IMF Survey: Tax Policy Can Help Spur Economic Growth
IMF News, November 19, 2012
Source details
- Canonical URL
- IMF Survey: Tax Policy Can Help Spur Economic Growth
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 19, 2012
Overview and key messages
- Publication date: November 19, 2012.
- Central message: Taxation plays an important role in promoting economic growth by generating revenue to finance governments' economic development policies and creating a framework for development of private sector activities.
- Growth objectives must be balanced with distributional goals: "Growth-friendly objectives must be balanced with improved distribution of income."
Regional context and motivation
- Most Latin American economies continued to perform well despite global uncertainties, but policymakers sought ways to boost sluggish growth across the region.
- Improved government balance sheets, lower external debt, and higher international reserves contributed to regional resilience.
- Persistent global risks and uncertainty underscore the need to strengthen taxation and public spending frameworks to secure government revenues and support growth.
Conference purpose and participants
- Organized by the Inter-American Center of Tax Administrations, the Receita Federal do Brasil, and the IMF.
- Participants included policymakers and tax administration officials from Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Mexico, Paraguay, and Uruguay.
- Conference agenda focused on: the impact of tax policy and administration on private sector development and economic development resources; the role of taxation in reducing inequality; taxation of natural resources; and taxation of the financial sector.
Findings on tax structure and administration
- "Strengthening fiscal frameworks requires building stronger and more reliable revenue bases," said IMF Deputy Managing Director Naoyuki Shinohara.
- A stronger revenue base provides a more stable source of income to finance public investment and helps countries weather global shocks and limit income volatility associated with commodity dependence.
- Key challenge highlighted by Gilbert Terrier: increase the revenue productivity and structure of the personal income tax so it can contribute to growth-enhancing public expenditure while helping attain distributional goals.
- Continued efforts to improve the effectiveness of tax administration would help bolster tax revenues; countries with relatively more effective tax administrations have the best tax revenue performance.
Natural resource taxation issues and guidance
- Many Latin American countries have substantial natural resources that generate significant revenues for private sector and governments, but face challenges:
- Vulnerability to sharp reversals in commodity prices if windfalls are not saved.
- Lack of effective administration systems to collect taxes and royalties.
- Need for stronger institutions to make good quality public investments.
- Volatility concerns: Saul Lizondo cautioned that volatile commodity prices lead to volatility in natural resource revenue and higher volatility of government expenditure in resource-rich countries.
- Policy guidance from Victoria Perry: ensure taxation of nonrenewable natural resources captures sector gains effectively while encouraging needed investment.
- A robust framework would ideally combine:
- a royalty on gross revenue,
- a tax targeted explicitly on rents (and thus on the achieved results of extraction),
- and a standard corporate income tax.
- The framework should reflect each country's circumstances.
Financial sector taxation issues and proposals
- Financial sectors across many Latin American countries have shown marked resilience through the global downturn and sluggish recovery.
- Design considerations:
- The mobile nature of financial services requires tax systems that avoid inducing capital flight to jurisdictions with more favorable tax treatment.
- Bank transaction taxes (levied on deposits or withdrawals) are easy to administer and generate short-term revenue but may create distortions, including reluctance of financial institutions to act as intermediaries.
- A well-designed bank tax could:
- help ensure the financial sector pays for direct support in future financial crises,
- dampen potential damage from future banking crises,
- address existing tax distortions such as the bias in favor of debt financing.
- IMF proposal to the Group of Twenty: a Financial Activities Tax (FAT), described as a type of value-added tax for the financial sector, with dual rationale:
- to raise revenue from the financial sector,
- and to reduce economic distortions associated with taxation of this sector.
Source: IMF Survey: Tax Policy Can Help Spur Economic Growth (November 19, 2012).