Can the East Asian Miracle Persist?
IMF News, December 2, 2004
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Can the East Asian Miracle Persist?
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: December 2, 2004
I. The Evolving Context for East Asian Growth
- Real per capita GDP in the East Asia and Pacific region has grown by about 4¾ percent a year, on average, since 1960, resulting in a seven-fold increase in per capita income.
- Real per capita GDP growth has been even faster in China and Korea, at about 5½ percent per year over the same period.
- Life expectancy in East Asia and the Pacific has risen from 53 years to 70 years today over the last forty years.
- Key historical factors behind growth:
- Adoption of wide-ranging policies to transform into market economies beginning in the 1950s.
- Sound macroeconomic policies providing a stable backdrop.
- Early emphasis on infrastructure investment to aid exporters and import-competing firms.
- Later liberalization of trade and financial sectors and outward orientation with strong incentives for exporters.
- Political stability (likely both cause and consequence of growth).
- Debate on sources of the "Asian miracle":
- World Bank (1993) emphasized superior accumulation of physical and human capital and high productivity growth.
- Other research (e.g., Alwyn Young, Larry Lau, highlighted by Paul Krugman) argued rapid growth was primarily due to increases in quantities of physical capital and labor rather than total factor productivity.
- Implication: limits to catch-up growth from factor accumulation alone—necessity of productivity-enhancing reforms.
- Post-1997-98 crisis shift:
- Focus moved from determinants of growth to sound structural policies to reduce vulnerability to crisis.
- Emergence of a wide-ranging structural reform agenda emphasizing financial and corporate reform and strengthening legal and regulatory underpinnings.
II. The Unfinished Structural Reform Agenda
- Overarching lesson: strong "market economy fundamentals"—institutions, regulatory frameworks, and business practices—are essential for sustaining rapid growth and increasing resilience to shocks.
- Prior to the crisis, East Asian economies generally pursued prudent macroeconomic policies with high saving and investment rates, but lacked sufficient institutional checks and balances to limit investment bubbles.
A. Financial and Corporate Sector Reform
- Preconditions for sustained growth:
- Well-developed, well-capitalized, sensibly managed financial institutions with appropriate regulatory oversight and vigorous competition.
- Pre-crisis banking weaknesses:
- Under-developed risk management capabilities.
- Imprudently high related-party lending.
- Weak supervision systems vulnerable to political interference.
- Overreliance on continued good times and exchange rate stability.
- Post-crisis progress and remaining needs:
- Significant consolidation: Indonesia banks fell from about 240 before the crisis to 136 today; Korea commercial banks declined from 33 in 1997 to 19 today.
- Improved financial condition: average capital adequacy ratios now around 8 percent in emerging Asia; nonperforming loan ratios have fallen sharply, to about 10 percent of total loans.
- Strengthened supervisory and regulatory institutions; new agencies in China, Korea, and Japan; upgraded capacities such as risk assessment.
- Corporate sector: aggregate debt-to-equity ratios in emerging Asia fell to about 45 percent in 2003, down from about 75 percent in 1997.3
- Further operational restructuring of banks needed: rationalizing branch networks, reducing staffing, revamping loan approval and analysis procedures.
- Strengthen risk management as countries move towards implementing the Basle II capital accord.
- Regulators should insist banks remedy deficiencies in asset-quality assessment, press creditors to acknowledge true health of debtors, and avoid regulatory forbearance—particularly concerning state-owned banks.
B. Corporate Governance Reform
- Mobilizing capital requires investor confidence ensured by institutions, laws, and practices encouraging recipients of capital to act in savers' interests.
- Post-crisis priority: strengthen corporate governance to address high concentration and low transparency ("crony capitalism").
- Evidence: countries with sound corporate governance and strong investor protection have deeper capital markets and cheaper financing.
- Required reforms:
- Improve disclosure requirements and accounting standards.
- Strengthen rights of minority shareholders.
- Match advances in rules with advances in implementation and enforcement.
- Legal reforms to support corporate restructuring, including enactment of cram-down provisions allowing court approval of majority-approved restructuring plans despite dissenting creditors.
- Improve implementation: substantial training of judges and lawyers, entry of additional professionals where needed, expedite court processes and foreclosure proceedings to clear judicial backlogs that in some cases amount to several years.
