IMF Survey: Difficult Policy Choices Await Europe As Recovery Gets Under Way
IMF News, October 20, 2010
Source details
- Canonical URL
- IMF Survey: Difficult Policy Choices Await Europe As Recovery Gets Under Way
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Christoph Klingen IMF European Department October
- Published: October 20, 2010
Overview
- The IMF is predicting growth of 2¼ percent for Europe in 2010, according to the IMF’s latest Regional Economic Outlook.
- The recovery is described as sluggish and uneven but represents a turnaround from fears over sovereign solvency in May 2010 that threatened monetary union.
- The recovery has withstood turmoil in financial markets largely due to a forceful policy response, including the establishment of the European Stabilization Mechanism to backstop EU governments with financing problems.
- Europe’s economy is projected to expand by 2¼ percent this year and next.
Advanced Europe: moderate recovery and priorities
- Growth projections:
- Advanced Europe projected to grow at 1.7 and 1.6 percent this year and next.
- Characterization of growth:
- Recovery reflects structural rigidities that limit potential growth and the temporary nature of early recovery drivers (restocking, frozen investment plans moving ahead, rebound of exports).
- Fiscal policy stance is set to become more restrictive.
- Financial sector recommendations:
- Vulnerable banks should be resolved, restructured, or recapitalized without delay, using the recent EU-wide stress tests as a road map.
- These measures would allow the European Central Bank (ECB) to exit from extraordinary liquidity measures before they become entrenched.
- Strengthened banks would be better positioned to increase lending, especially to smaller firms that lack access to capital markets.
- Fiscal consolidation guidance:
- Expenditure-based fiscal consolidation, especially when it tackles entitlement reforms, tends to be more growth friendly than tax hikes or cuts to public investment.
- Embedding fiscal consolidation into credible medium-term plans backed by concrete measures helps.
- Phasing of consolidation should be tailored to country-specific circumstances:
- Countries under market pressure should frontload fiscal adjustment.
- Countries with fiscal space can proceed less aggressively and may delay consolidation if the recovery proves weaker than expected.
- For the euro area, the overall projected fiscal stance is neutral in 2010 and turns mildly contractionary in 2011.
- The composition of planned fiscal adjustment is broadly reassuring, but many countries should enhance the credibility of their plans.
- Governance:
- Policymakers should move swiftly to fill gaps in the EU’s governance framework exposed by the crisis to build confidence and support the recovery.
- Progress is furthest in the financial sector with the decision to establish European Supervisory Authorities and a European Risk Management Board in 2011.
- Policymakers are debating how to enhance fiscal governance; broader structural reforms have so far been less of a priority though they could help redress intra-euro area external imbalances and unlock growth potential.
Emerging Europe: export-led recovery and structural adjustment
- Growth projections and recent performance:
- Emerging Europe projected to grow at 3.9 and 3.8 percent this year and next, compared with a contraction of 6 percent in 2009.
- The current account for emerging Europe was balanced overall in 2009 and is projected to broadly remain so this year and next, although a few smaller countries continue to post relatively large deficits.
- Inflation pressures subsided quickly with the Great Recession; the outlook for inflation remains generally benign.
- Growth is strongest in Turkey and Russia and weakest in south-eastern Europe.
- Fiscal credibility and banking repair:
- Emerging Europe is planning to bring down its fiscal deficit from 6 percent of GDP in 2009 to 4.1 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Financing constraints are often binding; markets increasingly differentiate countries according to the health of their public finances, and government securities account for a large share of bank assets in many countries.
- Recommendation: follow the same broad principles concerning composition and phasing of fiscal consolidation as in advanced Europe to enhance credibility in financial markets.
- For countries outside the EU’s fiscal framework, national fiscal rules are a particularly valuable commitment tool.
- Encouraging credit growth:
- Except for Turkey, Belarus, and Serbia, credit growth has remained very low or in negative territory, reflecting the drying up of financing from abroad and rising nonperforming loans.
- The sooner banks recognize loan-losses and recapitalize, the sooner they will be able to regenerate loan growth.
- Governments can indirectly support credit growth by fostering credible macroeconomic policies that encourage a low interest rate environment and by enhancing international cooperation on financial sector policies (example cited: Nordic-Baltic Cooperation Agreement).
- Long-term growth model:
- Projected growth rates remain low by historical standards; many countries will need to build new engines of growth.
- Adjustment involves shifting economic structures toward the tradable sector (for instance, manufacturing) from the nontradable sector (for instance, housing and financial services).
- Policy measures to support this adjustment include:
- Wages policies to help align wages and productivity.
- Structural reforms to address skill mismatches.
- Investment in education and infrastructure to attract foreign direct investment into the tradable sector.
Key policy choices and trade-offs
- Policymakers face difficult choices balancing vulnerabilities and recovery support:
- Fiscal policy must support demand through deficits while addressing unsustainable debt dynamics and eroding market acceptance.
- Financial sector reform must both revive credit growth and strengthen a still vulnerable system.
- Structural reforms require strong political will amid high unemployment and uncertain prospects.
- Strengthened governance frameworks would help build much-needed confidence.
Selected key statistics (preserved exactly as in source)
- Europe growth prediction for 2010: 2¼ percent.
- Europe projected to expand by: 2¼ percent this year and next.
- Advanced Europe growth projections: 1.7 and 1.6 percent this year and next.
- Emerging Europe growth projections: 3.9 and 3.8 percent this year and next.
- Emerging Europe 2009 contraction: 6 percent.
- Emerging Europe current account: balanced overall in 2009.
- Emerging Europe fiscal deficit trajectory: from 6 percent of GDP in 2009 to 4.1 percent of GDP in 2011.
- EU supervisory/governance action: establishment of European Supervisory Authorities and a European Risk Management Board in 2011.
IMF Survey: Difficult Policy Choices Await Europe As Recovery Gets Under Way