Adapting to Climate Change: Pricing Right, Taxing Smart, and Acting Now
IMF News, January 31, 2018
Source details
- Canonical URL
- Adapting to Climate Change: Pricing Right, Taxing Smart, and Acting Now
Other formats
Bibliographic details
- Published: January 31, 2018
Why the IMF is stepping up on climate change
- Short answer: response to the threat climate change poses to the planet and growing demand from membership and the international community for a response.
- Long answer:
- The Fund’s core mandate is to ensure economic stability and resilience; climate change could be a destabilizing force for the global economy if not addressed.
- Recent extreme events (for example, an especially damaging hurricane season in the Caribbean and the U.S.) illustrate the macroeconomic impact and the expectation of more frequent and more damaging natural disasters.
- Two key areas of work: mitigation (helping countries meet commitments under the Paris Agreement to reduce emissions) and adaptation (building resilience to climate change).
- General policy message: “price it right; tax it smart; and do it now.”
Main findings and macroeconomic risks
- Climate and macroeconomy:
- Global temperatures have increased at an unprecedented rate over the past 40 years, and significant additional warming could occur.
- All countries will be affected if greenhouse gas emissions are not reduced.
- Uneven macroeconomic effects by income group:
- Average annual cost of natural disasters in low-income countries is equal to 2 percent of GDP.
- That is four times the impact on larger economies.
- Implication: clear focus on low-income countries, including small island economies.
- Adaptation findings:
- Sound domestic policies and investment in specific strategies can help reduce adverse consequences of weather shocks.
- Example: Grenada encouraged to save 40 percent of the revenue from its Citizenship by Investment Program as a buffer against future natural disasters; Grenada has included a hurricane clause in its debt agreements to defer debt payments if there is a natural disaster.
- Mitigation findings:
- Carbon pricing is crucial in reducing emissions; carbon taxes are more effective than other mitigation instruments.
- Co-benefits include reduced air pollution and increased government revenues.
How the IMF helps members and which countries are most affected
- Modes of assistance:
- Macroeconomic analysis at country, regional, and global levels (noting the October 2017 World Economic Outlook chapter on implications of weather shocks for low-income countries).
- Assessment of emissions prices and other policies needed to meet mitigation pledges (key input for developing carbon pricing measures).
- Policy advice informed by analysis.
- Capacity development: training and customized advice to help governments implement policies.
- Financial assistance: examples include the Catastrophe Containment and Relief Trust established during the 2015 Ebola crisis to provide debt relief to poor countries hit by natural disasters.
- Financial support enhancements:
- Beginning in December 2016, the amount that countries can borrow after a large natural disaster was nearly doubled.
Energy subsidy reform and carbon taxes — costs and impacts
- Two ways to assess fossil-fuel costs:
- Failure to fully recover supply costs in subsidized user prices for energy: in 2015, this part of the subsidy amounted to $330 billion worldwide.
- Broader measure including undercharging for environmental costs and for general consumer taxes: estimated at $5.3 trillion—equivalent to about 14 percent of global GDP in 2016.
- IMF view and empirical effects:
- Energy subsidies have negative economic and environmental effects.
- Subsidies tend to benefit the wealthiest households, reinforce income inequalities, and encourage wasteful energy consumption.
- The IMF assesses energy subsidies, emissions prices, and related policies to inform reform.
Private sector role and financing resilient infrastructure
- Public–private partnership necessity:
- Addressing climate change requires partnership among governments, international organizations, and the private sector.
- Business plays a critical role in infrastructure development; challenge is designing projects attractive to investors.
- IMF initiatives and tools:
- Infrastructure policy support initiative to help countries meet infrastructure needs while supporting macroeconomic stability and fiscal sustainability.
- A model analyzing macroeconomic effects of natural disasters to define appropriate financing mixes for resilient infrastructure; applied in policy recommendations for countries including the Solomon Islands and the Maldives.
Future risks and next steps for IMF work
- Acceptance of scientific facts and focus areas:
- The IMF fully accepts the scientific facts about future climate risks.
- Efforts focus on developing tools to help countries meet mitigation commitments and recognize environmental, economic, and fiscal impacts of policies.
- Financial stability and green finance:
- Beginning assessment of the interaction of climate risks and financial stability.
- Collaboration with the World Bank and UN Environment on a “roadmap” for green financing.
- Small island states focus:
- Small island states are most vulnerable to climate change and least equipped to build resilience.
- To attract investors and donors, small islands need favorable macroeconomic and business environments, assurances on returns, and credible spending.
- Climate Change Policy Assessments for island states:
- Take stock of mitigation and adaptation plans, risk-management strategies, and financing capabilities.
- Identify areas needing investment, policy changes, or capacity-building assistance.
- Emphasis on creating room in government budgets to enhance preparedness and resilience by mobilizing revenue, redirecting spending, and improving public financial management.
- Example: Seychelles links mitigation and adaptation plans to financial support and risk-management, using financial innovations such as “blue bonds” to protect marine resources and debt-for-nature swaps attracting foreign investors.
A Conversation with IMF Deputy Managing Director Zhang Tao, United Nations Investor Summit on Climate Risk, January 31, 2018; IMF Communications Department.