Assessing the Impact of Restricting Skilled and Unskilled Migration: A General Equilibrium Approach
IMF Working Papers, August 28, 2026
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Assessing the Impact of Restricting Skilled and Unskilled Migration: A General Equilibrium Approach
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Alina Carare, Metodij Hadzi-Vaskov, Jessie Kilembe, Felipe Leal
- Published: August 28, 2026
- Series: IMF Working Papers
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.5089/9798229057462.001
Methodology and Model
- Augment the two-country DSGE model from Mandelman and Zlate (2012) with endogenous migration of both skilled and unskilled labor.
- Analyze economic impact of restricting migration for each labor type on migrants’ source and host countries.
Calibration and Data
- Model calibrated with data for Guatemala (source) and the U.S. (host).
Main Findings
- Restricting unskilled immigration has a more severe contractionary impact on the host economy than restricting skilled migration.
- Restricting unskilled immigration negatively affects skilled immigration flows, but restricting skilled immigration does not affect unskilled flows.
- Restricting unskilled immigration has a significant overall impact on the source economy, with aggregate consumption and income declining mainly due to a fall in remittances.
- Restrictive immigration policy (especially for unskilled labor) can reduce wage inequality in the host country by compressing the skill premium, but at the cost of lower overall economic activity and aggregate consumption.
- By increasing the wage gap for unskilled labor between host and source economies, restrictions raise incentives for immigration despite higher migration costs.
Impacts on the Host Economy (U.S. calibration)
- Aggregate output reduced by approximately 1 percent compared to the steady state when unskilled immigration is restricted.
- Aggregate consumption reduced by 0.6 percent compared to the steady state when unskilled immigration is restricted.
- Restrictive policy for unskilled labor raises host-country unskilled wages by 8 percent compared to the steady state.
- Restrictive policy for unskilled labor lowers host-country skilled wages by 1 percent compared to the steady state.
- Although output per capita could increase under restriction (especially for unskilled labor), overall economic activity and aggregate consumption decline.
Impacts on the Source Economy (Guatemala calibration)
- Aggregate consumption and income decline, primarily driven by a fall in remittances, when unskilled migration is restricted.
- Changes in skilled migration flows are negatively impacted by unskilled migration restrictions.
Policy Trade-offs and Implications
- Trade-off for host economy:
- Benefit: reduction in wage inequality via compressed skill premium; potential increase in output per capita.
- Cost: lower aggregate output and consumption; weaker overall economic activity.
- Unintended incentive effect: larger wage gap for unskilled labor between host and source raises incentives to migrate despite increased migration costs.
Subject Tags and Keywords
- Subjects: Balance of payments, Labor, Migration, Population and demographics, Remittances, Skilled labor, Unskilled labor, Wages
- Keywords: DSGE Model, Endogenous Migration, IMF working papers, immigration impact, Immigration Policy, International Migration, Remittances, Skill Heterogeneity
Assessing the Impact of Restricting Skilled and Unskilled Migration: A General Equilibrium Approach — By Alina Carare, Metodij Hadzi-Vaskov, Jessie Kilembe, Felipe Leal; August 28, 2026; IMF Working Papers 2026, 182 (Working Paper No. 2026/182).
Content in this bundle
- Working Paper