The Caribbean Challenge: Fostering Growth and Resilience Amidst Global Uncertainty
IMF News, June 10, 2025
Source details
- Canonical URL
- The Caribbean Challenge: Fostering Growth and Resilience Amidst Global Uncertainty
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: June 10, 2025
Introduction and road map
- Speech delivered at the 55th Annual Meeting of the Caribbean Development Bank, June 10, 2025.
- Two urgent regional priorities: (1) lift growth prospects and living standards; (2) build resilience against persistent economic shocks and natural disasters.
- Presentation outline: global context, Caribbean context, policy responses (macroeconomic and structural), IMF support.
The global growth challenge
- IMF April World Economic Outlook downgrades:
- Growth this year: from 3.3 to 2.8 percent (a 0.5 percentage point downgrade).
- Growth in 2026: from 3.3 to 3.0 percent (a 0.3 percentage point downgrade).
- Characterization:
- Lowest global growth in approximately two decades, outside of 2020.
- US effective tariff rate rose in early April to levels not seen in a century; trade policy uncertainty remains "off the charts."
- Transmission and risks:
- Uncertainty raises planning costs, delays shipping and investment.
- Tariffs raise fiscal revenues but reduce and shift economic activity and raise consumer prices.
- Protectionism erodes long-run productivity, especially in smaller economies.
- Financial vulnerabilities identified:
- High valuations in segments of global equity and corporate bond markets.
- Strain on highly leveraged nonbank financial institutions in volatile markets.
- Sovereign bond market turbulence risk, especially where government debt levels are high.
- Structural driver of weak medium‑term growth:
- Broad-based slowdown in productivity growth accounts for more than half of the decline in global growth.
- Without course correction, global growth by the end of this decade would be below the pre‑pandemic average by about 1 percentage point.
The Caribbean growth and resilience challenge — outlook and impacts
- Regional baseline: tepid growth projected in the latest World Economic Outlook even before April tariff announcements; country heterogeneity (e.g., stronger Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago; weak Haiti due to security).
- Estimated immediate impact of April tariff announcement:
- Lowers Caribbean regional growth by at least 0.2 percentage point on average.
- Channels of transmission:
- Tourism-dependent economies: impact depends on size of US tourist base.
- Oil-exporting countries: affected by lower commodity prices and higher volatility.
- Long-term trend and productivity:
- Caribbean growth potential has declined to about half of what it was a few decades ago.
- For tourism-dependent economies: potential growth decline from 3.3 percent (1981–2000) to 1.6 percent (2001–2019).
- Caribbean productivity growth has declined to almost zero — central to the region’s growth challenge.
- Notable exception:
- Guyana: growth accelerated to over 45 percent on average in the past three years, progressing from low‑middle‑income to high‑income status.
- Social and distributional stakes:
- Slower growth stalls improvements in living standards and convergence with advanced economies.
Major quantified vulnerabilities and regional statistics
- Debt and fiscal targets:
- ECCU regional debt target: 60 percent of GDP by 2035.
- Natural disaster impacts:
- Major natural disasters cost an average of 2 percent of GDP per year in Caribbean countries and close to 4 percent of GDP in the Eastern Caribbean countries.
- Insurance and risk transfer:
- CCRIF payout after Hurricane Beryl: US$85 million across five countries (Grenada, St Vincent & the Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago, the Cayman Islands and Jamaica).
- Labor market and inclusion:
- Youth unemployment in Caribbean countries: ranging from 10 to 40 percent.
- ECCU gender gap in labor force participation: over 11 percentage points on average; eliminating the gap could boost regional GDP by roughly 10 percent.
- Potential productivity gains from reforms:
- Overcoming structural obstacles could bring productivity gains ranging from 34 to 65 percent and close the gap in income per capita with the US by 9 to 27 percentage points.
- IMF membership and perspective:
- IMF has 191 member countries (compared with the UN’s 192).
Policy prescriptions — maintain and entrench macroeconomic stability
- Core objective: foster resilient and inclusive growth that sustainably raises living standards by:
- Maintaining macroeconomic stability (stable prices, sustainable fiscal trajectories, adequate foreign exchange reserves, financial sector stability).
- Decisively and comprehensively addressing factors that raise growth potential.
- Fiscal policy guidance:
- Restore fiscal buffers, strengthen fiscal frameworks, and bolster resilience.
- Mobilize tax revenue, spend wisely, and plan ahead.
- Address weak tax yields: broaden bases, remove distortions, curb inefficient tax exemptions, and strengthen tax administrations.
- Emphasize spending quality and composition; contain unproductive spending; enhance efficiency and digitalize government services.
- Adopt strong medium‑term fiscal frameworks, well‑designed fiscal rules, and specific reform plans; combine debt and operational targets backed by capacity and institutions.
- Example: Jamaica’s Financial Administration and Audit Act — public debt goal of 60 percent of GDP, rules for annual fiscal balance, and an Independent Fiscal Commission.
- Exchange rate regimes and currency unions:
- Internal consistency required within chosen currency regimes (floating or fixed).
- Fiscal policies need to be sustainable and consistent with exchange rate regime to preserve currency union stability.
