Denmark Staff Concluding Statement of the 2024 Article IV Mission
IMF News, June 19, 2024
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Denmark Staff Concluding Statement of the 2024 Article IV Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: June 19, 2024
Mission summary and priorities
- Denmark has demonstrated remarkable resilience in the face of the pandemic and energy crises.
- Staff expects robust growth to continue in 2024, but there are considerable external risks, including from geopolitical tensions.
- The financial system remains sound, but systemic risks are elevated due to still-high interest rates and heightened vulnerabilities in commercial real estate (CRE) markets.
- Demographic challenges and low productivity growth pose risks for long-term growth.
- Policy priorities:
- Calibrate fiscal policy, taking into account both cyclical conditions and growing long-term spending needs.
- Safeguard financial stability by closely monitoring risks emanating from vulnerable and leveraged borrowers.
- Continue implementing structural reforms to sustain the welfare state, including in the areas of labor markets, education, innovation, digitalization, business dynamism, and green transition.
Economic outlook and risks
- Growth projections and drivers:
- Growth is projected at around 2 percent in 2024, driven by pharmaceutical exports, the reopening of the Tyra natural gas field, and a gradual rebound in the non-pharmaceutical sector.
- Non-pharmaceutical output will be bolstered by a recovery in external demand, improved consumer purchasing power, and easing of financial conditions.
- In 2025, non-pharmaceutical output will continue to expand at a moderate pace, but GDP growth will decelerate to around 1½ percent as the growth of pharmaceutical exports tapers off.
- Beyond 2025, medium-term growth will stay at around 1.4 percent, down from the pre-pandemic average of 1.8 percent, largely due to lower global growth, demographic headwinds, and geoeconomic fragmentation.
- Labor market and inflation:
- Some signs of a cooling labor market: unemployment rates have crept up; job vacancy rates and the number of businesses reporting labor as a factor limiting production have fallen from their peaks; labor market remains relatively tight.
- Wage growth has accelerated moderately.
- Inflation has sharply fallen to around 2 percent, reflecting the decrease in global energy prices and lackluster domestic demand.
- Inflation might temporarily edge up due to the lagged effect of last year’s wage collective bargaining agreement but is expected to fall back to around 2 percent during the second half of 2025.
- Risk assessment:
- Balance of risks to growth is skewed to the downside.
- Primary external risks: a global slowdown in growth, possible escalation of Russia’s war in Ukraine, and deepening geoeconomic fragmentation.
- Adverse shocks in other Nordic countries, including a correction in the housing and CRE markets, may spill over to the Danish economy.
- If capacity pressures rise, inflation and wage growth would be higher than expected.
Calibrating fiscal policy (short- and medium-term)
- Short term:
- Fiscal policy should avoid adding to capacity pressures.
- New discretionary measures in the 2024 budget plan were small in size.
- Government agreed in April to boost defense spending, with details yet to be announced; fiscal stance in 2024 might turn out to be slightly expansionary.
- Recommendation: exercise tight spending control and save any revenue above budget forecasts.
- Medium term:
- Denmark’s accumulated fiscal space can help mitigate pressures from population aging, climate change, and defense spending.
- Public debt has been steadily reduced to around 30 percent of GDP, creating substantial fiscal space.
- Government has launched reform initiatives to enhance labor supply and boost growth and fiscal revenue.
- Anticipated slight easing of the fiscal stance starting in 2025 is viewed as appropriate to accommodate increased costs related to health and long-term care, coastal protection, and defense.
- Fiscal sustainability metrics and risks:
- Structural balance projected to gradually deteriorate from a surplus of ½ percent of GDP in 2024 to a deficit of ½ percent of GDP by the mid-2030s.
- This trajectory is consistent with Denmark’s fiscal rules; staff’s debt sustainability analysis suggests low stress on sovereign debt.
- Downside risks to the long-term fiscal trajectory include:
- (i) supply-side measures may not generate expected growth and revenues;
- (ii) climate change could accelerate faster-than-expected, requiring larger adaptation investments;
- (iii) security conditions in Europe may further deteriorate, necessitating additional defense spending.
- If fiscal trends suggest risk of breaching the structural deficit limit (minus one percent of GDP), additional fiscal adjustment measures would be needed.
