Medium-term Macroeconomic Effects of Russia’s War in Ukraine and How it Affects Energy Security and Global Emission Targets
IMF Working Papers, March 1, 2024
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Medium-term Macroeconomic Effects of Russia’s War in Ukraine and How it Affects Energy Security and Global Emission Targets
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Hugo Rojas-Romagosa
- Published: March 1, 2024
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9798400264269.001
Summary findings
- Russia’s war in Ukraine disrupted the supply of natural gas for many European countries, triggering an energy crisis and affecting energy security.
- Simulations of the medium-term effects of these trade disruptions indicate:
- Most European countries have limited GDP losses.
- Countries more dependent on Russian natural gas face moderate GDP losses.
- European fossil fuel consumption and emissions are reduced as a consequence of the disruptions.
- After accounting for the war impacts, achieving Europe’s emission targets becomes slightly less costly.
Energy security and trade substitution
- The war eliminates European energy dependency from Russian imports.
- Most of the natural gas and oil imports formerly sourced from Russia will be substituted by other suppliers.
- Constructing a new Russian pipeline to China does not provide significant macroeconomic benefits to either country.
Sectoral and environmental effects
- Fossil fuel consumption in Europe declines in the simulated medium-term scenarios.
- Greenhouse gas emissions in Europe decline alongside fossil fuel consumption.
- The reduction in emissions lowers the marginal cost of meeting Europe’s emission targets relative to the pre-war baseline.
Macroeconomic implications
- Overall GDP impacts are heterogeneous across Europe:
- "Most" countries: limited GDP losses.
- Countries with higher dependence on Russian natural gas: moderate GDP losses.
- No substantial macroeconomic gains are identified from a new Russia–China pipeline in the modeled scenarios.
Policy-relevant takeaways
- Diversification of suppliers substitutes most lost Russian natural gas and oil imports, reducing direct energy dependence.
- Reduced fossil fuel consumption and emissions imply some easing in the cost of meeting emission targets, but policy design should account for distributional and sectoral impacts of the disruptions.
- Investments or projects aimed at reconnecting Russian supply to large alternative markets (for example, a new pipeline to China) are unlikely to deliver significant macroeconomic benefits according to the simulations.
IMF Working Paper — March 1, 2024.
Content in this bundle
- Working Paper