- Sovereign wealth and contingency funds:
- Well‑designed transparent sovereign wealth funds can stabilize public finances (examples: Trinidad and Tobago; Guyana; proposed St. Kitts and Nevis fund).
- Legislated natural disaster saving (example: Jamaica).
Disaster preparedness and multi‑layered risk financing
- Multi-layer insurance framework recommended:
- Layer 1: self‑insurance through fiscal buffers.
- Layer 2: pooled risk transfer arrangements (CCRIF).
- Layer 3: contingent financing (e.g., World Bank catastrophe deferred drawdown options; IDB credit contingent facilities).
- Layer 4: catastrophe bonds (Jamaica with World Bank assistance).
- Address rising reinsurance and domestic insurance premiums that reduce private coverage and increase government fiscal exposure.
Structural reforms to raise growth potential — productivity, finance, energy, human capital, and infrastructure
- Raise total factor productivity and boost investment in physical and human capital.
- Key structural obstacles in ECCU and broadly in the Caribbean:
- High costs of finance, cumbersome tax administration, inefficient business licensing and permits, skills mismatches.
- Regulatory simplification and digitalization:
- Simplify and digitalize licensing, permitting, regulatory regimes, and tax payment procedures (e‑payment, e‑filing, e‑registration).
- Invest in digital infrastructure, lower data transmission costs, improve digital literacy.
- Improve access to finance:
- Address bank balance sheet weaknesses; reduce non‑performing loan ratios; modernize insolvency regimes; enable faster out‑of‑court debt workouts.
- Strengthen collateral infrastructure via credit registries and partial credit guarantee schemes (e.g., regional credit bureau in the Eastern Caribbean).
- Strengthen AML/CFT frameworks to retain correspondent banking relationships.
- Pursue payment-system innovations (mobile real‑time, instant, 24/7 platforms) modeled on India’s UPI and Brazil’s Pix, supported by national ID systems.
- Seize renewable energy transition opportunities:
- Energy importers: diversify into renewables to reduce import bills and high electricity prices (electricity in many Caribbean countries costs a minimum of twice as much as in advanced economies).
- Energy exporters: manage fossil fuel demand changes, explore green petrochemicals and green hydrogen, consider carbon pricing to retain revenue domestically.
- Example spillover risk: Trinidad and Tobago exposed to EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism affecting over 5 percent of total exports (and a further 5 percent at risk if EU expands).
- Immediate low‑cost steps: energy efficiency measures and retrofits (examples: Barbados and Jamaica).
- Regional initiatives: Resilient Renewable Energy Infrastructure Investment Facility; pooled procurement and harmonized regulatory frameworks.
- Invest in human capital and bridge skills gaps:
- Expand vocational training, modernize education, active labor market policies, integrate AI/data science into education.
- Aim for Caribbean schools to rank in the upper quartile of PISA benchmarks.
- Examples of national efforts: Jamaica STEAM initiative; Barbados Economic Recovery and Transformation Plan (2022); St. Vincent and the Grenadines education reform; Antigua and Barbuda expansion of UWI Five Islands Campus.
- Boost infrastructure investment:
- Priority sectors: transportation (mass transit), roads and highways, broadband and telecommunications, water treatment and distribution, energy.
- Governments should attract local, regional, and international private capital via well‑structured PPPs.
- Pursue PPPs programmatically (pipeline developed in parallel) rather than sequentially to attract seasoned investors.
The role of the IMF — modalities of engagement and regional support
- IMF engagement modalities:
- Surveillance: Article IV Consultations (country‑specific policy advice, published).
- Capacity development: technical assistance, training (e.g., CARTAC), tailored policy advice on tax, public spending, debt management, statistics, monetary tools.
- Financing: lending toolkit to address balance of payments challenges; rapid facilities for emergencies; Resilience and Sustainability Facility for affordable long‑term financing.
- Regional examples of IMF support:
- Program engagements: Jamaica, Barbados, Suriname have made notable progress with IMF‑supported programs (Extended Fund Facility and other facilities).
- Jamaica used the Precautionary and Liquidity Line without drawing, providing an insurance buffer.
- Rapid financing provided to seven Caribbean member countries during the pandemic.
- Barbados and Jamaica benefitted from the Resilience and Sustainability Facility to integrate climate risks, support renewable energy incentives, and catalyze resilience financing.
- Haiti: engagement through a Staff‑Monitored Program to support policy objectives and build a track record for future financial assistance.
- Capacity building and CARTAC:
- CARTAC provides capacity building and policy advice across public finance management, tax and customs administration, financial supervision, and more.
- CARTAC has operated since 2001; additional financing support is needed to close the financing gap.
Call to action
- Imperatives for Caribbean policymakers:
- Put macro‑fiscal houses in order.
- Engage in deep, meaningful structural reforms to increase growth potential.
- Implement reforms under national control; continue regional cooperation and capitalize on CARICOM for larger markets, movement of people, investment, and trade.
- Maintain focus on delivering economic resilience, higher growth prospects, and better living standards.
- IMF commitment:
- The IMF remains committed to supporting Caribbean members through surveillance, capacity development, and financing.
Source: Nigel Clarke, “The Caribbean Challenge: Fostering Growth and Resilience Amidst Global Uncertainty,” speech as prepared for delivery, June 10, 2025.