monetary policy stance:
- Directors supported proposed tightening of the monetary stance and endorsed efforts to bring base money down substantially through vigorous open market operations.
- Monetary policy should remain cautious in 1999/2000 and should not be eased prematurely—before clear signs of improving confidence and lower inflation.
- Concern about inadequate availability of credit to the export sector and continuing negative spreads between borrowing and lending rates of banks.
- Fiscal policy and social spending:
- Fiscal stimulus had been slow to develop due to delays in finalizing spending programs, execution, and slower-than-anticipated disbursements of external financing.
- Directors considered the size of the 1999/2000 budget deficit appropriate to impart a larger stimulus than in 1998/99.
- Budget projected to be fully financed without recourse to domestic bank financing, but framework needs flexibility to respond to evolving circumstances and to maintain long-term sustainability.
- Welcomed planned expansion of well-targeted social spending in 1999/2000; urged authorities to ensure spending goals on health, education, and employment generation were fully met consistent with the overall deficit target.
- Noted requirement for timely agreement with multilateral and bilateral donors on transparent administration and monitoring of social safety net programs.
- Banking, corporate restructuring, governance:
- Urged intensification of asset recoveries from large corporate debtors and reversal of declining budgetary revenue effort.
- Strongly urged removal of recently granted income tax holidays—for up to eight years to newly established corporations in 22 industrial sectors—in accordance with Fiscal Affairs Department recommendations.
- Called for efforts to strengthen tax and customs administration.
- Stressed urgency of accelerating bank and corporate restructuring; state bank restructuring and early privatization seen as critical.
- Emphasized IBRA’s central role for banking system reform and asset recovery; IBRA and the Asset Management Unit must be fully independent and adequately resourced.
- Urged acceleration of corporate debt restructuring under the Jakarta Initiative, vigorous use of the bankruptcy law, and early implementation of legislation to improve governance and strengthen the Commercial Court.
- Pressed for aggressive loan collection by state banks and IBRA and rapid initiation of bankruptcy filings against recalcitrant debtors.
- Expressed disappointment at delays in privatization and urged acceleration, including improving the regulatory and legislative framework.
- Broader structural and political considerations:
- Supported authorities’ commitments to broaden participation by weaker economic groups and regions, while respecting existing ownership rights and moving cautiously to avoid loss of macroeconomic control.
- Noted consolidation of the new competition law and first phase of fiscal decentralization would be tasks for the successor government and an early part of the Fund’s dialogue.
- Cautioned that devolution of revenue should be commensurate with expenditure responsibilities to avoid loss of macroeconomic control.
- Concluded macroeconomic situation would remain difficult until political transition advanced; firm implementation and continued strong international financial support should allow restoration of positive real growth from late this year.
- Underscored importance of transparency in program implementation, avoidance of political interference, policy continuity after elections, and clear political will for reform.
Selected economic indicators and key statistics (1996/97–1999/2000)
- GDP: $113 billion (1998/99)
- Population: 203 million (1998)
- Quota: SDR 2,079.3 million
Growth and inflation (percent change)
- Real GDP growth:
- 1996/97: 8.2
- 1997/98: 2.0
- 1998/99: -16
- 1999/2000: -2 to 1
- CPI inflation (end-period):
- 1996/97: 5.3
- 1997/98: 39.1
- 1998/99: 45
- 1999/2000: 10 to 13
- CPI inflation (period average):
- 1996/97: 5.2
- 1997/98: 12.9
- 1998/99: 66
- 1999/2000: 15 to 20
Savings and investment (in percent of GDP)
- National savings:
- 1996/97: 26.7
- 1997/98: 26.0
- 1998/99: 18.9
- 1999/2000: 17.6
- Private savings:
- 1996/97: 19.9
- 1997/98: 20.6
- 1998/99: 18.6
- 1999/2000: 19.0
- Domestic investment:
- 1996/97: 30.0
- 1997/98: 27.1
- 1998/99: 14.0
- 1999/2000: 15.5
- Private investment:
- 1996/97: 24.3
- 1997/98: 20.8
- 1998/99: 9.5
- 1999/2000: 10.3
Central government operations (in percent of GDP)
- Revenue and grants:
- 1996/97: 15.1
- 1997/98: 15.4
- 1998/99: 13.5
- 1999/2000: 11.2
- Oil/gas revenue:
- 1996/97: 3.6
- 1997/98: 4.4
- 1998/99: 3.8
- 1999/2000: 1.7
- Non-oil/gas revenue:
- 1996/97: 11.4
- 1997/98: 11.0
- 1998/99: 9.7
- 1999/2000: 8.4
- Expenditure and net lending:
- 1996/97: 13.9
- 1997/98: 16.5
- 1998/99: 17.1
- 1999/2000: 17.0
- Overall balance:
- 1996/97: 1.2
- 1997/98: -1.1
- 1998/99: -3.6
- 1999/2000: -5.8
Money and credit (annual percent change)
- Credit to the private sector:
- 1996/97: 23.8
- 1997/98: 14.1
- 1998/99: 4
- 1999/2000: 12
- Broad money:
- 1996/97: 10.4
- 1997/98: 37
- 1998/99: 18
- Base money:
- 1996/97: 70.8
- 1997/98: 21
- 1998/99: 14
- Overnight JIBOR rate (percent; end-period):
- 1996/97: 47.1
- 1997/98: 34.4
Balance of payments ($ billion)
- Current account balance:
- 1996/97: -8.1
- 1997/98: -1.7
- 1998/99: 5.5
- 1999/2000: 3.4
- (In percent of GDP):
- 1996/97: -3.4
- 1997/98: -0.9
- 1998/99: 4.8
- Trade balance:
- 1996/97: 8.8
- 1997/98: 17.2
- 1998/99: 17.4
- Exports f.o.b.:
- 1996/97: 52.0
- 1997/98: 56.2
- 1998/99: 52.2
- 1999/2000: 54.5
- o/w: non-oil/gas exports:
- 1996/97: 39.3
- 1997/98: 45.9
- 1998/99: 45.1
- 1999/2000: 47.4
- Imports f.o.b.:
- 1996/97: 50.9
- 1997/98: 34.9
- 1998/99: 37.1
Capital account
- Capital account:
- 1996/97: -11.6
- 1997/98: -3.0
- 1998/99: -1.4
- Direct investment:
- 1996/97: 6.5
- 1997/98: 1.8
- 1998/99: 0.9
- 1999/2000: 0.5
Foreign reserves and debt ($ billion)
- Gross official foreign assets:
- 1996/97: 26.6
- 1997/98: 16.4
- 1998/99: 25.7
- 1999/2000: 28.6
- Of which: Liquid reserves:
- 1996/97: 25.8
- 1997/98: 10.7
- 1998/99: 20.3
- 1999/2000: 22.6
- (In months of imports):
- 1996/97: 5.1
- 1997/98: 2.2
- 1998/99: 5.7
- 1999/2000: 6.0
- Total external debt:
- 1996/97: 127.4
- 1997/98: 138.0
- 1998/99: 139.8
- 1999/2000: 143
Other indicators
- Exchange rate (Rp/US$; end period):
- 1996/97: 2,403
- 1997/98: 10,200
- 1998/99: 8,700
- Nominal effective exchange rate (1990=100):
- 1996/97: 90.3
- 1997/98: 24.4
- 1998/99 estimate is for February 1999: 25.2
- Real effective exchange rate (1990=100):
- 1996/97: 108.2
- 1997/98: 39.2
- 1998/99: 58.0
Public Information Notice: IMF Concludes Article IV Consultation with Indonesia, April 13, 1999.