Safeguarding financial stability — findings and recommendations
- Systemic assessment:
- Financial system sound, but systemic risks elevated due to still-high interest rates and heightened vulnerabilities in CRE markets.
- Recommended supervisory and macroprudential actions:
- Ensure banks closely assess how developments in real estate prices, labor markets, and financial conditions affect balance sheets of vulnerable borrowers and update provisions for credit risks accordingly.
- In line with new supervisory guidelines on CRE, ensure banks maintain adequate provisioning against losses; banks’ internal-rating models should adequately capture the risks.
- Continue work on the Nordic-wide bank stress testing exercise with other Nordic policymakers.
- Develop a framework for a systemic risk assessment encompassing banks and non-bank financial institutions (NBFIs) and incorporating domestic and cross-border interconnectedness.
- Consider developing and deploying a system-wide stress testing framework.
- Continue efforts to strengthen resilience against cyberattacks.
- Recent measures and further steps:
- The new capital-based macroprudential policy measure to mitigate CRE risks and the property tax reform are welcome.
- The 7 percent sector-specific systemic risk buffer (effective at the end of June) will strengthen banks’ resilience to CRE-related risks.
- The new property tax system (which went into effect in January 2024) will help improve the stability of housing markets.
- Additional borrower-based measures recommended to address pockets of vulnerabilities, including:
- lowering the maximum loan-to-value ratio below the current 95 percent or
- requiring mandatory amortization until a certain equity threshold is reached.
- Reduce high tax deductibility of mortgage interest expense and incorporate borrower-based measures into national legislation.
- Non-bank financial institutions and consumer protection:
- Insurance and pension companies have ample capital buffers; supervisors have developed and implemented a stress-testing framework to identify and assess residual risks.
- The share of non-guaranteed market-return products has increased significantly, exposing customers to investment and longevity risks.
- Recommendation: finalize a supervisory order by the end of this year aiming to strengthen firms’ duties to provide clients with clear advice on financial and longevity risks.
- Institutional arrangements:
- Authorities have made important progress implementing 2020 Financial Sector Assessment Program recommendations, particularly in banking and insurance supervision and systemic liquidity.
- Several recommendations in systemic risk oversight and governance of resolution authorities remain unaddressed.
Pursuing structural reforms
- Labor market and skills:
- Continued efforts needed to increase the quantity of labor and address skill mismatches.
- The proposed personal income tax reform is a step in the right direction to enhance work incentives.
- Additional measures: vocational training, education, recruitment from abroad.
- Public sector wage setting should be reformed to better address labor shortages in sectors such as health and long-term care.
- Continue close monitoring of educational outcomes for students with an immigrant background and strengthen their integration.
- Digitalization, innovation, and business dynamism:
- Staff welcomes commitment to enhance digitalization, innovation, and business dynamism.
- Implementation of Denmark’s Recovery and Resilience Plan is underway to accelerate digitalization for SMEs, public administration, rural broadband, and the health sector.
- Government’s new strategy for entrepreneurship should support startups by improving access to capital, lowering taxes, and easing regulatory burden.
- Consider further enhancing R&D tax incentives.
- Following expert group recommendation, business subsidies should be streamlined, except those addressing market failures.
- Climate mitigation and adaptation:
- Additional measures are needed to meet the 70 percent reduction target (relative to 1990 levels) by 2030 according to authorities’ latest projections.
- Given agriculture’s significant contribution to total greenhouse gas emissions, reaching political consensus on implementing carbon taxation on agriculture early is vital.
- For climate adaptation:
- Development of the 2023 National Climate Adaptation Plan I is welcome.
- Next steps: develop its implementation plan and update estimates of investment needs for adaptation.
- Review the property insurance scheme (“Storm Surge Scheme”) to make insurance premiums risk-based.
Acknowledgements
- The mission thanks the authorities and private sector counterparts for accommodative flexibility, warm hospitality, and candid high-quality discussions.
- The IMF team is especially grateful to Danmarks Nationalbank for assistance with meeting and logistical arrangements.
Source: Denmark Staff Concluding Statement of the 2024 Article IV Mission (IMF).