What a Drag: The Burden of Nonperforming Loans on Credit in the Euro Area

High and rising levels of nonperforming loans in the euro area have burdened bank balance sheets and acted as a drag on bank profits. Banks, striving to maintain provisions to cover bad loans, have had fewer earnings to build-up their capital buffers. This combination of weak profits and a decline in the quality of bank assets, resulting in tighter lending standards, has created challenging conditions when it comes to new lending.

We took a closer look at this relationship and the policies to help fix the problem in our latest Global Financial Stability Report because credit is the grease that helps the economy function.

The stock of nonperforming loans has doubled since the start of 2009 and now stands at more than €800 billion for the euro area as whole (see chart). Around 60 percent of these nonperforming loans stem from the corporate loan book.

Resolution of nonperforming loans 

There is a need to resolve this large stock of nonperforming loans clogging bank balance sheets. But there has not been much progress to date. The stock of nonperforming loans continues to rise, albeit at a slower pace than before, and banks have sold less than 6 % of the stock of nonperforming loans. Resolution has been hampered by three key factors.

• Bank financial capacity—capital and provision buffers—to dispose of nonperforming loan portfolios given the current gap between what the loans were originally worth and what financial markets think they’re worth now.

• Bank operational capacity to handle the quantity of bad assets.

• Legal system capacity to process nonperforming assets—though a number of countries have recently introduced reforms to speed-up debt workouts—and relative immaturity of out-of-court restructuring frameworks in some countries.

Cleanup of bank balance sheets 

Policymakers and banks have two other avenues they should pursue.

First, banks need to clean up their balance sheets. The ongoing assessment of banks, conducted by the European Central Bank and the European Banking Authority is a first step in this process. The assessment needs to be credible, reliable and transparent, and should be followed by remedial actions that are implemented on a timely basis and clearly communicated to the market.

In parallel, further actions are needed to fully address the constraints impeding the resolution of nonperforming assets:

• Bank supervisors should continue to provide strong incentives for banks to maintain prudent provisioning levels, ensure that provisioning reflects forward-looking expected credit losses, and that a conservative approach is taken to collateral valuation, recovery rates and resolution time;

• Banks that are overcapitalized for precautionary reasons need to use capital buffers to deal with losses;

• Banks need a specialized capacity to deal with problem loans , either in-house or across different institutions;

• Authorities should promote a liquid secondary market for nonperforming loans, for example through regulatory guidance on time limits for bad loan provisioning and retention or requirements to keep rigorous loan-servicing records and security documentation;

• Legislators should reform legal frameworks—as has begun in a number of stressed euro area countries—and these should be resourced adequately to facilitate timely resolution of nonperforming assets;

• Authorities should step-up efforts to increase debtor awareness of available restructuring tools;

• Regulators should help to improve the transparency, timeliness, frequency and harmonization of bank and corporate balance sheets to aid the  assessments of bank and corporate creditworthiness.

New sources of credit 

Along with measures to facilitate an increase in corporate equity levels, including via targeted measures to encourage debt-for-equity swaps, authorities and markets could develop nonbank sources of credit, including bonds, further. However, officials need to ensure that effective regulation and supervision of nonbank entities should accompany these efforts to avoid building future problems.

• Regulators should review existing constraints on nonbank long-term investors acting as lenders;

• Officials should promote the listing of bonds by smaller firms;

• Regulators should reconsider impediments to ‘safe’ securitization of loans

• Official guarantees may be required, though governments should offer them in amounts consistent with the overall fiscal position of the economy, and structure them to prevent leaving guarantors with poor credits.

Euro area policymakers face a daunting task in addressing the legacy debt burden to help complete the transition to an integrated financial system. Without significant policy efforts to address the burden of nonperforming loans, some economies may find they remain stuck in the mire of low profitability, low credit and low growth.