Spain: 2014 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement of the Mission
IMF News, May 27, 2014
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Spain: 2014 Article IV Consultation Concluding Statement of the Mission
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: May 27, 2014
Mission timing and context
- Madrid, May 27, 2014
- Publication date: May 27, 2014
- Describes preliminary findings of IMF staff at conclusion of the mission under Article IV consultations.
Macro outlook and recent developments
- The recovery started in the second half of 2013 and gained strength in the first quarter of 2014, with the economy growing at the fastest pace since 2008.
- Recovery drivers:
- Robust exports.
- Sharp improvement in financial market conditions.
- Rising private consumption and business investment as confidence recovers.
- Improving labor market trends.
- Expectation: The recovery is expected to continue over the medium term.
- Distributional and balance-sheet legacies:
- 5.9 million people are unemployed, more than half of them for more than a year.
- Average household income remains below pre-crisis levels.
- Households, firms, and the government still face heavy debt burdens.
Contributions of past policy actions
- Fiscal and pension measures: Difficult decisions about spending, taxes, and pensions have strengthened Spain’s budget and pension system.
- Financial sector program: Forcing weak banks to repair balance sheets; program successfully completed and supporting recovery by improving lending conditions.
- European-level actions: Helped reduce the government’s borrowing costs to record lows, catalyzing the recovery.
- Labor market reform and wage moderation: Helping turn job destruction to job creation.
- Compared to a year before, unemployment fell in the first quarter of 2014.
- Jobs, as measured by social security affiliations, increased by about 200,000 in April.
Four priority areas for action (policy recommendations)
1. Helping firms expand, hire, and invest
- Rationale:
- Firms have been under incessant pressure to cut costs and jobs.
- Debt reduction for operationally-viable but heavily-indebted firms could reduce financial stress and allow growth.
- Recommended measures:
- Catalyze comprehensive debt restructuring involving all stakeholders, led by the official sector.
- Banks could adopt a voluntary code of conduct, similar to that for individuals, offering operationally-viable SMEs a menu of standardized restructuring terms.
- Government participation example: allow outstanding tax and social security claims of such firms to be restructured to sustainable levels if other creditors do the same, without undermining tax compliance.
- Enhance the insolvency framework with focus on SMEs and individual entrepreneurs.
- Consider introducing a personal insolvency framework allowing insolvent debtors a fresh start after surrendering non-exempt assets and a substantial period of good faith efforts to pay outstanding debt.
- Banking sector support:
- Continue to bolster banks’ ability to support the economy.
- Despite improvements, credit is still contracting faster than desirable.
- Causes include lack of solvent demand from firms and banks increasing capital ratios more by shrinking lending than by raising capital.
- Banks should continue to raise capital levels over time, including by limiting cash dividends and bonuses, and reducing costs.
2. Lowering regulatory barriers to boost jobs and growth
- Rationale:
- Removing regulatory barriers would improve efficiency, increase employment, and sustain competitiveness that has improved external trade.
- Recommended measures:
- Implement the Market Unity law to remove barriers hindering businesses across regions.
- Eliminate some 2,700 identified regulatory barriers, most at the regional level.
- Remove regulatory barriers in professional services; submit an ambitious draft law to Parliament without further delay and pass it without granting special treatment for vested interests.
- Make labor market more dynamic and inclusive through:
- Regional governments implementing plans to more widely use private job placement agencies.
- Improving training services by opening them up to competition.
- Establishing a single portal for job vacancies throughout Spain.
- Striking a better balance between highly-protected permanent contracts and precarious temporary contracts to increase hiring on permanent contracts.
- Further enhancing the ability of individual firms to adapt remuneration to their specific conditions to better align productivity to wages.
3. Pursuing growth- and job-friendly fiscal consolidation
- Fiscal position:
- Spain made strong progress in cutting its deficit in the last two years.
- The deficit is still very large.
- Debt, already above the Euro area average, is rapidly approaching 100 percent of GDP.
- Guiding principle: Get debt to trend down through gradual, well-designed efforts to reduce the deficit with minimal drag on growth and employment.
- Tax reform priorities (three key goals):
- Increase revenues to protect public services for current and future generations:
- There is room for increasing indirect revenues.
- Raise excise duties and environmental levies.
- Gradually reduce preferential treatments in the VAT to bring Spain’s collection effort more into line with its European peers.
- Combine revenue-raising measures with clearly-identified measures to protect the most vulnerable.
- Help create jobs for the low skilled:
- Incentivize firms to hire the low skilled by cutting the social security contributions firms pay when employing them.
- To protect the social security system, the cost would be covered by government transfers.
- Promote inclusive growth:
- Broaden the base of income taxes by reducing exemptions and special treatments.
- Scope exists for gradually cutting corporate income tax rates to promote growth (though not to 20 percent, which is below the EU average).
- Given the need to sustain revenues and preserve progressivity, there is less scope for significantly cutting top personal income tax rates.
4. More support from Europe
- Rationale: Stronger policies by Spain’s European partners would help both the Euro area and Spain by lowering borrowing costs for Spanish firms and households and increasing demand for Spanish exports.
- IMF staff recommendations:
- More monetary easing by the ECB to achieve the ECB’s price stability objective, support demand, and reduce financial fragmentation.
- Progress toward a more ambitious banking union.
Concluding assessment
- Collective policy efforts by Spain and at the European level are beginning to bear fruit and have substantially improved the prospects for creating jobs and raising living standards.
- Continued and broad-based efforts are needed to ensure the recovery is strong, long-lasting, and inclusive so unemployed persons benefit from more job opportunities.
International Monetary Fund, Mission Concluding Statement, May 27, 2014.