IMF Survey: Germany Faces Extended Downturn Despite Stimulus
IMF News, January 22, 2009
Source details
- Canonical URL
- IMF Survey: Germany Faces Extended Downturn Despite Stimulus
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Camilla Andersen IMF Survey
- Published: January 22, 2009
Outlook and headline projections
- German output projected to fall by 2.5 percent in 2009.
- Economy went from robust growth—an annual average rate of 3½ percent—in mid-2007 to a contraction in the second and third quarters of 2008.
- A tentative recovery is expected in 2010.
- Investment is projected to fall by ¼ percent in 2009, contributing 0.1 percentage point to the decline in output.
Principal causes of the downturn
- Slowing demand for German exports
- Primary shock: slowing world demand and a sharp deceleration of world trade, linked to the weakening U.S. economy and global knock-on effects.
- Exports are falling sharply; Germany has relied heavily on exports since the mid-1990s.
- Continued caution among German consumers
- Consumers were cautious throughout the upswing and the financial crisis is likely to encourage continued saving rather than spending.
- Sharp drop in investment
- Worsening business outlook and shrinking foreign and domestic order books have led companies to postpone planned investment.
- Investment volatility has traditionally amplified export volatility.
Fiscal stimulus: size, composition, and IMF assessment
- Government measures
- More substantial measures announced amounting to about 50 billion euros to be spent over two years.
- By IMF staff's estimates, the stimulus will be just over 1¼ percent of GDP in 2009, and about ½ percent of GDP in 2010.
- IMF prior recommendation and assessment
- In the annual Article IV consultation concluded in November, the IMF had recommended a stimulus in 2009 of 1½ to 2 percent of GDP.
- Given rapidly deteriorating conditions, the IMF judged that a stimulus of at least 2 percent of GDP would have been desirable.
- IMF analysis of which measures are most effective
- Bringing forward the proposed reduction in social security contributions would reduce high labor tax rates and boost private consumption; greater emphasis could have been placed on reducing these contributions rather than on reducing personal income tax rates.
- Increased social benefits, mainly child benefits and short-term labor subsidies, direct funds to poorer households and are likely to be spent.
- Public investment in infrastructure—accelerating "shovel-ready" projects—should help boost output and confidence.
- Private investment incentives and increased lending to SMEs are unlikely to raise investment while business confidence is low.
- Fiscal sustainability and credibility
- Any stimulus should be accompanied by a credible long-term commitment to fiscal sustainability.
- Concern areas: trends in healthcare costs and debt accumulation by Germany's states.
- The government's plan to introduce a disciplining rule requiring returning to fiscal balance is an important step to maintain credibility and speed recovery.
Financial system vulnerabilities and policy needs
- Bank losses and exposures
- As of end-September 2008, Germany accounted for about a quarter of European bank writedowns.
- Of these writedowns, about two-thirds have been in public or quasi-public sector banks.
- Two large private banks—Hypo Real Estate and Commerzbank—have sought assistance through the government's financial stabilization package.
- Borrowing costs and sectors affected
- Borrowing costs in construction, automobiles, engineering, and chemicals have increased sharply as defaults are perceived as increasingly likely.
- Stabilization fund and regulatory response
- The Financial Market Stabilization Fund has been vital and should be used as a stepping stone for broader financial reform.
- The German approach is voluntary, allowing banks to choose from a range of stabilization measures.
- Given low absolute capital in several banks and expected deterioration in asset quality, a more proactive recapitalization may be needed.
- Compelling case for tightening bank regulation and supervision and strengthening the financial safety net through better deposit protection.
International repercussions and regional spillovers
- Openness and transmission
- Germany's openness means prolonged global shocks will make the downturn more severe and prolonged, transmitting lower growth across Europe.
- Exposure to emerging markets
- From June 2007 to September 2008, German banks' exposure to emerging markets via loans and credit derivatives doubled to about $450 billion—4 percent of all German banking assets and 12 percent of all German banks' cross-border claims.
- A likely reduction of that exposure by German banks could generate cascading spillovers and add to troubles of emerging markets in Europe; several have already requested IMF financial assistance.
- Eurozone sentiment and coordination
- A lack of confidence in Germany could hurt growth in the entire eurozone due to more closely aligned sentiment when prospects worsen.
- Stronger cooperation in fiscal policy and financial sector regulation across Europe is needed.
Policy recommendations and strategic priorities
- Implement sizeable but targeted fiscal stimulus focused on measures with quick demand impact:
- Prioritize reductions in social security contributions to boost consumption.
- Increase social benefits aimed at poorer households and short-term labor subsidies.
- Accelerate public infrastructure ("shovel-ready") projects.
- Maintain fiscal sustainability and adopt a disciplining rule to ensure deficits are temporary and credible.
- Use the Financial Market Stabilization Fund as a platform for broader financial reform:
- Consider proactive recapitalization where bank capital is low.
- Tighten bank regulation and supervision.
- Strengthen deposit protection and the financial safety net.
- Enhance European cooperation in fiscal policy and financial regulation to limit spillovers and coordinate stimulus.
International Monetary Fund, IMF Survey: Germany Faces Extended Downturn Despite Stimulus
Content in this bundle
References
- https://www.imf.org/en/News/country-focus
- PRESS CENTER
- IMF Country Focus
- Press release
- Watch the video summary
- Germany and the IMF
- World faces deepening crisis
- Crises hit workers hardest
- IMF on fiscal stimulus
- IMF and financial crisis
- F&D magazine on the crisis
- Harsh crisis toll on Europe
- IMF hails euro zone plan
- https://www.imf.org/en/home