- Corruption remains a concern in a number of East Asian economies; poor rule of law, weak institutions, and lack of transparency worsen investment climate and hinder growth of less-connected firms.
C. The IMF's Involvement in Promoting Structural Reform
- Post-crisis IMF–World Bank initiatives:
- Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP) introduced in 1999 to strengthen monitoring of financial systems and detect vulnerabilities early. Eight countries in Asia, including Korea, Japan, and Thailand, have undertaken an FSAP; China participation is hoped for in the near future.
- Development of a system of Standards and Codes with the World Bank using internationally-recognized standards to define "best practices" in areas including financial regulation and supervision, bankruptcy practices, and corporate governance.
III. Other Trends That Will Affect Growth
- Three major trends likely to affect East Asian growth over the medium term: international trade, foreign direct investment and innovation, and aging.
A. International Trade
- Regional trade expansion:
- East Asia's share of world trade increased from less than 16 percent of world exports in 1980 to over 28 percent by 2003.
- Intra-regional trade accounts for 40 percent of Asia's exports, up from 30 percent a decade ago.
- China's role:
- China’s opening and WTO accession have made it a manufacturing powerhouse and central to global supply chains, benefiting neighbors through imports of intermediate inputs.
- Competitive challenges for neighbors; ASEAN–China trade agreement referenced as part of adjustment strategies.
- India:
- India remains relatively closed: exports of goods and services represent only about 15 percent of GDP; India accounts for less than 1 percent of the world's merchandise exports.
- Further trade liberalization could allow India to benefit from Emerging Asia and vice versa.
- Diversification:
- Greater export diversification would reduce vulnerability from overspecialization in IT products and reliance on the United States.
- Open question whether deeper intra-Asian trade will promote diversification or specialization—area for further academic study.
B. Foreign Direct Investment and Innovation
- FDI patterns and implications:
- China: successful at attracting FDI; foreign-owned firms are key drivers of higher-value added Chinese exports.
- India: relatively little FDI historically; inflows rising but stock of FDI small relative to GDP and geared to domestic market.
- ASEAN: inward FDI declined from some $17 billion in 1997 to about $9 billion in 2003—partly due to competition from China and concerns about investment climate and political risk.
- Innovation:
- Openness to FDI should spur innovation and productivity, but experiences differ across countries.
- Some economies have moved beyond imitation to innovation; in China, innovation has played a relatively small role so far.
- Public policy to stimulate innovation requires supporting legal and financial systems, protection of shareholder rights, enforcement of contracts, and strengthened governance and regulatory bodies—linking back to the structural reform agenda.
C. Aging
- Demographic transition and aging:
- Asia's share of the elderly set to rise from 6 percent in 2000 to 17 percent by 2005.4
- Aging expected to be most dramatic in Japan, significant in Hong Kong SAR, Korea, and Singapore.
- Economic impacts:
- Aging may reduce economic performance via declining private savings and pressures on government budgets.
- Slower growth in advanced economies could reduce demand for exports and flows of investment capital to less advanced economies.
- IMF research suggests demographic changes could reduce per capita income growth in emerging Asia by 0.2 percentage point per year over the 2000-2050 period.
- Policy responses:
- Boost labor supply, saving, or productivity.
- Advanced economies may need greater immigration; increasing labor force participation may be insufficient.
- Equip workforce with larger and more labor-efficient capital stock.
- Developing countries should absorb working-age populations via labor-market flexibility, education, and training.
IV. Concluding Remarks
- Near-term outlook: bright, with Chinese authorities working to moderate excessive investment growth.
- Long-term perspective:
- Sustaining favorable performance is possible due to solid economic fundamentals and openness to trade and investment, but not at pre-crisis growth paces indefinitely.
- Call to apply the spirit of "sacrifice now and enjoy fruits later"—undertake needed reforms now.
- Japan's experience demonstrates costs of avoiding reforms—failure to address structural problems led to a "lost decade."
- Structural reform remains necessary for sustaining dynamic economic growth even at advanced-economy levels.
Remarks by Takatoshi Kato, Deputy Managing Director, International Monetary Fund, Princeton University—Woodrow Wilson School and East Asian Studies Department, December 2, 2004.