Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses the Multilateral Aspects of Policies Affecting Capital Flows
IMF News, November 29, 2011
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Public Information Notice: IMF Executive Board Discusses the Multilateral Aspects of Policies Affecting Capital Flows
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: November 29, 2011
Background
- Document: Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 11/143
- Date of PIN publication: November 29, 2011
- Executive Board discussion date: On November 14, 2011 the Executive Board discussed a staff paper on “The Multilateral Aspects of Policies Affecting Capital Flows.”
- Purpose of the staff paper:
- Draw greater attention to the multilateral aspects of policies affecting capital flows.
- Argues that the crisis showed national policies affecting capital flows can have multilateral consequences, including spillovers from a breakdown in domestic stability of a large country to other countries and the global system.
- Notes that activities of global institutions and markets—some regulated and some not—can bear on the riskiness of flows.
- Presents the IMF staff paper as a building block toward a comprehensive, flexible, and balanced approach for the management of capital flows, drawing on country experiences.
- Scope and emphasis of the staff paper:
- Revisits stylized facts related to global capital flows in light of the recent crisis, stressing the key role of a small number of countries and financial institutions in “sourcing” global capital flows.
- Provides an assessment of regulatory and supervisory policies of mainly source countries, and of reserve currency issuing economies’ monetary policy.
- Addresses the multilateral transmission of capital flow management measures (CFMs).
- Notes further work planned for early next year to cover capital account liberalization and managing capital outflows.
Executive Board Assessment — Key findings
- General view:
- Executive Directors welcomed the discussion as an important step in developing a comprehensive perspective for the management of capital flows.
- Directors agreed national policies, including prudential frameworks, can influence the riskiness of capital flows in ways that affect cross-border stability.
- Directors noted national authorities may not fully appreciate the multilateral transmission of their policies and may not internalize cross-border effects.
- Role of policies:
- Policies of both source and recipient countries play a role in reaping benefits of capital flows while limiting risks.
- National policymakers should pay more attention to the multilateral transmission of their policies, including prudential frameworks and monetary policy.
- Fund’s role:
- The Fund, in accordance with its mandate, has an important role in bilateral and multilateral surveillance, including:
- Monitoring global liquidity and cross-border flows.
- Surveying international spillovers.
- Fostering a multilateral dialogue and policy coordination over capital flows.
- Providing candid advice.
- Regulatory and supervisory shortcomings:
- Before and during the crisis, shortcomings in regulation and supervision in source countries allowed banks and other market participants to take excessive cross-border risks that led to macrofinancial instability.
- More effective regulatory and supervisory policies in both source and recipient countries would help limit systemic stress, including transmission via capital flows.
- Improved national prudential frameworks benefit all countries and the global system as a whole.
- Prudential policy and coordination:
- Prudential policies should be strengthened at both national and international levels.
- Completing and fully implementing national and international regulatory and supervisory reforms now underway and developing new macroprudential frameworks will help reduce arbitrage opportunities and mitigate cross-border risks.
- Greater cross-border coordination, including of macroprudential policies, would help reduce the riskiness of capital flows.
- Directors called for more analysis to fully understand drivers of global systemic risk and implications for macroprudential policies and their coordination.
- Monetary policy transmission:
- Directors concurred that the monetary policy of major central banks affects capital flows to other economies.
- Most Directors noted the complicated transmission process limits the case for major central banks to proactively consider in their monetary policy its multilateral effects.
- Sound prudential frameworks in source countries would help mitigate multilateral risks associated with global liquidity creation.
- A significant minority of the Board called for considering exchange rate flexibility in the analysis of recipient countries.
- Capital Flow Management Measures (CFMs):
- Renewed interest in CFMs suggests their multilateral implications warrant attention, as CFMs could transmit multilaterally by increasing or decreasing capital flows to countries with similar characteristics.
- Directors noted a lack of firm empirical evidence to date on the magnitude and direction of multilateral effects of CFMs.
- Most Directors agreed that a moderate use of CFMs has few implications for the overall riskiness of capital flows and global stability, but noted CFMs, if they proliferate or intensify, would have escalating global costs.
- A few Directors considered the likelihood of proliferation of CFMs to be low, noting it did not happen at the height of the current crisis.
- Some Directors pointed to the importance of flexibility in recipient countries’ policies to mitigate risks without stigma attached to particular instruments.
- Most Directors called on the Fund to continue to monitor CFMs; a few Directors requested regular publication of an overview of CFMs applied by countries.
- Assessment of Fund work and next steps:
- Directors welcomed the Fund’s work on capital flows.
- Most Directors saw elements in Box 6 of the staff report as a step in the right direction, with some asking for further specificity.
- Next steps identified:
- A paper on capital account liberalization and net capital outflows that will examine among other issues the multilateral effects of maintaining and liberalizing closed capital accounts by large countries.
- A paper that will draw together previous, current, and planned work toward articulation of a comprehensive, balanced, and flexible Fund institutional view on policies affecting capital flows, drawing on country experiences, to underpin consistent and evenhanded policy advice appropriate to country-specific circumstances.
Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 11/143 — November 29, 2011