IMF Survey: Biofuel Demand Pushes Up Food Prices
IMF News, October 17, 2007
Source details
- Canonical URL
- IMF Survey: Biofuel Demand Pushes Up Food Prices
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Authors: Valerie Mercer-Blackman
- Published: October 17, 2007
Overview
- By Valerie Mercer-Blackman, Hossein Samiei, and Kevin Cheng; IMF Research Department; October 17, 2007.
- Commodity prices rose sharply during 2007, with oil and a number of metal and food items setting new record highs.
- The rise in food prices raises questions about how to manage growing demand for biofuel.
Causes of higher food prices
- Higher biofuel demand in the United States and the European Union (EU) has:
- Led to higher corn and soybean prices.
- Resulted in price increases on substitution crops.
- Increased the cost of livestock feed by providing incentives to switch away from other crops.
- Poor harvests in many countries and outbreaks of animal diseases (for example in China) have contributed to price hikes.
- Increased demand from emerging markets, particularly China and India, has added to pressures on commodity prices.
- Oil prices hit record highs during September and October 2007, reflecting solid demand growth, sluggish supply, and ongoing geopolitical concerns.
- Futures markets indicate that high prices are likely to continue over the medium term, providing incentives for a surge in biofuel production as a supplement to transportation fuels.
Impact on inflation
- The direct first round contribution of food to inflation for the world as a whole:
- Rose from about one-fourth in 2000-06 to more than one-third in the first four months of 2007.
- The impact of higher food prices on inflation is higher for poorer countries.
- IMF analysis finds that food prices have had a discernible impact on non-food price inflation in many emerging and low-income countries.
Dilemma of biofuels
- Pros and cons of using biofuels at modest blends under current technology:
- Pros: Can supplement traditional fuels and contribute to rural development.
- Cons: Using food to produce biofuels may further strain arable land and water supplies and push food prices up.
- Technology and cost comparisons:
- Brazilian ethanol derived from sugarcane is less costly to produce than corn-based U.S. ethanol and yields greater environmental benefits (as presented).
- Policy and market distortions:
- Generous tax credits for blenders, tariffs on imported biofuels, and agricultural support for grain farmers in the United States and the EU make it difficult for low-cost foreign biofuel producers to compete in these markets.
- If tariffs and subsidies in the United States and EU were eliminated:
- Biofuels would likely be produced largely by lower-cost producers such as Brazil and other Latin American countries.
- Biodiesel would be produced mostly by Malaysia, Indonesia, India, and some African countries.
Key findings and projections
- Commodity prices rose sharply during 2007 across energy, metals, and food.
- Food price increases have pushed up inflation, particularly in developing countries.
- Futures market signals and record oil prices in September and October 2007 point to sustained incentives for increased biofuel production over the medium term.
Policy recommendations
- Realizing the potential benefits of biofuels requires better policies, including:
- Reducing trade and fiscal barriers that prevent lower-cost producers from competing (specifically addressing tariffs and subsidies in the United States and EU).
- Allowing free trade in biofuels as the first-best policy while waiting for more efficient fuel technologies to emerge, to benefit the environment and make biofuel economically more viable.
IMF Research Department; "IMF Survey: Biofuel Demand Pushes Up Food Prices"; October 17, 2007.